Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/98/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/98/2004 KI-generiert

Compelling Arbitration Despite Prior Agreement Conflict

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/98/2004
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

A party sought to enforce a contractual provision mandating arbitration for disputes arising under a contract, which was executed between the parties and involved the transfer of certain assets and rights in exchange for specified payments. The opposing party asserted that the arbitration clause was invalid due to a preceding, related agreement that purportedly superseded it or contained conflicting dispute resolution terms, and also argued that the current dispute fell outside the scope of the arbitration agreement. The court reasoned that the plain language of the challenged contract clearly mandated arbitration for all disputes arising thereunder, and the preceding agreement did not explicitly revoke or override the arbitration provision of the operative contract; therefore, the court granted the motion to compel arbitration as the dispute was subject to the agreed-upon mandatory arbitration clause.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Compelling Arbitration Despite Prior Agreement Conflict: The opposing party asserted that the arbitration clause was invalid due to a preceding, related agreement that purportedly superseded it or contained conflicting dispute resolution terms, and also argued that the current dispute fell outside the scope of the arbitration agreement. The court reasoned that the plain language of the challenged contract clearly mandated arbitration for all disputes arising thereunder, and the preceding agreement did not explicitly revoke or override the arbitration provision of the operative contract; therefore, the court granted the motion to compel arbitration as the dispute was subject to the agreed-upon mandatory arbitration clause.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Schiedsklausel Vertragspartei triftige Gründe Verleitung zu Vertragsverletzung oder -auflösung Effektivklausel im Gesamtarbeitsvertrag Tausch

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the court fees.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

     

    &'())&*++, -&.)&+/

0-

 -!  -"    "

%,  *++/

(1  2 

  

   3333333333   !"  #$ $   %& '  () * * +  )$ *$$

% 3333333333   !"  !$, '-  () * *+ $ )$ *$$  

 

!4  " &$*. /0- 1203 %4 ' $ $)

                    !"# " $%

5 0675

 5-

/8  9. * : 9$ 0220- $+) ;  $  01 9$ 0220  <  / 9$ 0220-  $= * $> $   )  *$ $   *$? * $.   )  /@ A)?$ /@@3  !* BBBBBBBBBB- $ C *  5$ *( )$+-  !$ BBBBBBBBBB *  $$ )

=.8

08  ) * *$? (C  ) )   )-  9.  *? *)A$$ $A  3  = 02208

38  A$- !* BBBBBBBBBB  $ 9 )     9. -        *$ ) *  . *   $ *  $ 8 &   *  * *  -   * 9 $  *)-   D *

00 $ 0223-   .  $ $) *   $ *  $ +$  !$ BBBBBBBBBB *  *) * $.- $    /@ A)?$ /@@3   3  = 02208

E8  $? $. $ ;+  )*)  $= * )  $ *() =$ +    $ * $=5. * !$ BBBBBBBBBB ()?$ F  *  * 3/ G 0220 F 7/3H::3 A8 @78  $ $) *    )  07IH11: A8-  #$AA *$8

78 &  $ $ * 1  = 0223 * $ * !$ BBBBBBBBBB- (?$ * )?C *  *$  ) ) A))     * $= . F  + !& F %$#8

I8  $ *  $   *)) *(* ?  #$AA )$ )8

6/71160223

5 3675

 "-

/8 & ( 8 07 *  $ A)*)   $=5. *  )?C A$- ?$$- ?$?   $?$*$ ) * /: *)= /@@3 JKL-  9. )    * ( 8 :38 8 / *  $ A)*)   )?C A$ * 07 9$ /@10 JL $ F >? *>  / G 0223  $=   *  $- *$ ;)  *(AA$   . * ?$    = *  ) * ) $ $ A$;)   9. * *$?-   * *)* * 9$      $ *  $ F  .8

08 ( 8 00 8 0 K )$ +-  #+ 9$ -    $ *  $ F  . * F  *$AA)      $ *  $ . ) * ?$ * $=5. ;$  )?    * *$?     $ *  $ . ) * ?$ * $=5. ;$  )?    *  $ * $.8   - $ C  $ *(9  F    $ *  $  F (?$ * $=5. ;$    *  $ * $.  $ )D    * *$? J D * $= *$$  $A 8 * // *)= 022/L8

38  (>-   * 9 $  *)   .  $ $) *   $ *  $ +$  !$ BBBBBBBBBB    /@ A)?$ /@@3   3  = 02208 *   * - $  )    $ * $=5 .  3/ G 0220 * 7/3H::3-@7 A8-  +   *  $ $ *  $ *  $  &$ M $ & 8

E8  $ $) *    )  07IH11: A8- $ ?$ * A) 5 $     * $=5. ?  !* BBBBBBBBBB > *  +   * >?8

78 $  9 *) $    . 9+(  * A *    $ *  $  *  *-  9$ *$?) =))A$$$ *     $  *$ F * $ )D   $     * 5$8  $ )D   )  ; $$ ).  ( 8 /0 * (*   )?C A$ ?$$- ?$?   $?$*$ ) * /1 ?$ /@1E J 0L    ; ). $- $ $5$  )$ J K  =$)

 3I620 * /1 9$ 0223L8

6/71160223

5 E675

I8    N !$ BBBBBBBBBB   $ *  $ * $ ))*   +    $ *  $  ) ) ?)     =+) * $= .-  ($ )D ).  *G     F A)- *>  3  = 0220- *  * ( )  A * ) * *$?8

:8     * $ $.-  )   <8

  "-5  -!  -"    "

% 67   8  9   :; '<* "=

/8 ?$   + !$. F %$# F ?     * $=5. ) 0/@E337 J  *  K* $ * $=5. ' 3020807822L * !* BBBBBBBBBB > *  K* $ * $=5. *  +   * >?   * 07IH11: A8   *)=$ *   * !$ BBBBBBBBBB ) E0 /00 I/@ 20 O

08 ?$   + !$. F %$# F ?-   *    - * $ )D   $  ; $$ ).   * $*) - *>  3  = 0220- 9+(  * A O

38 (C *   + =$ O

E8 $ +($ (  < *() $ ) *($*$ ) O

78 A   $ *  +H ? A     ) D *  *)$ * 32 9 *>   $A$ $  $ *) *)  $= A)*) * - &#P$Q#A+$ I- I22E   -  $ ;$8  *)$   D  .)8  )$ *$ R L $*$+ ;  +H *)$$   *)$ = $  $   *  *)$$  +)O =L ;  +  $A $  $ ?$ **     *)$$O L    $.    *  )  8 &$  )$   $   $ ))  )))    L =L  L $5*-  $= A)*) *         $>    +H$ *? *) $?=8  )$ *   $   C

6/71160223

5 7675

* ?- +$  9$ - $$ +  *)$$  +)  H? * +   ) ) ;)*$)   J 8 /30- /2I  /21 L8

 .AA$> R  )$*  R

ST  % !C  ! 

 $ A * ) D   $A$) ;  $ $$ +HF HAA$ A)*) *  $   .AA

6/71160223