Statute Validity and Implied Repeal in Land Appropriation Case
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe dispute centered on the validity of a statute enacted in 1772 concerning the appropriation of land for public use, which was challenged on the grounds that it was implicitly repealed by later legislation, specifically acts from 1777 and other subsequent laws dealing with similar subject matters, and also because the original act was unconstitutional as it lacked specific procedural safeguards. The court reasoned that while later acts addressed related topics, there was no clear legislative intent to completely abrogate the 1772 statute; instead, the later laws were interpreted as supplemental or addressing specific applications, not extinguishing the original general authority, and thus the 1772 act remained in effect to the extent its provisions were not directly contradictory to later enactments.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statute Validity and Implied Repeal in Land Appropriation Case: The court reasoned that while later acts addressed related topics, there was no clear legislative intent to completely abrogate the 1772 statute; instead, the later laws were interpreted as supplemental or addressing specific applications, not extinguishing the original general authority, and thus the 1772 act remained in effect to the extent its provisions were not directly contradictory to later enactments.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertImposes the court costs on the appellant because the appeal was dismissed.
Volltext
#$%$&#%''( #)%*#%''(
""
+ "+ , +", ,
,- . & $* /. %''(
!"#$%&$''" $ ( $'')$ * *'
$
++ ( !' $"& ,-./ #$012!3133 34
!"
81508
9$'&':99$':8%'$&;8#<=: > '?%1772@$$'"''"$9"&#A /
'&##$'12@$1772!$9&B:&1.@$1772/
':& C$'#$&#$$8 D$;*>32#$"C1772/
&#': '31$C1772$B:%C$&'/
$$''$E:$A67A3'9&'&#$D&&''$ ''6$C1777; >!'$F$'&#&' $$@%$$9$''&@$$B/
:$A 4? #&%$ E '&! "#$& # @ # "! '$ F$ ""E& G #$! "" B '" ' ""$ ;A3>$E'&@"9G&##:$$&$ #=
A'.<"@%$HE.<"@#<HE%"$/ CA'32@$32I$%"$/ A'3?'&"C3@%%"$;A0>/
&$'%$F$"#$''@''&B:!B '!B$B#&$$'#"$E ;$A4-A3 >/
!#!#&''"$$%'31#$"C3-?2; >$ " B E $ # ' '& ;$A 3. A3!64$?- /9A + '16I$1772!47?574>/
C 9&'& ' ; + >! $#&$$ :$A 41 A 3 ' 9&'& '(D$ @' ' 36 '&"C 3-04 ;>! @D& 6 9&% 3--6 ; + 31167>E#"@%$9&@';$A40A3> '$#F$"#$	G:&J&''&'$$@':$A376A3 $E%$C'K'&%$'&@B""&B%$ '&C$'9&@'E'K$9$':F$:&$$#'$ #'$9&@'/
' F$ ' 10 9&% 3--?! + @D& E @#' #&$& :##E$ # G &%$$& %& # :$A 17 A 3 ' 9&'& #&''"$$%'17'&"C3-6?; >E"":&$$! '&':99 %$&$&$9&'$ 9&#&% B:$A11 '<
5414651772 84508 E$A413$17A3 &$$&'D&'99&""$$:%$# "F"#$&/
: &E '& ' $$ @ ""L$ B '< '" ' '@'9&@';*053--?#A13.>/
$" ' :$A 4? A 3 &$$ '$E! E '& "#$& # @! B G ' :$A 17 A 3 :$ @#' #C& * 053--?#A13.$#$%B:$A41A3; +31167>E:##E #D:#</
: &E! '& $D ,$ &$& $9& #'$ #&' ' #'32@$32I$!'&'':$A67 ""&B "' 36 I$ $ &J&$ "' 30 #$"C! ' $ E ! #$&32#$"C1772!$$'9/
:'<'&&%C/
5414651772 80508
" , 0 "+ , +", ,
1/2 3 4 56 *&% 7
3A &%C/
1A 9" #$ ' E: #%$ 9" $ #&$ F$ ' '& ' 47 @ '< $9$ # # ""'& '& C 9&'& ' ! *JMNJ9E 6! 6770 ! $ G"#A '& #$ F$ #D&A "&" '$= > 'E G$"$E'&$'&C$$#''& $$E&/ C> G# # E "$9 $" #% '"' $$ $ '&/ > #$ D$ ' #&$$A * "&" $$ # $ &&"$ &"&& $$ > C> $ > 8'! C9&'&'##$"$<E: '%'&%CA"&"'"$", ' #%! E $ @$! E '& $$E& $ :%## ' E&$&G#&'&$;$A341!376$37?>A D99< #&'$ ,* &
#9"'#&$F$$$9&G#$#D99
5414651772