Insurance Policy Construction: Specific Exclusion Versus General Coverage
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe appellate court reviewed a case concerning the proper construction of certain liability insurance policies in light of conflicting clauses regarding available coverage limits, specifically addressing whether an exclusion for designated risks superseded a general grant of coverage. The court reasoned that where a policy contains both a specific exclusion for a defined risk and a general insuring clause that appears to cover that risk, the specific exclusion governs, but only if it is clearly and unambiguously worded and does not render the general coverage illusory; in this instance, the exclusion was deemed sufficiently specific to control the coverage outcome, thereby limiting the insurer's liability to zero under the circumstances presented.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Insurance Policy Construction: Specific Exclusion Versus General Coverage: The court reasoned that where a policy contains both a specific exclusion for a defined risk and a general insuring clause that appears to cover that risk, the specific exclusion governs, but only if it is clearly and unambiguously worded and does not render the general coverage illusory; in this instance, the exclusion was deemed sufficiently specific to control the coverage outcome, thereby limiting the insurer's liability to zero under the circumstances presented.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited for the rejection of the appeal and the allocation of costs.
Volltext
!
"###$% &%'%" %
" #( $# #( % "#$% $ (%
) *) !
$+,
!" #$%& '( !)* ( * "* ! +"* ,* "
*
-- . // 0 *!" 1 23 )* 4$5 #$## #6
0 $780
) - 9 .:: * .0( *" ;0)' < = :" .* ** )** ;! + ): * *= > ;0)' *= " #28% ) " $8 * $3 :"( $%%$ !*: 9 )*" *( * ** ( +?)* !* ) ::*" 2 ! $%%% ) * !* ) ) + )* @ A
." *B*" * " * #5 ( $%%$ * > .* " 9+ ( + ) ** !)"!* A
") #5 B $%%$ . B* A
) "* !)"!* #$ :"( $%%6 * "@" @@(* "** *" :!" ) !" *** A
+ )" "( "*" (* * 9 +* "** )"* "*" ) $ )*!C $%%6 A
+ ?)* * ) ::*" ) * +?)* !" ;0 )' < = 4 ! $%%5 * > ) )*" *( )' ( **" 9 +D"!1 ! * (@ * )* * )(* E* ?)9" ) " !*9 CB*(C * 9+ +1 ) +* !** > )*" *( 9 !)9" ) "*D1! D9 A
) " 3 ( $%%5 :!" $# ( $%%8 + :!" : )** ! F +?)* *D0)1D*9 +* ) * > ! : ))"* A
* :* * $4 ! $%%8 A
"*" ) * #8 B $%%8 A
* ")" ))* !" ? !)"!* 9 * "*" ! ) ( 9 !** **: ))"* ) ) #4 "!C $%%8 A
. !)* ! * 9 .* * * 8 :"( $%%3 "*" ( B* * +(* 9E* ( + * A
7#4&67$%%$
0 6780
!" "*" * > + #5 ! $%%3 * )'0(C *! ) ( ) ) $$ ! $%%3 A
+D1)*D' "! ) *"! +* ) (!CC ?)* @9 B * + ?)* )1D*9 9 )!* ! "( :: )1D@9 )** * :! "D"* )*" *( A
) # B $%%3 C 9 +( )* * > > )" A
+ * E* @ " > B@ +:: !** )* 9 * ?)* )1D*9 * E* @*"A
) . 9 C " * !)"** !*' ) "* # G* $%%6 ;*H 58 .@* B 0 = A
")" :! * " )"( ) * (C > :! ;*H 58 * 8% = A
.**" !**( * ** .:: :* "*!* .*0>0 ** * * ") .))* '@ * ; - ##3 $8# H 6 )H $86 A H I /J(D@D* #224 *H# )H 46&= A
. . !** * * . ** !)"!* 9 "@* )* * ""!* ** 9'* * ! * 9. )* * ! K( ?)* 9. ),* " : )* !" ? ; - ##3 $&$ H 4 )H $&6 A #2&5 )H $4% H4 A I H *H= A
L*" B@ 9 ' 9 :* * ) ::!!* " " )* (1 > . !** ) !)"!* .** )" 0!E! > * ** !)"!* ; #226 )H #68= A
)C"!*9 +)' * !)? +*" )" )**" * * 9 * M * !*) ( !" ? :@* A
+ )),* B +D J !* 9 :: * +* ) +@ @9 CB*(C * 9 + +* ) ) !* A
7#4&67$%%$
0 4780
+ B*: : ?! * ' : ) !" )1D* ? : "*! * :: + ::* )1D*9 ( * * 9 ! A
. (* . * ?)* * : !" )1D* D: B* ( )1D* * N"*C!* D)*N > D@ ) +::* 0!E! +?)* : 0 :' A
. ))* .*H 62 )" !**( ; = " #% B " ? )* ) "(* "* .?)* * 9* !)"!* * 9 )"* !!9"A
" !)* +*!" ! 9 +?)* "@" )" 9 ))"* (@* +?)* )1D* +"** )" +?)* * ) )*9" ;:H ))* +?)* 4 ! $%%5=H
///
" $% 0 1 (% " #( $# #( % "#$% $ (%
) 22.,
#H ?)* )1D*9 .?)* 1* ) ! .?! * .* )' .E* *" * ""!* * * )' ( ) . 9 )"* )" .** .( * C A
$H D@ .?)* ") ? 9* (* < #H !' $H " CB*( ) 6H *** CB*( 4H @*;=
7#4&67$%%$
0 5780
5H * ) D9 @* )" "9 )*" *( * )0*H 8H * ( .)*" *( C "D"* 1 !) "(* * $%%$ * BH 3H 9 ! *(*" *( )*" *0 C!* ?@C * * 9 ! O &H ( D ' . " )** ):H 2H )*" *( )*0 E* !"" ) ! !" O #%H * ##H " "D"* 9 ))"* (@ * ))* 4 ! $%%5H #$H * !)"!* *C !*:! ? <
= P00*0 )" !:* + !C *" )1D*9 + *" * + " !)** O C= / 100*0 ::*;= );= D9;= ) ! : +"* * ) " "! C O = )* +*"@* ** !:** ( O = "** )1D9 *" ; "(* )C ) *D")*9= = D **!* !C* ** :! ? '@ +* * ! "DC** ")* !*(* * ::* ) O := : 100*0 (@ * "* * !)*!* C(" "@* .* * *"*9 !* (@ C ! @ (@ * :!* : ) )** * ** .!' )* *' "!**( 9 * C .?)* 9 ."@* D ) !@" (!* )1D ** O @= * )0*0 )1D9 .* *! *0 ?@C 9. ) *(*" *( !E! )? .!)** ::* O
#6H * !9 * * ))* .?)*H
6H !!* > : A
7#4&67$%%$
0 8780
4H (* .?)* > ") > ! ( ))* ?
?!) C " A
5H "( : A
@::' " *
PQ R C /
) :! )"* E* * *:" ? )* 9+> +:: :" " ) @::
7#4&67$%%$