Judicial Review of Agency Penalty Calculation Based on Statutory Misinterpretation
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertA party sought judicial review of a governmental agency's decision regarding the imposition of a penalty based on alleged improper calculation of damages, arguing that the agency misapplied a statutory provision governing the calculation method. The court reasoned that the relevant statute clearly mandated a specific formula for calculating the penalty, and the agency's deviation from this mandated calculation was not supported by any permissible interpretation or exception within the statutory language, thus constituting an arbitrary and capricious application of the law that required reversal of the penalty assessment.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertJudicial Review of Agency Penalty Calculation Based on Statutory Misinterpretation: The court reasoned that the relevant statute clearly mandated a specific formula for calculating the penalty, and the agency's deviation from this mandated calculation was not supported by any permissible interpretation or exception within the statutory language, thus constituting an arbitrary and capricious application of the law that required reversal of the penalty assessment.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertVolltext
#$%%&#'(() #%(%#'(()
*+ **+ * +
&, -. ! / 0-0 '(()
1111111111
**+ 2*3 ** ,,-. !"#$%&'()*)) *+
!"
0*/&0
4 1 2 - 3333333333 ,4. )* 5 *(($ 6, .,, ,67, -%,8
,9 .,,-%,%, )&5*(($ .,.!. *$ 5 *(($ % % , , ,, 1: %, .,,1.%, :,79,,.8
: .,;-,,78
:,,-. % ., %-9 *(($ : %%. ; :%%.,, ,9 .:6, 79,,. ,,6. .,, %%,, )$4,*(($%%4 ,0,8
0 1 < - := '# = ) , %. -,,,7 )*%-9)+>#? @: ,,%, :,79,,. .,6, .,,1.8
1,-%4, ,,-%.,-%,9A ., %,A,;<,6%, :,79,,.8
4,% %7<,61 -,,. 7 6 AA,, , 7 ,. 8
:,, 1, : % . ,6. 6 % " .. ,79%1%,9,,.,.. .;:,.. % , . ,6. 6 ,? B)(*&C8" ,9A. .%9,. , *((* $) *+' )++& C> *)# % D7 , E )++> &))8 -"- .,, :,79,,. --,, %. , :!--, )++C)(#+#(@8
:: ,9 .,-%,; .,*$5 *(($ % , -,, : %, .,, 1.8
:%<.. .,8
:,7,%.1 .,79%.8
5 + *+ **+ * +
/ 0&/&0 ! -040 6 700 0 8" $/' +9
)= . ,79 2 - 3333333333 .,, %%,, )$4,*(($ ,67, -%,8
*= ,1%. 6,= 6AA,DF ., F GH I 2J 2
%,A- %.",A,.<%,,,1:;:AA,A. . ,%6AA
/