Construction Board Permit Denial Overturned for Lack of Substantial Evidence
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertA party challenged a construction board's decision affirming the denial of a permit application, asserting that the board failed to consider evidence that the proposed building's size, setback, and height complied with local zoning requirements, and that the board's reliance on a single, unsupported opinion that the project would negatively impact neighborhood character constituted arbitrary and capricious action. The court held that while the board's decision referenced the zoning compliance and considered the neighborhood impact, the record lacked substantial evidence to support the board's finding that the proposed structure was incompatible with the area, as the board appeared to disregard specific evidence submitted by the applicant demonstrating compliance with all dimensional standards and offered only conclusory statements regarding aesthetic objections.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 106 al. 1 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Construction Board Permit Denial Overturned for Lack of Substantial Evidence: The court held that while the board's decision referenced the zoning compliance and considered the neighborhood impact, the record lacked substantial evidence to support the board's finding that the proposed structure was incompatible with the area, as the board appeared to disregard specific evidence submitted by the applicant demonstrating compliance with all dimensional standards and offered only conclusory statements regarding aesthetic objections.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertUsed to dismiss the appeal as inadmissible.
Applied to order the appellant to pay the costs of the federal procedure.
Volltext
#$%&#'(($ #)%*#'((+
,- --
! !- !-
.' / " '((+
# !"""## ./ $%&&'()(* +, --./(-$%((
$
01111111111$%&&'(-' , -- ./(-$%((
! "
3#043
- 2
5 .,6,/)(7-$(8/-/,3%-(9 ': ()($-;(7(%<$(&(./6=)/((% &(;7&$%&/%(5
#5 22>, ?? ? ? ? 9 : @ ? ? ?? ?3' 9@ ': 3 . %&&-? ??? A$(((/-/7$(($)-8(B (8&$(%()($-;(7(%<$(&(./& ((.&()/6;7-,$<(7$(-$(5
!5 ,-/-/7$(($&$$$&$)($(//$) #1%22>5 ((-%!-/%<22>C&-,()($// /%//<-,(8&$)($(5
15 ) - 2 -/%< 22> $- // &$$7/ D.,6 8( - ,/22 %(&(-%%<-@ 'C-;//5
45 # $$< 222 -) ,/; - /7$(($ ) , @ ' -%-/ $(-, -/&<(.$-=)-,/<((8 -5
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
>&%<#"""@ '(D/$$=7%&=- $( 8/-/5 %( & &((& - 8$8( %(
012!0"1 3!043 $(%$$(&((&%6,($-,5!5 &$$/-%&$)(($5
5 , &( ((. &()/ $ /7% (D/ $ &= - $( 8/-/5 $( ) - &$( A -$ -%-( ., $( 8(B/ 6 @5 1524 ( - @5 15" A ,&&(($ /$() - =7%D)(#"""5
25 ,(($-$//$8(//&%8/-/-D(&$( 9@:.(&-/(($((-- D)(#""D$($8(%/ ,88 &(85 ( - % &$)(($ @ -/(-/ . - D)( #""" D., %$% - -/(($ 8$- - $( 8/-/ =7%8(B(8--&($%/-(&$$(%<$(- !D(2 (&&(<&$8($-;$$(%/-(B -$&($B&/-,$&/($,((($-( )( &$3$&/$( . ( 8/ $ + ) )-&$(-@51524;$%/(5//&/(/.,$M $( 8/-/ -)( -/(- -, &(B (8/( ) 88 D)( #""" $ / ( -$( -,B(7 - & - ((. %<$%--(88/-(89&(=1.5:5
"5 -/(($->%#""! $(8/-/-%($-@ ' D/(-, F,5!5-=7%-#ED(#"""/// ( // $-$/ . (% %<$( ()($ - ;(7( %<$($(%<$/&&(($- +)-&$(/8(B/ 6 @5 15" ,7( - &($ %/-( %/( / 8/ 9&(=4.:5
5 ?(6-/(($ $(-, 7)$(%$-(8(/=7%((7(B -->%(#""!5/,5!59-$(&&/.,(&/)$C(. (%()($/(7$&/!"8$8(,7$<& %/($.,/(&/(8(/:%$-(8(/$(/#%F
N?,7( - (% %<$( - &($ - ;(7( %<$( +&($%%<-(8(($)) -&$( 8(B/ 6 @5 15" &$ .( $ -,$&/($ ,((($ -( (( . )( &$$&/$(5 %/( ((/ $ - ,()($ 8/5O9@ ->%(#""!F&(=E.5:5
,5#5#-/8((&($$%<$$&-/7%($ (8(//<$7/5
%$-(8(($ $ / )(7 - %(= /$() D)( #"""5
012!0"1 31043 #5 ! D( #""! ? ??? A .( )( 3%& %&/ @ ' 3 8$%/ .L (&/($ - -/(($ &= - $( 8/-/ 9&(=-/85:5
!5 %L% D$ /7% (D/ $ $ %$-(8(($ - =7%-%-,($-#=%(/-,5!-$) =7%$,D$-=7%-,-(&$(($&/(. &($ (% /%// 6 ,5 ! 5 N-$() L /%// &&(($ - + ) - &$( / 8(B/ 6 @5 15" ,7( - &($%/-(5O9&(=>.5:
15 -/(($((--1$J#""!@(/,88&(8$ - ? ??? ,7( - ,5 - =7% - > %( #""!5 , ); $8(%/ ,7( - ,5 # &/( . )-(($ /$()/(/)/5((&-&$-/-&$/- ,&&(($ - $(-/ 525! - = -/(($ - $( 8/-/5 -( C &&( . C -$( &$( )-(. -(88/ -,&(88(B/--/(($-,&(88()%&&(./ & &( 6 &( - D)( #"""5 @ $(7/ .,( C )( /7% ( - $( (% - /) -%- - %<$%$8(-,/)(-%(&(8(($9&(=>.5:5
45 -/(($ - #E &%< #""! $( 8/-/ D/ -%- -,(&/($5
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
012!0"1 34043 ()($%(6 -(&$(($--,$&/($-()( &$$&/$(5
/&(-8-((.9$(@5E>S!#!524: $/-(88/-4# >T.,(&&(./6$(/- 8%<$/6((.-&(D)(#"""9$(@5#>!S2"54: .( $-( 6 $&3&U - @511S1!E54E &$ (% $&/($%<$(5 CD$/8(-%(((8(;/$ 6-/%(($-%$/%/.$//(%/6#4T-%$ $-8$(@5!E,""5335 /7%-%-/$-%($- ((.6(/L-4T6$%&-D)(#""#-.($&$-6 - %$C - &($ (-J% &U5 B&(./ $) - ,$<(7($ - -/&$ .L &$ )7- -$( $((/ &$(<((/-,%&(8($-/-($($8$($-/(($- $(8/-/$-? ??? 5
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
5 !" % #""1 ' ' ' (8$%/ (< <( ., $((&$-/8-(/L-((.)/($--$%((5
25 #> )( #""1 -( - $((($ , -) (< <(5 (-(./ %(( $($ $) -/(($ - $(8/-/,C&&%(-&)(6$-)((.5 6 ((. /7% %( &$(($ (% . -/(($ -
012!0"1 3E043 $( 8/-/ ( -$( ($5 ((. & ( $)/ ,B&($ -,($%&/ - (< <(5 8( )$( . .L - $((-%--&(%)-(<B$-((5-/( // 8(B/ B &( &$ -/(7 <( -/( !" D( #""1 // (%&(6((.&$8()$(7%,7(-$%&/- (<<(5
#"5 ,(-$.-&$/-&=$&&$ 6 ((.9 01240#""1: (<-&%(=(9 :((-,($ $($-,(B(-,/(/&((.9 0#1E>40#""!E "":,-//()<-L-2%(#""15&&/.((7 8$( - &($ )( - (< <( - 5 $-D(9 :-L-#!$)%<#""1$8(%/ D7%5 $ /8$% // (/ & ((. . (< 8/-/D7/()<&L-E)(#""494 5E0#""4:%$(8. ,($ &$( - &/($ ) - -$( &<( $ - -$( ()( 8/-/5
#5 $( - !" )( #""1 ((. -/(7/ $%% <( '$( @RRRRRRRRRR5
##5 $( - > %( #""1 &$ & -/(7/ '$( RRRRRRRRRR5
#!5 $%/%$(-!"D(#""1((.$6,($%&/($ %(- (<<(5 =7./($/ .,$/- $(8/-/$8(%/,(&/($-$/& , =7%((7(B6)$(.8($-$&($ %/-(-(&/-)(L8/$(83--!D(2 6 ,B&($ - ( - )( &$$&/$( $ - -,$&/($ B.$-$(&&(. +))-&$(-@515"5?$ $(8/-/((( )(-/((7-$$<D-,&&. .($ &$/ $ () ;%& -,&&(($ - =7% A . &/(/%8(,$<D-&(-/(($- $(8/-/A-,& & . ((. %<$ -(% B &( -(88/ /$() () 6 ) - &$( + /;/5 ((7 ) - -/%(($-(8(($&&(<(,&&(& (<<(- ;5 ((. 8( )$( . ( 6 &%(= -/(($ - $( 8/-/(%%/-(%&&(./)-&$(-@515"6,((($ -(--,$&/($6)(&$3$&/$(5( 88(%.$C=%-(7$$%%/6%<$ -(%B&($/-(88//-,&-<(- )-&$(-,&-(%(($-%D$($-%/(6"T5 $ . -(%(($ - ) - &$( ,&&(. 6 $
012!0"1 3>043 &($ %<$( . (83- ,&&(. .,B %/-( (-/&-5
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
#15 $(-#"D(#""1 $((//($-,<(-/(7/ &((.%$(8.-(-%((/(- -( - /<(% /7% $8( ) %&(( & $-(($ -,(%&((/ .(5
#45 /&$ - ! $J #""1 ,((- -,($%&/ , -,<$-/8//BD7%-& @-&$/- &= .( -/D6 // %($/ &5 ?$ - % $M &/($$8$-/$(,3%-( (<<( $%&/5?,7(-/7((%($()8()$(.$-(($- ,B(-,((78$(-&($3(=.(&$ &(((7A%(8%%&(,&=5 &&. ( $(&/)$(88()% -BC=%- %$-(/-&(% 3(- (7(-(&CA(,7(6.-%$-(/-&(%F --B8$&(;7&,5 =) . .($ - )$( ( , &( -(% 8$( -
012!0"1 3 043 &($ $ %<$ ,/ , & -/%( &$ $%&/ - (<<(-%$M$(&/)$(/7%6,5 25! ' .,( $%&/ $. ,/ -/<( - &($5 &( ,&/,/&$=5 ()$./7%4E5#5 '.($%<$%-&($5 $6. (<<(-%$%&/-/<$((.$(-8( -/&$-%6%-&&(($-,5 -$($ -#&%<2 4&$/--%((()9 G 4":5
#E5 /;7 - $&$- , ()( &( -$ $&( // 8$( (<<(5
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
# 5 3%&&$(-!-/%<#""1((.&$-(-/(($ -& $(8/-/--!$)%<#""1-$&&$ ? ??? $(-, -5 ($($., -%$-(8(($/$()-,(8%(3%<$(,(()-C=% -(7/&)/%$&3&U5
#25 $(-#D)(#""4 ,/$/--,L&$-( )/ ., $(-/ > $( 8/-/ ,/( <$/ 6 -( - .($ - )$( ( &/($- ($( -)( L %/7/ 8) - ((.&$()6$($.D(8((&.& /)(-$( %<$%-$&3&U5 )/ . & $(8/-/,)(88(%/.-$(B((-,5
!"5 ?//7-/6D7((-5
012!0"1 32043
- ,
5 : ?$ ,5 2 5 - $( 8/-/ ,3%-( - % 221 9 ': ((7 8$( $ D7/ & (< <(5 $%&/ (< <( - $ -$ (8 &&(./ $ - . 8$( - &($ (/ 6 ( &% 95 2 5# ':5 (< <( ( $%&/ ( -/<( - /%/($,/9C=%-( 751#5 ':G&( , &/ 6 8( ,/ &$= 95 2 5 ! ':5 &$/-/7(&-$($95 254 ':5
<: ,&=.(/-8$(-&($-5!4 ' ! - ,$-$ ,3%-( - #> D( 224 9 ': - ((.,&$/5 6./-/7$(- - '5 $%&/ - (< <( - $ - =).(($$(-%$M((.C(/6( &%5
#5 : &-((.$.,$$(&/-,((7 8$(5 ?$ / ( /7((%($ () ($ &$ . (< <( - ( & $%&/ ($ %(5
<: ?$ ,5 14 5 1 - $( $ -,&&(($ - $( 8/-/ ,3%-( - #2 %( 22> 9 'G ! "4: =7 7// - &$/- - $( - &$/- -%((() - # &%< 2 2 9 : ,&&(.$%%.($/($-%%<-(< ,/<(% - 8(5 $( &/)$( . $., &( $ $%&/ ,$(/ .( ( &$ $%&/ -$( $ - -/(($ ($ &$ . (< - / )$( - ,$<(7($ - --/(($((-9855! :5
!5 :( '(-(&$(($-SB/($-/8((&/(/%.S( 8-&((78$(-&($5 $%%$ /7(%- ' 95#45 ' :$($-((7-$(L-- 79 @!1#$(-5</8/:6%$(.(3( &$ &/(8(.% ,&&$<($ -, $)($ (8( $ %$-(8(($ D 6 &&$<($ -, $)($ .( $( 6 $%&/ - 7$)% $ $ - $( 8/-/ 9 @#! # 4 $(-5 4 E #E $(-5 # # ! $(-5 !< /8/:5 /($.$(-&&$D(-(..(/- ' $ .( $ // /<( ) - $(5 ((7 -$( $
012!0"1 3"043 &$(($&((=-S$-8$(-&($--- ' 9<;- ? PX)(;7 (F ?;Y(K(; -)Y7; H?I ?$K( ?(;;( &5 #! ;5 1!G 8- ' PX)(;7;&5>#G ' #""1ZP# E&5 #2$(-51G @#!# "$(-54:5
<: @ &/(/ . <( . ( $( 9 ': ( S$-$ 9 ':$(-/8((($-((7$%<$$&-S5 2 ' D(&- $(-= . $($ <$& & /$( . $ S( -$(5 88 ' ($-( $) %/7% - C=% - $)($ (8( ( - -$%( &((& - = /$$%(. - &($ 985 5 4E 5 ':5 &$ $/. -S/- $%&/ - $(/ ;7/ -S&&$) $)($(8(97$)%$$ $(8/-/$.)(-(/ -$)($S/-6$?(H51E51 'I$$- $$-/(($-S7$)%$H54!5 'I:F $(/$S$<(7($-$W$%($)($ $8$% 6 $( 6 S/.(/ 985 5 ## 5 ! ##. 5 4 ' : %( /7% ( (8( 6 SB(7 - = /$$%(. - &($
9 @#!# E$(-5E:5 -(=B(7$/(/&-)$( -$(/-S&&$<($-./(&/<%S)(-?)(-&(B
9 @#!# >$(-5E<G' PX)(;7;[ 22E&5 1:5S$(($-?)(-&(B6&$/--S&&$<($- $)($ (8( &% $ % -S $8$%(/ - $)($ &((& -S/$$%( 6 S/.(/ 95 1E 5 1 ': %( /7%-($%&-N(/L&<(&/(.(&)B(O95 15!-$(8/-/$)(-&(BH?21#5#"G?I:5 ;%&-$%&//--$(/-S&&$<($$S%&(-$) -$(&$88-/-($%&/%/(-(<<($ $ S5 2 ' .S( S & 8$-/ & B%& 6 B%( &$/ -S -S(-B($ -S $)($ $(($ $ -%/-(8/-/($$-(3%-(8(B)-&$(
9 @#!# $(-5E-G @ P>>0""-1&%<#""$(-5<:5
: ,&=&-$($-./&$(.% $-%($-((.-/8-6(&C$&3&U&&(($ -(8$%,B%-$8$%(/--(. -/D6 8( ,$<D -, -/(($ - $( 8/-/5 % ((7 &$.($-,&&(($-(8$-(($$= $%< -$ - $%&/ 8$($ - (< <(5 & 8(. (-/&$/-%-7$<&$$/(C 8($<9 @ $&<(/P!2024-D(22E$(-54-.(/8= (3%L%6, @ $&<(/P"02#-#2$$<22!:5
012!0"1 3043 8( . -%- &$ (%($ - $&3&U &W . -,L;(88/&/(/%8&88,$<D-,B%8$-5 $)(- 3%& - -$ ,$($ 6 ./ - &$) -$%%7.,=75
15 .($ - .(/ &$ 7( - ,5 &$/- <(=)$%%-&$=()(-8$-%%/(-S($
9 @!1>$(-5:5D(&-$$S%&(- ' 9 ' 2>" Z E4 &5 4 $(-5 #G @ "! 4 $(-5 ! L (/G '2 "Z!2!&5!:(3%-($)$V-C=% - ( 7 ((/ - / &/(( -/$ - (% $ /$$%(.-S5#! ' 5
:6B%(($($&/)/7%- '5 B% - S5 4E 5 # ' N 8$( - &($ -$( (%( &($ 6 % B(7/ & S(/L - S/ < - (%5 /%/($ - &($ .( -/& (%( & L 8/5 8$( - &($ & L - ( $%% U 6 $ - $(5 .(/ &$ -%- (($ F 5 S/ $ $8$%/%6S5 25!S-C=%-(7951#5 :G<5S-C=%-(&C951#5#:O5
L/9 @#># : (<8/-/-9 @ : S$($ - &/( &$/ - S5 4E ' (7(=% - #=%(/5
&&/.B-S54E5#5 '(&(.% ;7%-S51 5#5-&$D- $(8/-/-E$)%<22 9@@22# #E": (3%L% &( ) .. %$-(8(($ &% /-($ - S5 1 5 # 5 - &$D - $%%(($ -SB& - #$)%<22"9&5#13#4:5 -(=SB&(%(((.S((-$ &&$ 9&5 E>: F \ $%% % 95 #! ' : - ;. &(( $ 8$- S(/L - S/ < - (% &$ -/%( - . % &($ -$( L &( ;7 & S$<(7$(-$(58$(-&($-$()S(6 (%(9555:5?(&$-&($.(-/&(%(-/%/($ $-/D6//&C/(($&L-%-/5 -$(--%- (($-C=%-(&CS-(-(7 S/$S5 -((7)8$(-&($S -C=%-(7-$(68(&/S/5\ &7 &( &$ S( - %7 - $( 8/-/ 6 S&&( - S51 -&$D-$(9@@22#>:5
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
8(()/.S5#! ' -$S(&(S54E '$( & - &(&($ 8$% S$<(7($ - (($ - 8$( - &($$%%-%/-(5 S.()(%/ (<8/-/ --L8$-%-!-/%<2E29P#10E2:6D7 .((F
\ 7- P ;] ^< -( ^X7&8(; X( $;(85 ; -( <-](; $;8 ] (; -K (;5 ( - 7- 5#! P )&8(; -( _K K Y(;8(; ;-7Y( (% <( %;(< ;% - -%( ( ?;K)$;(8 8^ -( (; - -( P -5 ( (- 7%] 5 ! <5 ! P )&8(; -( PX)(;7 ; - -]K - 7((7X( K <(<5 ?( %^ 8 ?(;;( -8^ <( - ( -( ^<$%% &8(;7 8^ X` 9 5 ! <5 1 P:5 a Y(X(;7 - (K(& - 7((7X( - K ( (; (78];(7X(;<-(P-8^K$7--(_K-(8(;K Y(;8(; ;-7Y( <8$75 ( 87< X` ( (; ;((;- 7; Y- Y (; <$ 7 Y] ( Y(;8(;;-7(%)$<K;Y$;;(&X(; 77 K88 -^85 (%; % (; ; -( '`7(;X( $88 ; a;7 8^ &8(;3 - ;Y(-(7 ;-7 K )Y(75 @$7(;(7 -^8 <( <; (7 K^X78$- Y- Y (; ;]7(; 7(< - ( K ; <K$7 Y$- (-5 -8 Y] 5 #! P 3 ; 7; - 5 #1 ^< - ; )$ _K 3 Y(7;- ($(;5 ( P (- %( - *$ 77^< -
012!0"1 3!043 %;((;(;7;;%](78$7 (7Y(- (K(< -%( - )$ 5 #! KY(7- 78$- 7K(; a- )Y(X(; - 77<8 Y(- ;7 Y(-5 3 -(X 7; ^<(7 ; 5#4 <5!P-)$--P(^X8$-7&; 77^< - _K K; <(%% -$; - - ?;(-7(; ; K]-(7 ( Y - +$$ )$% (; 7;- Y(- - - -( PK<]-(7 $K8^;7%];(7($;^X(;-8$< -(;7)$%(;+$$;-<(<K;Y$-(5\ 9?P 2>" $ E4 &5 4 $(-5 # -( 8U( ' 2>" &5 4 $(-5#:5
D(&- &( 8$( $8(%/ -&( $ 985 @ "! 4 $(-5 !: 8$- -$( &$& - (3%-( 6 B(7 -S 8$( - &($ (($ - $%% .S( &U (-J% %L% $. 3(($//)/&S/$&(9C=%-(7: 8J3$)$$/-/9 '2 "$!2!&5!G85( @# ! $(-5 1<:5 @ -/-( - )B &/&$( - ' %($/&;.S54E5#5 '$-(8(&(..( $ /7% - S5 2 5 ! ' . ( )$(5 -(= -(&$(($&-88=7.(8(7(&)6S5#45! ' 985@@22# 2G)$((SL @#1!" + ? PX)(;7 (F ?;Y(K(; -)Y7; H?I ;51E1>:5
= $ S5 4E 5 # 5 ' S % (/ $) &((& -S&=.-C=%-(7-S51#5 ' S/ ( -$( -SB(7 - 8$( - &($ (($ - /%/($.S(()/$.3(-/&(%(8(B/&S54E 5 '5$)(--)B&/&$(-$(S %L%8()($B-3(.-S88(%$(5
S(./7((%($()- -$/$S7- '
9 @ P40"-4)(#""#$(-51:5
45 8( 6 B%( .($ - &/%&($5 ,&= &($ &$ . -%- (($ - $&3&U $ / #"""6#""!5
-$( - S3%-( $ ' - %$( D.S !-/%< #""# S5 1> ? &&(< & $7( S< - -(&$(($/7 &$(6(($-&($-S3%-( )/ (-J% - &&$ 8$( - &($ 9L $ &<(/ Q5 - #! $)%< #""1 HP E0"!I $(-5 151G (%&((%
012!0"1 31043 @ !" !>> $(-5 >51G &$ S( -$( ' #""! Z P#4" &5 #E $(-5#522!ZP2#1&5>#$(-5!:5
$)(&--$.,/)(7D)(#""!$( 8/-/ &( 7// - -$( - $( 9 :5 ( . -(&$(($--(=$(&&&(<%(=-&$/- &= - (< <( $ 95 5 # 5 ': ( , ) & - %L%--(&$(($%/(5 $%<-3(8(7,5#4(8 6 (($ - &($ (-J% $;/ -$ &- - ,51> ?5
(( -$( - -%- (($ &( & / 6 $%& - %$%$MS$(-8(%6S$<(7($-(5 '7/ %($$7( %&$C/ & /7( ( S7( -S -/( - &/%&($ 9 @ 2 1! $(-5 ! /8/: .( & L ( ($%& ( &- 9 @ !4:5 ); SB( - -$( $ S$%&(%-/(6$B(--/(B8$( &$$.-$(&/(%9 ' #""!ZP#4"&5#E$(-5#5? 22 &5 #22 $(-5 4G ( 7 (/ - $<(7($ -$( ( 22> #=% /-5 &5 >2 :5 ?$ D(&- S &/%( $ &/%&($ - $ -$( (( - -/( -S / S$7 - %/-(($$)($S(-$((($/7$(<<(- -%- (($ 9 ' #""! Z P #4" &5 #E $(-5 #5#5 /8/:5
,&= $( - $ -$( 6 /&($ - -/(($ - $(8/-/->%#""!5=$$)($-) (<- /-- %#""17(%&(5
012!0"1 34043 ,2 !- !- 3
5 /.L)<G
#5 ?-/$%&/&$$V-((7G
!5 $-% ((. 6 &C /%$% - @5 !""533 (( . 8( ;$$(- (<<(-6;-@51 4533G
15 $-% ((. 6 ) 6 $%% - @5 #S"""533 6 ( - &((&($68(-/&G
45 /)8$-G
E5 8$% &( - ., &) 8$% $ $ &/ L - -/( - " D$ -= $(8(($ & &( $%%-/ -/ (< 8/-/ - ?;Y(K;$8.( E E""1 $( B%&(5 -/( & L &$$7/5 %/%$( -$(F : (-(. B%.-/(($$-/($<((&--/(($ ./G <: B&$ &$ . %$(8 ( (% &$)$( -%- -/(($G : &$ (7 $ - $ &/5 ?( %/%$( $( & $( //% /%// $ : <: : (3- (<8/-/-&$&%(=$.,( -)-/()<5%/%$(-$%($$%$C - &) .( $ D$( (( . -/(($ ./ ,)$&& - .//B&/-(/$95!#"E" :5
$%- (< <( - 788(=F /(-&&/F (@@ P(? P
$&($8$%-&/L$(8(/B&(((.,6,88(8/-/ -/&<(.&788
012!0"1