Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/785/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/785/2007 KI-generiert

Contract Formation Based on Conduct Over Ambiguous Communications

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/785/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

A litigant challenged the sufficiency of evidence supporting a finding that a contractual agreement existed, based on communications that were disputed as unclear and insufficient to form the requisite mutual assent, particularly regarding essential terms. The court reasoned that despite the ambiguity in some exchanges, the totality of the documented conduct and subsequent actions demonstrated a clear manifestation of intent to contract by both parties, satisfying the legal standard for contractual formation because the essential terms were sufficiently defined and relied upon by the parties' subsequent performance.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Formation Based on Conduct Over Ambiguous Communications: The court reasoned that despite the ambiguity in some exchanges, the totality of the documented conduct and subsequent actions demonstrated a clear manifestation of intent to contract by both parties, satisfying the legal standard for contractual formation because the essential terms were sufficiently defined and relied upon by the parties' subsequent performance.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Vertragspartei Beweiswürdigung und Beweiskraft Nichtigkeit des Vertrages Vertragshaftung Bestimmtheit rechtlicher Normen Vollmacht

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the decision regarding court costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

            ! !!"  "#$ !!"

%%

&' %()'* * * & '%* (

+,    $ - !!" 



   !  ""#

#"

$$ % $&  "## #'"( # ! )#(( $'$'* +

                

   '.,1'  

* .(

(2 3 #456##(76 #.//74!    89:$& ; ')"<= >3 "!(?@5" .//7")) #   3 :#) #"#' A6" " #B4  #!89:)"@ ""!  !#"##"@ A   # B $$   $ B<@-/@" .//7)" -/6 .//724"!@ #"# @!:!)""  @#= C)33 #4"#)"#:#)3"#  #  )  8 "  8": ) 33 # 4!#   )"#  :#)!)"##)")4!A #!  4#")" ##")45#!  4#")" C2

.2 4"! @ # #"6#! "" @#  " 5 #  "  !:#@ " #"B#"##"@ )"" )"!# )"#!2@ #)" #B4))  "####   "2  )!  # +%  )D8 #"  # )D8#8!")  "! :!   #" = CE @"  .//7 4!##  #!  FEG  !2(HIH )"## #)4"""!:" #!#A #!  4J"    #"@ 2  J) A  :" )"#  )"A    8 #!"!  C2

-2 $ #B)"# # )"!  I .//? !!  ) 2

72 (-)#5".//I"!  !#"##"@ A     # B  K ' L  @ # !#! ::!  ? 6 # .//I ' @ 33#./)#5".//I2

?2 @ #!B  A"# 3!)"#4"!J) A!B  89: $&  )" 3J  I @5" .//I  5# A <  ::#  @ # ) ##" A  )" !# #  '33# 3 # A4  M )"  3#   #"  <: 5# "# J  A4 #M""#"@ )"<J)##  "#    A4    # 3"!A# "" @!  3 "  8" ))!# "    #  A4 #  (- )#5" .//I   33!"# #"@#")!" "#A4B##  !@!  @ J #     # C # # 3   A 6 #   FEG  # # # C   ## 4#@ !#  3 #  A!A4 !# # JA4 )"#2 4"!  J) A! A # !@<# 46# # B  @  ": #  !#!#A43":  !2

I2 "!  0@5".//I 89:$& ) " #J  #!4"!"#@ :#6"2  !"!A



,-./,.//0  '-,1'    "  ! )" 4"! 6# 3  # )"# #  "!  #   "))"##"@  A4"!@ #! )"#  )": ! B 4"'89:  )")"#    3#   A4  A 3 !:"@ #!D2

02  (- @5" .//I 4"!  3"! )) #  B ## !    !:# A 4## # #  )"##   )!" " @ # !#! ### 6# 3 !# "")#JA#)D!4!#5 #   #   ) "   #   #"@  A  @ # ))"#5 # #"< !#5  # )D8: A# # A4 !3  # @  @ #! :!)"@:""#!## !@ #"4"" @"B ) #'"#"2

12 " !   " )) #   0 !5" .//I     3 "!  !    0 @5" .//I2   3 # ""A" A4 @ # !6B # )#  ":# # ! )" 4"! # A 4#  "  )" A:"@ #!3#@ #!#!##!!#A 3 !D# :"@2

H2 " "" "  .7 6@ " .//0 4"!  #"6#! "" #" ## !  2  <: N#"  @  )"  )D8 #" )"  #"5 )D8 AA #::"@!) ):8O)D"2

(/2 @ #!B)"" "!)(H3!@" ".//0A#B 3"  A!A44@ #))"@#BA!   ")) # 0!5".//I@ #!#!"P)"# # " "L@ #!#!@D!)  )2 #3 "6#""2

 "<@ A  ""# 5  A4 <: N#"  @  )"  )D8 #"  3 # ) @ "  "  !  @ "# 3 # !  "")#"# 3 #A# # # @ #!"# @)"< " ")D"!# #! ##"'  A!2N""# 3 # #    "  ##  )D8 A   4 @A  3 # 33 # :"@ )@# )"##"   !"" A 4  )@ # ##" 4 A4 "@Q#  )  ##  "8"8#  @ # @ #!2    ")) A4  # #  33 # ) B A 3 "  ) @52

((2  " #.7 .//0)" " 5! ## A #!   J) A! A4  @ # !#! ")5 "  # ' 33  #'' "#"5AA @ #)D!""#2   A!@ ")"#  )!B4::###" <" <"B  #<2



,-./,.//0  '7,1'    #!   3 "! A   "#    "  <@ :!" #  )"C3P))! C233 "!@ "#"@ !) " #"!#5 #5 " 4@ "6 #D)45  #)"# A #"@ 2

  J) A! A  J :    "#  # !@! " A  "  <@ 4 )  D  """  5A   )#A4 4 #!")" "!)"#!"5"#"# :#!)"3 #A ##)#6"3 2

#! 6#!A "#""<@!# # 33  B @ @" A4  J"P # "  5"  4:  "#  )"  )D8: A#A4!# ##3PB # @":  A4 "!# #5 3 ##B@  2

  !:# )"! ! A4  @ # !#! ::!    4@"  # A4    !5"  @#  3  # )"#   )D!  )    A  #" #")  #!8:#)"4!#5 #2

$#!  6 #"#6")5  #!L8 "6# #  3#  #  # !@!#2   33 "! A  ""#   #!# "##! :!4@ "@#")" #" )""2

3 33 "!@ "!#!)"##! <L44" # J5"#""###")"3 ## !A#6## A4!# #@85 #2

(.2 R:##B# #"#! " )!  #+% )D8 #" B## # J) A!@ " @ ""# 5" <@#I(1!5".//I2 ##" <" @ #!#!"!)" ":L4@ #!<"2

"   A!A""#!# #)"#"5 !)" 3 "!""# #  #"5  # " 5  A )  ) " !   A4 #       #"  #8!")  5"<@ ; >4!# #) @ )")D8 #"#" ##2

 ""#  3 "! @ " !#!  @  6A4 .//? )"  "   " "  2   J) A! A4 @ # " )! @ " "#"@!33 #3")")"4 @ )D8 #" AA   ) #   " L    !# # "" @!  #" 6A4B J 3  )"  22

 "   J) A! A "A4   "P  ""#  I !5" .//I  !# # ### !)! # #"@" #  " 



,-./,.//0  '?,1'   @" #:"@2!# # )5"# "8O#6##B"  5  -B73 )"6"2

! ! 4@ A4 4D@ #)@" #4!!#!8"# A  "  !# # )#9# ))"   @"" )  A  !5" B  # !2   J) A! A4B 4!)A  )# # @ @ #  ")#" # #A4@ #!#!5 :!4!:"B@8O)"# #A # B3 #2!# #4 ) #!:!"" 33 ")"2

 !   6#! A      33 #! "#"!  )  )@ # 4J) A" )"    A  )# # 4@ # ) "#"!   33 #! @  )   )"#  "   :5# A4    !# #  33    3P :!!"  ))"#"  )"  # A4  @ #   # #A4  #  ) !2

)"<A" A ##! ""#!#! @ )" "  )D8 #"   #  6A4 .H 6@ " .//02  ""# "A!##4#)! "!3 #)2

(-2 " "" "  I 6  .//0 4 # !  3 # @ " A4   ""# # )  !"# " A)" #4# @ #!4"!!# # ! # #"'  A! ) A4  #  # A  )# # 4@ # ) "#"!   33 #!   )#  )"#  "2   "))! A  )"  #  #! :!  "  # !6B !#! )"   )#!  ##)" 4##!"3#4"!2

* &%(

(2  @"#4"#2?I2(#2821 :@ "S": #  6   "  .. @5" (H7( ;>  " 5 #  "  T# # A### )"!@B4"#2?I  3!!"")"# :!!"" #" I#5" .///; >"# @B 3!!""S"'89:5 :# "# S  #!S @5  #!.?6 (H1.; >2$)!#)" 6:"S)<#  !#5 2

.2  #"6#!  #) #  @#  6"  #  )!##  "" # "@5;"#2?I2(#282H#I/ >2

-2  $S"#2-/2(#2 S"! #N#")SJ"   " # B S  #! "AS  #  #"@  )"  )")" 3#2  # ##S)D!A "!  ! 'N#"##"@ 



,-./,.//0  'I,1'   N#")"!5#"!S#") B ASSM#)J :"  AS "@Q# ) ;"#2772(#25 >2

 $ S"#2 -/ 2 .    "!   )  # )")"#  B  :"@ #!3#2#(B(?6"3#!:<"(IB-/6" 3#:"@ #!D#-(BI/6"3#:"@;"#2 7? 2 . #2  B   >2  D  ## 3# :"@ "A S"! 5  )  "!)#! @5  N#" "! S5# "  @ ) ;"#27?2- >2

""N#2)5 !(?3!@" "(HHH; ..I,H1> " 53!!" " !"!A) )"# 3)"!@ B S"#2 77 2 ( #2 5 S"#2 7? 2 -    # # # AS )"  ) # S  #"#  #  6:  " )@ # S!"#" "A   "# )"#  <"   S)<  6# 3  #2     )@ " S))"! #   S #  S#" S# )   #! B  "!     )  3 J! )"    3# :"@2   5  S  #"#  A  6: #  ) 5  #! S 3 :"  #    !@<"2  # #AS 3#D"!  # )"S"!  #"#  #"@  # @! )"  )"5<  #! A   ##  3    : <"#      <" # )"@A! ; (HHH )2?7>2

$S"#2(I2. #"@ A S#)"!)#!@5#J S5 :# SN#")#!; +(.7I- 2-5#"!3!">2"  )# "" @" AS )  A  "!) # B #  " #<" S #"@  @5B#!)"##A #!B #S8:#   "#2   # !@# #!   )# J :" S " ! AS  "@  )   SN#" )"!5# "! S @ " 5# #"# ")"!)#!#"@ )")")"3#;"#2772 (#25  3 U$(HHH @..?->2

 )"#  " S# ) "!)#! @5  #"@  A   @ # ) B   ## )"S"!;"#2(I2.#2 >2

"!  # #"##"@ S"!)#  N#"# ! A S)@ ###"S"!AS "@Q#) 2"#<" @5  S  )  # J ! B S   " #<" #" #2   # # )" J)  33 # ) )" A 3 "  )    @5 ; " "  $  "# @ B S  #!  89:,6@ " .//-,.?>2

72   S)<  @ # ## S5" SJ "   S )@ # J :"   ""#AS"@) )## ## )" S#"#" " "# # ##"@ @52



,-./,.//0  '0,1'   $S: #    ##  )"  S"!  # ))" A 4!##  #!##" <"#3":  !#"#A4)###" 4 A4))"#)" #"@ N"A4)" ) ) D2"   J) A!A #"5 # # ## # 4"! )   : ! J) A#   33 #!A4)"#"" 33!"#)#2

  )# !:# )"! ! A  "   !)#  # !# # @ # 4"!"A4 4@!5".//I4J) A ###)" ")#"# #A4@ #"!##" <"2 #4!#! !@A!) 5  #!A" ")# #)::"@" ## 2

"  "  !    A! A 4!##  #!  4"! )@ # J) A" 33 #!C:5#C#)""))"#B)#)"! #B " ") )"#  "2

 " 5!)" #:" 3 @A!)"""##" )D"#)"AS# ## 3 @A! #) )"@A"!  "!  "#"##"@ 2 ! :"@ #! 3 # S# )# ) # AS S # ) J :"  S"! AS "@)#"@ ###"#"@"@) 2 " # "S)<A# # "))"##"@ !# # @ @!" #5# #!"52  ""# 4 4 " ) !:! @ "@!" #5#8"8!@) @#"!  

 !3  # @   ""# )   33!"# # # #! :: "   A  # #   "))"#  #"@  6A4B 45##  4 @)#!# ##"'  A!! #2

@A )"!<  D  !""A)#A4) # ""# !# #  #"@  @5    S"#2 (I  2  !A S#   <" 3# @ A  ""# S# "#"@!  # @ #!"# @2

 $4: #   A 3 #   ## 3#  # "@! A 4 # !  # )#   3":  #!  4"! #  #  #" !:!   "##B#" A4 3# :"@ #!D#:"@A  ))"T# 6# 3 !2 "##  " 5  ! 4 )  # 3 )"# #  4!"#"4))"! # 4  #"# ; +(.I1( 2I(.- (?. 2.#"!3!">2

 "##""#"6#!2





,-./,.//0  '1,1'    %  / (.  %()'* * * & '%* (



  01 +

(2 !""""@52

 01

.2 "6##2

-2  #A)"!"#:"# #2

72 3"  )"#    AS )@# 3"" "" #"  )"!# ""N#   !   -/ 6" <  # 3 #  )"<  " 5 3!!" ;$8V O"83A II//7  >)"@ ""# <"" # )5 3"!#J"#21. 3!!"" " 53!!"(0 6  .//? ; +>U  ! "  ""  #  A"    # 3 # D)"@#)"#" :#"""## "U  # N#" "!  " 5 3!!" )" @  )#  )" @  !#" A J  #   4"#2 7.  +2  )"!# ""N# #  ) <  )   ""# @A!D)"@ @#N#"6 #B4@ 2  :"33 <"  "! #=              ++ W" $  W



 ) 3" )"!# ""N### 3 !J)"# #$"!#" #S##B S! )":"33



,-./,.//0