Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/784/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/784/2007 KI-generiert

Securities Repurchase Damages Calculation Dispute

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/784/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The proceeding concerned several claims arising from a business transaction involving the sale and repurchase of securities, where the appellate court was asked to review the application of various statutory and contractual provisions regarding warranties, representations, and the determination of damages following a breach. The court reasoned that the plain language of the relevant statute dictated that the proper measure of damages was based on the difference between the contract price and the market value at the time of the breach, rather than the actual repurchase price paid by the aggrieved party, because the statute provided a specific, mandatory measure of recovery superseding common law or contract terms, and that certain exclusions cited by the opposing party did not apply under the facts presented.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Securities Repurchase Damages Calculation Dispute: The court reasoned that the plain language of the relevant statute dictated that the proper measure of damages was based on the difference between the contract price and the market value at the time of the breach, rather than the actual repurchase price paid by the aggrieved party, because the statute provided a specific, mandatory measure of recovery superseding common law or contract terms, and that certain exclusions cited by the opposing party did not apply under the facts presented.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Wertpapierumsätze Schadenberechnung Streitwert Wert der Umsätze Ertrag Bestimmung des relevanten Marktes

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for the allocation of court costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

            !! ""#  $%& ""$

''

() '*+), , , ( )', *

-.    ! / ""$ 



   !  ""#

#"

$$  $  $ $$$$$  # ! %"#"&'#()+,- .

                

   20/32  

, 0*

*4  "  # !!!  5 !6" 0,,& 7"8 9 " !7!    7"##   :" 9   # "9 9# ; $< 7"8   $$  $  $ $$$$$; 27"8 <# :=#"9"# 7" 7##4

04 " "" "  *' (!9" " 0,,1  99    ! > 79 "#" "! # #!7":(( #:"2 9  #!; <"#!(#" 4

'4  0* (!9" " 0,,1 :         ("! : #!"! ?:  !# # : 7 6  #!" #(9"6>"?=#4

@4 """ "0@(!9" "0,,1( #7"#!" ?#"(## ?  9 #!#!77!#!9 ( ? "!(#"   #"!4

&4 "A!    #A00"0,,1 $$  $  $  $ $$$$  "(! ("# :8   "  ( >994

    BC! ? ## " 8"  79 #  7"!9 " : #!"=# 7"  C7"## >#" "# #!": #"#  !7D"79 #7"!#">:#" 7"##  $  97"## !7!7"" "4

 7" "# !?= 7"## 7" #!(   # 7"  "#  :77"  # 7 !7"9    C"# " D #!"! ?:7"8 " !8  " C# ( C"#  "  "  7# # "" # 9"# 7"  "# !  #  " # 7  9C!   #"E!98"4

  (  !#! "9! ?   7 8 9"!   "  !7D  9 9 # !7"! > ##    7   *& (!9" " 0,,' # > ? "9 #? ##!89#:!# ## #!9    7"8   7"!!# !7 > )74      # "!   ?99 "" #7"!9 "    #9!7D?" "" #  #"? " !   # 9C!"#" # 7"8"#4

14 """ "039" 0,,1"! " 6#"   #  -" )    #"B#! "" #" ## !  4



/'0&&/0,,1  2'/32   ( #9 "?: !# #" ! 9!(#? #  ((" # 7"# #A" ?F(# #( :"!9 ("# 7"66  #!  "!7"  "  (    !7A # ? :# ((# 9#  ?  :# 7" # 7 ? 8  (      " 0,,&  7  ?   9" #  !7D  !#! 7  9"# # #  D7 # 4: #!"!# #"7?:" #G=#"# "7"##  #" #7"!7D48C?  ##9" "#!:#7"?A(  A!7D: 7    !?#"!4  "! #8"    79 " #"   " ! 2 # #!7" 4

+4 " BC#  + B # 0,,1  " 6 #  "    #-" )! !7!###"  " 6!4

34 """ "&#6"0,,1 "B#""4

"77?:>#" #" ##" "H:"! 7"!? "#7"# :C #!? "# ! "7"D""" #"7 "6 C# ? !: " " 7"( "9 "F" #?!   (! " ## =    #" #! )6  #! > ##" "  "" #"  !   (! "    "  "   7"  ! ! ">:7 ####I)#( # ""76# "" 7"  ! ?  " # ! " 7"  !#" " "  7"!## "!" ":" "!4

54 " "" "  + #6" 0,,1 "!  " 6  !  ""#  !  9 (  > 79 " #"   " !    !(# " "# (>:# 7" 7##4

*,4 " "" "  0' B9 " 0,,+  ""#   #" 7" #  !   "7")6"7! " 6## # 0+ !6" 0,,1    :77# > :((   BC : #"#    #">$ 4

""#H

2 ?  "   !#6   7""#  #!  ' " 0,,'? (!"!>7" 8"!7$7  79 "7"C!""(#"7 ##"" "J

2 ?##" 8"7" )"CC#   #"# 9#(  8"  #!"=#D2" !7"!"7!77  *551J

2 ? #"8 C"9# ## #   #!  "  # 9(  "B" #"7"8( #"8"J



/'0&&/0,,1  2@/32  

2 ? 7" :7"   D2"   $  !  !C#  ',,("4 7"   7"  7  #  7"#  7#   0,,("4 7"   7"   9  "7C #  ##FC# 

2 ?:>7#"0*B 0,,&#>? " !#! 7!  !#6 # ! 2  ; ?  G# # ':'1,("4 7"  <  $ # 7"9 >    ?  "9   D2!7D ;*:1*'("4  "# $ K ':@,'("4  "#" # <    7"## # 7  9""  #" 6#   :#"# *:'1*("40,(9"J

2 ?:#?  ###" 8">C "7"9 7" ## 77!J

2 ?:" 7"C"   "6# !# ### #  7 #!   "#   "   7"=#! >       !#!  !"!  (( #    0,,@ 7"  D7"# B   " #  '*   0,,& 7"  )6" 77  "  "  #?"(! ##"6:"# ( # !#" J

2 ?  05 96" 0,,&  " "  ##(  ("! :#" #!  ""  7"?7# #2? "#" # B"2>>  7"F(  "9 2:9 #7##7 #!J

2 ? :#" #! 77  "  "  !"! ?  "" " # G =#"    ":!# #7!!!#"2#7J

2 ?:#"2#7  1 #6" 0,,&  ## !#! "# "!  7# 7" 9!   "   ## *@:@50(" 6 ( !  05 7#6"7"!!#7""" !"!:# 7" 7##J

2 ?$:#  #!># "? ##  !# # # ! 7# ?: :7 # # 8"#   D2" J ?:       :9 "  ! 7" 2= " ? : #!"!!B" #!B>)7 0*B 0,,&J

2 ?7"!" #"057#6"0,,&!7! 7 ##"7" 8"!7!(#" 

2 ? ## 7 #  !#! ! 7"  BC : #"#   0, !6" 0,,& #!8: #!"!

2 ? "!:#"7""## !") #  (   9 "  ?:  !# # 9  "9   !(#" #""#!6"0,,&

2 ?:"7!7!7 #7!7!# "#" 7" 8"!7" 



/'0&&/0,,1  2&/32  

2 ? 7" !    + 7#6" 0,,1  BC : #"#   ! :(( " (#   7 #  7! 77 6 7"8 9 " "9! ? :?=#:9 #77" :!#6 "?7"!9 #C > :#"  #!"=#   "   ?: :!# # 77"7" !9" 77"##

2 ?  *3 7#6" 0,,1   :# 77! >  #

2 ?  )6" 7!  " 6 #  #     # !!  0+!6"0,,1?:  7"# # D !#" ">7"# "? "9 #!#!7" 9!  7 #!   "#J ?:   7"  " BC! ! " ?  ?=#"6# #$7 8B# ( # 9 ####  :((##   ## "# "!  7# 6 "   " J ?:   BC! ? :!# # > #"# ?  BC : #"#  9 #    ( " 7"!" >  9# C#  7# 6 :77"#"  !!# !  ( ##  7 6B# ( ? 6B# ( ## ?# >  )( :#   :6  (    C#  !FJ ?: !?   9 #!  BC : #"# >7!#":?=#7"!   "# ## "  8"("D"?  #  D7!# 8"4

4 #  7"#  7"  + B  0,,+  ""#  !C! ? " #C"!!  !7"# B   "#9!6 0,,*>(!9" "0,,'#>?D2!7#( #9)")" >A!#6 #)7 # "A4""#( "!:9 "7"7"# 7"!##  > ( " 9 " > :!C"  "  4   D7 ?! ?: ) # # 7#79 "#" "!7D( 9 " ? 9 ## 9!:#" :# 7" 7#4" #((#? :"C# #!#!!#"!>!#" #4

 ""#  7" #  7"829"6  : #""C# "   !(# "  ?BC  9 9 #7"!!'"0,,&"  9"? 9 #!#! #" ##>? 9 #( #"!4# "  ?7 #! "#" !# #!( ##?:  " #777!>?:7 #" "! 4

*04 " "" "  5 B  0,,+  ""#  "  #! 7"8  " 6  !7"9 """?:4

*'4   "" " #!" "  #!   !C# 7" #  ##"  BC : #"#  9  #!  *0 B  0,,+ >  "!  ?  BC  ? 9 " 7"  #   "?=# #  7"7 :F" #!" "#    !7E#   " !  # 9" # ! " >  7"!)   :(( " ( # ##(  ""?" ?  ( # :6# "  #  7" 7# 



/'0&&/0,,1  21/32   7"# 7  7"!#" ?:  F     9  27 #   7   # "4

*@4 $"!#!C"!>BC"4



, ('*

*4 ("!#>:"#4&14*#4)4* C9 "L"C #  B   "0096"*5@*;< " 6#"  M# # ?### 7"!9>:"#4&1 (!!" "  7"#  C!!"  " #  "    1 #6" 0,,, ; < ? #"# 9> (!!"0,!6"*5@1"L"29  # "9 9#; $<4

04  # C7"#"" #99:"!#" "# #!   "    :#  7" 7## !7! 7"  " " # " ? !B>!#!##!4 "?!"##6"" "7" !#F"7 #7!!7!#"7" 8"!7" 7"6 ( #C# !F##4

'4 7##( #? "!  (""6:"#4 @5   ? 7"!9 # ? :""  # "" 7" !" #  !   ?  7"##" B#  7"##9?: #!"!:#7:"  " 6!#7!##"# #" 4:#!C#"#   ("!# > :"#4 &3 4 *    ? :#  " 6 #  "    #  ?  7" "!   ""#  #"9? #7!##4((#""##   !>894

@4 #":"#4@+ #" ##" ""N #!"=#7" 9!7"!7!"##9C"!H <:"!7"!? "# 6<7"# :C #!? "#! "7"D"" " #"7 "6 C# ? !: ""   7" ( " 9 "  F  " # ?  !   (! " ## =  <#" #!)6  #!>##""""#"!  (! "    "  "   7"  ! ! " > :7 ####I) <  # " "76 #  "" 7"  ! ?  " # ! " 7"  !#" " "  7"!##  "!" "  :"  "!4



/'0&&/0,,1  2+/32   &4  :78 (" #  ##" ?  ""#  "7 #     #  7 ?: :# ( " 9 "  " # !# :   "  " 4"! #!>79 "#" " !(#" :7 ":F#"9"  ?#>7 #! "# ( 79 "!#F"7 #7!?:!7!#"7" 8"!74 :# 7" !?# > B# # #" ? : # !    "(!  " #  #"   "  :"! !## 7"! ! ?:  #   6 >  ""#     BC ! "":77"# "! !(#" 7"BC : #"#  9  )"C!  : #"#    7 #4  "89" "   7!#" "BC" #77"#B# ( 4 



/'0&&/0,,1  23/32  

'  1 *0  '*+), , , ( )', *



  23 -

*4 !""""964

 23

04 "B##4

'4  #?7"!"#C"# #4

@4 ("  7"#    ?L 79# ("" "" #"  7"!# ""=#   !   ', B" 8  # ( #  7"8  " 6 (!!" ;$)O P")(? 11,,@  <7"9 ""# 8"" # 76 ("!#D"#430 (!!"" " 6(!!"*+ B  0,,& ; Q<J  ! "  ""  #  ?"    # ( # F7"9#7"#" C#"""## "J  # =#" "!  " 6 (!!" 7" 9  7#  7" 9  !#" ? D  #   :"#4 @0  Q4  7"!# ""=# #  7 8  7   ""# 9?!F7"9 9#=#"B #>:9 4  C"(( 8"  "! #H              QQ R" $  R



7 ("7"!#""=### ( !D7"#   ?L>L(( (!!" " 7"C"((





/'0&&/0,,1