Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/774/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/774/2007 KI-generiert

Contract Formation Dispute Regarding Financial Instruments

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/774/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The case involves a dispute over the validity of an alleged contract, where the court needed to determine if the required elements for contract formation, specifically an offer and acceptance leading to mutual assent, were present based on the parties' conduct and communications, including concerning certain financial instruments and associated rights. The court reasoned that despite the parties engaging in negotiations and making certain provisional exchanges, the totality of the documented interactions, including ambiguous language and the absence of a clear, unqualified agreement on all essential terms, demonstrated a lack of the necessary meeting of the minds, thereby precluding the formation of an enforceable contract.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Formation Dispute Regarding Financial Instruments: The court reasoned that despite the parties engaging in negotiations and making certain provisional exchanges, the totality of the documented interactions, including ambiguous language and the absence of a clear, unqualified agreement on all essential terms, demonstrated a lack of the necessary meeting of the minds, thereby precluding the formation of an enforceable contract.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Gültigkeit des Vertrages Finanzinstrument Annahme des Antrags Prozesserledigung Mäklervertrag Haftungskonkurrenz

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

           #$$$%#&''( )#+#&''*

,,)

- ),.- )  -, .

/ +  + 0   &''* 



   !"#$%  &&'

'&

((   )*&+ ,&  - . ' ! . +/0+

          !"   

   .#13.  

 1.)

"4 !"5//'&+ !6 "&'7&#$$$6&0  )'&6& 4 8 *   - '! )+& 0& 9 6  '64 *!6&! ) '!&! ' 0&  '&  :'  !  "5;3 " !"55#'!#$$%4

#4 &'6!& #$+& #$$%56'7&#$$%) '!&!7!!:  ! 6&''   )&.'& '! 6    !  !   6  + ::'2$+7&#$$%4

24 ) '!&!)' & '9):: &!< 6'= .6&0>' 5 ,+ & #$$/   ''   '!  ?@<4    )  '!   ' ! -) !' '  6 7   -& '':    )!' '6&6 '6'66&' 4

A4 '&6!6&):: ')6 = .6&0) >-'B' : !   ) '!&!  &!6 6& && &  "& :!+& & #$$/ -)  !'! '& '  !  & 6&  &   '!4  ::'  66&' '        6& ' ?  - '  ! 6&  :7& '   6 0  +&'::&'6 !7')!#$$%6&70&6 &' 4 )'& 6&'      :     6!  6&70  <   -  &  <&C    !' '  ::   )&< &  <& ''  &    ?& & -  6 '  + :  &4 &  &  )D + ' 6  6  6 7&0?&'''6!& 4  '<+  ?@< = .6&0   >      &  ) '!&! 9  '   )&.?@< = .6&0  * E> :  -) !'&   6' '  6'4

%4 '&6!6&* E) '!&!6&! !-)+ '6&!! 9) & 6'    :  9  &0?  &+  7  +'    ' -) + ' &6&  ''+ &' -  &!:& &69: 6 7&:! <&!6&70-64, '''''  &0?  -)'!'7 #$&#$$/6&"    !9&D- &' :  'F'& 6 76&<&&: 4

/4 & !    "2 +&  #$$/ )   6&! ) 6' '  6'  ) '!&!05,+ &#$$/4 !&!-'& &'B!&'    " .  )!' ' 6  &  <&&  :   ) '!&!0&-)'.F & '9)6 3, #$$% - '!&)6 )+& 0&:7& -96 '6'-) ' 0&   B :'4   '  &'&  6 7 9 6  '6 6&  6'4)'&6&') '!&!)+ '66& ')'''' &0?



1222"1#$$/  .213.   &+   ) '& !'7 ' !'&' -  <&   :  !' ' &!4

34 & ) '&!  &   ' & ) '!&!  :&! 66 '  '  #2  #$$/4&!:0&9&& &&) :&' 96' ':  "; +&  #$$/ '''' -) + ' !6!   6&  6 ) &': 4: '+ &6& &-: G!& ' &<&&,:&0&''-)6) )&6!'!'&+!4

;4 &!  #", '#$$/) &,'!)66 ' ' :-))!''   ' F'&   -)   6 6 ) 6 7  '! &0'  <& ' - 6''6 7  '!&'& '6&''&&+ )6D& ?&'&+&6 ''&6 &' 4

54 "A6'7&#$$/) '!&!6&) '&!  &' & '&,'' &&4  '' )66&! '   )  !<' -) + ' 7   6 7  '!&0'<&'-6& &: G!! "5;3 !' '  &  <&&  , :&0& 9    '' -) 6 )  )& 6 !'! '&+!4  ' 9 )'    !   ' 9 )'& )  '!?@<4

"$4 &-F' & 7!) '!&! <!6&'' &&'"3'7&#$$/'6&!!&!+'6&4

""4 &!62$+7&#$$/) '&,'&&' : -) '  6&' )!'7 &  6 7  '! &!  :  G! 6& <&&:&0&4 '9)'''' &) :&' 6' ':  '   ' )'&! ? '!  "; +&  #$$/ & -  &&'+ '  -!-)+ '!6!!,9+'  & &:'4

"#4  & 7+-!6&' 9 6&' 6& '  #; & #$$3 9 -  &&'  )' 6 6&!'!4  &6&!''  )   6&! ! -  :  G!   &&' ' && +!  *   ; :!+& & #$$/ ' -)   7'  6&  HH  #A   #$$/4  )'  ' & '  ?@<  & )6  '  ! .&  !'! +&'   :+&  % +&  #$$/  A +&  #$$;4  ' 6' &'   ?@<  2$ '7& #$$/ &   )!' ' 6 6&!'!  '&@4    ' ) 6+ '6''&-) !' '&<&&, :&0&4 '9&&'& ' !6&)E6 <!!&C: '6 &?&?)6 6 6'7&#$$/: '6'&@&?@< ')6:&  6 '7&#$$/4

"24  B 0    !'! : B! 6&  & 7  !  "; +&  #$$34  &&'B6!-)+ ' & ': &0? -,-)9



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

6&' '6& '!& 4

"A4 *&- !'!<&!9,<&4



 ,.)

"4  +&'  )&'4 %/  4 " '4  ?4 ;     <+  & K&< '  ,   &##+7&"5A"=> & 7'&  G' ' -''' 6&!+9)&'4%/ :!!& &  6&'  <!!&  & '  &    / '7& #$$$ = > -  ' &' + 9    :!!& & K&.?@< 7 <' & ' K  '!K +7  '!#%, "5;#= >4

*6!'6&,<&K60'  !'7 4

#4 '&,'!:&'! 6&!+6& &&'&+7=&'4%/' /$ >4

24   ' < 6&' &  -'   )6' '  6'   &&' ' 6& !-'& '9  '!)&.?@<4



1222"1#$$/  .%13.   A4 )&!)& '9)  '!?@<-) '6'6'=&'4;4 "'4: >4'&!6'!6'9F'&6!?@&- ' 6!96'& '&+ +7'96&'  6&9&) '!<&' '- '&' & ': &=&'4"%4" +'&+ <&0"& , '#$$2>4)6' '6'6&  B!!'L6 '! '&+  ) 6&' )'.9. &  :'!  :& &  '&+  . 6 6&! !' )B&&' + '!&' +& !.-)&! '6F?!6&  ?!&'96&')'&6&' 6 ' 96'&'&+  +7)&'4"/ -  6 -'+'! 6&&''&+ ) 6&!'   6 7  '!:: '-'  '6 - )&! 6' && 9  6  ' -'  7&  6D&6'' 4

 &!- 6&' :6&:  B6'+' 6::& &96D&'' 6 7  '!&'B < 76'F'&  !&!6'9F'&6!= ("#%%; 4/"#2#"/ 42 '&!:!&>4

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



1222"1#$$/  ./13.   %4 )60&&')66&! !6&'<)' + '!&?&?! :& &&' :B  ' 6&&!= > ,+ & #$$/ ' ) 6 ::'!  &?&? )6  &'   4  &+? 9 6&' & :!+& &#$$/' !'B)' + '!&?&?!"$$ I'::'!&?&?)6 -))& '': 9)-) '  "2 & #$$/ 6&0  &664 + '! 9 &  B6 '   &&' :&!) 6&&& &"&:!+& &#$$/-)&'& ' 6&70 <- & <& : -)  !' ' ::   )&< &  &   ?& & - : &  :  9  ' & 6&   6 '  6&70 :  & ' -) 6   &0? )!' ' 6  6 74    '  ) ' ! !' ' :! 9 +!& : & )6' '  6'   &&' ' )B <&  6&+ &0'   6 7  '!  <&):'4

*6 06& ' )+0&&'-&&'+ ' & ':   &0?-  ' F'& &+!''&    '6& ')'''6)6 6 76&):'4 &6 ')'&!? '!' !'";+& #$$/4 '96&-  '''!6+ &<&&):':&'''&-)'.F & '  ?@< 6&  6' )6  )+& 0& 9 6  '6  &' -)  6'F'& 6 76&<&&):'&&'=:4 ( "5 #$$/ AA1$%>4

&&'' ': -: G!M<!"5#$$/ '- + ')&& +&* :!+& &#$$/!' '9F)6& :&0&,-)9-)' <& ''&+!4&:&'''&- : G!)'!<' & '?@<'-)! .&!'!+&' :+&0%+& #$$/4: )< ''&6 7  '!<&6& ,:'&<:&'''&-&&')6& ' 6 09'!<&4

+- 6&!0 D ''&-&&')+ '6 6 7  '!&0'<&6&: 6&0!6&',: 6 &9  :   )! #$$/4  !- )' 9 ,' ' '& - ) ' !  6&!  6' '6'4

/4 :!&& 'F'&&,'!4



1222"1#$$/  .313.   ,  ").1  ),.- )  -, .

 

  2

"4 !&&&&+74

 2

#4 &,''4

24  '-6&!&'<&' '4

A4 :&  6&'    -K 6+' :&& && '&  6&!' &&F'   !   2$ ,& 0  ' : '  6&0  & 7 :!!& =*?P Q&?:- //$$A  >6&+ &&' 0&& ' 67 :&!'B&'4;# :!!&& & 7:!!&"3 ,  #$$% = (>C  ! &  &&  '  -&    ' : ' D6&+'6&'& <'&&&'' &C  ' F'& &!  & 7 :!!& 6& +  6'  6& +  !'& - B  '   )&'4 A#  (4  6&!' &&F' '  6 0  6   &&' +-!D6&+ +'F'&, '9)+ 4  <&:: 0&  &! 'L         *D+  E 8        

 6 :& 6&!' &&F''' : !B6&' '*&!'& 'K''9 K! 6&<&::



1222"1#$$/