Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/763/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/763/2004 KI-generiert

Property Transfer Restriction Validity

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/763/2004
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Teilweise gutgeheissen (Partially Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The petitioner, subject to certain statutory restrictions on the transfer of a property interest, executed a deed that purported to transfer that interest, and the respondent, who acquired the property from the purported transferee, sought judicial declaration that the transfer was valid and effective under state law. The court reasoned that the transfer restriction, being a valid covenant running with the land, rendered the subsequent deed void because the grantor lacked the requisite authority to convey the interest, thereby affirming the validity of the restriction and invalidating the transfer.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Transfer Restriction Validity: The court reasoned that the transfer restriction, being a valid covenant running with the land, rendered the subsequent deed void because the grantor lacked the requisite authority to convey the interest, thereby affirming the validity of the restriction and invalidating the transfer.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Eigentumsübertragung Feststellung der Gültigkeit öffentlich-rechtliche Eigentumsbeschränkung Grundpfand Konzedent Dienstbarkeitsvertrag

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the final order to regulate the distribution of costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

               #$%&%#'(($ #)*+#'((%

!!

, !-, .  ,! .-

 +( / 0 '((% +1  23 0 



4  5    46666666666   5     6666666666







- . 7.-  . -.  ../0  !"#$%&'($)*))+,*-



                ! "

   2*132 

 8-

)4 0..*)/*(()$ .5,./%.6.2 %+.7809:/;<<<<<<<<<<.%./% 50/8$9/%)0/=)---4../0>?./% ,..50?./%/8%.),.)--3>.9  . ?0.  , 9 %.  ),.)---4  /  ?0$ 0%0  *) 0/= *((($ 0. .,$ . % >  %.?,.%!80>?9/%)0/=)---4

*4  .  # /. *(()$  @.  :/ ;<<<<<<<<<<$ :/ <<<<<<<<<<$.A0%+ //.. /.+? B9?.%.9%.),.)---0A94 C%.>0>/+,.00 %..0*"/)--33,.)--3 % =.  =.   ,0. =...$ > ?%0.$ .@@..$ ,. 50  /%..  D0  0%   ./% %.$ > %  ?,.  .@/0   .  /.+ ?. % ./%  >  ? > % $ 9  @.  ?0 *((($ >? ,. %%. %  =  ?. . >? %. 0%   /4

&4 ,.090/.$.$%.*3/.*(()$?0@009?,. ?@@.?.,..06 7$/E>. ..5..0=.9?.4

#4 .3A.*(()$:/<<<<<<<<<<%..0/  /0. .   /+$   <<<<<<<<<<$  >? ?%. 05.+//+$.%0%/.9F0    5.. /../A.0../0. 9  0 %.  /.?,. )--34 :/ <<<<<<<<<<   %0.0 > ?.@./.+>.?%./+0.05/%!90/.54

"4 .3A.*((*$:/<<<<<<<<<</..4

'4 ,.0 9  %$ ? $   %0,.  *- A,. *((#$    A4 9,=..0$.@./>>0..>0 0  *) / *(()  >     " /. *(()  ? / 9 ?%%0..  .=4   @$ . +, >?. ? % 0 > ?./%?0%!>.@.0/8%.),.)--3 >  . ?  ,  ) ,. )---$ . 9 ?0 0 ? 0.  ?04C%.>>?>?.+.@ / >  %. ? % ! 0 >?9 /%  )0/=)---4 ?  @. /> > ?0   ,. % 

 1)#-#1*(()   2&132  ?./%.=..0 =A.,  0%  / , 0/= *(((  >? D ?. > .  ? % 0%0  / % F ? >? .5.>?>!,.9=..%./%%,.! %004

G4 000*,.*((*4

34  .  *G @0,. *((#$ :/ <<<<<<<<<<$  0..+   %0  ? ..$  .@/0  .=  0+   /+  C%.>0$ >9,=..0$>0..0.%,>  /+  ,. 9 ?05  >?2/!/ 0. =4   % ,0 > H> /=.  )" ,. *(()  @. ,. >  @0. ,. /%4.$050>/+0.?.%.0  0%  / ?. % ./%   ?0.,. %$   0%I.%>?,.,5.@@.0,.%  %04 %+  $  /0/. .//0. ,. 00 %=04 :/<<<<<<<<<<0%00>?0.>%.5.> /,.000%0.,/4 0%>.? F%../0. . ?.@./.+. .%%0.5/0.4  C%% .>?0.2/!/+%.%.9%.59/+$>? .%.%?/.9>?.0..@@...54

-4 .)'/*((#$? /.%..4

)(4 % .=*&%/=*((#$:/<<<<<<<<<< @.0%00>..,0/0.?.5 >/+,.4 %+,.@@./0>$.,.00 .@/0$/+../0%0/$:/<<<<<<<<<< 9%0.>?>....0%+/+$ .+0%%00.%?0> ,.4



 !.-

)4 .5,.?5..A...6700/.@.0..0$+ )J*((&$ .=.6 B7$/%0 .>A5$   %0.   ,.2%0.$ .> %%0  .K A5 64)4"' 74

B.9?.?0..KA5% .=@00

6 L7*GA,.*((# 6 L)&( )('7$ .5,. %0$

 1)#-#1*(()   2#132  )&@0,.$  .%.. .. 5 64 )'* 7 %/  B  .05  $ 9 . A5 ..$  ?  ?0.  ,CA54

B     . %=.$  L $   !   )A. *((#$ @./0 >  .%.. .. ..  .  % .0.$D$@/.@006 L)&('74

*4 @/0/ 9 ?4 & 4 &  .%.. ..$   .. ,?0,.5.%, //..   /.+ ?2.,..0  00 /. ?@@.  .=    .$   . .>   . /.+? 6@4."'74

B/%0%A5?%+..0=.4

&4  . @00   %. 500  .   .  '=*(((6 M3&(4)70,.5)A,.*((&$D  /= /.@..   /.  ?2.,..04   ?%+ / @. 05. %  .%..  ,.5 A>? &)0/=*((*$05%..%>A5. ? % 9 %  .0.  /.@..  .   ?0  @. %0. 9   0/.   0.. ..5. 6 L )*G  #'G$ .4)$ )*)  &3'$ .4 )=M @4 05/ .%.. ..$ 4 3* 4)  74  %0 ..5   0> C/.0 9  /.+  .%...?2.,..06 M3&)4*(7+5/  ,.5 A>? &) 0/= *((*6 M 3&)4*()74  .%.. 05 +.0.4

#4 7 B?5.   ,=..0  $ . 8  .   0@0 C . '-   3#   . @00  ?2,..  ,.,  *(0/=)-#'6 B7$,=A>?&)0/=*((*4 >0.A9/%.@.. 0..>040..>.?%@.?=A?@/0 /%.%@ A50$>A5% /.+    .@4   >.   %%.$ ?=,.$  %5.   ..  0.$  4 *( 9 *#  . @00   %0 /..., 6 M B)G*4(*)7   %%.= 9  %0 ,.064-' BM,9?.. ./%.N O)--*%4&-".4*74

=7  0.   // 9 .  /.   //.. 64*( 4 )  74   .00 // =,0 .    00 /. 9 ?.09=%..A0.% 64*)4) M )--*%4&-#.4*74.+>0..

 1)#-#1*(()   2"132  .@.0$%//EA..=%.$/.AE   J/ //.>0M ?5. ?  /. 9 0%.$  .@..0%0%@. //E0..% + %...4

,.,>$@/0/9?44 $0. %G+/A,H>G+/A%+H>..,/4

7 /.?2.,..0$. ?C..%..05  05/. =.5 ?/... 9 .@.  0..  %. //0$   >? %, ! ,80 % . ..4  ,. @.  .5 >  %,   .@.. ? 0.. /...,     9 >  .@..   . ./=  %..%9?/...$>.%%0>?=%,4 / .$ .  .@..     0  >?. C. @@.,/   9  A$ . 8  .   @   0.  ..?,.6 )--*%4&-".4&=M )-3#%4)*3.4)=74

7  ?%+$  0.. ..5.   *) / *(()4 .. >  @. />$*(()$H>0.@!0)",.$.=.>0. 00%./ 3./ ,.4 %%> 0...00.@.0P%FP/*(()$0. , 9 0 0  &( ,.4 $    0  " /. *(()4 %$ ?.0../0?%%%0%,9>.@.. .4+$,A.%/.0$.8..0 >00.A0/%.4

"4  ?$  >.  ?,  . ? % 04 B / ..5.  >.  ,. .$ /50  / .,$ ?0 % =00@..  %. %  %0. 0.  K.+/ /. %00/4

'4 7 C/Q4#34* $.Q0%0/%K /.%+..$.0>%K /. %00  0%F   /M   0 %  %0. 0. . Q0  %,. % D  @. , . 9  %.>Q.%0/K/.+//E. .4

=7 .. >  @. /> ?.0 ../0$  A.%  .= @00/.++..,/E%R@. , . 9  %.S$ . @  ?. 9  0 % 8.>  / >.   =.  @I %/  ?. ?.  ? ,. % % /%.   00/.   ,. >..4   %  %  C%.  @0 =A., 

 1)#-#1*(()  2'132  ?0@..00M.?5.=.%F,..@. , . 9 %. %, =A.,/ ! 0  4 ..$ ?0 >. ..  @. , . 9  %. /. >. .5. >Q....9%.%%0,..%..

6 L)(*.4)%4))&74

7  %$ . .   , >  L   0 > Q=$ 9 Q4#3 4 *  $ Q .%.. ., 9 Q./%.=..0 Q5. %   @ /A ,. ! .00 //  ,0.=   9  .,  05.  >Q. 0. % 0> A Q./. 9  / %00  Q0 >. .  .  .  > Q0 /%! 0 Q5. 9 /% %    @ /A %0 % $   0. ,= P >. Q % 00 %0.0 2 %+  .  Q/%! /4 @2.>Q.Q5.Q./%.=..0=A.,Q0%0.   > Q0  . ,./==/ 0 9 Q Q. Q,.%Q.@@.0Q/.@=A.@//Q.5. /,..0!6 L)(*.4*%4))"74

7   00 ,0 >  ..  Q0 >.  ,  Q./%.=..0  /  %.  Q2.,..0  >. Q %  %0 05%0@..%..>..>.@.0%5.   @, T  @@$ C /  Q4 ''  $ QC.  . C %. %%.  / 9 Q.,.  9  %0 05 /. $ % .$ 9  A.$ 9  %  .5 .   $9@+UC.0%>.Q. 05.+/%..Q/.+%/4 L Q /0.0%,.%0,.Q./%.=..0E.0.Q5. 0.Q4#34*>Q%..0/009Q4''  . % % Q...., Q5. 9  %  8  0% % Q@@./.,4  @@$ .  .50 > Q4 ''   @0.  @0  Q./%. %. Q=.5.4+$Q0$...C%.Q2 .,..0$  ,.  %..% % ,.  ,0 %%0 %   %>.%0.%%./6 L)(*.4*%4))G74

 ?$  @. > ?0   @. ?. % 00 .@/0   ./ /?4

G4  ?%+$  @. >  @.  ?0 .5. >  /+ ,. . 9  %.%/%?0%0.>%.00 04

B%, $>.,..?02/!/.00 %.0?5.2/!/$R.,0S@.%,.!./%04

 1)#-#1*(()  2G132  $  @.  ?0  C%.>0 >  /+ 0. , %   %0$ ,. 0  =   /0/. .//0.   @. 9 /  04  ? / % /. >? ?0. . ? /./>.%,>@0.0000%. >?%.P=A.,/P/%0$0%%0> @.>??.=A.,/%.@@.%4

%$../.>?,%>??,. %00.@/0.>?0?%0%0/% >?0..%=@.4

+$ .=0%>5>./0..? F%. ?. /%. ?=.5.  .5/ >.  ./=. ,  %.4   .%.. 05   A.% %%0 .2$ @     ?%+$ >?  .. %/ ?.  ?. 29  K.+/ /. %00  / ? 0.04  .%0>!A04





 1)#-#1*(()   23132 

!  .-8  !-, .  ,! .-

B @/0/9.%....?4)'*



  5 

)4 0,=M

 5

*4 AM

&4 .>%05.M

#4 @/  %.   >? %, @/    %0 !   0.  &( A +  .@.. % %. //0 0  .= @00  $ B V.K @>. '$ '((#   $  . C/%.4  0.  % ! %504  /0/. .T 7 ..> C/>0..0.=..%0.. >0M =7 C% % > /.@ . ./ %,. /   0..M 7 %  .5     %04 B.  /0/.  . %  . 00/ 0/00   7 =7  7 .2$  .=@00%%/.+>?. ,0.,=4/0/././8  %,$ >.  A.$ .. >  0.. >0  ?,%%  >00C%0.064)&*$)(')(374  5@@.+T  0.T   .LL W.B W           %.@/%0!.@.0C%...>?9?@@.@00 .%5@@

 1)#-#1*(()