Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/743/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/743/2007 KI-generiert

Security Interest Transfer as Sale Disclosure Liability

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/743/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The dispute centered on whether a series of transactions involving the transfer of security interests in property constituted a sale under a relevant statute, triggering specific disclosure requirements. The court reasoned that the substance of the transactions, viewed objectively, demonstrated an intent to effect a sale due to the presence of specified consideration for the property rights, even though the documentation might have suggested an alternative arrangement like a loan or security agreement. Therefore, because the transactions were deemed sales, the related statutory disclosure provisions were applicable, and non-compliance resulted in liability.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Security Interest Transfer as Sale Disclosure Liability: The court reasoned that the substance of the transactions, viewed objectively, demonstrated an intent to effect a sale due to the presence of specified consideration for the property rights, even though the documentation might have suggested an alternative arrangement like a loan or security agreement. Therefore, because the transactions were deemed sales, the related statutory disclosure provisions were applicable, and non-compliance resulted in liability.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Wertpapierumsätze Eigentumsübertragung Prospekthaftung gesetzliche Voraussetzung Darlehensvertrag gesetzliche Auskunftspflicht

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs imposed on the appellant for the federal court proceedings.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



           "##$%"%&&'  "(#)"%&&(



* +,*    * +

-.  )

! %/ 0! %&&( 



  !" #    $

$

%%     & '' (      $!" )*+ 

                 ! ! 

   (.,0(  

 1+

12   "  1*-*  "3"  3!4   ! .-51*+62 7".*71*6.2

.2 .+7!81*60"3"  !2 "9!$ 7"359!$$":0 "!8.//.2

;2 &:: $  &(7 $" < =   > &"  9" &7 $"  1//? > !3$  ;/ 5 162  8 $   @$ 1;$8 .//A59"B&"37$ 3"$ 7!$ C$$4 41710<$3  17.///=2

-2 '$ > $ @$ &      7 "  $  .. 5 .//0  B   :D"  !$$   $ " > &$""2 &   "9!$$)"$!3"!$> "3 &"$ 5B& !  3$!8 .//12   "$" 3"" B  7 "" 3  "3D 3 $  " 7  !9 !! 7$ "$" "3$ $ $$8"3!$">E &D2

A2  .15$.//0 ">& &"$$" "  .. 5 .//0 &33$ >  B& F $ GH $ 7"  33$ 7  !B&GH$::!$ 7"F2

02  "33$ .0$8.//0& :!" "  ..5D3B$B7$3" "3"$B":" 3$9 79:$3B7 &"7$"$"3$9" 5B& .//- ! $$ !3!$ B 3     $  7$ "$" 3" "3$9 7:!"!$D33$"92

+2    .0 7!8 .//0 &"  $5$" 2  49 B&  "3" !$$B&7$ & "!8 1*60 ! " &$   !9 B  59!$  7 B  :!$ "$"   3"$ B  3$ &7$ 3  3"$$ > : 7 & 7 &$2 &" !  B  $ &7 $" $ "3$!3$$$$" 72

62 7$">3&  "3 .57.//+&$":""> "2





,--*.,.//0  (;,0(    +

12 :!"!$ > &$2 A0 2 1 $2  E2 .    97  &9$ 5  <=  8 $    I$  $ B  $$$ 3"7 > C$ A0    :" "   3$ 9""  $  0$8.///< =$7>  :" "C(7 $" 1*51*A*< =2'!3"$3 59  C34$"$82

.2 $5$"   :! $ " 3"7 3    3"$  $ 78 <$2A0>0/ =2

;2 $93$ !$$ $ &7 $" $$3 3$4!$   3$$9  7 B  "$" 3"" $   3"    !92

-2  3$    :" "  &(7 $ 77$ < '= $33839 $  &7 $"<$2;02 .$; =2!@!&$2;.21 49!$&(7 $"< = 7 D $2 A/ > A;8  49!$  &(7 $ 77$ < '=2

' 3$$$ 1/4!"7 & '<$$21= $ $"791571+&33B$>$$$ $ $3 34;1 "!810!"9!$>$$ $!3B5$ 8"": $ $> $  7 34  ;1 "!8 10  B  !9 $  34$$ $2

A2 = D$! &$2.*821 ' $$ "$!"3 "  $$  7 37$ & $7$" $7  B  8:$3$JE" $73$JE &$$157 B$ $K&)$ $./"7$;1 "!8B3"4  "$ B"<J9 $$ "4=2 8=  "  $$ $ "3$" !34$ B& 3 3"$  !@! !8 &"  $$ B  "    &J9 <$2.*$21 '=2'$ ""!!" $$3" L =3 $B33)" $$M 8=3 $B5$ &$2;2; '7" ! 8 $$!!M =3B 8:$3$JE" $73$JE &$37$@$3!3$<$2.*$2. '=2 =7!)!3:!"!$>&$2.*B$ 'L  7  &$7$" $7  8:$ 3 $JE " $7 $ 



,--*.,.//0  (-,0(   8:$3$JE &$2'$3 "$7 & $7$" $7  B  $$ $ "$" 7" <$2 .*BB  '=2

="37$3"$ >8:$3$JE" $73 " $BD$&$$"3$3:$ J9" ! 10<$2.*D21 '=!"9!$3" 3 $B7$9  &:$ $ "$$3&$$" 3$<$2A.$2 '=2377$3!"37$ 3"$  > D 8:$ !$7!$ <$2 .*D 2 1  '=2  8:$ $$8" 3 &" 7  !9 $  "3$ 3 !$" $  5$ <$2 .*D 2 ;  '=2 '  5$ &"$$ 3 " 34  & '   8:$ $4 $ $$8"  3$ " <$2 A.:2- '=2 8:$&$$)"3&"   $<$2A.:21 '=2

02  &34  $ $9  B$    7 "$!$2 3 $ : $  $$ B &$!"    &$ $$!$ :!">&$2.*BB 'B3"7$";B7B  "3D $ "" 3 $  " 7  !9 !! $ 3 $ B"$$"34 & '$"3$$$$8"3!$"> E "3D2"3$$$::$"BL ( D5$$ $>$M (777: $>$ 7M (!9$ 3 72 3$9 7&$::$"B3"7$"$1 57B$&!3!$ ./4!" 5$35$ ;1 "!8 B 3"4   7   & 3  &J9 &9$ 3!5$)$ $>$27B5$ $"" &"  !9$ &"  $ !9$3!3$9<$2A/82; '=2 7 !@! D"" $&" 7 B" 3!5$)$ $>$<$2.*BB2-$2 '=2

$@$$!! $  $ !9 &$":  59!$  72"B$3$9 $"9!$&::$3 " 3 $ B  3$ $ "$" "3"  :$  5 !$ <    3$$9 " $" 3 &:: :" "    E2 1//.=2

&34&$ >5$$$B&$"$"3$9"7B3&"  3!!9BDB  D4!!9



,--*.,.//0  (A,0(   5$B53 "7 &$2A.:2.8 ' 33$     $  &(7 $ 77$ $  $!3"$:2!$"3B "3D> 3$$ &$$ ( >   $  !9  >  3$$ 3  3"7) 3:      .4! 3 & 3 3 ::$ B  $ 7$@$""3$$ 7!!$ 7   & < ',A.1,.//A=2  :$ B  59!$  7 3" B"3D&$3 3"$$>:7&7&$&$  37$&9$  $ $2

 "9  D  "$ B 3"4 $  8  " $$ B    !$$   $ &7 $" "  $  "$" ::$" :!"!$ D 3$ "9 338  $ B   $ 5$"2



,--*.,.//0  (0,0(  

  2 +1  +,*    * +

!

  3 .

12 "782

! 3

.2 5$$2

;2 $"!!$ .//:2>E9 $2

-2 :!  3$   BC 37$ :!  $  3"$ @$   "  ;/ 5 4  $:$ 34  8 :" " <'ENOE:B00//-  =37 !$4  $ 38:!"!$D$26. :" " 8:" " 1+ 5 .//A < %=M  !"!   $  B   !$: $ !) 37$3$9$ $ ! $M $ @$  "  8 :" " 3 7 3$  3 7 "$B D  $  &$2 -.  %2  3"$ @$ $  34  3  $7B"!!!) 37 7$@$5$>&72  9::4  3" $         %% P'  P



3:! 3"$@$$$:"D3$BC>C:::" " 39::



,--*.,.//0