Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/732/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/732/2005 KI-generiert

Administrative Finding Challenge Based on Failure to Consider Evidence

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/732/2005
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The dispute involved challenging an administrative finding that disregarded certain evidence related to the petitioner's financial standing, leading to a determination that adversely affected the petitioner's standing under a specific regulation. The court reasoned that the administrative body failed in its duty to adequately consider all relevant evidence, specifically pointing to the unexplained rejection of material testimony and documentation that directly addressed the core issue of the petitioner's financial condition, thus rendering the final determination arbitrary and capricious due to insufficient factual basis.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Administrative Finding Challenge Based on Failure to Consider Evidence: The court reasoned that the administrative body failed in its duty to adequately consider all relevant evidence, specifically pointing to the unexplained rejection of material testimony and documentation that directly addressed the core issue of the petitioner's financial condition, thus rendering the final determination arbitrary and capricious due to insufficient factual basis.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Beweislosigkeit Anfechtung von Verwaltungsverfügungen unvollständige Aktenführung Rüge der Sachverhaltsfeststellung Verwirkung im öffentlichen Recht Streitgegenstand

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the allocation of court costs, which is determined in the dispositive section.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

               %&''%'(()  %*+'%'((&



 !   "    "

,-  + $ . /-  '((& 



0- 1111111111 



"22  "  3  4    +, !"#$%&'()'))   )*

              !" #$

   /'-0/  

 2

)1 2#+3333333333,)!('4 ,%5 ,,#65  7558#)!")9)!!*,#6,,  ,1

'1  )( : )!!( ; ,,  #,%,  #+# # %  %< # ;==   # ;/ 4 # , 7 /%<>  8 4  9 ;?  #;1  46,#,% #%?<+#4 ##1

*1   %% +,#  ,?   '! @4  )!!" 9 ;   # ;    3333333333+,#   # 6,6% == #;   9  ,1   # A 6,  % , #,%#   #  $#+ = ?+$A 6   %,  6  %?<+ ,   + #;#%$B/ BCD% #,%# ,E1

&1  '& =,4  )!!"   3333333333  = +, % ,,%B  +,# /  #; 6; ;F   %#; 9,== % G % ,#4 1

(1 #,   = ,+)!!"; @,#+##% 1

H1  0 %+? '..* ;,  #,%,  4 #+# # % 

4 9;? #; #;== +,# F #%  )!0*1

"1  = +,# #,#).?'..* 3333333333 # 6, 6  %  ==  #; , ?/#,% = #; = ?+$A  ,A<  # ? 4#; ,A  /%= 12,# + ;$4  % # %?<+ %     ; F%   ++ ,  < #,%#  # ? %$B== =1 5  +,#      ;4  A<BA,#% )!!"1

01 A, % ;  ;,  # 6, % ,,%B # )' 4+? '..* 6;;, % 4 %%$B 1

!1  )& 4+? '..*  54  +,#  ,A  # ;/ 4 # , 7 / %<>5284,6;,#,#; ,,;4 %BA,#%  )!!"6?, #= ? +%1

).1 #,  #'.4+?'..*; @,#+##+ = 6;,#,#;,;, %AA4,#% )!!"1

))1  & #,+? '..& ;, ; %%, 9  #,  1   , 6; %#  #C/4 BC  +,#  % =   # %  #  4,?1



-(''-'..&  /*-0/   )'1  = +,# #)!@4 '..&3333333333%,   +# B+ ++,#   # 6,6;,% A # #+? #% 4  1   6+  # +?   $#+ 4,?1  ?  # A 6  +   ,4 #  # %B  +#,, (/5)   A #;B #    %,    + 1

@ 9 = %%,? )!#,+?'..*%55  # A1  /  ;  6; # %B  +#,, (/5)1    A, ;?#;B#  %, #;+ #F  #    /  61   , ,  ?  4  ?   ;F   % #  =   %  %@  #  A 4,   %, 6#4   1

)*1 '.@4 '..& 3333333333B %  = +,9;  6;,== #%?<++? #% # C #;,6; ,    + +,# +F  4   9  %B$ B,%   9  B % 61 4 ,, ,%,4 4+#= #F ,A #;, +  #;,4  # 4 # BA F 4  #    # A%, #1

)&1 ))=,4 '..&52,;?#;,,+%+#;#+ AA4 ?#;,#,#;,1

)(1 #,  #'.=,4 '..&; @,;%%  #;,+ = 6  # %B  +#,,  ;+%IB  % #;F   4 , # $% ,# 1   ,, , 6  %  # ;, 4  # $#+ #F 6  4  #,@9 #  9  = # %   )!!"  6; AA4 ;4 ,,#% ?1

)H1 ).+'..&;, @,#,  1 ,A, I #A %%% = %== ,A <+#+F# #;+%IB#= +,A1 4,% 6;+%$ ;4 %,#;AAB6;, 4?% # ,1

)"1 ,%#'&+'..&; @#4$ %%9#,  %%  #'.=,4 '..&9;4 #52 #))=,4 '..&1

)01  ( @  '..(   #;     # , #;F  = +, 9  #+##  ?#,6;,,  4 % 3333333333 3333333333 33333333331



-(''-'..&  /&-0/   )!1  #'"@ '..(  ?#,#+#,3333333333 # %,    =  +,#  # )! @4  '..&   6     % ,#4 #% 1

'.1 ,%#'':'..(3333333333 # 6,6;  #, 9 ;  #  3333333333 6    # ==    ,   ,6   % , # 4 1 +%  #  # %B    %4 6++##;,4 %,%,  =##BA   %A,1

')1 'H:'..( ,,+ F% %  ?6   A#,9@A1

 "

)1  A4 ;A  @#   78,,+# = ,  ,#< ):'..*  ?# +%,#(@A #  %, #   4 /%, # ( %%,  )H @A  71 ) 1(H 81

5 9; #;, #)H@A%  ?=,#, '"@4 '..&7 J)*.).H8#  A4 #%,)*=,4   # %    A%+  ?#   #  ,A   9   @A     # ; # ;, #4F@A1

'1 =+,+ 9 ;1 (H 1 ) 1  B1 '   ? G    6# %,49;1(H# =,#,% A,, ## # #H?'...7 /%<> 8 49  =,#,;/ 4 # ,#)!@ )!(!7 /%<> 81

5+%,%@A##;%<  ,? 1

*1    ,  4 A  ) @4  '..*  G,  +# =   # +? # %   ,A #  #+  #   1 5  %+, % #4 6# K%% 6# IB,9+ < #%  %6<A%% ?4 A++L  =  @ # 6+ #,+    %#  7 J )'"  &H"  #1 ) )'H  )*H  #1 &?   ,=,81  4B   6    %,#9#,=#<A   4# K%% 6 ,4#<@#,4 A7 J))"!* #1H?))' *H.  #1 &M  2  )!!0 N *" %1 *)H  #1 *?81 K %6  



-(''-'..&  /(-0/   %,#%#)@4 '..* # %<##4  ?  +%,  + < #K    ,A  %  4 <A # %,#  #     %  # %   # %,### ==, %, +# = ,% 1

  6   #;%< %   #+# # %  #,%,  0%+?'..*,AA4 #;,#,,A,% ;,   ,A  %      4 #   4 A #<  )@4 '..*1

&1 ,%,#=+#,  +%,% %,4? 7=11(HH. 81

(1 5 ;1 0 1 )    ,%, 4 # , ; % , # A    %  6   %,+, %+  # A #,1 5 ;1 &   ; 4 # , % , #; = + , A,  #; +#   #;  #1

$ #%, 6@ %# #; 4 # ,# # #  ,+ 6+,# M  ,6 ,+ 6 ?@ 4 # ; % , =  6;  +% #;,4 7 J )).  '"(  #1 & ).(  '."  #1 '81 6;  #;  4 ,#;,#,,+ 6=#,= $ #  =#   #, #;# +,#  #  + L  %+ #;,4  % , # 4  # ; ,, # #  4 ,  ?+ F A ?7 J))() #1').()(0 #1)81

K,# 9K  4 #9&.O+ 1  4 6#15K  4 #9(.O 4$#+ /  4 # , HH'-*O # 9 <71'01) # 4 A)@4 '..*81

6    K  % +%  ,, =, % 6  #A, #K 4 # , ,  ==   % 6K  K$ 4  % #K +%  4 #+#%IF+ ,6 K,#% ?6 4 # ,  +% K +# = , # + < 9 =  #  71 0" 1 *  & 81 #K#+   + <4#+##  F+ K== =#4, = 6+# =  ##A,#K 4 # ,# K +% # % ? % K,  ,+ 41  #  % ,6 %,# #  +I+ + < 6K  # ,4     # K1&) 1 5    6 K 4 # ,  K +%  K % +# = , #% #,  %,,#%,=@#+#15  # F+  +# =  ,== 9=# 4 # ,  +% # #  9 %     ,61   #



-(''-'..&  /H-0/     +I+ #4  # P 6  =# +?  @A 7 J ))"  )!0 #1*,=,81

 ,4   #   #K 4 # ,  ,A  % K1 )"   6 K % %%,#+# =  F%  %@ %# #,4%%,,A +# K  1 &)    4 A @6K *) #,+? '..' 7 J )*.  *&*  #1*1(81

5 #  #,4  #,% =+,+9 K1)"1) +# = ,%K4 #F A,%4#A, #K 4 # ,1   F + # K1 )"      F #K 4 # , # ?,,=   #? +# =  ?#K==  #+#,4 ,%K4 94 A+,,# ,6  %% +,1  %  # 4      BA+ K %#  #  I B,+%= 6K %, ++##,      #      ,A 9 K,%6 #  #,     A 

7 J)'(*H! #1').!'H( #1&).H0" #1)).(*. ,=, ,81== = %6K  #+, BA, %K  %%, ,#+ <# ==,7 J))'*"' #1'? *!. #1)?81

H1    A %   %  # 4    K 4 # , #   K +# = , )!!"/#96# 9 ,,=,%+ <= / + #%+?'..*1

 $    # 4 6 ;==   ,  + <   4 #+# #,%,%;,  = ,#,  #=1 ;,6 A###  #,4  ## 9%% ?%A 9 ;F+ # #   +,  #; 4 #+# 6  %,  #  I F+ , 7=1 5 )!!! %10(  #1 '?   ,=,M J)*."* #1*M J))")!0 #1*,=,81

"1 ;%<9;%% ##+#;, 46 +%% %  # 6 6; D  4 #E   % % =  6 # %  4FBC15 FQ  4 , 4,#,  #   ++6?+ 9 + %   ? #  6; =    %4BP+A1

+%#,,++,# F= A# %6 6 ;, # , #    ; % AA4, #%  6  #  9   ,,=,)!!"1  , ++I+> ==#;== == ++A4%# +  # % ,#4 1 ==+,#   3333333333= +, 6  +,# , , BA,#% )!!"1 +,#  ;<A6;, %%?#;F%= ,A<  



-(''-'..&  /"-0/   6;;#,@9= %41 % ,#4  <1  %   = +, %  #+ +,# F = A  #   ,A+ %33333333336 <,++ # 6,  ?#, 6?,,=   #;% ,#4 +%<1

01 J  # #  6; BA+ +% #   %%9 =#A,#K 4 # ,## 9#; ,,#% ?1#,  % K#<%  6? # I@,1



-(''-'..&  /0-0/  

  0" 2  !   "    "

$

567 -- 8  /     9 : ;<' "#=

  7 -

)1 ,4?1

$ 7

'1 @1

*1  6%,#A 1

&1 =+  %  #  6; %4 =+    %, I #  #,  # *. @ #<   =   % %  ++#, #,   ? =,#, #  5BR CB=6  H H..&       F+% 1  #,   % I %A,1  +,+  # > 8 # 6 F+6#,  #, ?  %##,   6,M ?8 F% % 6 + =   + %4  #+#   #,  M 8 %   A   #  %,1 5   +,+     %    ,,+ ,+,,   8 ?8  8  /#   ?=,#,#%%+ <6;  #4#, 4?1+,+ #+ +$ # %4 6   @     6  #,   6,  ;4%% # 6,,F%,# ,71)*').H).081  A== <>  , #>      JJ N 5 N      , /@ > 2 S 22 

% =+#%,I = ,F%   6;9;== =,#, # %A==



-(''-'..&