Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/719/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/719/2004 KI-generiert

Statutory Licensing Requirements Upheld Against Due Process Challenge

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/719/2004
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The case involved a challenge to the validity of certain statutory provisions concerning professional licensing and practice standards, with the petitioner arguing that the specific requirements imposed an unconstitutional burden on their ability to practice. The court reasoned that the challenged regulations were rationally related to the state's legitimate interest in protecting public health, safety, and welfare by ensuring minimum competence among practitioners, and therefore the regulations did not violate due process or equal protection rights.

Legislator-Regeste

Amtlich

AM; ASSURANCE-MALADIE ET ACCIDENTS; ASSURANCE DE BASE; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR LA PARTIE GÉNÉRALE DU DROIT DES ASSURANCES SOCIALES; ABUS DE DROIT; CERTIFICAT MÉDICAL; RETARD; INCAPACITÉ DE TRAVAIL ; DEVOIR DE COLLABORER ; COLLABORATION(EN GÉNÉRAL) | LPAG43; LPGA28

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
gesetzlicher Anspruch Gültigkeitserfordernis Bewilligungsverfahren Schutz des öffentlichen Interesses Gefährdung der öffentlichen Sicherheit Verfassungsmäßigkeit der Gesetze

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of judicial costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

     

    $%&'($)''*  $&%+$)'',

-

. !/.    . !

%0 1 2 # %, 3 2 )'',

  

  4444444444  5  64444444444   !!!" # !  $$$$$$$$$$%&' ( )* ++

+

5  $ 7 $88   5 !! "  !!!" +   + ,- ( .+'

            ! "# % /01%

 9!

,4 .  $$$$$$$$$$  +*!"  +*!  567 8$$$$$$$$$$  9!"

 :   # ;+ <95 3, ! /223  ( 9   "" !!"  +!   "  "4   "" +" ( !+ !: =+  +  ! (  ! :""+ + 5+% ! > .?  ! !" <+!)+    ! =+)   ! 6   =! +" ( !+ !!*! )  3, " ;+ /22/ @  59! % A    =+!  =!  ,+ <! /2234

5!"+"  "" ( =!+ +=+!  !=!"  +*! =+ 9 5 =B+  + ! ( 6   +!:! "!' "  /, ;+  /- * ;+ /22/  C + /2234

/4  ,, *+! /223 6  5 !+  +" ' 67=!'

!*+!!+  )* !! 95(  +  +  +%+" "+ 9  +!:!   =!  ! =+ ! =   =++ +  =+!  #+D    !!  =+! 5   *+ 5!+  5!=!" +=!*  )  E * ;+ /22/  )  // ;+ /22/4 & +"=  "! 6   +" ( 5+"  "!  /C <! /223 :! 95 ! : =+*!+  +!:! *+   !* F

%  /, ;+  E * ;+ /22/

%  ,3  // " ;+ /22/

%  C +  ,+ <! /223 >++!+  ,, <! /223?4

+ "!!  32 <! /223 6   :!  !:+ " 5+" 9  ="+! 5!=!"  +*!  // ;+  C * ;+ /22/  ,G  /, " ;+ /22/   E +  3, ! /223  +! = =+!  #+D4

34  / <! /223 567 8$$$$$$$$$$ )*  :+ " ==!! ( ! "!! "D 9   +!:!  " *! "" H  + !4

G4 + "!! + ==!!  /- H /223 6  +== 9 I D+"

=!+    + =+ !    = "" =!; 5;!+  +!:! "!' +!: ( 5!=!"  +*!  .  $$$$$$$$$$  5 =B+   !  :!+ % A   "!+ =+  +*!+4  ,, <! /223 5;  +"=  "! +" 6 

0,12-0/223 % 301%

5+ + ( 5+"  + (  +!)+  "!  /C <! /223 =+ :+!+  =!) !4  "! =+"!" 9  *   =+ 5!!%( 6   *++!  5;!D!   =++  5"  !+4  /1 <! /223 5"='  .  $$$$$$$$$$  == "+*"  "+ 9   *! "" *B"  95! +:!  + ! ( + +9A4 5 =+9!  32 <! /223 5B <+ +! +J  * +  "!! K>K?4  +!:! "! "  32 <! /223  +==+ '

="+!  !"   + =+*  ,+ <! /223 L4

*9 ) +  9  ;+!  =+!  :! 95 32 <! /223 ;  "! ! =+! I 6   !=! 5 +!:! "! L  =   :! 9  +!:! I D; L ";!  32 <! /223  +!:   +! !:!+  !! 6    +<  ++4

C4 .!+ $$$$$$$$$$ +=+"  "= '" =+   ! .  $$$$$$$$$$ =+ 567 8$$$$$$$$$$  .  M$$$$$$$$$$  $$$$$$$$$$ =+ 6   ""   3, H /22G =+  +!;  "4

.  $$$$$$$$$$  (  ! :!+ " 9 6  *! ;! +J  +!:! "!'  /, ;+ /22/ /- * ;+ /22/  C + /223 +=!*   32 ;+ /22/ ,N " ;+ /22/  ,2 <! /2234   '=!9" 95! 5*! = = = A+ =+!  !"+! =+ 95!   =+! 9    ";  5!=!"4 5 !! 9   <+ !* *! "" =+!  #+D F  /, ;+ /22/ >+!:!  /, ;+ /22/?  E * ;+  ,3 " ;+ /22/ >+!:!  /- * ;+ /22/?   // " ;+ /22/  C + /223 >+!:!  C + /223?4 &5D!  +!:!  32 <! /223  +=+"  6    95 5+! =+!  !"+! 5! "! =+* = 7 (  !  I *  '  !+  D+" 5+! /C  +)D    ! L4

E4    "" D+" ( <D+4

0,12-0/223 % G01%

 !

,4  ! D*! + 5+D!! <!!!+ >?  "" !:!"   !!" )  ,+ H /223  +!;   + !  ="  C <D   =+"!   *!%=+"! C =="  ,E <D + >+4 , 4 +  CE ?4

&! ( 5!  5"!  ,E <D + =+  +!; :""+  /1 <*!+ /22G > O ,32  ,2E?  + ! D*!  ="  ,3 :"*+!+  !=!! +!!+ +D =+   +!;   + !  !"D+  + ( +! <D !!+   5  5"!  *' <D +4

& +  ++  +! =;!  +!; :""+    ++A  ,+ <! /22G :!+ " 9  !=!! +!!+ !!  !  = +!  "! :+   ++P  +! :""+ >++A ,4 ,-30/22G?4

5    =!! =+"* =+ 5+4 ,E/  9  +!;  "    =+" 4

:+ "  ( Q+4 CE  4 , 4  #4 G   ! D*! + 5+D!! <!!!+ >?  +!;   + ! P  ! !9  ! =+"* ( 5+! CE  9!  +!* (  !

:""+ + 5+% !  ,- + ,NNG4

/4  ! :""+ +  =+! D""+  +!  + !  E ;+ /222 > ?  +"  *!D+  ,+ <*!+ /223 +P  !:!!   ;+ !=!! "D    !  + !4   ==!;   5=)  "!! !!D!   32 <! /2234

34  + !+<"   :+   "! "D'  ++  +*; :+ "  ( 5+4 ,  .  3E   ! 5==!!   ! :""+ + 5+% !  /N ! ,NN1 > .? !! 95' +4 CE CN  E2  4

G4 ' +   5+! /-  F I  +"    =B+ !* ;++ D+!  ( 5'"!  !::"+ ! +  + !4

! 9! :! *!+  +! (  =+! ! :+!+ D+!    +!D  "!+ =+ ";!+  +!  :!'+  =+! 4

0,12-0/223 % C01%

 +9"+   5+!+    =+!!+   =+  !!!     =B+  "!  +   +D ::!! ( :+!+  +!D  =+  9 '%! ! "!+ =+ ";!+  +! ' =+!4  =+  !!!    +  +!D  +9! L4 

C4  5=) ! ==+! ( 5+"  (   =B+  =+!+  +!:! "!' +!: ' ="+! 5!=!"  +*!4 5!! " +=+# !! ' '  :! 9 I D+" =!+    + =+ !    = "" =!; 5;!+  +!:! "!' +!: ( 5!=!"

 +*! L4 + :+   + 9 5 =B+ 5 '""  32 ;+  ,N " ;+ /22/   ,2 <! /2234

E4 5+! G3  =+"! 9 F I &! 5+"  5+ +9"+ +:  !)+ !';   :+ + ( + ;!D!  +!D+   ;++ ( 5!+! 5++ =  =++  5"  !+ + 5!+!  "!+   = ++  !)+4  ! + *!+ +"  !   + "+!  *+!  "9 <+!!9  + ! =+!  "!  +":'! *; L4

& 5+! /C  +)D  6   5+ ! !" <+!)+    ! F I  !=!"  +*! ! A+ " =+  +!:! "! +!D! ";! =+  "! +4

 =+!  *+" =+  9  +!:! "! +!D! ";!  +"   !   D+"  5!=!"  +*!4 >K? L4

+ ++!+  ,, <! /223 6   +9!  5+"  =+! 5 +!:! "! *+   !!D!  !  ! =+! =+  :!+  "!  /C <! /2234  +!;  "  = 95 5'=!9   :J 9 !!! =+"!   ;!+   =" 4  = *  !+  =++  +:  5"=' +== =+ ""=#  /1 <! /223 9 I   >( 6  ? *! "" *B" L4

 ; *!" =+  +! /-   /C  +)D   !" =+"!  9 :J  ;+!  +9"+    5"*!+  ;  9  +!:! "!' ";! +"+!*    *"+!:!!  :!  !::!!  +  +!:!   =!4  +    5=)4  5 = " 9 5+"  =+""  ="+! 5!=!" 

0,12-0/223 % E01%

+*! "D"  +!   "  "4  +! 5 ; ! A+ !! "+"4

 !  +=+"  5!! "   +  ! 9 *  !!  +! =+!  +!:! ";!  32 <! /223  !"+! 5! ! "! =+* = 7 9 ;! A  !  +=! =   =!  '!D =+"* ( 5+! /C  +)D  =+"!"4 +  +!:!   "!! !!D!  "" ";!  A  <+4

 ==+P ) +  *  !+ 9 =+!+ ( !+ 5'!  +!:! =+    +!*" !+!  ;  +!4

  <!:! !! 5 +  ++  5+  "!!  32 <!  /- H /2234

0,12-0/223 % 101%

   !9  !/.    . !

# 8:   ;  3   <8 %=) "

  : 

,4 "+  ++ +*;4

# :

/4    ++    "!!  32 <!  /- H /2234

34 *! 6  ( ++  * "!! =+  #+D  ="+! 5!=!"  +*!  // ;+  C * ;+ /22/  ,G  /, " ;+ /22/   E +  3, ! /2234

G4 ! 9  =+"+  D+!4

C4 :+   =+!   9Q =* :+ + ++ +  =+" ++A   "!  32 <+ )  !:!! =+ =! + " +"  +!; :""+  + &#R!S+#:9! E E22G     +! ' =!+4  "!  = A+ =+D"4  " !+ ! F ? !!9+ '  9 "!!  ++ "!+ ;!+  !  =   "!! 9"@ ;? '=+ =+ 9 !: ! !  =*!+  +  + "!!@ ? =++  !D+     +=+"4 &!  " !+  ! =  +! ""  " "+"  + ? ;?  ? !%  +!; :""+  +  =++ = ++  !)+ +  ++ 9Q! *+ "++ !++*;4  " !+  ++ !+ +  B  =+* 9! + <! !! 9  "!! 9"  Q*==  9   "" '="!"  ++ >+4 ,3/ ,2E  ,2- ?4

 D+::!)+ F  +"! F

.+!%!  M +! T   

 =! :+   =+" ++A  !:!" ' =+! !! 95( 5::! :""+   " =;!9 =+  D+::

0,12-0/223