Landlord-Tenant Lease Dispute Over Default and Termination
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertIn a dispute concerning a lease agreement, the court considered whether the tenant's alleged default, based on failure to pay rent and other charges, justified the landlord's immediate termination of the lease and recovery of the premises. The court reasoned that while the lease provided for termination upon default, the tenant had presented evidence of proper payment and disputed the landlord's calculations, raising genuine issues of material fact regarding whether a default actually occurred, thus precluding summary judgment for the landlord and requiring a full adjudication of the contractual dispute.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Landlord-Tenant Lease Dispute Over Default and Termination: The court reasoned that while the lease provided for termination upon default, the tenant had presented evidence of proper payment and disputed the landlord's calculations, raising genuine issues of material fact regarding whether a default actually occurred, thus precluding summary judgment for the landlord and requiring a full adjudication of the contractual dispute.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertApplied because the appeal was dismissed, necessitating an order on costs.
Volltext
&'()*&'((* "&+,-&'((.
"
" #" # #
#/ '
% 0( 1 '((.
!"#$#"%$&' () $ & *+,
$
* ! * - * $0# - *!./0$$$1!2334 !"#$# "%$ "
! "#! $%
)4514)
2 "
18 9)":$;!$$"<#1=21! $,#000>,?@A$0$":?-$"B * ? 1=CC D 0 1===8 : 0 ? E, 1===! #$# $$ "$# ? $,?"@:0?F8
48 01===!?#"#?0??"$$?-),?$#!G ?#! $$! D ""$?$?-@,$"H?- 9)": ;8"$,$,$#D"$0"":?#$# I * ?: E, 43348 ": , HH$# 0" ? ,,$D?#$0$F?-,?$#!-HH$?-)
,?$# 9 ; H# $$ "$$ $ " ?# ? E, 43348*!$$?##$#H0#"J$? @?#? 4C$@433K9 *516=5433K;8
K8 6E,433K!?-/$!$@$)?$? -#" ?$ G- HH$$ $, ? 00)
0$$8
78 ?$?1C,0@433K!#$#-@E$?-?$? $! ?G,#/#$#"$#"-:8@?$? ,!#8
L8 ?F ?$ $ ?# ,0$ ?-?0$# E: " $?-?-?$9)":* ;8
28 ""$ ? 42 E, 4337! ! "## ? 0?/0$0!H$#$$00$##?$?0@$<</ 1===!0"$#D/?7)L8?-?$?$? 0?,0@433K!-#@/:$#</!0"$ ?$J$8$??,?$8"$$"$ $$ ? ? , $ 0@! $+"G0$ 0#G! ?$ "$ ? H ? @$#8 -+ " D ""0$ " ? ?$D"$GG0"8$"#$? ,<,??-#"?$$0@<$$??? $@ ?#<##$H 0?##! ? D /$ -#" ?$ $ D ?$ ? $ 433K8 :, H$ ? $, G ? "@:0H8-<$??-"@:00"F?,)0@< ?-< 0#G ##0$ "$/<G 0E! ?$ +0"$0$< <)H$$F@#"?##0$"+/F8"$$ 0@,?$##?$$?$$8
5436754337 )K514)
68 ""$0#?D-$$$?* ! !0#? $$$ ? $! ?<$G# ?$ ? 44 H#, 4337 M"@@ N"/+?0M8:,G"$$$$:<GDG!?!D #< 0@! ?$ 0 D ? ?! HH ? 0F ? $J$ $ ? ,$<!$$@),F!M9888;))@M8 ""$?1=,4337! "$ H0 ?<$ ? N"/ +?08 -+ 0#$#,$8
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
=8 *$$@!* 0HF"$$"?#?4L04337 K104337!-@?$$?$#8
138 *$ D -""$ ? $ H$ 4L E 4337! * H0# ?#?$?2E$43378 "?<0$$8
118 ? 6 $@ 4337! $ $ D -$ ? $$ ?#$DG-$?#D* ?"+"$$E: G $ ?! ?#?$ ? @? # " -&" <##8 @$! ?: G <# , ? $ GHH0$-F$?-,-?$ ?,0@433K8*-<$?+?0?"?"!#0?$ 0#? + $, $ "" G- $ +?0 -$ " ,@
5436754337 )7514) ?<"/8 F0 "+/<G! F0 "+/$G $ #,$@0#G$#"?#$0$$ ?8H$"HF-#,$0G-$?O"" ,!0-#,$:$?$$8 -":!?$# $ $ #,?$8 *-<$ ? ? $# ?#G$! ?$ J$ ?0 -":!-?$$$?-0@??$8 $?0"@$8
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
1K8 ? ? 1K ?#0@ 4337! @ ?# 0"$ "?"$!G-$$?$?7E,433L8 -?$$ ?! #$# ?#?# ?-? "?$ ? ? ! $ ? "#? D $$#$":? 8
178 " ? 13 E, 433L! @ $# "?$ ? ? ? - !$$<# ""$0#?H?44, 43378#$$?0?#G-,$0#DG--<$" $0$ ?- +0"$0$< ": " ? "! ?G$ G $ +0"$Q0 ": " ? " $ " #G$! G $ +0"$Q0 @$-":8
1L8 ? #$#0D?"$"$$?"$!? <HH?KH#,433L8
5436754337 )L514) ? $$ ##0$ 0#?F ,$P ? $ ""$ 0#?F? (!"#$*&0#?$!GH$#$$?- HH$/0$<G0$$D1==3!F@#?"1===9H8""$? 6E1===;!?0@$<?$#$9""$?46O$4331;!$ ?-""$ ? ,)@/< ?$ @ $$0$ 9 ? 47 "$0@4331;R""$? !/0$<!?42"$0@ 4331 G $$ "# ?- +?0 ?F /GR ""$ 0#? ? & ? 1 ,0@ 4331 "$$ ?<$ ? +?0 ?F /G! ?+$/+0! " ? " ?$! $$ "$)
?//$8
128 " ? 4C H#, 433L! #"? 00 $ P M +?0 G ": " ? " $ $$# +0"$0$<G G $:<?0F?$J$?HH!?,$<!?$@?$$!? $@ ? 0#0! H$<@$#! ? $@ ? ,! $@$#! @$##0$!?#"$?0?H$?$:" ? ? ,8 $$ $$# #$# ?#H " $@F8 $ ? -?$ ? 1C,0@ 433K! 8 -$ $0$ "$ ? ?$#-F,$#@!?GEG-F,$:@0@8* -?##0$$$$H?+0"$0$<$?"#$?8 -$ "$ -$$ ? ? 0$# G +0"$0$< G$ F$$D-?$G,$-?$8M
168 ? ? 17 0 433L! @ ?# -?$ ? G$#?$#0!?G-$$1=,433L8 $$!)$00$?##G$P
M 0#?)$$$ ? 8 , ?#ED ,$ 1==K8 + $"$ $ 1==6 $ ?#0@ 4331! "#? D G "$$,08 $$#"G,$?#"# ?0? 8
$$ "0: $$ HH$ ?S "@:0 #$?<<8S,$H#,43348$$D"$$0SF"# ?HH$#8HH$?"@:0??8
S ? $0$0 )##@ GS 1==18 0 "$!ES"?S##0$DE$?0?0$?1==KD1==68
0$T0""$?404337DS$$$?* ?G ES?<$G#+?0?"?"8"#G?0"##?$ ""$! ES,$ "# ? "@@ +?08 0 ?<$ ",$ J$ H0#8 S$ "# ? " ##0$! S ?$ $ D ##$5?###$! ? ? ?$! "# ? 0F ? $J$! ,$< $ $@$#8 ##0$! ?<$
5436754337 )2514) S0" D $ ? ?$ 0#?8 0 ,! E S, " $$# $@ ,$ S?$! D SF"$ ? ? 8 HH$ HH$ ? ? ""0$ 0@ 0 "H #<0$ ,8S<S<#$$?$?#<##$,800@ GS$0$ #$$?#"H8S$$#? $00#?$0$":S?$!D,?40D40":8 "G$#$$S$0H$#"$$D"$$89888;
SF"G G 0J0 0F ? $J$! ,$< $ ? "#F$$DS?$!E0$??<$?"?"GS $ G H#8 ##0$ $ HH$ ? H$ <<,$8 $$ " "" ? G! $"$G??$#SF,$#@!? GF0@89888;M
1C8 #$":GJ$?12E433L!$H0# G<0$$8
1=8 ": $0 ? #$ $ ?0$ F "$ " " ? 44 E 433L!#$#<?#DE<8
"
18 <,S<$E?9;#$#0?H#$$$#!?: 1O$433K! @$?!0"#?LE<! ?$"#?$$,)"#?$!L""#$$12E<9$81$8 $L2 ;8
*$DS$?S#$?12E<!" @H#?# 46E,43379 .1K3132;!? <,?"$#!1KH#,! ?"$$$<$"0$$$ @$? ? #< D $ E< $$! ! ? S$$$ ? S#$?,FE<8
48 H0#0$ D -$8 L2 8 1 $8 /8 L ! @ $ ? %$$G?$$$"#,DS$ L2 G $ $, D H#?# S)?$ ? 430 1=C19 ;8
*0"#$"E<??S":$#$@8
K8 H#?#"$<##??$??2$@ 43339 ;$$#,<1E,433K!$%$0?H$ ?0@?"$#<??0?8* "0$#!"$?,G?$-""G?$J$$/#D0:
5436754337 )6514) ?""G:<""@$,<00$U H$E?G0$?#$0$$"?$9 .1K34K3?8181R KKL?8184R .14=7?8184R .146726?81!1421K2 ?87@$#H#;8:<?"#?G$D-""G$ #,?:E?$#,<9 .116=K?82@!114K23 ?87R 1==CVK6"8K12?8K@;8 S""G? ?S":8
78 ?#<$D-$23 G"#,$?#??K3E?: $H$??#""$!?#?$?$0" ?# ""$ "$$ "$$ ?-)?$! ""$ ? -$ 132 ? H#?# -)?$ 9)": ;8$E$#?H0$?#$!$,@8
L8 $<"$"$?,-$0##$$H?#D""0K10 4337?$?$D?"$$?-8
28 ;?$D?"$$?#$?-?$#""?-@?!$ -#,#0$?00<@?$:?$$-$$$D$#!? $#$8 $$F<$0"G-+?-?0$$G! $#,#0$?$!?00<$""?$?$$!G- $ " , ? 0J0 0:8 -$ " #! ,/! G -?$$G00#?$?-$$$D$#RH$$HH$ G -#,#0$ ?00<@! # #,$0$ D ?-$ H$! $ ",G#-$$$D$#"/+G"+/G?-#!-$)D)?G- "#$00?$G?)8*,-#,#0$# $-$$$D$#$#"""$?$#$$G$ ? H$! G -?0$$ ! #/#$! E< F0 H?$ $0$?<0$?-?0#?!$G?$J$$/# H0$ D :< ? ?<# ? ,0@ "#"?#$! ""G# <##0$ D -""#$ ? ", ? - 8 ! G -F$ ?- ""$ ? D HH$ $ -?$ $ ?00< "%$ "@!0G-"$"J$GH#?"@@?"$! ?$D?"$$H?#-?$#?$J$#9 .11=KK6 ?81!11C4C=?81@$#H#;8
"$ "" #<0$ G E"? $# ? -$ K2 ! G- #$$ 0?H "#F$$ $ <<,# ! ? 0: <##! ""%$ #$,0$ D ?$! ?, ? -)?$ ?- ? "$$ -?$ $$ " $ 9$ ?#G$; ? ?00<!$G?"F,0$?#$<:D -?$8 $G-#$$?$#?-$##$0DG F$$ 00#?$0$ ,$ -?$ ) $$ G $ ) D G $ ,$Q$$?!0J0-?$!"$?-?#,""0$?)
5436754337 )C514) $$ G 9 1==4 "8 6L ?8 7@R . "@# &8 ? 14 O$ 1==2! 1=5=2 $ 8 ? 1K E$ 1==3! 4L5=3R 8 ! VW,/</$! A! 1==2! "8 72=! X K $ 7R <$/$< , YW/Z?!1==3!"8L4R8 I !(00@$,/$ ? T$ ? *T,/<! $ ? 0#? 6151==3! "8 13=KR . 88?41E,1===;8
@; 0$:?#/,"?$?$+"["?"\!? $0$0 < ? $0$0 )##@! ", ?- ?#H$ H$<G!-F$?-?$#$$-?$$ -"$# ? $, ? < ?$ "" J$ "# ?- $@ G $+"G "#$$ ? 0$" "$ 90F ? $J$ ?HH! ,$<! $@ ? $$ $ ? 0#0! H$<@$#! ?#"! $8;8H$"?$G!0#?0$!"$"$?0:#?@ J$ $$@# D $$$ D $#R ) ?$ ""%$! , ?<# ? ,0@ "#"?#$! 00 #G ? -?$ 9 . 11= KKC?84!116K23,8?87@;8
; ?$ D ? "$$ "" $ -F$ ?- ? $# ?#G$8 $# $ ?#G$ ! ?-": ? ? / $ -F"#?,!H$?###$$""D$%HH$?<? G -$ "?$! , ? #$$ "$ ? H] <## H,#"$$9 .14L721?8L$#H#;8
:!-?$$?<,$#0+!H$F0$$: ?#G$??$#H?$$:#0##F .116 K22 ,8 ?8 2 $ KC4 ,8 ?8 7@8 $: $ ,$P $ 0$$ "$:0$ ?0$G $: "$:0$ 0"$ ? -?$R <,$# $ "$: ? # "/+GR ?# 00$ < ? $$0$ 0#?R ? "$$R ? $$0$ 0#? $%$ <<,$$@?#G?-?$R?HH$#""? <#$0"$0"$$R?<#$?#?-"$#? $,8
?HH# ? $: ,@ ?-$$$ D $# "+/G #$,D$0$0?$+"["?"\!-$"?#H?, $@?$$$$$-#$"$Q$?$0$G"+/G
9 .116K26?82R 1===K71"873C,8?8K@;8
?; *S<$ ? S""#$ ? ",! E<! H?$ ""#$?",H",$<$FG "#?# ?SHH! $ , G $ H$ "#$$ ?<# ? ,0@"#"?#$$G?S$0"@$"$"
5436754337 )=514) 0?H $$ ""#$! $ "H ?S?0$ ?S$ ", 9""#$ $"# ? ",R V! N$<,H/ ? *T,/<! "8 414! X 7L3R V^T5&Z! N$<,H/ ? N$</$"H<??!4#?8!"8K=!X111$"8116!XK43R+<! ?,N$</$"H<!4#?8!"8467RH8 .14472=!$144 124;8
* "" ? @ ""#$ ? ",! E< ?$ F0 ? 0:@E$,$0+?",!GG-$",!" ?#??0$D?"$"0$$$?"$E<0$,@ ?$$<F8*""$0#?F$$?$!"$G? -HH ""# -0@ ? ", $ ?G " GH?"0#?$"$80"$! "H#,"@$""$0#?!G$"$$<F 0"$$ $ H$ -@E$ ?- #$? H#! G ""$ H? ? F00"$!G-"#<0$?#$"$F"0#! G-$#$##$@"??90:;!G?"$ ? $H# 0#? $ $! H! G ? -F"$ $@0$,#9 .144123?81$#H8R1==L"877;8
*E"?? . !0#?$$$0?$?8$? "$"$:!?H#"GG#<$$ "$$50#?8 S "! ?S0@#! ? ? 0$$ ?$ S"$# #<# " "$$! $$ ? $$ ?S#,$ ?HH8 ""!H$?HD"$$!G$/$@!$H$? "$E",?S@E$,$##!<?#GS$"!@ ! ?SJ$ " $ "@ D "$$8 :< $ ?S GS #"SF"$?"""$$9*4331!13=?8K@5R 1=CC!"8L37?84;8$$!?S""#$?""$#0$ ? 0#? $$$ E< "$ $ ?$ $ 0"$ ? H$ ,$ ? SF"# G! ? " "$ ? H?$ ",#<# G H: 0?$!0#?$$$$/??$H,?"$$9 . 14716L?87$#H#$#RZ?+25=7"826;8
68 S":!@G-$"#?$##0$?$@G $+"G!?#H$?<,$#?-$$$@"0$"?-?0$$-F$! ?<# ? ,0@ "#"?#$ ) <##0$ ""G# ? ?0?9 .142K23?8L@!14L1=L?84 $#H#;)!?-$$$<D#,?$+"["? "\8 HH$ ? $ "?$ G $: "$0$ $@G$+"G?-$0$0?$+"["?"\$$#" 0 ? "$! $ G 0F ? $J$ ?HH! ,$<! $@ ? $$$?0#0!#!H$<@$#!$@?,! $@$#! @$# #0$! ?#"! 0?H$ ? $:! $8
5436754337 )13514) HH$! ? 0F ? $J$ $ ? ,$< $ ""! " ? ? "/+G! G $ $: HH$ D 0: ? E"? H#?# ""@ 0$: ? $0$0 ? $+" [" ? "\ 9, " F0" S . 7K3537?17,433L;8
! ! 0#? $$$! ?<$G# $ +?08 $0$DG)?G#??$!##0$F$$ /T"$$HH$"D",$$?$?<$!,? E"?0$#!G H0#$F"G# @8 $!S+H$")DS0"$",$ ? @! G S#$ " $$ ? 8 ,/! ""$! 0"#$#! ? 0"$ $: E"?$ "0$$$?%$","@$8
*S<$ ? ? , $ 0@! H $ ? $$ GS "#F$$ 0$ D S?$ ! $$ G $! $ $ H?#?S<?"$?0??"$$ $0$? $8$HF??G $$$$#?? $# , S?$P " $ ? $@ ?#<##$H! $ ? D S?$ 0 ? D )8 ? ! $ " G $@ ,$ #$# ?<$G# 1=== ?#ED! $ 0$$! " SHH$ /0$<G! D 1==38 4331! +?0 ?F /G,$#$#0#,?8D! "? $# #,?$ , S?$P 0 + "$ ? S/+"$/: GS +?0 ? [" ? "\ "$ J$ $! $ "$ " ? ,$0@D""0$"!?$"D%$9H8? ?$;8S+? ?$?J$,"0J0 G"##?00$8
H! $ " ?$# ? S##0$ "+/G! @ G $ "< ?S#$$ ?#"H8 "?$! D E$ ?G# GS 0@$GS$#$$F$$$0$!0GSS,$$$#?$ 00#?$0$ ": S?$! S$)D)? ? 4 0 D 4 0 #$H8!,0@4331&,$?#ED?<$G# ?+$/+0!$0@?"$@$?S/09?#"!F$$! F#$#; 9H8 ! ! $ ? $0 ? 0#?! 46:0#?8;8
!$?$#$$$@?$$ S?$ ? ,0@ 433K "$ J$ $8 0$! $@ G $+"G ?- $0$0 ? $+" [" ? "\ S$ G $: "$0$0"R0$@"#F$$DS?$!$ ""$ 0#? S#$@$ ?<# ? ,0@ G 9H8 . 141 43C ?82@$11=KKC?81;GS$#$#<<,#")8
5436754337 )11514) : ! S$ " # ?SF0 $: ?#G$ ? ? $#8"$"?$?!S<$?S?$?<,$#0+!G ""$ ? $: $ " 0"8 "$ S+ " ? $ 0$$ "$:0$ ?0$G ? $: "$:0$0"$?-?$!?<,$#?$"$: ?#"/+G!$S+"?S?$$0$0#?$%$ <<,$ $@ ? #G ? -?$R ? ?HH$# "" ?<#?0"$0"$$R?#?$$0$ 0#?! ? "$$ $ ?<# $ ?# ? -"$# ? $, $ ? "#$! ##0$ G S $, H#G00$ ? ? +?0 ?F "$$8 $! H?$ $ 0"$ ? H$ F$#$G?HH$#"H#<0$0E8
C8 G"#:?!E$#8
5436754337 )14514)
# " 2 " #" # #
%
456 7 8 9: ;+' $<
6
18 #,@8
% 6
48 E$$8
K8 $G"#?$<$$8
78 H0 "$ ? GS ",$ H0 $ "#$ J$ ? ?# ? K3 E ?: $H$ " " 00?# ?# @ H#?# ? ! */NT/HG 2! 2337 ! $ F0"8 ?# "$ J$ "<#8 0#0 ?$P ; ?G F$0$G?#$?#@$$"??# $$G#R @; F" " G 0$H $0 ", ?0? $$ $ ?#R ; "$ <$ ? "#$$8 * 0#0 $$ " $ ##0$ #0## $$ ; @; $ ; )?! @H#?#?""$0$:GS ?,?#,@80#0?0$0+ ? ",! G $ E$! G ?# $$G# $ S,"" ? G#$#F"#?#$9$81K4!132$13C;8 <HH #?$P * @*
"H0?"#$J$$$H#F"$GSDSHHH#?# ?$#"@G"<HH
5436754337