Indemnification Agreement Scope and Extrinsic Evidence in Liability Determination
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe petitioner challenged a decision affirming a determination that they were responsible for a portion of the underlying obligation based on the language of a written agreement regarding an indemnification clause and subsequent waivers, arguing the clause was ambiguous regarding the scope of liability and that the court erred by relying on extrinsic evidence. The court reasoned that the agreement's language, while potentially open to interpretation, clearly established the petitioner's obligation under the indemnity provision, and the extrinsic evidence used was properly considered to clarify the intent of the parties regarding the scope of that obligation, thereby affirming the finding of liability.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Indemnification Agreement Scope and Extrinsic Evidence in Liability Determination: The court reasoned that the agreement's language, while potentially open to interpretation, clearly established the petitioner's obligation under the indemnity provision, and the extrinsic evidence used was properly considered to clarify the intent of the parties regarding the scope of that obligation, thereby affirming the finding of liability.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertThis provision was cited in the dispositive orders regarding the allocation of costs for the appeal proceedings.
Volltext
"#$%"&''# "(%'"&'')
* +* ! , *! ,!+
!- . / &0 1 &'')
2222222222 ! "#! " " $ %& ! ' !( () *+! (++
!
3 *! + ,!(-. ! /0 1 +!+* 2 +-
! & /35 &
4+
89 ! '* /77: "( ;;;;;;;;;; *!+! * < ( $ , ,, , =+& < ' > !+! ( ' ?+@!+ ( +9
/9 6 A + /77: '+!* * ?+ +! A!+ ?!+ 1 ++) B;;;;;;;;;; ) *+ 8/ + /77: .! ( 8C4D6 . 9 00 ! + 1 ' 9 ' * '! +!*@ ! )+!!* ( !!9
:9 + ( 88 E+! /77: ' +(+)* 1 +*!+ )' !!+! !+ +!+ ! +.+ *9 .+ +! ) '+! A!+ *+* *!+! 1 - @ !+! ( ' ?+@!+ ( + + )' A +! !++!+ ) ! !!* ( .! )+ !+! 1 45D . 9 479 '-F!-< G ' * +! )+!!* ( '!+ ( .! + + +?+! ( (( ? ! ( ! !!* 1 '*!?+! *9 ( . ' +! ('! ( !! E(+++ !+9
49 + ( H E ' .+! A+ 1 ++) B;;;;;;;;;;
) .! ( 8/ + /77: 'A+! *!* *!?+ . *! I (*++ + ! +!* *!! +! A!+ ..!* E !
'+A+!+! 1 !+.+ 9
09 86 E+! /77: ' *!?+ (*! ( !!+ +!
#! !! ( 4/J . 9 50 .A ( ' *9
D9 + ( 87 !? /77: ' * +(+)* 1 ' )'+ *!+!
+!? )' . . + (' +!+@ '! 1 ++)9 !!
* 1 !+! ?+@!+ (A+! H! A ! ('+! A!+ ?!+ 9 +A+!+! ' 1 ( (*++ . ( '-F!-< G &+ +!+! ( +!+9
J9 * ( D A? /77: ' .+! A+ 1 +! ) +!+@ )+ '+! 1 ++) ! ( ( .! !+ *!+! (!
< ( + .*(* 9 .!+ ( '+ ( !! *( (+..* +!+@+ ( 65: . 9 80 +! +! 1 - @ ( ' +! * ++)9
59 + ( : (*? /77: ++) B;;;;;;;;;; +(+)* 1 ' * ) .! A+! *!* *!?+ !! ! (+! ! +!! 1 (*++ ( + .*(* ( J /77:9 ? ( .! !+ ( !!+ *!+! I+)* 1 ' * .+ )' + .+ ? +& (+9
34563/774 & :35 &
69 8D (*? /77: ' * ! + + 1 ' '+A+!!
A .+ 1 A+ +!+ ! 1 + !!+ (9 ( +!!+ +++ ('! + A+! ? * * ! + ( *!!+ * + *A! ! '*!?+! +A* *9 ' * +A+!+! ' 1 +(* !! A+ 1 ( (*++ . G (+.++! +!+9
879 /: EA+ /774 ' * A .+ * + ( ( (*++ . .! ( )+ ! +! (A! ! +?I9
889 * ( / .*A + /774 ' .+ * )' '*!+! ( ( ( (*++ + ( *( (! (A! + .*(* 9
8/9 ! ( 6 /774 ' * (** (A! +? ( * ! . @* ( !! ( 9 +! 1 ) !! ( +< +! (* 1 + F ( 8'748 . 9 J09 , *( (! (A! + .*(* AH!+! !< *E(++ +!+@ ( ! ) '*!+! 1 ! ! ) ' !+++! !+.
. ( ( (*++9 .! A+! *!* *!?+ !! ++ ) 'A+! (*! * ++)9
8:9 * ( /7 A + /774 ' E! ( 9 +(+)* )'+ I+!+! ?< * ( '? ( A!+ ! +.+ ! &H ! ++)9 <@! )+ A+! *!* *(+!* + (' !!
@A+ A+! *!* ! + < ( + .*(* ' @+!+ ,!*+ , 9 ,'@+! (' +!+@ ! ! . + ( !!+ )!+ ('+! *!!+ ( ! +. '*!+! -?++!* 1 ( ( (*++ + A+! *! ! ( *A! *( ?+! ! ++)9
!++! ) +!+@ )+ '+! 1 ! 'A+! 1 H! ! -* ?++ (' (*++ ! ) *)! + A+! F A+ ( (*+ ( E!+9 + A+! ( (*++ ! !!
( .! +) '*!+! *+*! ! +. F !+. )+ *!+! !!* & (A! + .*(* 9 +!!+ E +(+) 'H-+! ( ( (*++ !! )!+9 E!+.++! ( ('!!( '+ ( +!+@9
! G ' * +A+! * + .*(* '*!+! (*! +* ! A+! E!* ( ,!*+9 "@ * ' +(+)+! )' '*!+! !E ( (*! + .! + ( (+A @ ('+! *!!+9 A(+!+ ( !! !!* !+! ( ('!+!* ! )!+ (A+! H! ! -* +? ?+! 9 +! ( ? ( ( ! +( 1 ( +!+ ) *@+!++!* ( +!+ *!+! !E ('I9
34563/774 & 435 &
.+ + F A+! + ( *+ )'+ '*!+! ** ) )! + ! + ( ( ' * ! )+ !+!+! ! ..+! E!+.+ 'I+! (' (*+ ( E!+ ('!! + ) *E(+ ?+ ! *!+! ( !+.9 ( ?+ H (*+ ( E!+ (A+! H! (+ +? A+! (-* I + +! ( ! + (A+! !! ( + AF )' ( (*++ !+? ( 9
849 *+) ( 87 + /774 ! +!* ( +9 ! *( ) + F+! . ( ( (*++ *!+! ! +* )+ (A +! (+ &+ 1 +(* +!+ ! ! ( ( - @ . +9 .+! ) (*++ + + .*(* E!+.++! (+.+!+ ( +!+ ( ' A+! ) *( 'A+! ( !* *E(++ *! +!+@9 ,!*+ A+! .+! ! (*?! @! 1 'I!* + ( ( ( +!+@ ! ( + ( *( 9 + .*(* + A+! ('+ * ) +!+@ ! (A+! H! ! -* ! +?I *!!9 "+!! ) *( E(+++ A+! *-* + 'F A+! + ('!!( '+ ( *( ?+! +A)* ' !! ( +< '*!! &H ? ( (+ + *( ?+! !! +! ( *( +!+@9 .+ ' .! ( (*! + + 'F A+! + ( + AF ! +? (A+! (+ !! ( +!9
809 (+) ( // E+ /774 ' +!* ( +9 ! + ! 1 ) *!(+! ! !! *( !+A 1 )!+ ( !! .! * ++) +A* '*!+! *@* +) +? ?+! (A+! !+ !9 + ! 'A+! +A+ + (* + .+ ('*A+! ( ?+ *) ( *( 9 G + I+!+!
+ !! (+..* ( ! ++) +A* ! (+ + +! +-* ! ( ! ( ' ( ? 1 * ) !! !!*9
8D9 + ( ' ! *!* ! + 1 ! ! *!* @ (* 1 E@ 9
34563/774 & 035 &
,+
89 + @A+ ' @+!+ E(+++ => *!* (+.+* ! +!+!* (< 8 K! /77: +? ! ( + * ( 0 E@ (! *+(! ! A+& *+(! 0 *! ! 8D E@ = !9 8 !9 ! 0D >9
,+! 1 '!+ ( '*!+ ( 8D E@ +? .*(* /J EA+ /774 = L 8:7 87D> ( + @A+ (!* 8:
.*A + (++!+ ! +!+ @! !!! +? ! ( + ( +*@ 1 ! + E@ !+!+ ( '!!! ( '*!+ ( AI E@ 9
/9 + .*(* !+ @** ( ( +! ( + ( D !? /777 =+& < M > ! ! * A+@ 8 EA+ /77:
! #! (+.+!+ ( ? (++!+ *@ ( (+ ( ' &(+9 ! +? ('< ++ ( +? ( * (*+ ( E!+ (!! ( + ( /7749
:9 . *! 1 C !9 0D 9 8 !9 -9 4 +? ! ( + #! +! +) ( !!!+ *A 1 ' !+ 0D )+ ! !+A 1 + .*(* ' &(+ ( 85 8664 =+& < M ">9
, *! E@ ( ('< ! ++ *!?+9
49 ' !9 /6 9 8 !9 & )+ *(* 1 C !9 4 9 8 !9 (+ 8 EA+ /777 & (+ ) !! ( +! ( *( E(+++ (++! !+A 1 ) +! ! +!* *)+!?! ! E@* ( (*+ +?9 C+! ( C !9 D 9 8 $ & )+ C.. 1 ! *@ ( !!+ *!( = 86J5 9 :/0 +(9 /> & !! (++!+ ++ ( ** +!* ! ! (+! -+? ! ( +E!+.+* 1 !! 9 C! +!* A+ !! @ !+ !+!!+ )C ( (*++ )C+ + +? ( ( ( (*+ +! + ( (*+ ) ! ( C..+ ++ ) !! ! + ! .! #! +? = L 8/6 48D +(9 8 8/D /46 +(9 4 8/4 8:6 886 8 88J 88J +(9 : 86J +(9 8 N A+ + 3"+A +3$!!+ +!
!+!!+ + A9 ( +! .(!I 9 064 9 8/44 9> M
, C !9 8 9 8 " (++!+ ( ! * A+@ 8 EA+ /77: ! +? 1 C &(+ 1 'I!+ ( !+ (+ = !9 8 9 / ">9 I ! ( C !9 46 9 8 C (+!
( * +! (*++ )+ !! ( !!+ * +E!+ + !! A ) C+!* * C! (C (9 ,+ )* ! ( A +?? +!* H! (+@ (CH! !*@* C (
34563/774 & D35 &
(*++ !!!+ = !9 46 9 / >9 !!+ * ! +E!+ )+ ! A+* C !9 46 9 8 A! H! ! +!* *( ++.+*N C+!* * ! (! I+@ )C (*++ +! ( = !9 08 9 8 ! / >9 (*++ A! H! !!)* ( ! ! E A+ (C+!+ < ( C )+ ( = !9 0/ 9 8 > ! (*++ +!+ A! .+ C?E! (C (A! ! +? ! ( *!! = !9 0D 9 8 !+ A !9 0J 9 8 !
05 9 8 >9 ! ) (*++ +!+ (+A! H! ( ( (*+ +* (+A! H! !+A* ! +(+) A+ ( = !9 0/9 / >9
, C !9 0D 9 / ! + H! . * ) C @ * (( ( C+!* * ( ( (*++ ( (*++ +!+9 . ( !! ! ( 1 !! !+!! C?E! ( +!+@ + ! +? ( ! ( +! ?+@!+ ( ( +! ( .( ) C+!* * ((* I *! 1 C ( = L ?+* ( /: !? /77: :/537: ! O 0037:>9 *( .*(* ?*)! = !9 D/ 9 8 > C?E! ( +!+@ ! *@! ++!* . ( !! ! ( 1 !! ( C 1 CI+ ( ( +! ?+@!+ ( ( +! ( .(9
' ! 0D 9 / A+ . ( !! ! ! ( 1 !! (C (C ! +!* (++! !+A9 F ! ( +E!+.+* ( ! ( C! +!* )C (+..< (*++ &(1 ( !! (*+ +?9 !< +? ( ( * ( *( C *+ .!+ ( + ! !++< ( 9 .! !! ( +(* !+ C ! (+..+!* ( &+ ++ ) !! ( E!++? + ( + ! ! A +!+@ ! - @ ( ! A+ ( C! +!* = L 8/0 868 +(9 />9 , +! E + ( ( A! C! * A+@ ( + ( +? CF! !* (+.+!+ 1 !+ ( (*+ ( E!+ = L ?+* ( 4 E+ /774 O87637:>9
!++ + !+! E!++? (C! ( )+ ! A+ ) C! +!* . (++@ ) +! C+A+!! 1 ** *( ! *-*! ! ( +E!+.+* = L 87J ? 800 +(9 /? ! 9 805 9>9 !! ?+@!+ C *+ !!.+ A + ( +@ *( * ! (++! !+A =$.+@ 3,-P + Q+- "- -!RA!+ ( (+ ,-S+T 8666 9 /7:&/74N 3 "+A +3$!!+ +! !+!!+ + A9 9 8/4:>9 +! + - 1 ! +!* )) ! !N I&+ ! +*A+!? ( *( =.9 L 8/4 ! 886 *+!*>9 ( (C *+!+ (C? + .! *@! !+ ! ( .+! )C !+<
34563/774 & J35 &
(C + *@+! ( + ! !++< 1 +)+(!+ +( ( < = L 8/D /46 +(9 4>9
09 +!+@ ! +! ( A+ + ' + (*+ ( E!+ (! ( (*++ +!+ )' *!* +A+!* 1 .+ 1 + + !9
! ( (+ ) @ * (( *+!* * ( +*!+ C (+ .* ( !! (*++ E!! 1 (( ( C+!* * !(! 1 + - @ ( . + ( C+! A!+ ?!+ ( 6 A + /77:9 , !! ? . ( !! !+! (*E1 (*+ ( E!+ !! ) ! +! !+. ..+! +A+! C 1 ( (*++ . ) ) +! + ) &+ .+! ( !! 9
' I+) )' ! ( ( (*++ ( G !
* 1 ' +!+ ( ++) +A* ( <A )!+ ( ! +. ! ) !! )!+ ! *E(++ +!+@9 ! ++ ) ' (*E1 .+ * +? .*(* ( + ! ++? 1 C ( !! ?++ (C (*++ ( &! * !+< 9 ! ++ (C ! ! (*++ E +(+!+ ! +! ( +! ( (* A? .+ (CI+ ?+&.(* ( (*++ (++! !+A !! ('! !+< !+. ) ' . ( !! 9 *-*! +? +! ! +* 1 ! !+< ( +! ( .( ! 1 !! ( + +!9
( ( *! *( + ' !+! +? ( * ( +!+@ ! '+!+* 1 ' +!+ ( ++) +A* ( <A )!+ ( ! +. + +)! ( !! ) ' *!+! ( ( (*++ ! )' (*+?* *! .* ( .+ 9
++ )' A+! ( A+ ( ! '?E! ( +!+@ ! ++!* . ( !! ! ( 1 !! ( C 1 CI+ ( ( +! ?+@!+ ( ( +! ( .(9 ! + ! 1 ) !+! ! + ( )!+ +? ( * ('! !+< + +!9 , +! ! + A?9
D9 ! ( !+! (+ ! AF* 1 ' )' ( ( ? . (*+ (*++ . (K! !+A* !
!! F ( ( +!9
'+!+* (< (* +! ( (* .+I* 1 8C777 . 9
34563/774 & 535 &
! , +4 +* ! , *! ,!+
567 8 9 :; /(& ,<
7
89 * A?9
7
/9 '(! !+!9
:9 ( 1 $ , ,, , ( ( (*+ (*++ . (K! !+A* !! F ( ( +!9
49 ( $ , ,, , 1 A 1 ! ( 8C777 . 9 1 !+! ( !++!+ 1 . + ! (*9
09 . !+ ( )' A! . ! *! H!
( (*+ ( :7 E (< !+.+!+ + (* ( * +? .*(* ( ,-S+T -.)+ D D774 ! + I+ 9 (*+ ! H! @*9 *+ (+! M > +(+) I!! ) (*++ ! (*+ ?!+ + ! ( (*++ !!)*N ?> I ) !+. + !+ A+ (( !! ! (*++N > ! +@! ( *!!9 ,+ *+ !+! ! + **! ** * !! > ?> ! > +&( +? .*(* ( ! !+< )'+ (A (* + A?9 *+ ( !+ F ( A )+ ! E+! ++ ) (*++ !!)* ! 'A ( ) *!* I*(+* ! = !9 8:/ 87D ! 875 >9
@ ..+< *+(! M
" +&+ 2 + U
*!+ &E +! M " + $ ""
+ . ( *! H! ! !+.+* I !+ ++ )'1 '..+ .*(* ( !* ?+) @ ..
34563/774