Negligence in Motor Vehicle Collision Upheld
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertA party sought to recover damages for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident, claiming the other driver failed to maintain a proper lookout and control, leading to the collision. The court determined that the evidence, including photographs and skid mark analysis, sufficiently supported the jury's finding of negligence on the part of the defendant driver, whose inattention and excessive speed were deemed the proximate cause of the crash, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the injured party.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Negligence in Motor Vehicle Collision Upheld: The court determined that the evidence, including photographs and skid mark analysis, sufficiently supported the jury's finding of negligence on the part of the defendant driver, whose inattention and excessive speed were deemed the proximate cause of the crash, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the injured party.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited in the dispositive to order the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal.
Volltext
!"!#$$% &!'#$$&
( )(* *+* (* +)
,-. "
#& / #$$&
!"#$"%%% !!" &$"'"!( )* %+
"!
( (( (((& (( ( %"%$ & (),"""!-.//0
601-06
* 0)
-7 $ % -8.4 "!#%%" +%"$ "!% 9 "7 "%"!$"%"!$ !: %"%%&! &%" ;%6 !: ( < "! %" !=% " !=%7
07 4>%"0//2!+&$"%"!!?"$9=!@#"#%"! =" !"$ ! &!!%:! ! "! #$,%7 &!$ "$ ? >!9!@! $%& A ! %%%+ !9+""B$"$%!!?""!#%"": >!7
27 &!$! !%"!#%0->%"0//2" !%#%"!%"" !: ! "!,%! !"%+7! !"2$C!0//2 !)D$%@$$! $%@"%!#%@% "6"!"%+ " %%+$ + "%" %#%" "!%"" & "! ,E! 7
47 !!$! !"9( .#!%0//4+% $ %@"% !#%@% "6"!"%+ " "%$ !%" ! !#% C %!!%" #! C! $!%! @,7 =%" !"%+!!#%08>#%!0//4+%%$#%!%! @" !#% # $C, &%#!% ! ,F%@%+ % ",% $C"" 46 5 " 56 . %@ =%" %6!%%!7 !! $&!#%$"%"%%"!7 ! !$%$ "!#% !" ,!@ " &$#%"! %"%#+ ,$#"7
57 &!$$"$"!%"$ !!!,"@ )D+% !!%" !!?""!#%02#!%0//40.#!%0//47!#$+ "%" 9 !: "" +% G%" "!%"" !: H,% , F! " !$$9%=%"!"%3#!%0//47
.7 "! ) $% @$$! )D "! $"C% !"%=%" " -2 I" 0//4 G "! + &!$ #%" "!#%! %"%+ ,$#"% !"!,!@!7 !!%" !!?" "!#% : -8 I" 0//47 ! !" $% %"!$%%!!$9( 02 "C!0//4$%"!%""!#$ !%"!9+"G"! :E""%$ %% %% +& $ !%7 "%" $"%" "!%"" ,E ! ;$%<"!D F,%"!7
37 ( =%$G !"%!!@7
1234310//5 621-06 J7 ! !!%! -/ >#%! 0//5 9 ( $% "!%"" !:# + "%"==!! !%""9+9&$ @,%!!%"#! &% " " C! @, %" G "?" #!"%@ "!C#%%%7 F "K" !#+$%% &G%$"$ "!C $%! # + "!"% " ="%@ !+$7 ( ! ) &!$ !$" "" F! "! "6"!"%+#=!" "$ !%#"#!%"#%! ! F,@7
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
-/7 ! !!%!2 =$#!%!0//5( %=!$&!$+&$#"% %""% &C%@%" 9 !$G%! +"% ! C%%"$ " +& %"&"!%"" !""%&!#=="%$%"7
1234310//5 641-06 --7 !$"$ !%+( )* &!$=%"#%!9 ( +&""%"&!"$>9%! !"&G !"%! "%%"$$% !=%! !"C!#"%7
-07 % 2- ! 0//5 &!$ !:# + &G !" &" !$!"!"!"%%"$"!"!C F,%+" "" + &%" %" %" "$@!% %!7 !%" G G !"%#$,%%"$7
-27 &!$ $"$C!#"%"2>%0//5"#!$%! ! !"&G !"%#$,%+%"9%==$!#%""! #$,% % %+$ !% "! . " -2 M1,7 %% +& ! !" ! J #!% 0//5 + "!C +& !$" " "" 9 =%" "%C # %"7 G %+$ + % & %+!#&G !"&"& !" !+&"!!%#$9C%" &F" !"%+" !% %" !% ! " &"! !" !% #% !$,% @ =!P%7 9 ( =%! !$! 9 G !"% F,%"!%+ %% +&9 "!6 G !"% !@%+ # ! & "!"! !% +% !!%" %!9"!"%7
-47 ! $%% J >% 0//5 ( !$=$!" G % ! "%$+"!C+%C%""" 9&%" %G%#""!%#7&%"4>%"0//2%%$ %$ ==" !: !# %" 4 >%" 0//47 " G "!C F,%+ % " !"% %"$ $+" # &$#$" %" !%! #" ?"! +%=%$ "" @!#%"$ F7 $+( $%$!"""!=%G !""%# 2=$#!%!0//5%!7
-57 !&%"!$%%!"%!&!$=!$ %"%J>%"0//5 ! !," 9 ( &#%! !% " !!+ +& #%" =!$!" $!"&G !"%"$%"$&"!"!7 ! ! !:# +& G !"% F,%"!%+ " %% C !$"!C F,%+7
-.7 !$%%0/>%"0//5( !>"$& %"%&!$"%= + !"% %"$ $+" "! "!C F,%+ " " &%" &" $"C%7 ( ! ==" + &%" C% ! &!$"@!#%"$F9%%""$@!%%=$!%!!% ! +%!%"#%!&%=$"!%"& !%"%"!C F,%+7 %@"% !$% !"%= 9 &""%" F,%+ &" %% & "%%"$!"+%#"%@"%"9"$@!%"%7
1234310//5 651-06 -37 &!$%"!>""!!0/"C!0//5=%"#%!+&"9"!"+ ( %=%9 !""%2=$#!%!0//5!?+&G !" &" !$!"!C F,%+7"%"!+&G !"% &" $!$ &C & "!"! +% G %+ $=" %"%!#$ !!7!! "!$% """$""G !"%"!$=:!! !"!+%"% +& # G !"% " $%! # ! & %"! !:" $"$ %"# F,%"!%+7
-J7 !$ -- #C! 0//5 ( "" !%" + &G !"%&"$!$%:! !" !"%%:!!:#+&G !" !"%"!%!#%% "+&%""F N %N "?"! !":!+!!"& !$"$"C %%+ "F %+04930,!7 &"+02 "C!0//4%" & !: &%" + $% " =%" $"" &%% " $ !% =="%+%"%"" 9"C%%+"F %+7(! "%+ "" + "1% $"$ ""%" !: &%" %"4>%"0//47 "G"!C F,%+ ! 9 %" !"% %"$ $+" &@%" & %" !#" "$@!% @!#%"$ FB "! !%" ! ",$! "%+ &" %%+$!$& $"$!"@"%&F %"% ,! &@@!#"% F,@%+7 ( %:! + &G !"% %" #%! !'"! % #! !C" " " !>" !!7
-87 ! !$ %+ 3 $C! 0//5 !!" !%"$ % ! " + !%! $% "$ 9 ! ! $% &G#%"C% $%@"% %%%+!9 + " "7 "%" +& !% %==%"$ "%:! !$,% " &G !% @ =!P% & %%"%" $!%! :""$""&""+&&" &"! %"%=7
0/7 #%"$ 9 $"!%! ( ! !!%! 2 >#%! 0//. %" %"%7
0-7 (!$"$@!$9>@!7
1234310//5 6.1-06 * +)
-7 %@#%!Q!@%"%>%%%!;<$"$%=%$"%"%"$: -!I"0//2 !%C"!% $5>@ " !$%""#%6 !$%"5 $""-.>@!;!"7-"7 !"5. <7
(%"9Q"%Q$"%-.>@! ! !%C=$$! 03>#%!0//4; )-2/-/.<! %@#% "$-2=$#!%! % %"%"!%"%!!@" !""" !%C"! % %$@! ! 9 "!% >@ "%"%! Q""" Q$"%#G>@!7
07 =!$" 9 &!"7 5. 7 - "7 ,7 5 !%C " !%'"%"%+"""% !$#9Q!"75. %=$$!! !"%@$$!!%"!%."C! 0/// ; < +% " !"%# 9 % =$$! ! Q!6%" 0/!-8J-; <7
( $" !>@!Q :"%%$"C%7
27 " "!$ #%@! -! >#%! 0//2 "!'" %=%"% C! % %"% $@ % ! %7 (! "$!% %"#%!+!%"& %+%"?"!"!,$9%:! !%% +!:@ %C"#%@!"O =%">!%%+"$"!%"" !%"; )-2/02/%7-7-B 225%7-70B )-084%7-70B )-034.3%7--0.-2. %74C"!$=$!<7!:@ !$!+"9& %+" !$!#:>!"!$#%@!; )--382%7.C--02./ %74B -88JR23 72-.%72C<7 Q %+ Q :7
47 (&!"75.7- $%%! %"%">""9!! $% 2/ >! ;!"7 ./ 7 - < !: "!%C ! " %% &!$ ;;!"7 5J 7 - <7 "%:! &!6 %"""=%$!@"%9&!"7./ $%!!""!% % ! $%%! %"% !""! !""%&! ;!"7 -/. <7
"!>"$" "%"=! !!%"!!"!#C7
57 %"%@ !" ! !%" !!" 9 !""% &! "$!%!"2!0//5!%&%"!#4>%"0//27
1234310//5 631-06 .7 G"!&!"7.7- %%&% "!" !""% &! " $ &%" !=% &%" !=%"% !=%7! C%%"$&!!6%" &$" !%% 9""$+@C+%"!#" ! !"%"$"!; )--8223%7---J0J8%7-C "!$=$!<"$+"#&$#$"!$; )-054.-%75" !$=$!<7
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
C<!+&$""%= !$G%"""@@!#$%:!@$$! !'" $"%#" 9 %" #%! &!6%" &! !""% % &%" "%" "! ;" $+"< @ %" !+ !%! !$" G%#" $"!@:! 9 &%"7 "!+&$"""$&%"$!$"%%%!9%+% G%"%" %$%"" #" &%" ;"" + "< 9 % +% !%" !# "K" "! ? &%" ! %" & $# " !%%! ;"" + %< ;=7 -880 -40 7 35 %7 4CB (,H%E!%, =#!%,!@!," 7 4.8 2 " 4B 1 (%@","@#SM,T!-88/ 750BU6 ( % V!C%" # %,"! !E" % ! (E%#!%,!@ "%$%%3-1-88/ 7-/82<7 "!!%%@" + "" + % # " &" !$"C% &!!6%" %" !! 9 ,!@"!%""&$""%= !$G%""!O%$"$$ @@!#$ !&%"7
1234310//5 6J1-06 <"%:!$%!,%!#% !%""F W %X ;(,!"!H,% ,6%>!F< !#&$=%%"="%!@%+ &G%" & ! !" %"$ "! %" !:@ ?"! ! !+& " "!"% " %@"%+$ " + &!$ !$" "C %%+"F %+; %""+G"?"%==#!"%@"!C "!"% " $%! $ ="%@C%%"$ ! "!C #%% %!!%"C%%"$ C%%"$ $"% $ !% %=%"% !":! "7<7 =" " + $%" %" %" ?"! %:! !$%C""!%C$9""%"9"$B6%%" !'"!#@!$ #!%C !$ $!"$+&%"; )--8 22J%70--32./%74C<7
37 %"$"$+"%& !:!!%%!,"&G $!% #%=%"%$!$$"%" ! !9"!'!=="@!%+%&" !%"!#!$"" !%"=P@$$!=#!%$ ! " %!" ; ) -05 4.- %7 5 " !$=$!<7 "=% !$&""%"9"$ ,F%+ !C:%"$$+" @:! ! &!!6%" !$ % %"% %@%:! " @!# +% !%" ,C%"" &G $!%$%; )--J08-%72--32.5C%75CC " !$=$!B )( &!6%" C%@"%! % Y (,H%E!%,#!H"@!,"728<7
! "!C &!! F,%+ $"%= 9 %" & !$%"% %"$ $+" = ! !%":! %==$!" + &!$ $"$ #%"%&"!"%"F W %X9!#% & "!"% @ ;( -885 Z 02 7 .3 %7 0< & "!"% !%6$!$C!7 ==" !+ &G%" & " "!"% "F W % X " $"C% % =" % &%" " @!#%"$ F G%! !":! $+" % %"$ =" ! !%":! $$!$ G ) --3 2.. %7 . " 2J0 %7 4C +&% %" $%%= #%! % "!C " " ""%" &!$ " "K" "! "%+ F,%+ ; ) --3 2.3 %7 . !%! !@! ,B -888Z24- 74/J%72C<7!#,"!&G !":! $+" % %"$ %" =%! ! %" @!#%"$ F ! C !%":! $$!$ G ) --5 -4/ %7 .1 " 4/8%751; 0//0Z43/ 752-%74<7
(% $% !"" $%=%+" "C %%+ %" & "!"% "F W %X 9 !#% & "!"% @ & "!"% !L%6$!$C! C% +& !"% $"C% " ""=%!$@$ !! !"G !C:&!! F,%+ "!%":!$$!$G )--5-4/%7.1"4/8%751" G$$!$G )--32..%7."2J0%74C+%
1234310//5 681-06 %#" =! & !$%"% %"$ $+" ; ) -02 88 %7 0B 0//0Z43/ 7520%74-885 7--5,7.<7
J7 ) ! $+"G" !%!%"9 !""% !:@+=! !# !"%"9 !"%+%%#+ !%!%"; ) 03"C!0//52J81/4B 0///Z2.2 7 4. %7 0 " !$=$!< "! " %$!"% &% &" %C ! !%% %+%%"%! &$"C%! ! C & !$%"% !# $"" =%" +% @!$ #!%C !$ $!" !! 9 !$%"$ ; ) --3 0.4 %7 2C " !$=$!<7 !# % !%"% % %"$ "! %" ?"! !"$ ! !# ="! $"!@! 9 &%"7 " ! % +"%&G%@!&!!6%" !#$@"%#+&""%"9 "$C%" + !!$"!$#" !=%""$7 "$%%= %"#%!%%"&""%"9"$ >" !K"%#"%%?"!%$!$F"% !;!!?" 7 2/ #C! 0//4 0001/4 7 -4 "C! 0//4 ..1/4 " 7 4 "C!0//4-581/4<7
87 (&%"%$>!% !!"%#9%""F N %N "& %+!:!+&,!%!#%@%!!"& !$"$ $%04930,!"C%%+"F %+&""!"%7
>! ? &%" !!" $"$ G%$ 9 ! @! $% &G O $% $ %@"% N %N " "$+ "%" %@%"!9+""7!$" =%,"%! ! !%:!""% !:"!"%&$$!"% !%6!#% $"C% 4 >%" 0//2 + !!" %@%" $ ,$ % #!"%@ $ #%"7 !$"%" "!C%%$%"$+ "%"#%""!: ! !:&%"7
!!" $"$ %#% ! %" ! %#! $% ! !#%@% "6"!"%+ !%""B C$$=%%$&"!%"" ,F%",$! % & "!"&%=%"!"%!"%"$![7 & !#% !"%+$08 >#%!0//4& "!$$%%&"!%!@"!#%" % ",% $C"" 46 5 " 56 . %@ =%" %6 !%%!7 &"! !" "C!0//4+ ! !%:!=% ! ) %@ !$ &%% " $ !% ,E !!"7"$!%!"%!:#+ "%"==!! !%"" >! " %" 9 + &$ @, %!!%" #! &% " " C! @, "G"?"#!"%@"!C#%%% %%"% =! %# C! $!%! @,7 % !#+ ,E
1234310//5 6-/1-06 &%% &G%$"$ #%! &@%""% "!C $%! # +"!"%"="%@"!:!+$7
! !"&G !"%!=%"$""+ !" &!$ ==!" %$%"" !#%6C!,%@% "% #!"%@% " C!,%@% @, # + =! C! $!%! @,7 "% $@" + ! !$ "%"!!"%%"9 %!!#%6$ ,$ %+"C!,%@%@,"!C#$%!" "!"%7(&G !"%&F &$$"9&:+% %=%! ! + &%" %" %+$ & "!"% !L% & "! "!"% %!" % ! "! % F #!%CC" , F,@%+ G %+" =%" + "%" &%" ! %! 6? "" &%" 9 &%C7 (&@%" &$"" G%6$ !%= !$"$ ! !!" ! $!$ #%! !! ! % !" " !"% %"$ # &$#$" %" : ! +&% &" F,%"!7
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
!!O+"%"% !>@!!%"G !""% 69 2 ! 0//5 " #%! % =="% +% C%"" ,E &!$ !!"%" $%=%+" "C %%+ "!"% !#% "F N %N "%"" ""%" 9 "$ %! %$ " " + !%@" F,%"!%+ =" """ $=" !%C $ %:! +&% " $%! !$! 9 %#"%@"% $"%!7
1234310//5 6--1-06 ! $+ !#F$ 9 &%"%$ =% +& !: 9 %"!"% $"%!"" !:! %%+ ! % \#! & G !"% !6 F,%"!%+ # ! $,$"&%"! !:"7&G !"#! !%@"% !$%!"! "!C %! % G6% "!#" ! !" %"$ "! # &%" % !! ! %"$ "!#%7 % =%" &%"%$ !! #$%%7
-/7 #&%%"%@!!"!%"9%%"$9"%"!$ + !%C=%G9-&///=!7
]]]
1234310//5 6-01-06 +)0 )(* *+* (* +)
12343-- 5 633 3 78 '&# + 9
43-
-7 $!!!!#C7
43
07 Q"7
27 $%%( 0/>%"0//57
47 #% 9 &%"%$ ! %"!"% $"%! %$!""#$%%7
57 &%"%$ 9 F! 9 !!" -/// =!7 9 "%"! !"%% "%9=!%"$ 77
.7 =! !"% +Q #" =!! !! "! !$" !!?" $% 2/ >! : "%=%"% ! % !$ !$ !%C =$$! ! (,H%E!,=+% . .//4 "!% G %!7 $% " ?"! !@$7 $%! %"Y < %%+! G""+$%%!!"$%!C"%!%" $%% ""+$B C< G ! ! + "%= % "% #%! ! "" "! $%%B < !"! %@"! ! !$""7 (% $%! "%" "!% $$" $$!$ ""! < C< " < %6 !%C=$$!! !! "!!"%:!!!!+Q% #!$!!%!!#C7$%!!!"%!!F !# +% !" >%" %% + $%% ""+$ " Q# +$"$G $%$!!";!"7-20-/."-/J<7 @!==%! !$%"Y ^% %
%=! !$"!!?"""%=%$G !"%%%+Q9Q==%=$$! "$ C%+ !@!==
1234310//5