Platform Liability for Copyright Infringement Despite Notice-and-Takedown System
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe case concerns whether an entity can be held liable for copyright infringement based on vicarious liability for content uploaded by third parties to its platform, despite implementing a notice-and-takedown system, when the entity was aware of infringing activity but allegedly failed to take reasonable steps to stop it. The court reasoned that while a notice-and-takedown procedure provides a safe harbor, actual knowledge of specific infringing material and the failure to expeditiously remove or disable access to it, or a direct financial interest in the infringement coupled with a right and ability to police the infringing material, can negate that safe harbor and support a finding of secondary liability.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Platform Liability for Copyright Infringement Despite Notice-and-Takedown System: The court reasoned that while a notice-and-takedown procedure provides a safe harbor, actual knowledge of specific infringing material and the failure to expeditiously remove or disable access to it, or a direct financial interest in the infringement coupled with a right and ability to police the infringing material, can negate that safe harbor and support a finding of secondary liability.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertApplied because the appellant must bear the costs of the proceedings.
Volltext
!"#$"!"%%& '!()%!"%%#
'
* '+ * ', * ,+
-. / 0 -( 1 "%%#
* ! ! "! # $% #! &'' # ( ) *#!++
2222222222 ,-!- , * ./# 0 1 ! 2 - ! #
#!
3* ,+ * "! # $% , * ! -
3
+ 54: +
4+'
(' *# ;<<<<<<<<<< ! - 3 ! ! #= %!# #! ! ,#> # ! # ,#> # ! #! ,#> # # # >-- 1+ ! 58 (:7( ,$ # %-- #,% 1 ? +,$ 1+ !@'
5' (: A 5889 A#! = %!# 1- = ,! ,#!+ !! 2 !# 1 B # !'
1- C, 2- 2! # 1+ ! , (D A ! 5889 21 A# ! = %!# !2 ! A # >$ !
21 E ! ! - !! ,# , $ ># # #!
,! !# 1 B ' !! # -! ! ,, # ! # # F >>#! =2 G' 1% ! 1 F >C , # ! G'
# 2- 2 > E ! -!- !-# 1-E-!'
H' - # 57 ,!= 5889 1+ ! >#- 1- 2 ,#E ! I! , B% 1% ! , 1 ! 1!' 9 # ,! %-- # ! # ? +,$ @'
9' + ! 1- #! > ! #,,# ! # 3 !! - # ,! E! (5 ! (7 #!#= 5889'
6' !! 55 #!#= 5889 - 3 1+ ! #! <<<<<<<<<< ,- - J F # ,! ! + I 1 ,! 2 ! >/# !2 = %!# 1 -- 1I! -,! #- 1 ! --2 = = >- # ! E #!! # E##! ! E #! %!#- "! ,#==! =#! 3 -B !# 1 B !' 1= !#! ! !! !- ,# #!!
- # !", ! #,!B B# 2 1= !#! , - ! # >E# ! ,! ,#!- ! ?#! #K 2 ##L@ A , 2 #! # ,! - # #! #>> ?1-@ 3 - # - 3 ! ! # #E! , E#! #,% G'
D' - # #,,# ! # (6 #E= 5889 1+ ! #> - - #' E- =! 2 # ! # 1 >! C!- F C!# G 1-! ! , , 1!' 9 # >-- D #!#= 5888 ,! %-- # ! # ? @ ! 21 1" E ! , >! C!- 1!' : ' 5 1## 1+ ! 58 -= (:75 ? @'
4567545889 + H4: +
M' 1+ !A!! # #! !! - # #,,# ! # , ! C,- - 58 -= 5889' #! 3 2 = - 2 1 # ! , 3 B% ! 1-E-! (: A 5889 !
,!! 2 # # ! ' 1,, # # #! !
#!! 2 -,! # = >- # ! 1- ! = >! C!- 2 # #- -B !# 1 B ! 21 !
$ # #- # - 2 1>>! # ! E 21 >! -B! % > ! > 1 # ! ' , > ! 21 1% ! 1 ! E !- ,#! E !2 >> ! # , 3 C 1,, ! # 1!' : ' 5 '
7' -# -,# 59 -= 5889 1+ ! ! ,# ! # # -! 21 1-! ! , #!!- 2 1!! ! #,# F ! -!- #%= # ! E##! ! 21 > ! = ,! ! - # --- 3 1!' : ' 5 ' #!># , ! , # ! # - - >! C!- '
:' ## (H AE 5886 #! > - = - ,, 1- ! ,! ! - M >-E 5886 ,# -! ' 1- - ! ,##%- (M >-E 5886'
(8' ! C,- - (D >-E 5886 1- !A!! # #! - # 1+ ! #,,# ! #' #! 3 21 # ! ! 2 ! # ! , B% ! 1 ! (: A 5889 #! -!- E ! '
#! ! 2 #! E - # , ! !#! # ! # - ,# ! 1C ! 1 ! 1!' : ' 5 ' F >C , # ! G 2 ,#E#2- - # 3 # !# 1 B # ! >>! I! # -- # # C!- # ! -E-! 3 ! C! #, B ,! = 1I! #!!- $ #=A! E ! 2 ,-! ! ,#!'
((' ; ! - 2 ,! ! ; (6 5886 E # ! #- 1+ ! ! ! # # # - !
7 5886 -,-!! 2 # ! # , B% ! ! 1!' :
' 5 #! , - -' $E 2 1 ! # 1 F >C , G ,,N! ,! # F -! # ,#! # >#- ,-,,#- 2 2#2 #E! !N - # 1! 21 - !
-!- ,!=- 1C!- G'
4567545889 + 94: +
,+'
(' # %E# 1#% ! # A ?@ -!- # > - ! ! !- $ ( #O! 588H = !# # ? +,$ =@ #,#- 6 A% #! ,- ! ! E +,- ! 6 ,,-! ! (D A% ?!' ( !' ! 6D @'
; ! 3 1! # 1-! # (D A% , = >-- 5M AE 5889 ? . (H8 (8D@ # %E# #,!- (H >-E ,# ! # ! !# %! ,!!! = !# # -% 3 !# A% ! ! 1!!! 1-! # #EC A% '
; #,-! ,# A% 1,$ ! -!= '
5' 1!' ( # >-- 1+ ! 58 (:7( ? +,$ @ ,# 2 ,# ! # # >-- D #!#= 5888 ,! %-- # ! # ? @ 1,, 2! 3 1+ ! 3 # 2 # 1" -#% C,-!'
1!' (8D ' ( C $ ,B -#%! # 3 1!' D8 ,-E# ! 2 - # ! !# # ,# - # #,,# ! # ,#!! ,!! # 1' - # - -! # ! # > C- , # ! ,# ! # ,-! E # ! ,= ' 1! , , , ,! = PI! ,##%- ?!' (D ' ( , $ ,B @' 2 P% ! , - , ! ! >## ! - # 2 ! ># #= %!# ? . (:79 ,,' 558+55(@'
# ! >-- - # # 3 # # ! # # #! > ! # 3 8B88 ? . (8H (6M #!' (6:Q ' ; !- # ! !! > (:79 ,' 77:@' ! #,!- 2! $ 2! $ ! 2! $ # ! , I! #,!- C ># ?# ## ,' (D8Q B' (9 -= (:::Q ' : -= (::M #> - , . (9 AE (::: ! -- ; (::: ,' ((:@'
P,$ - # #,,# ! # -!- # 2- 3 1+ (D #E= 5889 , !R!' 1! # 58 -= 5889 !! $ ! $ # E= ? S 4567545889@'
2 # 1- - # "! #- 3 # (M #E= 5889 3 8B88 ! E- 3 -B- (M >-E 3 59B88 #! 2 # E#"- %>> = - (D >-E 5886 ! E= ? S 4H6H45886@'
4567545889 + 64: +
$! 1- -!- ,,- , ## = - (9 AE 5886 ! - M >-E -!- ,! ,# -! ' ; # ! - -!- ,##%- (M >-E 5886' ; # # ,, C,- - (D >-E 86 #! = ,E - ,! ' #! , C!# 1%!! # ! # # ,-!- # #' #!># # # ,$ 1- ! ,, 1 , # 1I!'
= - 5 5886 ##- A#! # 4H6H45886 ! 4567545889 # S 45675 E #C !-'
H' ! ! % 2! # E# ,! !# 1 B #! #>> #! ! 3 ! # ,! I! 2 > - - # - 3 !'
! 1!' 9 ! -,!- ! !#! !! ! #%= # ! E##! ,#!- #, B , C!- C!# 2 #,#! !- ,B" 2 ! # ,"B 2 # 2 !N #!'
;# P!' D ' 5 # >-- ,! P - # #,# 2 #! == C #-2 P !' C ! 1!' : ' 5 ?! E % , ( AE (::7@ - !- , P!# !- C-! E E! !! --%! # #,-! ,# !! 2P # ! , >!! ,!= 3 # 3 ,B-#$ -%--! > - # #,# E! #! ! ! CB! E #!
- 3 ! I #! , - , >! C!- !$ C!# J ' >!Q =' -=#N!! P! ! #Q ' -B - 2Q ' -B Q ' -#%! # Q >' -B !#Q %' - # %!Q B' - # !",'
#! # - # - 3 ! !! ,# ! # -%! ,# =! P!!- >E P- % -!! ! ! # 2 # ! >-- #,$ ! ! P !' + ! # E!+ 2 2 # ! ! # ,- !- E ! , , I! #E! , P+ ? .
55 >-E 5885 # 57M488 T! # ' 5 Q . (5H 99 E # ' 5=Q * 588( S 9H6 ,' HHH E # ' 5@'
4567545889 + D4: +
= >-- #> - -! PC % P >! C!- # # ! # # ! C ,!! # ? . (5: 9DD@' PC,! # !$ FC!# G C!- !#! ! # ! # #! !! E #! # P ! # E! I! - -'
,! 3 ->! PC ! P C!- + # ! P -E-!
3 ! C! #, B ,! = PI! #!!- $ #=A! E ! 2 ,-! ! ,#! + >O!+ # , >! -B! - # #,# --- 3 1!' : ' 5 !#= #!!- #! 3 B% P+ '
PC ! P - # #,# - 3 ! # ! I! - !# #U >! #%= C!- #># E P,, ! # ?,# , $ ># @ # ! > - # -!! ",!R - # #,# --- 3 1!' : ' 5 !' 3 B ' I $ PC % P >! #%= C!- P! , , #2 P- > !
-!! # ,, ,# , $ ># ,$ E# #, %! E #! ? E! P"! #B! -,/! , $ !'@ 3 # 2 %! P ! 2 # !! # #, ,! = , -E- 2 # ,# ! E ,B" ##% 2 ! -, 2 ! #! N! - ,# ! E' #! # C!- ,,# >>! -E-! %--! 2 - # ' !
#!! # P B%! ,# ! # #, 2 ! >-2!
! 3 ,#E#2 - # #,# # #!! # - ! ?=2 ! #, 3 ,! ,# ! # #, #, ! P %! E #! # P #E! -!! #! B%- B%! ,# ! # #,# $ #!R- # P > ,B-#$ C!- @ ? . 5H #E= # 5889 H(648H # ' 5'5 -%! . 5H -= 588H # (7848H # ' 9'H@'
9' 1,$ 1! , #!!- , ,! 2 - # ,! !# 1 B ! -B !# 1!' : ' 5 !' > ' 1! , E!% #!!- 2 !! !! ! #,# -!- #%= # ! E##! '
! ! % 2! # E# 1!! ! -!- - , >! C!- ' 1! ! #E ! 1C # A , ,- !- #E! 2 ! 3 1# % -B # ! I! # -- # # !! # = >- # ! , -E- 2 # ,# ! E ,B" ##% 2 2 E I! # -- # -E-! %--! 2 - # # #! # ! I! # -- # > ! ,! %! E #!'
4567545889 + M4: +
;# A , ? . (9 E 5886 # (D9489 # ' 5'(@ ,,! ! 3 P- , = #! #- !! 2P !' ! # #,$! , ,- # #! !# -#! P-E-! ,E! # 3 P#= %! # ,! P+ !' #2 P !! # ,! , ! --! P ! ,# -!= # # ,# E == + , ,# = !- >> ! , + A% #!! P= ,E # P ! , #-2! P C ! P ! ? . ((D (98 # ' 9=Q * 588H S 976 ,' 56: # ' 6@'
,- C E # >>-! #! P ! >! # A , # ,->- 3 2 P- #- , # 2P %# ! #-2 A 2 C, ! # #E ,#E! I! + # ! # # + ,# ! ->C # !- ? . (5( 9M # ' 5 ! ->- ; 5888 ,' 58( # ' 5=@'
1# 1- C, 2- , !, E# > ! F >C , # ! G' C $ !, ,- - , 1! #! <<<<<<<<<< 1I! -,! #- 1 ! --2 = = # ! >- E #!! # E##! ! E #! %!#- "! ,#==! =#! 3 -B !# 1 B '
1+ $E 2 -B !# ! E 3 -,! # 1 ! -2 = 2 #! ! = E 1 >! C!- "! # #- !! - #' #! # ! # 1,, ! # 1!' : ' 5 -!! 3 # E , 1+ ! # ! , B% ! 1-E-! (: A 5889'
1+ ! # $ ,# ,! 2 # ! # , B% ! ! 1!' : ' 5 #! , , ! , ,- -! # ! # >! C!- ' ;# 1 ! # 1 F >C , # ! G ,,N! # -! # 3 ,#! # F >#- ,-,,#- 2 2#2 #E! !N - # 1! 21 - ! -!- ,!=- 1C!- G'
#! ! 3 2 #! ! 1- C E # #! #! !# #U , ! # 1 F >C , # ! G ! I! - 3 -,! # 1 ! --2 =' ; 1- E ! >>! = E -,! # 3 ! # % # - 3 -B !# 1 B 1 ! , 2- ,- ' #! 1! #!!- 1C, 2 2 !! # -! ! ,, # ! # # F >>#! =2 G' #>#-! 3 A , = # #-2 ,->- 3 , $ E # 1-'
4567545889 + 74: +
#U 1! , -!= %- E = ,-,#-! 2 = >- # ! 1- ! -!- # !- 1 $ ,! $ # 21 ,B-#$ C!- # ! E !>- -#! #E! #E ! 21 -E-! 3 ! # ! ,# !' , > ! 2 #! 1 ! , = ! !! !- ,# - # !", ! #,!B B# 2 # 1 ! , , - ! >E# ! ,! ,#!- ! >> ! , # A , ,- !- 3 # 3 1C ! 1 >! C!- ' >>! !! # ! # ! - #2 1- # 1,$ > ! -!! # ,, ,# , $ ># ,$ E# #, %! 2 1 , 2 # !! # #, , -E- 2 # ,# ! E ,B" ##% 2 ! -, , 2 ! #! N! - ,# ! E'
#-2 = A!! # !A!- #! - # 1+ ! !! , 1+ 2 , 1- ! #> ! - #'
4567545889 + :4: +
,'+4 '+ * ', * ,+
567 8 9 :; -(" ,<
7
(' - E= # 1 ! *# ;<<<<<<<<<<'
7
5' A!!'
H' ! 2 ,#- ! %! !'
9' ># ,! 21 ,E! ># # #! ,-! I!
- H8 A# $ #! > ! # , , #- - = >-- ;BV WB#>2 D D889 !# C, ' - ,! I! ,##%-' -# # ! J @ 2 C!! 2 - # #! - #=! ! , - # !!2-Q =@ C,# ,# 2 #! > ! ,#E# !! ! - #Q @ ,#! %! # # ,-!!' ; -# #! ! , !# --! --- # !! @ =@ ! @ + = >-- ,# , ! ! $ # 21 E - E=' -# # ! # # #" ,E 2 #! A# ! 2 - # !!2- ! 1E#,, 2 -!- C,- - #! ?!' (H5 (8D ! (87 @'
%>> $ J - ! J
* +# & # X
-! +A ! J ;
#, #># ,-! I! ! #! > - C ,! 213 1>> >-- !- ,= 2 , %>>
4567545889