Contract Validity After Statutory Change
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe dispute concerned the validity of a contract following a change in the purported governing statute, with the initial transaction occurring before the statute's effective date and subsequent payments being made after. The court reasoned that because the formation and initial breach of the contract occurred when the pre-existing statute governed the transaction, the subsequent statutory change did not invalidate the contract; the court applied the law in effect at the time of the contract's execution to resolve the breach claim, affirming the lower court's findings regarding the contract's validity under the former law.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contract Validity After Statutory Change: The court reasoned that because the formation and initial breach of the contract occurred when the pre-existing statute governed the transaction, the subsequent statutory change did not invalidate the contract; the court applied the law in effect at the time of the contract's execution to resolve the breach claim, affirming the lower court's findings regarding the contract's validity under the former law.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited in the final order regarding the allocation of procedural costs.
Cited in the final order regarding the granting of legal aid.
Volltext
&'()'&*++, -&./.&*++,
-
-0 - 0
"12 '
% / 3% *++,
!" !#$ % $ "$ !&"$ '$(## $ )) * * * * $ $!" (+,-
! " # $% %
41.54
40-
/6 "/7,,"$"!8""9 & !$":; # # " /5 : 122- & $ $; &% $" ; / :$/7756
#$$!#"!$$$9" "$"$"$<" :%/77-=!/77>$ #/%!8/77>6
16 " /- %!8 122, ? * $=$ ;/:$/77>6"$$9 70&,1296 ;"$"%"6
06 #;%@# " //!1225&)) * * * * A4#; B # #$$ !#"!$ =&$""$# " 15!12259!" ##$ 1/ :$ 1225 "!" !8!$ !! 73&20396 #"$$ #$$ %" = $$ / %!8 /77> 0/ !12256
-6 " /- "!81225& :$" ! ! "#" #&$""6
,6 /, :% 1223 &$"" 9!" ##$ = 9 ##$ C&#; %"$"%$! & $/7>>#;#" &$$ C$= $$ : C #; # D#$ !" $ # C #" A#; & $ B&$C&=9122,C $%$# +$"$86 !$&%9!"& %!$ "$$9 C C ! # $ E $$9 C F&$ 8 $!# C "$" " # &9! $ $ 8E$ # &E 9;!$#;%$$ C " % "9$%F6
56 " , ! 1223 & :$" &##$6 "" C &8E$ E!$ &$6 1- & /, :% /73/ #$$ !#"!$ = G4% %%$ $ % $"A 4 *. B&%$#"$"#$"$&# !C $ (E $# "$$ "" #C / %!8 /77> 0/!1225&$""%$=9@ #$$!#"!$$ $ 6
36 &$"" #"$" # '$ (## $:$" , % 1223$ $ "6##C&%" " $EH=& &I#E"" #$C !!!%$$$ 8$$# 9 % $ #; "6 $ = !
./-0/.1223 40.54 &8E$ !8!! 73&20396$$$CC&$C !$$ %$ +$ !8" &$ C!$ #$$ C ! #$$#@#;$9$ " ! $$$" #$$ #%!8/77>6
>6 "# /2!1223& :$ 6
76 "$"$!=&$""$E "=:E6
0-
/6 9!"!$=&$6,56/$6(60 E%GE$ : AB 8 $ '$ $ C $$$ #"% = G$ ,5 C $ $% = 9" " #$$ !#"!$ = G4% %%$ $ % $" /7!/75,A )BC&=#$$$ !#"!$=&4%$%%$$=&4% $" 1,$8/75>A B6
*!#"$#:E G#;$"$86
16 " ##$ "$" #; &$" %E ##8!$; #$$!#"!$9" "! $$$ #$$ " %$ / :% 12206 $$ #$$$ &$6>16/#!;#( #$ C #$ !$" #"$ $ # ##8 D #$$ $ D " 9D" %$ $" %E6 $%D#"#$ &$61, A$601 #:$B$9= $$$ #$$ J!$$("$#"!$!$"!! D!# & #$C$###8= #$$ ":=%" %$&$"%E A))/77/155%6B6%(K* A *4K!!$L K!!$ M! E$M N8 E! *M%(E($%!56O$81222?(122067 $6>1B ! P C$ $$$ # #; / :% 1220 % $ $ ##8 ; C& $ $$" $$$ #; $" %E $ C 8 !+! $$$ #$ #$$ "$"!$6
C$ $ #$$ $ $!# %+$ $$9 # !#$ "%& !!$C####8= $$$ $ "E!$$ $ :# $"AK*#6$667 $6>1B6
./-0/.1223 4-.54
06 B !$; #$$ !#"!$ 9" " " ##$$:$$= " 02: A$6,56/$52 6/ Q96"E!$$67 $ /-$8/75, #$$9" "!#"!$=G4%$%%$$= G4% $" R )SB #; $8 $ ! G"A$6,>6/ B6 "9D"#$ # /,:$/,J$%!$A$60>6- B6
8B*GE$ #$$ !#"!$ $ G$ -0 1,$8 /75> #$$ $ !#"!$ = G4 % $ %%$ $ = G4% $" A4#;L B % !+!% $6
B G#;"$" "#" 9!$ "!#"# $CG$%86A$67 )$60>6-,56/$5/6/ Q $6-0 B6
-6 &8:$ #"$ $E !$ = C$ ! &8E$ $$=& !! 73&20396 "##$ 1/:$ 12259D$##$!$$ $$$$ 99$$"9 9$ 6
,6 * &$6 13 4 *4 #$$ !#"!$ J!$ $(" %$+$$$"#8""9#("$6##$ 9" " 12 "!8 /7-5 G4% $ %%$ 5 *B $##8#E=$$$ $#$$$=8"$ &8E$ $$6 #$ $C9E=&$61- 6
* &$6 -3 6 / * A1, 6 / B $9 = $$$ $ J!$$("$$$#$#+$ ! "C&$"""$$ 89$$! $$ 996&$6376/ ;E!$ 0/ $8 /7-3 G % $ %%$ A *B #" C C&#$=$$$#"$$"E#%$ 8 9 !$$ % $ $( $ $ +$ 9$ ! &8E$ $$ $$ #$ !$$ J!$ $(" $$ $$$ %$ !$$ $$ 99 $ &D$6
56 &#; & 9" & ! = &$"" !$9 C $ 89$ (E$# &"$$#""6
#( % !!C" # " /-%!8122,C&!1225$D!#$ 6
./-0/.1223 4,.54 *&$61- 4 *4 99$&<$ $ $!!C$ = GE $ !#"$$ $$ (E!$ $$ #6 %$ &8E$ & E&D$# $# 8 96 99$ C &$ &! 9$9 #"$ C& %$ "E; $$ 8E$ &" #$ $: %C 8 96 4&$DCC9$C $=&8E$ $$ $ &D# & !#$!$ 9 & "EE E% A ) //1/20 6 1B6 &$ C&% $ C& !$$ # $ C "EE##!#"!#$ 89A /732#60-3B6 E$# "EE E% <$ $ C 9! # = C #$ +$ DE" & # #8 !$ $$ $C $ !+! $ A ) /1/ -, 6 08 //> 025 6 1B6 &E#8""9 9$C&&%$# $D#$$99$ ## !$$C&"$$ 8969$8#$T$C&$ #8 !$ & $$ ! ! & "EE E%6 8 9 $ 9 &8:$ & D! !$D (C#$6 $$!!$+$"C%!$ #$$#E!#$!$$$"EEE% # $ = $$$6 C 9$ $ "$" $ 9!$ D$ " $$!$ = $ & "EE E%6% !+!C&8E$ &%&#"$"!#$!# $$$!$=$ &"EEE%6<9$E% (C9C"$" &(E!$%$"% $A /7>5#655>B6
36 &#; &$"" $$ # % $$ D ! %$ &9! & C $=$ %$"$"$C&"$$9 70&,1296%$"$"%"# ?6 ;# $%"$" 89 !P%$9 &8 &E9;!$$ # $!# &9! $$8E$6
>6 8 " $$ C &$"" & # 9 = 8E$ E#C&!84$4 "=& # " 6< %( "$! 9 #; D ! !$ $ $ 9 !#$ $ &$$$ C & #$ 8!$ DE & # #8 !$ #" $$ $C $ !+! $6 9 $ $$ C& #%$ !C !# C"#$ &!!!#$$C&"$$"$$9 ? $!!C8!$% " !$$ #$$ !#"!$ $"$$8""96!!"EEE% C99$=D896 "9$! $4 +$9!""$$#9"$$ &D! $ (E$# 6
./-0/.1223 45.54
6-04 -0 - 0
%
7 1
/6 "%86
% 7
16 :$$6
06 $C#" $E$$6
-6 $C#C$$D#$$!#"!$9" "#$ CG#%$9!$#"$+$ " 02: ; $9$ #; 8 9" " A*(UM(9C 5 522- B#% !$; $#89!"!$D $6 >1 9" " 8 9" " /3 : 122, A )BQ !"! $ C !$9 $ !< #% $ #$ E$ $ ! $Q $ +$ " 89" "#%#$#%"$CD $ &$6-1 )6 #"$ +$ $ #; # $ %C" !! !< #% %$+$:$=&%6 E99; " $L 4 ? V
#9! #"$+$$$9"D#$CG=G999" " #E99
./-0/.1223