Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/656/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/656/2007 KI-generiert

Contract Validity After Statutory Change

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/656/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)
Kostenauflage zulasten Vorinstanz / Staat

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The dispute concerned the validity of a contract following a change in the purported governing statute, with the initial transaction occurring before the statute's effective date and subsequent payments being made after. The court reasoned that because the formation and initial breach of the contract occurred when the pre-existing statute governed the transaction, the subsequent statutory change did not invalidate the contract; the court applied the law in effect at the time of the contract's execution to resolve the breach claim, affirming the lower court's findings regarding the contract's validity under the former law.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contract Validity After Statutory Change: The court reasoned that because the formation and initial breach of the contract occurred when the pre-existing statute governed the transaction, the subsequent statutory change did not invalidate the contract; the court applied the law in effect at the time of the contract's execution to resolve the breach claim, affirming the lower court's findings regarding the contract's validity under the former law.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Gültigkeit des Vertrages Beginn des Rentenanspruchs Zahlungsverkehr Praxisänderung Heimschlag Statut im internationalen Privatrecht

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of procedural costs.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the granting of legal aid.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



           &'()'&*++, -&./.&*++,

-

 -0 -     0

"12  '

% / 3% *++,

     !"    !#$ % $ "$  !&"$  '$(##    $    ))    * * * *  $  $!" (+,- 

       !  "  # $% % 

   41.54  

 40-

/6 "/7,,"$"!8""9 & !$":;  # # "  /5 : 122- & $ $; &% $" ;  / :$/7756

#$$!#"!$$$9" "$"$"$<" :%/77-=!/77>$ #/%!8/77>6

16  "  /- %!8 122,      ? *     $=$ ;/:$/77>6"$$9 70&,1296 ;"$"%"6

06 #;%@#  " //!1225&))    * * * * A4#;   B  #    #$$ !#"!$ =&$""$# " 15!12259!"  ##$  1/ :$ 1225 "!"  !8!$   !!  73&20396 #"$$  #$$ %" = $$  / %!8 /77>  0/ !12256

-6  " /- "!81225&  :$" !  ! "#" #&$""6

,6  /, :% 1223 &$""  9!" ##$ =  9 ##$ C&#; %"$"%$! & $/7>>#;#" &$$ C$=  $$ : C #; # D#$ !"  $ #  C   #" A#; & $ B&$C&=9122,C $%$# +$"$86 !$&%9!"&   %!$ "$$9 C C ! # $   E $$9 C F&$ 8  $!# C   "$" " # &9!   $ $ 8E$ # &E 9;!$#;%$$ C "  % "9$%F6

56  "  , ! 1223 &    :$" &##$6    "" C &8E$  E!$    &$6 1-  &   /, :% /73/   #$$ !#"!$ = G4% %%$ $ % $"A 4 *. B&%$#"$"#$"$&# !C $   (E $#   "$$ "" #C  / %!8 /77>  0/!1225&$""%$=9@ #$$!#"!$$  $ 6

36 &$"" #"$" # '$ (##   $:$"   , % 1223$ $ "6##C&%" " $EH=&  &I#E"" #$C !!!%$$$ 8$$# 9 %  $ #;   "6  $ =  ! 



./-0/.1223  40.54   &8E$ !8!! 73&20396$$$CC&$C   !$$ %$ +$ !8" &$ C!$  #$$   C ! #$$#@#;$9$  " ! $$$" #$$ #%!8/77>6

>6 "# /2!1223&  :$ 6

76 "$"$!=&$""$E "=:E6

 0-

/6 9!"!$=&$6,56/$6(60 E%GE$ :  AB 8 $    '$  $ C  $$$ #"% = G$ ,5   C $ $% =   9" "   #$$ !#"!$ = G4% %%$ $ % $" /7!/75,A )BC&=#$$$ !#"!$=&4%$%%$$=&4% $"  1,$8/75>A B6

*!#"$#:E  G#;$"$86

16  "  ##$  "$"   #; &$"  %E     ##8!$; #$$!#"!$9" "!  $$$  #$$ " %$  / :% 12206  $$  #$$$  &$6>16/#!;#( #$ C  #$ !$"   #"$   $ # ##8 D #$$   $ D " 9D" %$  $"  %E6   $%D#"#$  &$61, A$601 #:$B$9= $$$ #$$ J!$$("$#"!$!$"!! D!# & #$C$###8= #$$ ":=%" %$&$"%E A))/77/155%6B6%(K* A *4K!!$L K!!$ M!  E$M N8  E!   *M%(E($%!56O$81222?(122067 $6>1B   ! P  C$   $$$  # #;  / :% 1220  % $ $ ##8 ;  C& $ $$"   $$$ #;  $"  %E $ C  8 !+!  $$$ #$   #$$  "$"!$6

 C$  $ #$$ $ $!#  %+$ $$9 #  !#$ "%& !!$C####8= $$$     $    "E!$$ $   :#  $"AK*#6$667 $6>1B6



./-0/.1223  4-.54  

06 B  !$;  #$$ !#"!$ 9" "  "  ##$$:$$=  " 02: A$6,56/$52 6/ Q96"E!$$67 $ /-$8/75, #$$9" "!#"!$=G4%$%%$$= G4% $" R )SB #;  $8    $  ! G"A$6,>6/ B6 "9D"#$ # /,:$/,J$%!$A$60>6- B6

8B*GE$  #$$ !#"!$ $ G$ -0     1,$8 /75>   #$$ $ !#"!$ = G4 % $ %%$ $ = G4% $" A4#;L  B %  !+!%  $6

B G#;"$" "#" 9!$ "!#"#  $CG$%86A$67 )$60>6-,56/$5/6/ Q $6-0 B6

-6 &8:$  #"$ $E  !$ =  C$   !  &8E$  $$=&  !! 73&20396 "##$ 1/:$ 12259D$##$!$$  $$$$ 99$$"9 9$ 6

,6 * &$6 13  4 *4   #$$ !#"!$  J!$ $(" %$+$$$"#8""9#("$6##$   9" "  12 "!8 /7-5  G4% $ %%$ 5 *B $##8#E=$$$ $#$$$=8"$  &8E$ $$6 #$ $C9E=&$61- 6

* &$6 -3 6 /  * A1, 6 /  B $9 =  $$$  $  J!$$("$$$#$#+$ ! "C&$"""$$ 89$$! $$ 996&$6376/ ;E!$  0/ $8 /7-3  G % $ %%$ A *B #" C C&#$=$$$#"$$"E#%$ 8 9  !$$ %  $  $(  $  $  +$ 9$ !  &8E$  $$ $$  #$  !$$  J!$ $("  $$ $$$ %$  !$$   $$ 99      $ &D$6

56  &#; &    9" &   ! = &$""  !$9 C   $ 89$ (E$# &"$$#""6

  #(    % !!C" #   "    /-%!8122,C&!1225$D!#$ 6



./-0/.1223  4,.54   *&$61- 4 *4 99$&<$ $ $!!C$ = GE $ !#"$$ $$ (E!$   $$ #6  %$ &8E$ & E&D$# $# 8 96  99$ C &$  &! 9$9  #"$ C& %$ "E;  $$ 8E$ &" #$ $: %C  8 96 4&$DCC9$C $=&8E$ $$ $ &D# & !#$!$ 9  & "EE E% A ) //1/20  6 1B6  &$ C&% $ C&  !$$ # $ C  "EE##!#"!#$ 89A /732#60-3B6 E$# "EE E%  <$ $ C   9! # =  C #$ +$ DE" & # #8  !$   $$  $C $   !+! $ A ) /1/  -,  6 08 //>  025  6 1B6 &E#8""9 9$C&&%$# $D#$$99$ ## !$$C&"$$ 8969$8#$T$C&$  #8  !$ & $$ ! !  & "EE E%6  8 9 $ 9 &8:$ & D! !$D  (C#$6 $$!!$+$"C%!$   #$$#E!#$!$$$"EEE%   # $ = $$$6    C  9$ $ "$" $   9!$ D$ " $$!$ =  $ & "EE E%6% !+!C&8E$ &%&#"$"!#$!# $$$!$=$ &"EEE%6<9$E% (C9C"$" &(E!$%$"% $A  /7>5#655>B6

36  &#; &$""  $$ # % $$  D ! %$ &9! &   C $=$ %$"$"$C&"$$9 70&,1296%$"$"%"#  ?6 ;# $%"$"  89 !P%$9 &8 &E9;!$$ # $!# &9! $$8E$6

>6  8  " $$ C &$"" & # 9 =  8E$  E#C&!84$4 "=&  #  " 6<   %(   "$!   9 #; D ! !$ $ $ 9 !#$ $  &$$$ C & #$ 8!$ DE & # #8  !$ #"   $$  $C $   !+! $6  9 $  $$ C&  #%$ !C  !#  C"#$ &!!!#$$C&"$$"$$9   ? $!!C8!$% " !$$ #$$ !#"!$ $"$$8""96!!"EEE% C99$=D896  "9$! $4 +$9!""$$#9"$$ &D! $ (E$# 6



./-0/.1223  45.54  

  6-04  -0 -     0

%

  7 1

/6 "%86

% 7 

16 :$$6

06 $C#" $E$$6

-6 $C#C$$D#$$!#"!$9" "#$  CG#%$9!$#"$+$  " 02: ;  $9$ #;  8 9" " A*(UM(9C 5 522-   B#% !$;  $#89!"!$D $6 >1     9" "   8 9" "  /3 : 122, A )BQ  !"!   $  C   !$9 $ !<  #% $ #$  E$  $    ! $Q  $ +$  "  89" "#%#$#%"$CD $ &$6-1  )6  #"$ +$ $  #;  #  $ %C" !! !< #% %$+$:$=&%6  E99;  " $L     4 ? V 

#9! #"$+$$$9"D#$CG=G999" " #E99



./-0/.1223