Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/596/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/596/2005 KI-generiert

Securities Classification of Complex Financial Instruments

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/596/2005
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The court considered whether certain statutory reporting requirements imposed on a regulated entity were triggered by transactions involving complex financial instruments, specifically regarding the determination of whether an asset qualified as "securities" under the relevant statute. The court reasoned that the statutory language, when read in conjunction with the legislative purpose of promoting market transparency and investor protection, mandated the classification of the disputed instruments as securities due to their inherent nature as profit-sharing agreements based on the success of an underlying venture, thereby requiring the entity to comply with the associated regulatory obligations.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Securities Classification of Complex Financial Instruments: The court reasoned that the statutory language, when read in conjunction with the legislative purpose of promoting market transparency and investor protection, mandated the classification of the disputed instruments as securities due to their inherent nature as profit-sharing agreements based on the success of an underlying venture, thereby requiring the entity to comply with the associated regulatory obligations.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Finanzinstrumente gesetzliche Voraussetzung Bestimmung des relevanten Marktes börsenrechtliche Meldepflicht Vermögen Finanzbestimmung

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for the allocation of costs for the federal court proceedings.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for awarding costs to the respondent due to the appeal being dismissed.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

     

   

#$%&$#$''( )#*+%#$''*

)

! )! ,)"  !, ",

&- ,.   * / $''*

  

  01111111111  1111111111    ! " #$% & ' )   ()* () +,*)  ))  --  .*  / * 0  ! *   

 01111111111    !  )12 & '

*)

,  2"3, ! "  !9) 4)!,)" !5! )  6",)"  7 ))" 8,9   3.) -*1)4 56 " 7.

, 4!, : 6) !  2*   74 " -8

            !"  ;

 6)

=@ ) A4*  ;B *3) ;>>?  ) 3  () 7) *   * ()   .)  ) 4 *)*!  ;B (*3) =CC= () + @DDDDDDDDDD ! DDDDDDDDDD !  =CEE * + ) @DDDDDDDDDD !  =C<5@  ) 3  )9!  )* 9 )     .*  () 0  !(% )F *  ()*4  ) . )  ()!.2 ()9  *  )!

 ()*4 ()  * !  . ) ! (*  )!  ) 4@

;@  A4* * . !9  * 9  5 !3) ;>>?@

5@  ) 3  !    *!  ()*     ) * **   ()!.2 (   *)(!  * **  !9)   () *    0)  **  . )   ()*  0  )*  ) 4  * *)  ;B (*3) =CC= *  5 !3) ;>>?@

?@ -  )) )     /) G 9 *) +3 -  =< ) ;>>E  ()**  0  (*  ) 4 ()  ) *  E6H>B< 9)@ I   )) )      ()!.2  ()  / *)*  (3 0 *  9*  )  /  *)*  &  '  ;> .)  ;>>E    ) *  ;>E/C<C 9)@ ;E ** 0  . *  ! ) C5H>C> 9)@ EE )()!**  ()**   )*   ;B (*3) =CC= 2 ()   *!)J*   A)   .)@

E@  * * !*! *)  % ()*   *  ;< .)  ;>>E ()

!*) * @

<@  )  /* (  9*!@

 )  ).# *** 0  ()**  . * !*! !  5= !3) ;>>?  ! "  0   !*3   . !(*  5 !3) ;>>? ()! !*@

B@  5>  ;>>E    9)!  ) 3  ! 0/    !* * ( ( 3 /!) "   *   !** 99*! "  9  /  @       0!  ()**   )*    )  5> .3) ;>>?  * ;>EH=B< 9)@ EE@

6@  )) )  !*! *)  % ()* @  /* ( 9 * /3).*  *      !*! 4)! " A4)@

 ")

:;<=;:;>>?

=@ H)*@ ;E    9!!) )   3) (4   ()!.2 ()9  .   ). .* * .  *!  =B !3) =CC5 &K' *)!  . 4)  =) A. ) ;>>> )74  ()!)     .)@ )0  A *  * ( /) )  ()**   )*  " ()*4) &)*@ =;; * =;5  .  1 '  A4      .) (!**    H)*@ B5 @ =    9!!) )  ()!.2 ()9   ;E A  =C6; &'  * "

7.  ) 3 *  )   (   =) L* ;>>5  * ()7 0 H99 )   !*! *)  &)*@ =?; ' %!*) H99   ()*4 )

 3   !  )!()* *  !*) ! ()  A4   .).

;@ - H)*@ ;; K &. *)  . 4) (   =) A. ) ;>>>'     .)  ()**   )*  0  )*  ) 4 * ()*4! 9)!* % )*@ =;; =;5 =?= * =?; I  )*@ 5 " E K H(( 0* () 4   ** " *)9!)) &@ ='@ ) #0 A *  ()**   )*  " ()*4) ))( "   99!) *)  ()**   )*  4*!  . )   3) (4 % ** !.**  *   .) *  ()**   )*  4*!  . )   3) (4 % ** !.**  *      ) 4 &9@ )*@ ;? K'@ )

   A* "  ()**   )*  * " H. )   3) (4 % **  *      ) 4  *!)J*   *   .) & K =;6  ;5>I K =;C  ???'@

5@  /(7  A4  () 7) *  )!  ()*4 ()  * !  . ) ! (*  )!  ) 4@  * ()* * * / ()*   ) 4  ;B (*3) =CC= /*) ()*  5 !3) ;>>? * " 0  A4*   .) * . %!* )@

C@ -  * () *  ()**  0  (*  ) 4 ()  ) *  E6H>B< 9)@ *  0  0  ()  ) *  ==;H>6< 9)@ &;>EH=B< 9)@ EE G C5H>C> 9)@ EE'  *!)J* 2* !A" !*! ! ()

 * **   ()!.2 !9)@   )  * "  %1 !(%  **  E<H>?5 9)@ &==;H>6< 9)@ M ;' *  1   *  **  ;CH>56 9)@ &E6H>BE 9)@ M ;'  )* 0 /*  ) 0  *  )  **  ;BH>>E 9)@

?@ 9)!* "  A) () (   A) !*) * ()  ()*4 A0H *  *)9)*   ()**   )*     )  A *  .)! 3!!9   )   ()**   ) * "  *!)J* (* ) )  **  1 @  *!)J* * !  *%    !4  H)*@ =;  H) )  ()!.2 ()9  .   ). .* * .  *!  =6 .)  =C6? & ;'    *%

:;<=;:;>>?

?

)!4* )   1 * (!) ) & K  (3 !  5<:>;  =6 A * ;>>5'

E@  !*  ) ()F  ()!) !** 4)* * &)*@ B5 @ ;  * 6C8 @ =    )  ()!)   *)* .  =; (*3) =C6E'@

NNN

:;<=;:;>>?

E

 , ")6  )! ,)"  !, ",

 8;<   =  >   70 &%$ "9

=@ . *  --   O    -   /-     - K   -  / +-   &  ' "

*)9!))  (*  + @DDDDDDDDDD    ;BH>>E 9)@ "  -- / --  G K-  +  - -  9.)  + )

@DDDDDDDDDD@

;@ . *  --   O    -   /-     - K   -  / +-   &  ' "

.))  (   **  *!)J* (* )     !)* 7  5 !3) ;>>? A0H *  *)9)*@

5@ /2   ** 0  3 @

?@  * 0  ()!) * 4)* *@

E@ 9)  ()*    0H (.* 9)) )) *)  ()!* ))J*   !  5> A) 7  * 9 *  () ( )! )!  ) 3 9!!)  ) -#P Q)#90 < <>>?     *)  %( )@  !  (* J*) ()4!@  ! )  * M '  0)

%** 0 !    ))* ! ) 3* )    * (   !   0!I 3' %() () 0 * 9  *  (. ) )  *) !  I ' ()*)   4*)     )()!**@ -  ! )  * * (  *)  !!* !!)!  ) ' 3' * '  1  ) 3 9!!)  )  ()) ( *))  * 7) )  )) 0H  .) !)) )).3@  ! )  )) * ) )  2  (). 0 )* A *   0  !   0! * H.((  0   !*! %(! !  ))* &)*@ =5; =>< * =>6 '@

 4)99 7)  )! * M

+) 1   R )  S   

 (  9)  ()!* ))J* * * 9 ! % ()*    0/" /99  9!!)  )   ()  4)99 

:;<=;:;>>?