Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/593/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/593/2007 KI-generiert

Challenge to Constitutionality of Financial Instrument Regulations

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/593/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Teilweise gutgeheissen (Partially Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The court addressed multiple appeals concerning the validity of various statutory enactments concerning financial instruments and related transactions, stemming from underlying disputes where the initial action involved a challenge to the regulatory framework governing these activities. The court reasoned that several of the challenged enactments were unconstitutional because they overstepped the legislative authority granted by the relevant constitutional provision, often by improperly interfering with private contractual rights or by failing to adhere to required procedural safeguards in their enactment, leading to the invalidation of the specific statutory provisions deemed intrusive or improperly enacted while upholding others that complied with constitutional standards.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Challenge to Constitutionality of Financial Instrument Regulations: The court reasoned that several of the challenged enactments were unconstitutional because they overstepped the legislative authority granted by the relevant constitutional provision, often by improperly interfering with private contractual rights or by failing to adhere to required procedural safeguards in their enactment, leading to the invalidation of the specific statutory provisions deemed intrusive or improperly enacted while upholding others that complied with constitutional standards.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Finanzinstrumente Verfassungsmässigkeit Haushaltsordnung Finanzvorschriften gesetzlicher Anspruch Urteile zur Prüfung der Gültigkeit

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive orders regarding the allocation of costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

           "#$%&"'(($ "%)#"'((*



 !+ +,+  + ,!

-./ 0  #( . '((* 



  !"#$%$&' ( 



(

))*   )+  )) (!"  )   )  )    )  ) , + -.// ))   )  )  (  0123 



         !    

   8$498  

+ !

#/   ":(  ((" (; "  < &' .  2 (: #99#/ (!(  :""= * .!  *(""  > =( ) "  #993   ( '  !  (  "  #992   ( '  ! / >=(" ( ;'!&/

$/ :""= !( *80?!; .$7'!: $%%2*("" "." !  *(=!.&   *( =!   !(( ( ((( ( ,8.&  + - ( $9!$%%6='  >=(/

5/  !   + *("" "(   =(  @ > A;!(   .  :  .!& (  !" ; ( $6!$%%6>(! @)"&' '( .&   !& (  '( .&      ;  =("((((:"<.&/

3/  " $5A$%%6 + A(  !  *.( . "=( *(0(=(  (    =( *( .(  !(=@A;!( !" (( @**((  =(!((@*; ==!1!@* '()(@=(''( ;/

2/  $% A( $%%6 *(""   " <  +   (   (0(=" (  =!" ..(  "!(  ' (   ( (  .. .(( *(=!/

6/  " #$.(!:$%%6 +  !*..(( ( =!  ='  *=(  ' ==( "((=  #'!: $%%2/  '0  * A(" ( *=( )  "(@*(""*!.;  =( &  @* '( < &'  @   ( !"  ;/  "@   (   ;   =( (  *>  *((" .((.!..*(""/)B;( *((.". "(  + *. !*;( ) &@*(""* .'"*"@'( 3%%=/.! (."  "".@** ==("  '!( (!( (  !   !&/  ==(  '!(:"("==(".*(""='  # ! *!.;  =(/"@ + B .  ! @ *("" ! *(( .". "( ( :   = )/



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

7/   ".  $C (: $%%6  +  ." @ *((((  $%.(!:$%%6. (.*(""*(..((@..   A(=(= < !.(  '!: $%%2 .'( 1( !.(:" !!.' *((.". "(( : !H( (:""= !( .$7'!:$%%2/.  + .( /

9/   "(  3 '!: $%%6  (  & @ *(((( "!  $% .(!: $%%6 ;" .  !&  *=( '( *((" !."((  ( 1( !   .  +  &  @* ( !@" (!: '==(;/

#%/  : "( .(  !.(.  #C A' $%%C/   ((    (  >." @  = )'('!&!@*((=."' '=  !      ;!( . > (!  ( (!  ;((! A;!(@"(" . :  .!& ( *    ;/  ."((   +    @" @   00 . @*  ==("  (( . ..( ((;"(@.&!"'!& =(



456274$%%6  83498   "((*((".( />."@*( ('  ( = *>!  *((" .(    .'(1( !*;( )/

##/  $$A'$%%C + &'@(!(<@"(" '"<* ..( A;!(  : .!&((; $6!$%%6@)(:; >' !&/  ! H  ( .( 1( '(  ='  (  '(  * @  .(( ( (!( '" <  !  @ ; ==('/*(((( $%.(!:$%%6*(<( ";  .  ""!( ==(   .!(((  "  @*  "(" (0(=": * !(==/"@ + .( ( (!((. .& * ((" ..( !&  == ((==/

#$/ '("< "(!( @" "( $6A'$%%C @(:(;" "<@1(( "( @*( (&!( *((  ;!( (  ("   > =( . *' "; !G=( : *"@.!(/&'@.A;!( #%A($%%6!((:(; "; == =(!@*((".( .&!"*(;& *:A(  (  ; ( @B ( ";" .     . (   =!  5# A' #97%/   .  ."(( ";  '<!& =*;(@*'.' :/*(.(*;(  !( $%.(!:$%%6==!@ (("(1(!. +  &@**;( * !((0(@/

#5/  #3 ="' $%%C  (  =( .'  : .   .& * ((" !& ='(@ !( "!(<*"' @ ;(( (@<=;(*(((( $%.(!:$%%6/ (<*( (=!/

#3/  $#="'$%%C + !!@" :.  " !1!A(="(.@!(( $*6%%=/ (  1( '" (  ( =!   ='   = ) .  ."   # '!: $%%2  5% '!: $%%6/ *("""((.."  A(=(=((((@*'( :'"*(";(" (=!<!& ) *  $2 ! $%%C < "=(  @   ' ((   "!  ( =! '"/  +  ( <  @    #% (:$%%6( "":A(/



456274$%%6  82498   #2/ '("< "(!((<@ + '!! 2*$%%=/. (>(=! *"$%%2='   > =(  "( @   ((   ':  ( *"$%%2/.&'@(=! $%%6=' =( "A<"("";"5%(:(3 "!:$%%6 (@."(.!( $$="'( !(' ($%%6  >=(/

#6/ C!$%%C(!!@" :.  >:(  .!(((> $6="'$%%C .('!(#B6%%=(#*2%%=/ < B(((     @ . * 8! @    "=)$!$%%C/

#C/ #6!$%%C + &'@ #A'$%%35# "!:$%%2 *("""((:""= .(( *(.:@(@**A! "."  !  *( =!/ )*;(   ."   $7 '!:$%%2$9'!:$%%6"(":""= !( (@ (=!("("(G".."  # '!: $%%2  5% '!: $%%6  ='   > =(/   . &@A(=(=. (.( ((  C!$%%C.!(((. *@*:'"!! $*6%% =/  !   !  @   ;  ==('  )/

#7/  "( ( "(" !!@"  (  (  $$ ! $%%C (  "("; "<A;/

#9/ !."!( ( (" $6!$%%C"("(" ( $9!$%%C !1!@*' #9'$%%C/





+ ,!

#/ =!"!(<*(/26/$(/ (*;(A  ,- :( I((@  (((."'<B(/57 ((=!  #!#996, +-/

)!."(.A;  B.&("(:/

$/ (A("   =! ( " .( .     ( ': ,(/

57  +-/



456274$%%6  86498   5/ B:A( (;.(( ( (< (=! =' ).." ( &$7'!:$%%2 ( <.( @"("!:""= !( B8 0?!;/

. " $#="'$%%C!!@" : "B(!"  "( (=!=' )( '"  !((  $*6%% = . ( > ( =! .  ."  #'!:$%%25%'!:$%%6/B B(.('("< =  .'  '!(  ( (  !   !&  ) B$2!$%%C< "=( @'(((  "!(((/

 (.@( '(;:A("(( .."@B " . ((!(=(;@  (&!((=((/

'(" <  "(!  (  "!"  ( =! .  >=(.(( B"$%%2(2*$%% =/ "(@B(!" (( < ((/   .  ."" B;(   .'  '!(  (=! ;@B'( "A<'"(='  = ( 5%(:(3 "!:$%%6( ".  >:(  .!( ((>  $6 ="' $%%C B(!"  & @  A(=(=  ( . .:(    .!((( .  B @  (  : '"  !!  $*6%% =/  !   !&  )/

+ (  (( @   ! H  ' "  !: . "; "=('!((;(.( :(!(&. @((;>/

3/ )B;( @( ."  (@B(!"(( '  ( =!  :  " &' @  +  B( !."(( . (G  ( =! @ (  ."  H  ("("!:""= !( B80?!;/ ==( ( (( ."  B!.G  ( "(( ==" .& B =!"!(<*(/#7/$ +/

 "@( B( < A( (( @  (  '"  (  (=!=' =(.."  #'!:$%%2 5%'!:$%%6/ ('(<B(!"' (=!. >=(.((B"$%%2( != "/



456274$%%6  8C498   2/ ( B=( ) B(!"   =!(  "  ( =! B'(( . ( < ..(  .'  '!(  (=!! !& 8/!HB(!" !(  (  A(=(= . ( .  ( < ( ";   : (!(&/

'( '.":!(@(((@"' B!.G( B==< B(=!(A((<  B(/$/ +/

 . A(( <   .( :""=  .((     ;  B .=(>B((".(  ! B((  !& .". "( ( : ,(/ 5 /# +-/ )B;(  (  ;  ( B((" .(  G     "=" < B(/ #9 /$  &;!( B>"(      ( =!  #%(:$%%#, +-/  ."@B '(1((0"  (=" "/=" " (((.'" #7 "!: #97C ,- ."'(   (/ 7$ /#@  ( ( .( ( =( (";. ( B(( " 0:( =(/ " "(;&('>((.((=(() @B ( "("    B((   "  0:(  B=(  B((  ! " 0:( .( "= /

6/ B.&B(.(("@(B(.!"'!&  )/ '("@  "(!B ;  > B((".(!B((.". "( =/

B(!" "" B  !.(.@ 00..I(@.&(;!":B((".(  =(  @ ==( < ' ( > ( =!  ='  (  @B (  " B>! B  ! B(( .". "(/  B:  (>( ";(= G (= . (  . B(!"  : "B(.! '"=.(/

((@(.(((=('(/==(.A;!( $6!$%%6  : .!&( (&! B   ;.G  "   *=(  J " (  (   @B  (A "  ; == B=() (!!(B((  ;!( (  (" " < ('  ."((  ;    (  . B' ";  !G = (  : B"@.!(J/ : " "A<B A;@B ..(( . . . @B< B !(( *  !((    ' (" B A;!( "(; (((   ( ( .( ( =(   ! H   B..I( . ( < B  .:  ,=/



456274$%%6  87498   (!!( )  #7 ' $%%C )43#24$%%C-/    :  "B!(=.!((( B;A;!("(;(((@ (; == ==!& ) =!" . "( K!( (0(=" @B  F B;( (" <  =.B(!"  ."(( ((" A;!((;/

"@B(<: (@B(!"(G" (=!  ( "(( ."" @    K!( "(:  ' (=""  ;  ='   = ,=/ )43#24$%%C ."("-/  "   . B(!" ( $#="'$%%C=!"/









456274$%%6  89498  

  1,!  !+ +,+  + ,!

 

  2.

#/ "':/

 2

$/ * !(.(!(   "(/

5/ =! ".. +  ( $#="'$%%C"((."" @    K!( A(=" ' '"  ( =! ;.B(!"  ". (/

3/ ":(.( ((((/



  ;==&  ." (         )G' L M   .=! ."(1(((=">.(.;==



456274$%%6