Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/556/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/556/2006 KI-generiert

Property Owner v. Contractor: Workmanship Dispute and Contract Damages

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/556/2006
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The dispute arose from a property owner's claim that a contractor breached an agreement for home improvements by failing to perform the work in a "workmanlike manner," leading to subsequent litigation over costs and quality. The court analyzed the evidence, including expert testimony regarding the standard of work, and determined that while the contractor's performance was defective in certain areas, the record did not fully support the owner's claim of total breach or justify the complete withholding of payment; therefore, the court modified the initial judgment to reflect a proper offset for the deficiencies against the amount owed to the contractor, distributing liability based on the proven deviations from the required standard of workmanship.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Owner v. Contractor: Workmanship Dispute and Contract Damages: The court analyzed the evidence, including expert testimony regarding the standard of work, and determined that while the contractor's performance was defective in certain areas, the record did not fully support the owner's claim of total breach or justify the complete withholding of payment; therefore, the court modified the initial judgment to reflect a proper offset for the deficiencies against the amount owed to the contractor, distributing liability based on the proven deviations from the required standard of workmanship.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Werkvertragshaftung Schadenersatzzahlung Baumängel Immobilienbesitz Pflichtverletzung des Vermieters Vertragsauslegung

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

Used to declare the appeal inadmissible on procedural grounds.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



               $%&'($)+ $++($)(

!!

, !-, .  ,! .-

/0 %  1 "  )( 



  !"""#    $

!"$ !"""#   

!%$

& '   '   (!% #4$ )*+, *-))./ 0

&    ''               ,1  "2 (!%))3,  ,),,   )

   

      ! " #

  )5+  

 2-

,8 $9:%,;!%!<$)--3 ,=$><$ $"<($"=$"%  ($!!#  "!%"!  $": !%$%#  + 9" ,77- ? =@ ($   #,7+7 %!"$ #,7+18

)8 '!  >"44$ 1  "(!"%"4  9:% ($#"%#   $"<  ($"=$ "%!$!#($%:($!"%"#@!"$($#@!A($!4"! B"($>#(!C$%$":8

;8 9:%"@!$%@#4""%"4))!@<$)--3%#%#%$" 2!44" $"<#,$#<$)--3(!$C#%"!($%:8

68  $"<#!""%#($%"!$"%"%%"!($#@!A  (""%$(#"%"%%"!#4$($"%"!"B$ !%%  @!"$   ($%" B" $%  $":  !"% %$  + 9" ,77-%))!@<$)--38

38 "@%":%"!#($ $"<!%($"2#%<"$4"%"@%D

E '2:"%@!"$($#@!A D

• '!!$$"$ ''   '  '  '''   0     )- 9@"$ )--+  4%  !#   ($%%"!  "<$ (:9!$$":$(!@"%F%$#8 "  "4!$#  $"< B %% %G> $@"$"% ? ! "%"%%"!  ($#@!A %  = !$ B 2$# @"% B"%%#  "  ;, $ )--3 % @"% " !"B$  !   !@ "%"%%"!  ($#@!A8

• $ !$$"$  7 $ )--+   ''     '     '   '''    0     ($#"# B  $ @"% #%# 44""# ,$(%<$)--);,$)--3%B($%%"!"<$(:  ,723+- 4$8 )-  :%#  "%#$F%   #%# @$# ?             )*4#@$"$)--+8

• ,;@$")--+ &    ''               !4"$#@!"$$H"($#"%# ($%%"!"<$(:%)*4#@$"$)--+8 ""B#B !%%   ($%%"!  "<$ (:  )) !@<$ )--3 2#@"% ? ,72*13 4$8 6-  !% " !@"%  #"$  ($%%"!  "<$ (: B"!%$":,27*14$8338 !#B ($%%"! "<$(:?($%:$2#=@?,1214$8*38

    56,7+5)--3 ;5+  

• $>$>44%#($ $"<2!%(($"%$!@$2%$ @!"$  ($#@!A   $8  44%  " $#%  2C%$"%  !(%""@" 2($% B2#%#$%("$(#$"! >I: %  2%$ ($%  B2  $#"#  $@ %$!( 4"< (!$ F%$ !"?($#@!A($!4"!8

<E '2:"%@!"$!"$D

• '!  !$$"$   J   & ''     2'     ,;$)--+ $#%#44""#? %$!"$($"=,$4#@$"$,77) 9B2)*4#@$"$,77*8($%%"! !$%"  !%  $": % "!8 ' ($%%"!  !$%"  *2)6,4$8;3#%#@$#;-9"%)--,?& '    '  ?.$">8

•  ''     J     '  '      2'        ' &   '   2 '        K  !4"$#B $@"%#%#$#,$!%!<$)---;,#<$)--,%B ,3 9"% )--)   ($%%"!  !$%"  3261- 4$8 ;- @"% #%# %$4#$# ($=& '   '  ?.$">8

• ))4#@$"$)--+ & '   '   .$">  $#  $"<  $@#  !(%  "<$ (:  $8 ""B#B2%))!@<$)--3 ($%%"! "<$(:$2#@"%?,32+6,4$8138

• $>$>44%#($ $"<2!%(($"%$!@$2%$ @!"$($#@!A$8

+8 !%!%#%#%$"C($%"%,1")--+% $"<   "4!$# B 2%  !%%  ,2,,; 4$8 ,- B2" %"% %$4#$$  !(%$4@$$89$""%"!$""B# B2?#4%2!<$@%"!2"",$9")--+ $$F%$"%$$%%<8

18 2<2!<9%"!#"4"C# #%#:$#?9:$8

    56,7+5)--3 65+  

 !.-

,8 2$%8)3!"4##$$"<$(:($#@!A($!4"!  @"" $@"@%%"@""%#,1#<$,77;L&E %$#@":$ ,$9@"$)--- $=:($!#$"@!$8!$B!9!"%!% (M!$$($%%"!!$%"?($%:$L$%8,))%,); ! "@"K E  9:""@!$!(#%%2$%81;8,!"4##$$ ($#@!A ($!4"!  )3 9" ,7*) LE  !"% ? =@  $"< %!$!"(",$!N%)--; !"% ($=B244"$"  #%#%$"L$%8,6) E C#%$2!44"($%:$< # $#($%"%"!#%$"#($9:"@!$8

)8 '!2$%8))&L!@%$@":$(",$9@"$)---E   "@!$   ($%%"!  !$%" B" $%  $": !% ($%:# !4!$#% C$%8,)) ,); ,6,%,6) O$%8;?3 &2(("B% ($!:"!%%?%$4#$$L8,E8!$>B!9!"% ($%%"! !$%"?($%:$!$$(!?"44#$%$($%%"!!$%" :%#  @!"$  "<$ (: C"%% #@%%  !%  "@!$  %  ($%%"!!$%" :%#@!"$"<$(:C"%%#@%% !%!"!$":L48$%8)6&E8!$ !9!% ?  ($%%"!  !$%" % ? 2@!"$  "<$ (: C"%%  !%   !"!  $":  "%#$F%   !%  "@!$ L & ,)*  );-O &,)7666E8

 M(=   9:  ($"=$ "%  !$!#  ($%: ($ !"%"#  ($%%"!  !$%" B" $%  $": ($  $  !"% (!$  (#$"!+9",77-))!@<$)--3 %?B9:%"@!$ %@C#%!"$8

;8 '!  !% ($!"%   ($%%"! B" (%  $": ($  $2#=@?,32+6,4$8138%"BB"($$%  ,121 4$8 *3   "%#$F% A% #9? #%# # ($  "%"%%"!  ($#@!A#4$8 "" $!"%?!CK#(!!%% 4$8 12*)- 4$8 7- L ,32+6, 4$8 13D )E8 % ?  $   !"% ? ! CK #(!C$#"%#!%%*276;4$87-8L,1214$8*3D)E !$%B2!"% #4""%"@?!CK#(!C!%%,2,);4$8L*276; 7-K12*)- )-E8

68 !4!$#% ?  9$"($  ("  9!$ #%$"% (!$  ($%: 9B2!%%$4$%($%%"!!$%"!$ !9!"% "@!$#<##4"""$%%($%%"!$!"%?"%#$F%!(%!"$$ !%%K"8 "%#$F%!%#%C""#:!2$%8,) 2!$!$($#@!A($!4"!@"" $@"@%%"@""%#

    56,7+5)--3 35+  

 ,* @$" ,7*6 L )E ! !  %C $#:%"$  " "K" % (#$"$ L &!(<"#;+5-),*9"%)--;E

38  #!%  $ ($H   ($!#$ #%% :$%"% L$%8 1; 8 )  % *708,!"$($!#$""%$%"@,)(%<$,7*3E8



PPP



    56,7+5)--3 +5+  

!  .-2  !-, .  ,! .-

 

345 6  7   8# &() . 9

,8 @"%&    ''                  ? %$4#$$   !(%       !  ,2,); 4$8 ?  &  '    '     ""%$%"!  !(%  "<$ (:  ? .$">   4@$  !"$    "" B  "%#$F% !(%!"$    !"#$%  =  )) !@<$)--39B2!%%$4$%8

)8 MA!%%B<!"8

;8 "%B($!#$%:$%"%8

68 4!$  ($%"   B2 (@% 4!$$ $!$ !%$  ($#% $$F%   #"  ;- 9!$ =  !%"4"%"! ($ (" $!# $#  $"< 4##$  $  '>Q"R$>!4B" +  +--6     %$!" C("$8  #"  (% F%$ ($!!:#8  #!"$ !"% D E ""B$ C%% B #""!  $!$% #"$ !<%"$  " % (   #""!%%B#O<EC(!$(!$B!%"4"%"(!@!"$$%% %$#""!OE(!$%$":%$!!$($#%%8'"#!"$  !%"% (  %$!" ##% ##$# ! %%$ E <E % E "K   $"<4##$$(!$$(%$$%"=$$$!$B2" @$#$$"$$@<8#!"$$!$%"!$!$!A  ($@  B" $!% 9!"%  "" B  #""! %%B# % 2@!((  B#%#C(#"#$!$%L$%8,;) ,-+%,-*E8  :$44"$  $#"%D             S"    "   

!("!4!$($#%$$F%%!%"4"#C($%"""BM?M44"4##$ $!"($:$44

    56,7+5)--3