Estate Tax Valuation: Closely Held Stock and Marketability Discount
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe matter involved the calculation of an estate's fair market value for tax purposes, specifically concerning the valuation of closely held stock and whether a discount for lack of marketability should be applied. The court reasoned that while the stock was closely held and thus subject to a marketability discount, the discount must be weighed against the possibility of a market absorption that could occur shortly after the valuation date, potentially leading to a higher realized price than a purely restrictive valuation suggests, ultimately upholding the initial valuation based on the reasoning that the restrictive agreements and nature of the shares warranted a specific, justifiable discount from the raw value.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Estate Tax Valuation: Closely Held Stock and Marketability Discount: The court reasoned that while the stock was closely held and thus subject to a marketability discount, the discount must be weighed against the possibility of a market absorption that could occur shortly after the valuation date, potentially leading to a higher realized price than a purely restrictive valuation suggests, ultimately upholding the initial valuation based on the reasoning that the restrictive agreements and nature of the shares warranted a specific, justifiable discount from the raw value.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the federal proceedings.
Volltext
#$%%&#'&&( )#+#'&&+
,)
! )! -)" !- "-
$( . '&&+
$/ -0
1111111111 !" # $ %&' ' ( &# '##
"22- -)" 3!- 4 ) ##& '###& ' ) *+ , -.
!" / 0122/
2)
26 !' 77777777778 & .9 2*:*8  '& & - ' %;;# ' %/#.#'#& <#/ - = '' .# , %# '% ' . ;# > .# 04446
06 ? &'# #8 7777777777 ' @ ' &'# @&& ' A(#8 (# # ' # 2*3+8 #& # # 9 ' .# ' ;# '  &# B ' # #&6 '#@# ' B#'& ' B #&8 9C'#C #8 # #&#. ' &D'8 & '& #; &#'#.8 E 248 #& 9'#8 & # #8 D& # 8 / &# B# &#'#. ' %& @D @# &'# # 6 &'# '& ( F # & D#( . ; ' )D/'& '8 # 9##&8 % ' '& ' # - ;@# . ' ;&( & #' '& #;6 <G= # ' #& ' .# %# C 9 ' @' 9##& D)#( 9 ' #& H <;6 ' 24 # 0440=6
56 03 04408 %& &#& .# # # #. ' ##' ##- 25 E.# 246
>6 %& .# '& & #- '' 05 E.# 2+ ( % .# E& * 0444 # ' ( ' &# <# #9##& ' ## ' #@ - ' &'# '&#@& %& .# '% #;# &'# %# #&=6
:6 !'& % 8 77777777778 &## $!I )D##8 &9# 00 ;&.# 04458 ;# '%&. F #& #9 B#@#9 '# &. , H6
& ( %& F ;; '% 98 #& 9'#8 &#& @#. ' # 2 ' &.&#& J (#;#& ' &@-6 ?# 9 ' &8 # ) '#B8 #(8 # & &#' #& ' .# # % # 9 , # <, '= , 244K <& #8  .8 DL#8 6=6 # # D D#9 &'#
1233410445 / 5122/
'%J 9C'#C& # ' %### #. B#. % ' ;M 6 # &## )D# '& H6
? 77777777778 ' ' &' # ;# #B # # J .#@& ' 9 ' ' , %& #9##& ' %D9# , )D ' .#8 '%&# #' , %#&@ ' # # ' 9## ' B#6
N6 .#& , ' ?! & , #& ' .# B#@#9 ' 244K ' %#.#& D9# ( ' #.#& ' &6 .& ( %& & ' D@# )D##( E ## ' #- #@#;##. #& ' .#8 #( %B # '#@# 9 &@ ' #& ) 9'# ' %##& % & '# & ' & # #& ' .# ' , # 9 , # '%#.#&6 .D8 7777777777 ' ?! &8 @ %.# ' %B %@# ' ;# , '6 # ;; ( '## ' %6 > %& #8 % % , #- '' <;6 ' 5 0445=6
+6 '&## ' 02 04458 % #;& %& ( '' ' ' . ;# &# E&8 #; ( # #& ' @# %# , & %B# 6
36 %&8 && !" # $8 ;& ## 2N .#6 # ' '%B #8 ) -. ' '## . .# &'#B ' # &##6
*6 ' 23 E# 04458 ?! & & &&8 9 ' %B #8 ( %& &# '%# , & ' %/ #.#'#&6
246 '&## ## ' 2> O 04458 % E& % ##6
226 %#&'## ' #8 %& #E& 2 9 04456 ( F ' # '&9 ' %& 258 ' %# #& '% .# ;# 9# ( ' .#. . #9 @#8 # ##'# 9- ' & # ' ;; ( %& # # # @D - D'# & H6 ;# .# ( &'# '%.# '#.@8
1233410445 / >122/
##- 7777777777 77777777778 %@# ' ' &' # ;#6
206 @& #8 7777777777 &#& ( F %D) D- &# 2N 9 0440 %B# ' @. 9 ' #& %&. '# , 8 &# , %B # )D##( % && ;#& '#-6 %# ' E# B #& '%.# '#.@ ' 7777777777 # , ( # ' !" $ H <.# ' 04 9 0445=6
256 &# ' 22 .9 04458 % E ' 6
2>6 &# ' 2+ '&9 04458 %& # ' #6
2:6 &@& ' # # ( ' 9# ' # F '# H (# #6
")
25 = # @.# %@## E'### <= && '#;#& ##&8 '- 2 O 04458 #9 ' # <6 2 6 =6
J ' 54 044>8 '8 #9 '###; <#/ - = & '%;;# #& ' %6 2 6 8 #'& ( ? .# && && .## ' %6 252 ' ## @.# / /6
9= $ ' ( # # # #9 ' &8 B #; #. P
/ ;#@ ' '# ##; ' %J6 8 '# ##; '% E@ (&# %#& ' D E@&8 #;6 %#& ' D E@& %&' , B/# ( ' Q '# ##; ) .# B & Q # , (# ##@# < $ *N 0*: R S 8 &# ' '# '###;8 >-
1233410445 / :122/
&'##8 228 6 0>3 R I9D#'8 '# E'### #.& #8 2*32
6 525 6=6
/ %#& ' D E@& . (# (%# # ( ) ( #9 .# B# <;6 S 8 6 #6 6 0:2=6 8 # " % - 'B ( '.#8 J .#8 , %# '% #E& .## ' '# ##( J& ' # '% ;#B ' ' %&# ' E@ ?8 L ###& ' # ## E#'##6
/ # ### # J '&& 6 ?8 % # ## ' /# 9 <;6 /$M# 98 'D ' ?DT#C8 .6 8 228 6 2+38 >54=6 .# ' . (% #9 '# -@ @&& '%@# . 8 ##- ( &( ' %# 9.# &@# E#'#( < $ 220 525=6 #; ##8 '- ( #'& #( ' %J ' .# , # %B# '% E#'## (# ;# ' # 2 O 0445 '&E,8 ' E@ ##8 ## ( E@ &8 && &@#- &6
= ? B# '%;;# & R . %J ' ' 54 044> # E(%, B#8 # &@ , .&#;# ;#& , %6 252 ' # %##6
? E#'## '###.  (% # ' '# ## ' #6 ) # ' ( %6 :+ ' # ;&'& # @&& ' '# ' # / /8 & .#@ 2 E.# 04458 D( ## #9 ' 8 (# # #( ' '# ' #6 '# ## &@ ;&'& 9#@ , @ #B ' # J #8 #B E( , & # , -. '#. ## ' 6 % ## & ' , %B#@ & # ;&'& ( &@# @.# && ?6
? %6 252 6 2 8 F # &9# ' #9B E@ #.# & R -@ 98 %@##8 E#'## & H6 ' &# ' 2*+28 '# ## ## && && #& 08 #9& # P F #9
1233410445 / N122/
'###; ##& ' '# '###; ' Q # &.# H6
## %# - J ## ( # '##6 -@ '%# &# E@ ' '&@@ '% '# ## P '# # , # &# #&8 D##(8 &&@#( )&#( ' 6 E@ '. # ### ' B # ' #6 8 ' J ' 54 044>8 #'&& ( B ' %6 252 6 0 ## ' '% #9B ' '# '###; R # # && F #9 H #@#;# F #9 H6 8 %6 252 6 0 &# ( #9 '###; ##& F ' Q # &.# H6 % '# ( &# ' #B '###; -. '% E#'##6 ## %# &# #& , ' ( F H '# J (#;#&8@#8 '%# #'&#&6
) ' ;#& # &# D##( &&@#(6 & ' .B & # <!&# ' ' # U ! / 2*+48 6 ::> 6= ( &@# 2*+4 '# &8 B L& ' E#'## #.# & B# &. , %6 252 6 2 8 #9 '###; #'& ' ' .# B&#;6 #9 &# '#& , #& U # '% 8 ## ' 8 G (# .# , " ' '&## ' '& 6 %&# ' (# ( # @&&8 # ( #9 %&# . '& ' & '%#9#6 &# &.#' ( # ## &# '.# 9#8 # ' ## ##- < ## ##8 B G=6 ? !&# ' ' #8 6 ::+8 F ' )- .#@&8 8 # '% ## &##& ' ## && '&#'&8 # ' E#'## '###. '## #'& '8 ( & # & H6
- 2 E.# 04448 && # 9&&;# '% @&& ' &6 ## '. E#'## '###. &# ' '# <6 :N =6 .8 ## ' ## ' &# && B & &;;#& <! 2+8 6 *>54=6 ###& ' E#'## % ' E# && # 8 # $ # $ 6 .# ' '## (# # JD& &@#8 (( & '8 ' ;# & #- '% #8
1233410445 / +122/
E( , '&. , ## ' 8 , E#'## '###.  ? %6
?# % '.# #. %# &# ' ' J ' 54 044>8 ?8 # &@ ## '  ) # D& #/J # ###6 % #; && 9 .#& &@#6
. ' (# &-'8 &# ' ? ## ' ; , ## @.#6
%&# ' E@ ) # && & #9 ;&'&8 ' J ' 0+ E.# 044>8 ' # @.# ' &8
25 ;&.# 044>8 '# ## ## ? ' #&@ , # E@ ##8 8 ' % ' %&# ' .B 6
06 8 #E& #8 .9 <# :N N4 8 3> ? N* =6
5 # ;&'& # @&& ' '# ' # ' N 9 0444 < = & .#@ 2 E.# 0445 " '#;## ' 9 '# ## &@ ' '# ' % ?/ 6 #9 '% -8 '&## ##@# ' ' 2 9 04456
>6 B ' 6 + 3 > 8 & & #.#'#& %# #& ' @# #8 && ' @ '&8 # & '% # , & D)#( (% # - # ' &' # B#@#96
# # , & )D#(8 (# . # D)#(8 .( #.#'#&8 '# # U , '# '# U # )D#( (# &(#. , ' '#6 #'- ' &( '% & )D#( '#;8 ' ' ;;# , ' D@ %/ #.#'#&8 '### ' #& ' @# ( %& # JD ;# . ' 9 .& R ' (# B#@#9 '# J '&#& # 9E#. ( #96 ; ' &9# # ' ( & @& #;##& B #.#& ( D& ' .# # ;; ' #'6 # '&# ## ' .# ( #.#& #9 J B#@& ' 6
1233410445 / 3122/
' %B# '% # #& ' @# & # , & 8 # % ' '&##; ( %& B #.#& #. #;;# R # ; 9# L '' %# ) # '%' ( # , ;# ' #& ' .# #( #9 J B#@& ' # (% # J # 9 #&& < $ 240 2N: R 20 6 230=6
## .9 E# ' )D D#8 &# ' '&. )D#(8 %#8 DD& #8 D#8 B## &. < 20 6 230=6
'& ' , %#8 , D'& ' B## # # #.#'#& ' #6 .D E L ' %/#.#'#& (% .(& '# #' (# " # , & D)#( # , #& ' @# # & /J '% # , & D)#( (# . ' '# < $ ' 0: E# 0445 6 +52140 R ? 2N
6 52+=6
## 8 / E@ %& #; # &#; ' # '% B # &'#8 AD ' %B / & &#& ' # &# , '# ## ' E# ;# ' %&# &'#B '% & ' ;# '&6 ? E# '8 # # ' %& '% B # E'### ;# ( /# # ' '##8 (% B # '& #9 #;# # ' #- .#6 8 ( '% &## & ' ## # , &# ' # ' '&'# ' %B /8 B8 8 # &# '#.@ ' # ' '# / E@ 8 9#8 ## &# ; '% . B # &'# < $ 223 0*4 #'6 298 220 50 6 &;&=6
(# 8 #8 . 9 '% &'#8 (# ' % ( # ##@#B # # ;# %9E '% &' ;#&8 ( ;' ' B 8 (%# &@ #'&# # B #&8 (%# # && &9# # # ' '# <-=8 ( '# # ' B &'# # # ;# ( # ' %B / # 9# #.& < $ 200 2N4 #'6 2 &;&=6 %&& '&# . 9 % ## # %#@# ' ) ' .8 # '&#@#8 ;
1233410445 / *122/
'% '% B #8 # 9 9# < $ 200 2N4 #'6 2 R !8 '# .#'#V9@ # ' 9#@#D ;.#D@ 6 0*+ 6R ! 8 ;'#C##D @D@ # ' ? 8 # ? ? 5012*33 6 550 6=6
&@'8 ! #@ ( %B # '# J ;'& '# - ' '#@#  J @A , '## .# ' #&8 ' & BD#. &(#.( B (# & <! 8 %B # &'# ?# P #;#/ B B#@ ' (#& W # ? ? 28 6 5+ 6=6 J 8 I B (% B # '# J - ( B ;# 8 , # B & B (# &6 '# J &D#98 D ' # ' '# < I 8 T@ ' #D ' ?D.V'#@8 # 2 6 :N+ 6=6
:6 ? %6 03 8 %& '# , ( ' %# & B '%#.#'#& ' >4K #8 , '# # B '%#.#'#& ' :4K # , #- # B ' NN8015K6
N6 % -8 &'# # % D#& &# # # &# # 9 ' .# , ( B6 ;# ;# & '% # L '&;.96 ? %B )D# %& # ' #.#& #. ' '#;;& '# ( & #8  .8 %DL#8 6 &# # # )D##(6
D , %B ' 8 &;& B & , %.# ' 77777777778 (%# ) &## 9### ' %& ' #
28 ( &'# .# &#& E& ( # # F C 9 ' @' 9##& D)#( 9 ' #& H6 ;# &@ & '% '## # ' 7777777777 ' 7777777777 ( B ' &' # ;#6 7777777777 ' #& .# .# '#.@6
+6 $ ' ( %B ( &'# # , &## ' # 26 # L '&;.9 .#@& 7777777777 -. '% D) D- (# %;;# /J 6 %) '- # '% # %&6 &'# # (# (%# # &.&& ( # &# #9 9##& (%# %) .# '
1233410445 / 24122/
'& '6 &'# 'B %B# '% 9 ' #& 9'#6 %@# ,8 %B 8 ' ' %&'#;# ) #( ) D ' ;; %&6 9 & ' ) &@6
#9 # (% D@# )D##( %. #& ' .# ' #- #@#;##.8 (# E#;# (% # # J .#@&6
7777777777 & # X. ' ;# ' &' # #B #6 % ' #9 '% #- ## ( # '@& '%#.#'#& '% # 04K8 (# % < 2*3> 6 *: R $ 6 ' 23 E#
23 04:1*+=6
8 ;'&8 (%J E&6
1233410445 / 22122/
- ")2 )! -)" !- "-
67 8 9 36 $:' "
7
26 M# 6
7
06 E6
56 # ( &' @#6
>6 ; # ' (Y . ; & J ' '&# ' 54 E '- #;## # '& '& #9 ;&'& ' 8 ?DT#CD;(# N8 N44> 8 # B #6 '&# J @&6 &# '# P = #'#( B ( '&## '&# 9# # ' '&## (&R 9= B ( #; # # .# '' '&##R = #@ ' &6 ?# &# # # && &&& = 9= = #/'8 #9 ;&'& ' #- (Y# '. '& #.96 &# ' # ) ' .8 (# E#8 ## ( '&## (& Y. ' ( && B &'#& <6 2508 24N 243 =6
@;;#- P &#' P
!#/# Z # [
# ; ' & J #;#& B # ## (Y, Y;;# ;&'& ' # @;;
1233410445