Arbitration Clause Enforceability: Unconscionability Challenge Fails
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe case involves a dispute over the validity of an arbitration clause within an agreement, where one party sought to compel arbitration while the other argued the clause was unconscionable and thus unenforceable. The court reasoned that although certain procedural aspects of the agreement might raise concerns, the party seeking to avoid arbitration failed to demonstrate substantive unconscionability regarding the arbitration provision itself, which clearly and unambiguously covered the dispute at hand, leading the court to enforce the agreement and compel arbitration.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Arbitration Clause Enforceability: Unconscionability Challenge Fails: The court reasoned that although certain procedural aspects of the agreement might raise concerns, the party seeking to avoid arbitration failed to demonstrate substantive unconscionability regarding the arbitration provision itself, which clearly and unambiguously covered the dispute at hand, leading the court to enforce the agreement and compel arbitration.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertThe court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Volltext
"#$%&"%''( "&()"%''&
+ *+ +*
,- . / %' 0 %''&
1111111111 !" ##########$ % $
$
* &'%( (% % ) *+ ,--. ( ('
!
&1/*1&
2
*" !%' ########## *3+4" ( *33, 5 % 6 '%( (% 7(&58 9: $ 9$;(< $(%$( =$'($> (% (( ?$ %@$'' ("
1" 4 A( *301 9 B< % () >( (' %9 (% % ( ($" $ '' ;( C % (((> %9 ( (= ( %9('$ $($> $ D (?"
$( % ( $ $%(< ########## '%(&% ( E 5>" 9$? $ ( 5 % 9 $( ?9 ( >%%%9(% "
." $ % 9 $' 1--- !" ########## $@ % 9 ?( % 9 ( D< % C( %9 $> $ D5 $ $ $ % (E'?(>( $E9$(<("
2" F$ (' ($ %9D$$( % 0 '; 1--- % ########## '%(&% ( $ ( ' >(<(&(9>( E1+G+4-"&C"%$ 3G+20"&C"%C(%;$ $("
+" 3 $ $; 1--- ########## ?9 ' % ( %(( % $;5' %$%$ (? $%$ @ ( $ $?9('( ($%? % ((" >($ D (?( *301 %>( $? H %$ $> ( ($ $ D (? ("
1-$>';1--- ##########(%(?E9? ( ' > ( $?E 5$< '%9(% %>$( %$ ( >( >( ('4A( *301"ID;(( ($$ D (?>(% 4- J E 4+ J E *1 $ $(% ($ $C$% 7C$ ($ D (? (C ( ' (?: ( K ($; ?9 >( % ( $ D (?%$(>H D<5*+7F$(>( %5>:L"
," '%(&$( % 9 (D% ########## (' ? ( ' >(<9 ( ED<%9?$( ( %$( C%9&'%(%*4'*3327 !:$%$(C% 9&(% %1-'*34*7 :"9@ ($%% *1*+ 11 ( (($%( %$;5'%(?($ ( (' %$(% ##########%3$ $;1---"
0" 13A(1--*9 C%%D< ( ' '$ (C ?9(9<(( %? %(>%9(% "
/*01+/1--2 &./*1& 4" . A( 1--* 9 $(( %(($ C$' $( % .* $M 1--* 9 %( H E % D< $M (C(?' ( @ ? % %> H @ ( "
3" %(($C$'% ';1--*9$C('$( ($"
*-" * $>'; 1--* 9 $ 5 % (; %'(( (C C$ ($ $'' (; $ % $ %(($ $ E$ ($ E(D<%$M ( <(E( ($ % $> $ D5 % ( @ ($ C( % $M (C(?' ( E 9@ ($%? % $ $D9(% "
" A<' % 0 '( 1--1 (; %'(( (C %'( $ $%'9E';$E9C( (C'' % $ D5% ("
*1" F(( %9 $ % 9 (; C% % 7 N : 9 (' %'( 1* A( 1--2" A<' % (; %'(( (C%0'(1--1 >$= (; $%$( $ $'' %9( ($ % $(% $> A<' "
($';( E9?( %9&'%(%9'$' % ( ' % ';$ C( % (&( $ ? ($ % (( ( ' $ ( ( %? %(>%9(% "
F > % >( $ %( $( % '%( ########## ##########(9 ( $(;%>$(( ( ' $ D (?( %M ?% 'H' H ( ( '>( % ? % (( 9>( ( @ ($" ( ($ $'' ( ( ( $( "
*." .-$M 1--2 * ';1--29 9$ '( (;%%$(%(5"
*2" 9 '(C %2$M 1--.% ##########%9'$ %1,G1+2C"%$ *-G-.*C"%C(%;$ $($ ( ' % (% 10A(1--1*4A( 1--.((?9C % ##########(( $%$ (%*1%';1--1%9'$ %*+4C"$I@'% 9 $%"/('L"
*+" *. ';1--2E%'%% (;%9>" ##########% '%("
/*01+/1--2 &2/*1& *," *, ';1--2 (;%%'% ##########?9( (C(?'$ %C %2$M 1--.$ ( '' % $ D5 E? ( ' $ ( $%"
*0" *+ $ $; 1--2 9 (C$' (; % ? %($<D( % 9 >( $ ########## 13 '( 1--1"
*4" *4$ $;1--2 ########## ?$(% (= C( 9$;A %C %2$M 1--. ( $? E 5$< '% 9(% %>$( %$ >( >( ('*301"
*3" *1 $>'; 1--2 (; % (C$' ( ?9( %( $%$ @ ( $C( N##########" '( $( %9$A %'(($%9@ ( C(@%(.%';1--2$ ?9C >$(> % ($%9@ $A % '(($%9@ ("
(9$ %$( E$("
1-" *+>(1--+N##########%$$ %9@ ("
@'(91C>( 1.'1--+ 9 E $(( > ##########"(?((D%($<D(? " N##########5>?(( 8
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
/*01+/1--2 &+/*1& %9 $> ;(%< ( (" $ ( $ 9 ( ( '' % 9( $ $> ';; 5 @ ($%2((%$( $ ($>;(%< (( % 1.&1*&*. *, $'' ((" ( <$; % 12&1+&1, ? % CC " %(?$>;(%<>%E% ?(( ( ' (7*1' $(%3:"F($9 ( E 9( ($ ( % (C % ( ($ > $(
7 (C F:D$$(% ##########$$C ($%9;(%<%3 ' !%1.E*,( %81,01$( EC".*-RC"4G14.1-" 9A$ C(%;$ $(?9$ >EC"4G---"&"D$$(% ########## $ > ? (&% $ ($ (> 8 (( (C(> $ (C F".' $ $% ( ("C %;$ $( <' >( E$ ($ %.' ' ("$ %9D$$(% ##########%C" *+4*- A (C((9<( %9%@(5'>(%'%E(( > ( ' ('$ " $ (C FL"
N##########C$'C(%'?$"@$$ '' ? 9@ ($ % $> $ @ % 12&1+ 1, > &%E % (' ($ % 9 ( %$( H '( $ > % ( > % 9(% " % ($ % 2 (( @ ( H $(% $''( $( ( %( %9(% ?(($ (( E 9$? $ $ ( $ ($ $ D (? %" ( '5C ' E;(E$< '%<% ($('$ ?%9 % $$'(@'H'$ ( "9<( ((E$' %9 % ($ ($ %( ' $>$? 9(% '( $? $<(? % CC(;(' ( E % $(( ($ '(? %( ' ( E $ D (? $ ( E 9(% " ( %( $ $ %95%$' %($<D(?E%($( ($?A$ ($% ((9 $ $%( *332 1--*$( %1-5$% *$ %$%('( ;%%%>(%9 ($"
1*" *1'(1--+$ >?9( ('%>( %%D< <' $M % 9@ ($ % '' % ? % (( %5 $ ?9( 9<(( %9 ( $( ( %( % 9(% " ( %5 $ ? D$$( % ########## ( $ 9( (' ? (; %'(( (C ?9 % %@ 9>( $> ? ($ % (C((%;$C$(%>( 9(? ' ';$' $ %C % ##########$ (C(>"
11" *1'(1--+9( ('>?9($ ( %9@ (?9@ ($% $>$ @% 12&1+ 1,( &%E%(' ($%9 ( 9 ( ( > 9(% ?9( @( ( % %(><
/*01+/1--2 &,/*1& '(C % %9D$$( @ % 9@ C % ##########"
/*01+/1--2 &0/*1&
*
*" $%$%.A>(1--+ (;%$ $' $A<%%95"
1" $ H % 1* A( 1--2 N A< ?9( ($';( E 9( (' % %D<C(% ( ' % (%$ $ ? ($% (( ( ' $ ( %? %(>% 9(% $%$ ( ($ $'' ( $( ? (; % CC ;(( % 9@ ( A%((( $C( N##########"
." ?($>$; %9$ '%(?( % '( 9 ? $( ( (<(@ ( C( 9$;A %9 % ($ ( ? $ C$% % @' $' ?9( <' $(% ($( @('$@'(?9(( ;( ( $( % 9'5 ? %( ($ % $ @ '%( 9( ($%( ($'%($( ( C(?$($% 9@ $( %M' '$ (>" %' 9' % '( $ > $; 9 ( 9$(<( % '$= % > ( %(< ($ $'' $ $$''@ ('(; ;($$ 7 N*1+.+1$(%" .*11*,-$(%"* C:"
A< 9 (( '$ (C (' (C % $($ %9 @ ( '%( A%((( BD % 9@ (' % ' $( ( E %($( ($ % A ( C( % 9( '%(@%9 %C( %$" $ ( ($%9 % 9@ ( A%((( C( ? &( $ ( % $ %( ($ $ ?9 @ ( $%$ (; (C(' $($ % '(5 $>( " $ $? %9 (( ' % $(($ $ ( E ' (' %$ ( % %% ($ % 9@ $ @ $ ( ($ %(>< % $($%%(A<$;$(( ($$'' ( $C$'%9$>@ ('%(7 N*1+.+*:"
2" :%$( E% ($%$ %G(% $%G;$% G>' %$''<;% 5(% G ( E (% ( " @(< '($?G(=(%G%' ? >' (% %$''<( $%( % $ $?G( ( >%'H''(5"F>$((G>' G ( E $ ( $ % ( ? ($ % C( ? G%'(( ($ $ D A< @'( C$% ('
/*01+/1--2 &4/*1& %(<' %G$%'%( ?(%$( H D$C$' E 5< % %< % >('; $% (? <' E G( ($ % > % G $(" CC( ? G@( %G $ % E CC $( ('' $(; $ $;;" %$( % $( ( G@( (( $ ? G%'(( ($ $ A<%>( %%$ C>%G"%C %>> % (' % ( ?( %( ( %$( % C( $ $> 7 N *1, .11$(%"+ C:"
;: %$( E % ($ $ $ G@( %G ( % ( %? " ( %? ( %G5 $ $%(( % D$ G@(%>(C( $(% ( $E KCC %<% ( ?( G $%( > % ( % CS$ < C>$( ($ 7 N*1+2,*$(%"+ C:"
+" @ '%G ".1"* ! ($' ($@ (1+E .* %$(> H CC( $( $$'(?" GCC(( %$( H %'$ $%' D$%( (C(?"G$$'(% ( ' H E %(($ ' (5 % ( ' $ D (? %$ G> ( % ($&$'$($&?G$CC%$'('%(% ( 7;D% < % $( % ( $ G " .* " * ! E '(5 % %$( % G&'%( T % ($ CS( % '=U ( 8 > ' ( %G$%$ $ $' $$<( >$" *-0 T*330U " *11V % <' ;(% !&W(% >@GD$%F$( ( % %$( % *330 " 110 " 124:" F( ( ( ' $ %$ >(<; ( = ( % $% E ; $M ;C( % ( ' " F( G %G @ ' %G(> ; DD (;' '( 'D ? G G %$( ';$' % C( % ( ' $@ 7 N *12 1-- $(%". C( V>$((H !"%*3"-3"1--*W0./34;(( X%$=1--*$,"0*$(%"0;V N%1+A>(1--1W0/-*:"
," 95 ( $ (' % 9@ ( % N########## 6 ? $% @ @(< A(% ( ( ? E > $; %9 $ '%(6?C ($%;(%<$*301 ( E>(<'H'( 2 % (( O *1 *+ 11 >( >" $ %9 $> ;(%< ( %$(" %(( % H ('( E3' (%*1"
F9<( % 9@ ($ % 2 % (( $ (' E 9>( % $ 9@ ( ' %9CC(' ?9( @( ( % ( %? 9(% '>( %%( % " $ %9;$% ########## >( (&'H' CC(' 3 $ $; 1--- ? @ ($ ( ( ($ % % ( %(( %
/*01+/1--2 &3/*1& $;5' %$%$ (? $%$ @ ? $ $(% N % $ H % 1* A( 1--2 $'' (' ; E % C < E 9(% %> %9% %C( '%(@' ($ @ " *0 E *3 % 9 $;(< $( % $( % '%( % 13 ';*33+6 F7$M %$(% ((D< !:"
( $ > ?2% (($ >(';;' ;( CC(;(' %M E % $(( ($ '(? ( E $ D5 9@ $ ?A$ ($%((9 $ $%( %5*332$( 1-5$%'($ "( ((%' 9@( %9 ( %? %(%((%$;5' %$%$ (? $%$ @ 2 % (( 9@( % $ D5 $( E9(% "
$? (; % (> $($ % 9@ ( $ ?$C ($%9$>;(%<'$&' (? ( ( ($%%<% ($%$ D5$*301" % ( ($% (( % 9$$'(( % ( ' ( 9= ( %9('$ E 9( (' ( D< % ;(%< % *1 ' CC %5 $ ? ( %( 9@ &%3' &' ( <' %9(>; DD '( 'D 7 N % 1+ A>( 1--1 ( :" C( ( ' ( @ 2 % ((9EH (D<9( ('%5$?9(%$ %( %9(% "
0" :F9<( %'$ %D$$(% ##########($>( %> ?(( 8
@ '%9 "+, > %$> ($> $ @S (>( % %$'( '%( (( ?9> ;(' D$( ( ;(' % C( % < $;$ ($ %C(@ (C"> $C( ( ' %@ (< ( % $> ($" ( ?( '( $%( ($ $ %DE $> ($7"*:" $(C%>( E$$%( ($> <' ($ (C(%9 ;D%$( %(;"5<';$' %M@?(% % ;(' D$( (?9$% (C(9 (;7"1:" 9; % $> ($ $( C% %( ( ($ ( 5>$($ (7".:" @ %$(> H 'H' $ $ %9&(% 7"2:"
$''(($ % (C '%(@ 7 !: $ BD % < $;5' C$%' @ $ $< $; % 9& (% $;(< $(%%$'(%%$( '%( % (C'%(@"F %(($ $ 5 (' (C $ %$'( % 9&(%
/*01+/1--2 &*-/*1& $;(< $(" % 9 '(( ( % 9&(>(%( E ?9@ C(%< ($$%( ($> ;D%$(" 5<< !9 '(( ( 9&(>(%( $ ';%$ >DP( @ $( ($ % $ '%( 7D //YYY")' "D/C/>;":" 9 (( ? $( ( %9$%$ $& $' $$<( 7FF: %9 $ '' % !%9 $ $ *0A( *33,$> ($7(&58$> ($ %*A>(1---:" F$9 "4"*%$> ($' ($% ($'%($&% ( 9CC $C$'' (C @ E $> ($" (C '%($& % ( > $> ($ (C( FF $$% % &'%((7 !F:%*0A( *33,6<' (?@ $(@ % %$'( % 6 ; (( % 9 (; ($%9 ($';%$( @ ($'%($&% (" E>%$( C(@EC".*-9$%%*0A( *33,$> $(C%*2'(*330"
;: 95 9@ 9 (C % ( % ! ( (? > % $( % C" .*-" F$ ( ($ 9 (( ( (?;" $M % ( ' ( > 9(% $? % C"*,G22*.- $( ;(%< % 3 ' $M % C" 4G14.1- % C( % ;$ $(>EC"4G---"& C % ##########%C"*+4*-"
4" :%$( E$ ($%;$C$(%%( %G "2 " @' $ E G " 3 " F$ A(% % $ G( %$( ?( $A$>;7 N*10.,$(%".*1,.40$(%".V ! 1---O W *1, " 11.: ( ' ( $= & E ( $%( ($ & %G@(< ? G $( $' ?G >( % $ %(" (( (<' $%(($$> $;(<G%'(( ($E$ ( E%'(( > <$ (E$("$(C ((? G $( $( ( > % ( ($ $5 E G<% % $ % '( ?G ( <( $ $( >$( <( % ('( % $' 7 N *1* ,, $(%" 1 C:" $( $ C$( >;' $' C( %G $( 7( W (%%$( %'(( (C25'%""*-4:"
;: $ (>$? $ ($ % ;$ C$( $ ' ';$' % D$$( % ########## ;( ; %9 (C (>" (; % $ ? '(5 $%( ($ %$( E $ ($ % ;$ C$( C( %C %5 $ ? 9 $( 9$ 9( (' >$( (; %'(( (C $ % $% % $ = ;$ (A<' %0'(1--19$ $'(E9?C $ %>( ;( ########## (C(>( ';$"
/*01+/1--2 &/*1& > 9 '' E 9$? '( ? (C (;" % @' ( ' %5 $ ?9 ( ( (<( ? ($%(%( %? ( ' ECC 9(% %*301"$ ($$ ( >$(%%$( E $ ($ % ;$ C$(" $ (; % ? $ ? ##########'';%FFCC ( ' $> >%9&(% %>( %9(? (C% ( F >(<' (5% ($ "
3" > % ?( 5% $ (' %'( 9( (' $%'E=E$ '$ %C"*,G22*.-"
$ 9 >$ $ '% ( $C($' ?(C( '( $ $A$( " ($ %$( H ('(E( ($%9 (?(<( %$"95 $%( ($@? (?(<( %$ %E %%$9 (>( $?9%$=((?$ % '$%<($ '(7 N-41:"
/*01+/1--2 &*1/*1&
* 2 *+ +*
34565 7 855 5 9! #,% :
65
*" $>;"
65
1" 9%' (' "
." $%' '%( (% E = E !' ##########$''%C"*,G22*.-"
2" C$' ( % ?9 > C$' $ $ H % %( % .- A$ %5 $ (C( ($ ( $''% % (; C% % FDY()D$C?( , ,--2 $( @'(" %( H $$<" ''$( %$( 8 : (%(? @ ' ?%(($$ %($; (( %%(($ ?V ;: @$ $ ? '$ (C ( (' $>$( %'% %(($V : $ (< $ % $ " F( ''$( $ ( $( ' ' $ : ;: : (&% (;C%%$ ' (5$?9( %>%(>;"''$(%$' ($$'$= % > ?( $ A$( (( ? %(($ ? 9>$ % ? @%($ 7 "*.1*-, *-4:" <CC(58 (% 8 =F (!
$($C$'% H $ (C(@ (((?9E9CC(C% % ;(?<CC
/*01+/1--2