Property Claim Dispute Over Services Rendered
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe appeal concerned the rejection of claims asserting entitlement to property interests arising from a purported agreement to compensate an individual for services rendered in connection with obtaining certain assets and property. The court determined that the evidence failed to establish the existence of a legally enforceable agreement or a resulting trust, finding that the claimant did not demonstrate the requisite intent to create a present beneficial interest in the property or a clear agreement to share the benefits of the assets recovered, thus affirming the judgment against the claimant.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Claim Dispute Over Services Rendered: The court determined that the evidence failed to establish the existence of a legally enforceable agreement or a resulting trust, finding that the claimant did not demonstrate the requisite intent to create a present beneficial interest in the property or a clear agreement to share the benefits of the assets recovered, thus affirming the judgment against the claimant.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited in the dispositive for the allocation of costs related to the appeal.
Volltext
"#$%&"'(() "*#$"'((*
++
, +, ,+
)-. /.0 $ '((*
1 !"#!"$%#"&$" " "# ' ( #))*+#)
#"
, , 2,+ #+ 2 " &,-! #./01,-,, .
!
&-2,1&
3
,6 ,35/ ")()#)"# $ "+#+7# )(8"#")#" 9#8+"")8+")" #6 #)#+#+!" :"; !" << <<< = << < = < ><:?@": 87":";##A &!"B < C * +"#)(7)#+),1D6("+!"!")" #7#+ )E 6
-6 8) )!#F",335("+ 88"#) F "";;: 7)#6 < ") #7)FG##7"+ )#+H "B"),.,8"630)B.1!#F",335 ""! )# /1D)""+6
.6 -3 # F",335 & ## #"+;):"-&. !"&+);:I+7"F6
46 " )(88#+)#"## "7#",18+7"",33/("+ +#+ !+"+J(:K!## 7"#")B7>LC!""$9:8 ) *6 " ) ## !+"# & !" +)+ !" """ J
8 " # -#.)K#+)" ##!)K#+;:6"### #"7# :"";!F#!+".*+#++#"+& )J)*(! 7## +""6
06 ,, 8+7"" ,33/ ( !+"# +#+ "!"6 #+ # 8+"")-#!+"").!"#*+##8 )K#+;:6
M6 ., " ,33/ )(## 7 (" "! F#+ 7 ) L ("+ +#"J< 6 &7"+)#+H "B" ).38"6J !#"),.8+7"",33/6
56 "!! "#+)),/H,33/" )+"+* !##!"+##!#+)#"7),11D#)B")+8#76 ;+!"#)) ")+8#! #& !+"# "J)" # 8 " ) !"+ ) F" 8+"" # )(:9! #:+ ) #9! . ) #" F I+##)+!"8#9)" II6
/6 ,M !#F" ,333 < << < #" J !"## )+"#*)B##)#(!#+)#"7+###B"# !#F J ()# ) ,1 8+7"" ,33/6 " !+" ) ) ,. 8+7"" ,33/ ,0!#F",3337"+# #-/=,048"6016
36 B,M!#F",333< +J("+)#+H "B" ) ,.5 8"6 " F )( ; ) M-=-M4 8"6 )#+ H "B"
2,3452-11. &.2,1& 7"+!"< ),.8+7"",33/ .,)+F",333 #+7+ # #J.5=-538"6
,16 ")+ )5H7"-111(88# )("&7)#+>&!"B C + J ("+ )B ," !#F" ,33/ "# ")" ! #B">,=//.8"6,33/,=31,8"6),"H7".1H,333,=31,8"6)B ,"H#,333C"# ")" !+#"! " H #>0M08"6,33/ 0518"6)B,333C#"# ")"!! "8#>50.8"6,33/5M,8"6 ) ," H7" .1H ,333C6 ## # # ) "# H*( .,)+F",333(#+7+J45=1--8"6
,,6 < 88#+)")# ## !#)!"## ) ( ) "# # ) )#+ H "B" * )( ; !"+F !")),,5=5,48"6")+ )-,)+F",3338I+ ##) ()#+ H "B" "+)# J 5/ 8"6 51 )B ," H7" -111 # J ")# ) 4=455 8"6 31 ! " !+" ) ) ,1 8+7"" ,33/ .,)+F",333 !"+# * ## "# !+ 7 !"## 8#"6 " " "* ) ( !# ) 4=4558"631"!#"+#" #8)##"6
,-6 .,H7"-111("+8 "+ !! # #"##)+ ### ;!"+F"##!" )+"# ))!+" ) #+""7"#)!"## !B!"(""&)#6
,.6 " 7)+ )/ 7F"-11,< +)+ ) -, )+F" ,333 # !" +)+ J 7 ) ")# ! " !+" )),18+7"",33/.,)+F",333N"!"O++# *!"++)#(!# !#)"#),1D#8I+# # ))#+H "B"7"+J4,=/418"6406 F #J ) 87")("+)0=,548"6306 ##)+ ##"+8 "6
,46 ,0 7F"-11-< 8 "+("+*( )+"# +##) #+ +)##F+#*(####"J!":"; ) +)I6 #"!"++*( #" )()#+H "B" "F)(!#+)#"7),11D#"#.,)+F"-11-# *( I"# )" # J "# !"# )(7)#+ )B ," H7" -11.6
,06 " )+ ) ,. H7" -11. < !" +)+ J 8 ) ")# ! "!+" )),18+7"",33/.,)+F"-11-# J ")# ) ,M=1,/ 8"6 .06 # "7 " )+ ) / 7F" -11, ## !# ) "# ) ,1D # )( ; !"+F !")).1M=/148"6M1 ! "!+" )),18+7"",33/ .,)+F"-111 >")E *(! 9""##+;"#7"+()#C6
2,3452-11. &42,1& ,M6 ,MH7"-11.("+8 "+ !! # #8*!+" )#+"" .,)+F",3337#)+HJ8#( FH#)()+ )+8#76
,56 4"-11.< ))+J("+)!"+"( ### )")# J!" !"#!""6
,/6 0 H -11. ("+ )*+ 7 " "E ,14=-54 8"6 ##" ) "# # M.=/3M8"6/1##")()#+H "B"! "!+" )),"H7"-111 .,)+F" -11-6 ( ! ##+ ; !"+F !") "#6 < 8#7 "*< )7# "-M=1348"6306
,36 ")+ " !! # )3H#-11.< 8"+)+ ) ,.H7" -11. !"+# * )B ,M !#F" ,333 7# 7"+ )#+ H "B" ) 5/ 8"6 51 # ! ) 0/ 8"6 .1 !"+#)# ("+6
-16 ("+ #"H#+ " " #" ## )+ ,1 # F" -11.6 # J (F)")# 6 ##*< ! 7#"7"" )+ ) / 7F"-11, * +## #"+ 8 "6 " " )# 7 " "E ! " !+" ) ) ," H7" -111 ., )+F" -11- ) )#+H "B")( ### #)/M=4058"6/16
-,6 "+! ),,)+F"-11.(#+ #"H#)" "6 )B"*)")# ) #!")" )+"# # # !"## )" 9 !"*)+ #!)O +7+#6 # +;") "B7 * )+ ) / 7F" -11, +## "" + ## *( !"# ! )+"# "# ) ,1D ) "# *(!" +)+J" )+"# 6
--6 "+!*).1H7"-114" "#B;*"#),1D+## 7"+ !" < ! ) " *( "7# ) ! 9" ) "# *(8#(H #" ""++7#()#6!"+ ! ##")+ !#; F)")# )< " ))+ !#!"#H*(.,)+F",3336
-.6 ,38+7""-114(#+" +J)!*"6
+
,6 ;7 "( ";# H)">C+#+ )8+###+)B ," P#-11. "F# )" ! +)0H; ) # !"+)# # 7&!"+)# 0 !!+# # ,M H; " >"#6,#6"#0M C6
2,3452-11. &02,1& <#J(# )(+# ),MH;"!" "F8+)+" -5H7"-114> ',.1,1MC") ;7 ) !#+,.8+7"" )! # #"# "";#!"### "F# )" ) +;" " J #" H; ##" ) (### ) (+# ) 7IH;"6
-6 8 "+# J ="#6 0M 6 , #6 :6 0 "F # ) " %##*) ### !"+7J("# 0M "#7 J 8+)+" " ("&)# ) -1",3/,> C6< !+#! "H;"))(!B#+#F6
.6 #;! "#""+)# )()#+H "B"!"E!"" "#) ,.8+7"",33/.,)+F"-111))"))")# 88#+!"(#+#Q ##"! #)7 "(""&)# ! 7#"7"")+ )/ 7F"-11,6
46 8+)+" " !"# ;++" ) )" # ) " ) M # F"-111 > C # #"+ 7;" ," H7" -11. #"%# )8# ) F")! # )) )" 6 < H"!")+;# !!F):;#)"B;) )" # "# * +## 7;" " ) "+# ) =+## ) 8# * ) # O#"!!"++H")*# *) +*H")*> ',-54M5 )6,,-M,MM )64FC8#"*#"F)+!#O#" + J !" " ) )" )= !" +)" ) " "+## !" " I* #!" )#H*= #))+ )#"#7#; > ',-,.MM )6,FC6 (!B##;I)")# ! " !+" ) ) ,. 8+7"" ,33/ ., )+F" -1116 # ) )! # +; 7;" H*= ., )+F" -11- * # !!F6 #J)! # ;++")!" +)")4B:!#") >"#6-5JM- C=!!*#"+"7)BH ") #"+7;" > ',.131 )6.6-,.1, )6.6-,,53. )6MF $ ,33/ R.5!6.,M )6.FC6
06 ( "" )I !+" ) # J )#;"N ) ,1 8+7"" ,33/ .,)+F",333Q*8#( FH#)#)/ 7F"-11,)()+ #"+8 "Q#),"H7"-111.,)+F"-1116*# ) 7 " )# )( " )+"# # "+ ! * ! " !"B"!+" )# +6
"F!" ! )(I"7## # )!+" )# ## *# )7 ""#),1D)7# O#"!" )+"# 6 7)"#)(I" )# )" )+"# #"! (;#)!+" )*)+HJ8#( FH#)()+ #"+8 "6
2,3452-11. &M2,1& M6 C )+ #; 8 ) " ="#6 41 > 7;" H*= .,)+F" -11-C6 < ## )! # !"## !B ) ="&)# & J =I!# ) # ! " ! ## & "# 7 ) !"## )=#" " * ( ) "B; ) ")# ) #!!F #"+)#)" SH #+ I!"## )#"" IB)#;) # !# !"+" * ="+ #" 7 !"7+ =#&J&)" ; * ("+ ! ""# "+"((7#!F) ;>86"#60,6. C6
FC < "+ F++8 )= "# ) ="&)# # *= # 7# )= 7)##"%#!#+)#"7 #J!"7 " "# +! "!"")## ## :#)#+H "B"6 ; )+#"# ! " =)#+ H "B" # *= "+"# "7 ) 7 )# 7) !"# > 8") $ <:?@": 87":";":# " ,3/0 !6 .-5C6 # +7##+=9!"!!)")# "=)#+H "B" #+"F)!#+"+));6 #"+!#+;"+! " ) ()#+ H "B" )"" " * ("+ "E 7# ()#>"#6,06- C
C (!B " "# "7# H# 7# ) )# ) ,33/ "#)(7)#+)< ),1D)( ##).--8"6#" ) M-=-M4 8"6 >4=0M/ 8"6 I ,. T ,- I -41 8"6 )( # 8C6 !)# !# # ) 8# * (! 9" ( ! "+)# " ) ! 9+!"B!"")#< +##!"!+;#+J!" +)" J)")# 6
)C(#++#F!"#);H "B"!"+FJ,518"6M1! ",33/ #,333"F)=;)M-=-M48"6J,MM8"6M1! "-111"F )(;)M1=/,48"6J,5.8"651! "-11,"F)(; ) M.=4,4 8"6 # 8 J ,55 8"6 .1 ! " -11- " F )( ; ) M4=5,48"6 !# # )( ; )+#"# ) M-=-M4 8"6 # ) #I )()# !" " 8I+ J ,.5 8"6 ## ) =)#+ H "B")J=#+"+>/1D)M-=-M48"6N.M0H "C6
C " !+" ) ) ,. 8+7"" ,33/ ,0 !#F" ,333 (#+ 8I+ ##)()#+H "B"J.38"6 + ##H ##J !"# ) ; !"+F ()#+ H "B" ) ,., 8"6 30 7"+ !" < << <>4/=,M,8"650N.M0H "C6 ##+* ## )#+ H "B" ) ,.,8"630 +## 8+"" J !"# ) ; H "B" !"+F ) ,51 8"6 M1 # * " "# 7# ) )" # J )#+ H "B" !+#" ) .3 8"6 >,51 8"6 M1 Q ,., 8"6 30C6 " !+" ) ) ,M!#F" ,333 ., )+F" ,333 < 7"+ )#+H "B"#B"),.58"6 "!+" )),"H7"-111.,
2,3452-11. &52,1& )+F" -11- + ## ) ()#+ H "B" "+)# H ## J !"# ) ; !"+F ## H "" ) /, 8"6 -4 ""! )# J "# )=7)#+ ) ( !"E !" " "# >-3=M0- 8"6 U-=45, 8"6 V ,- W N .M0 H "C # ## ) ,18"6M- ""! )# J "#)(7)#+)< !"E!"" "#>.=/5M8"6U.-.8"6V,- W N .M0 H "C6 " ##+ * ## # # ) !"## + J ("+=+7#J--/8"6/M#*="+##")# )0/8"6.1 ";"))=!"#);H "B"!"+F),518"6M1>--/8"6/M&,51 8"6 M1C6 +## (#+ 8I+ J 5/8"651 >,.5 8"6 & 0/ 8"6 .1C ## ) =)#+H "B")" "#J!"#"),"H7"-1116
8C <=;# ) !+" ) ) ,. 8+7"" ,33/ ., )+F" -111 (#+ !" +)+ ; F7#N)#+H "B")(+7# # # J -44=-5, 8"6 )#+ H "B" 7"+ !" < << <J-/=,048"601"#)=7)#+J,51=4.58"6-16>,0,=-3M8"6 ) ( # ,3=,4, 8"6 -1 ) < C !"## )=" !"E !" ("+ # ### 44-=/M- 8"6 51 >-44=-5, 8"6 T -/=,04 8"6 01 T ,51=4.5 8"6 -1C6 !# # )= ; !"++ !") ) .1M=/14 8"6 M1 (# "#+ #+ ##+ (I# )( ")# ) ,.M=10/ 8"6 ,1 >44-=/M- 8"6 51 & .1M=/148"6M1C! "!+" ) )+"+6
;C )+ ) < 8 ) " ="#6 41 > 7;" H*= .,)+F" -11-C6 ## * ## )! # 7 ")# ) !"## ) ="&)# 7 )=#" " >$ !6#6!60.M7A) 8X'R ")# ":#:'";) < < ,334 !6 ,.C =# ! !!F " ) ()#+ H "B" # ) "# )(7)#+ 7"+ !" < > ' !F+ 414214 ) -, 8+7"" -110 )6 46,C6 88# :! )=!!# !"!# "#""#)="&7)#+#))#+ H "B" ) ="&)# ) S ="&7)#+ ## " )" # J "# 7# =""&)# > ' ,-M ,34 )6 , # ""O##+C6
:C " " H"!") > ' !F+ 414214 ) -, 8+7"" -110 )646.C=I#!)=#" ") ")# *H#8"# = "")#" !#)"#)(7)#+)< )) ")# 6 88# "# )=7)#+ ) # ="+ F++8 ! " ";)#"7,353 =!") $ 6< "+; "# + ! 7# O#" "+7+ &)J ) 7B + !"B =)# >"#6 /1 $ C # ! # # #! (# 7)! # +;>H*=J=G;)M-2M0A"#6--6, ) 7" 7;" H*= ., )+F" -11.C6 =+! * 9#B 7# +#+
7 !" +;#" ) =#+"O# ) #F#+ ) "# > 8") $ :# ) "I )" :?@": F;# ": 87":"; "
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
C )"))")# !"#! )+"# "#)(7)#+)< +J#)()#),35/;) # !#!"+"*("+#!"7+>"#60,6. C#")E 7"+ J ,11D !" ! 9" >.1M(/14 8"6 M1C6 ! # (# )(" ! ##+6 B " ## ) ")# (+B7 J ,,M=3,M 8"6 31 >4-.=5-, 8"601U!"## # #)" WQ.1M=/148"6M1U; !"+F ) ("+WC * ) " "# )" # I )#+ H "B" "+)# ) < ) ,-5=.048"6,1 >-44=-5, 8"6 U)" # I )#+ H "B" ) < 7# "+)# W Q ,,M=3,M 8"6 31 U")# WC # )87")" "#).=,--8"6/0>,-5=.04 8"6,1U)" #I)#+H "B")< !"B"+)# W&,-4=-.,8"6 -0U)#+H "B")+HJ7"+!"< WC6
56 ;"8 ) " "# # ) 8 )+ * " !+" ) ) ," H7" -111 ., )+F" -1116 # J I" ) ,1 8+7"" ,33/ .,)+F",333Q*8#( FH#)#)/ 7F"-11,)()+ #"+8 "6
/6 < ="#6 0. )+ 8 "# !+ 8 " # J "+7 )8# 7I! "## #)+ 7"#F+*# ) 7I 9 ) !"7 # #" 7+ * ! 7# ! O#" !" )# !"7# >6 ,C6 #" !# O#" " )+"+ "*= #
2,3452-11. &32,1& 8## "" + ! " ## * "#8# "7O# ! "# #F>6-C6
36 (!B (#+ (7 * ! ) 8# 7I (:9! #:B ) " )+"# "+; !" (+ -6 9 # # )(F ") ) ##" * #""# J *(88" (#+ )+ ) ,. H7" # 3 H# -11.( ##I+ )# )(" )+"# ))+ ) / 7F" -11, +## "++6 " !!"%# * # (# ! !*(++# 7(#!!"#* 7#)7 " )+ (+## ! ! 8## "" +6 <" ! # +;# " "# F##) ;)6
,16 B")*!"+B)" "#)#)+ " !! # ) 3H#-11.+6" "# F##;))#+)-(111 8"6" ")+J##")!"#!# J8"#)+!6
2,3452-11. &,12,1&
+ 3 +, ,+
45161 .. 7 811 1 9 ! #:' ;
61 .
,6 +"" ""7FA
61
-6 ()#A
.6 )+ " !! # )3H#-11.A
46 # * )" # ) " "# I )#+ H "B" ! " !+" ) ) ,.8+7"",33/.,)+F"-111(+B7J,-5(.048"6,1A
06 # * " "# )" # J !+# )()#+ H "B" ) .=,--8"6/0A
M6 ) (#+ J 7"" " "# )#+ ) -(111 8"6 J ##" ) !"#!# J8"#)+!A
56 8 " !"# ) *( !7# 8 "" " " #" !"+# ""O# ) )+ ) .1 H " )B #8# !" ! " )+ )"+ "F 8+)+" ) " <:?@": 8* M M114 #" I!"6 )+ !# O#" !" ;+6 + " ) #N C )*" I##*)+ " "#)+" F#"#!))+ ##*+A FC I! " ! " * #8 # ! 7 " ))" ## #" )+ A C ! "#" ;#" ) "!"+##6 < + " ## ! #" ++# ++"+ ##" C FC # C &) "F8+)+")"! ""!#""#B""" "*( )7")+""""7F6+ ")" "# " " 9 ) !"7 * " # H # * )+ ##*+ # (7 !! ) *+#+I!+)+" "#>"#6,.-,1M#,1/C6 ;"88B" "+)#N '' R"< R "+#"&H"#N :!! Y
! 8 ")!"+#""O## #8+I!"#*(J(888+)+" )#+!F*!";"88
2,3452-11.