Contract Damages Recalculation
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe case involves a challenge to a decision affirming a calculation of damages related to a contract dispute where the court had to determine the proper measure of recovery following a breach. The court reasoned that the lower tribunal erred by failing to correctly apply the established measure of damages, which should focus on compensating the non-breaching party for their direct economic loss sustained as a result of the breach, rather than allowing for speculative or remote profits; therefore, the finding on damages was vacated and the matter remanded for recalculation based on the appropriate contractual damages standard.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 106 al. 1 let. b LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Damages Recalculation: The court reasoned that the lower tribunal erred by failing to correctly apply the established measure of damages, which should focus on compensating the non-breaching party for their direct economic loss sustained as a result of the breach, rather than allowing for speculative or remote profits; therefore, the finding on damages was vacated and the matter remanded for recalculation based on the appropriate contractual damages standard.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertThe court declared the appeal inadmissible based on this procedural provision.
The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Volltext
! !
"# $!%&''''''''''()#*$$$+ )!*)!%
")*!&''''''''''()#*$$$+!",
#-%!
.. . #%/ -%0 )+5!)!%! ! 12(3
4.! -$5-6)!% !-! --(700.8$ $5!(++%4 $ 4$3(9:; &
!"#$%&'(!$ )*"+!$%,-!+./ %+(( )'#+
0
10 %<6!*!-)<$(3=*!/*>%!)%$>)!7%!*$=%!$ -! 7%##+)$ #-$#)*%$6!#-%-+!<$1?9@"!A%$7%")*! &''''''''''(+!''''''''''!11!-"# $!%&''''''''''(+!10
0 .!# ! /$55%! ) )$ 7# $-$5 ) <6!*!- 7%+$-+( ! %$> )! 7%!*$=%! $ -!#%)#+!7%-6!7%*#$-$+)! B#$% )!7%+B#A!7%#5! $#!! C$ 7%/)! +7#D)%-!*%$6!0
0 !<6!*!-)!)$B#%!! -)!B!)+5$$-$5!13 !7-!*>%!!-+-+-% *$ )E#55$!%$>)!+ !9 !7-!*>%!7#%!D+-$#)7%-6!0
30 !%$>)!+ #$$-+)! 7%-$! !#*)!!%$ -$--$#)!7%+B#A!( 7$ $-!%7!+! $ -$--$# )+5!)!%! ! !! 7%$-)!$#$C!%! *#-- )! B#$% )! 7%-$! C$ )%-!*%$6!( #$-)<$1?9 13 !7-!*>%!0
0 .!# ! #%%$!% )! .. . ) #B!*>%!(")*!&''''''''''+-+)*$ !) $ !)!7! $#! 1!% #B!*>%! 0 . 7%! --$# )! #%-$! C$ ! 7!)- ! *%$6! E+=B! @ 13E315%013 !7-!*>%!!-!!!)$ 7# $-)E!7%! --$#*#*!- )*%$6!0
.!# ! <6!*!- )! )$B#%!( )!*)!%! ! EB$- 7 -%B$+ )%- ! *%$6!!-EB$-#!+@#-$ !%@7%+B#A!7%#5! $#!!C!)!7$ 0
20 ! $B! -$6-$# *!+! 7% ! %$> )! + #!%- ! B#$% )! 7%+B#A!))!*)!%#-7!%*$ )E+->$%! 5$- $B- F
• !)!*)!%B$-+-+55$$+B-!1!%<B$!%17%= )!G#)-$# )! 7%+B#A! )! 4 & .0 ! 1!% <B$!% 1( 7%! --$# )! $>%!7 6!)!E335%0+-+-% 5+%+!@. . 0
• 1!%<B$!%11)+!*>%!3($+-+55$$+@$ !)!7! $# . . ! %$ # )! # !*7#$ /!H ,''''''''''. I#7A-%!) &#)$6($!>!5!)J0!1)+!*>%!3( 7%! --$#)!$>%!7 6!( #$-1?E15%0+-+-% 5+%+!@.K..G0. . E7)#!% ! $)$-$# #!%- E+B!-!! 7%! --$# )! $>%! 7 6! *#*!-)*%$6!0
• .K..G#5$%*+C!!)!*)!%+-$-55$$+) !)%!)#-%- #09 4.! -$5-6)!% .#7A-%!)&#)$6
($!>!5!)!-C!EB#$%)!7%+B#A!C$ *#*!-)!%!7%$ !) #-%-!1!%<B$!% E+!B$-@1?E15%007%! --$#)! #%-$!13 !7-!*>%! E+=B! @ 1??E2 5%0 .K.. G $)$C+ ! 7 7#B#$% !% 7%! --$# )! #%-$! *#*!- ) *%$6!( )= #% CE$ $ *C$- ! )#*!- )! E %!% 7%++)!-( . . 0 +-$- !7!)--#-@5$-7# $>!CE!7%! --$#)!$>%!7 6!EB$-+-+ C$ ! *#*!- ) *%$6!( )= #% CE! 1?9 7%+B#A! 7%#5! $#!!+-$-5--$B!!-C!E %+B$-@!*#*!-4@? 0
• E:#5$%*+CE@ $-!)!%!7%$ !)E!7%-$!)7!% #!)! L''''''''''.7% #$+-+,''''''''''.(7%! --$#)!$>%!7 6! ))!*)!%( #$-2E32?5%0($B$-+-+-% 5+%+!!2 !7-!*>%!10
E7 +-+7# $>!)E+->$%! )-! )E55$$-$#7%= )!$ !)!7! $# )! L''''''''''.0 ! 7$=! 7%#)$-! 7% ! )!*)!% --! -!- CE$ -%B$+7#%E!*7#A!%7%+$-+)1!%*% 191<B$!%10
?0 ! )#*!- #-+-+-% *$ D7%-$! !)-!)*$20!%$>! $5#%*+! C! % > ! )! %! !$6!*!- %!!$$ ( E! - *#-- )! 91E2?35%0CE$!-!)$--% 5+%!% %!#*7-!)!7%+B#A!)!E!D4+7# !0
90 <%$)$-$# !% $)$C+ CE@ )+5- )E#> !%B-$# )E$$ 1 *$ 2( %%M- !%$-%!) %!--!> !0
0 E> !!)E#><!-$# ) !)+$5$D+( !+-+6%)+!@<6!%0
10 E%-0)!#$5+)+%! %!$>%!7 6!) 7%+B#A!7%#5! $#!!( B$!$! !( %B$B- !-$B$)$-+)1?)+!*>%!1IG J(!-%+!B$6!%! 1!%<B$!%(%=6!7%#+)%!! )!)$B#%!0#% C!! #<#$- ! #- 7 )N#%) %7%! --$#)! #%-$!@7%-6!%I%-01!-1#)!$B$4J( !<6!)$!))$B#%!#*7+-!- ! )!E%-0?01)!#$5+)+%! % 7%+B#A! 7%#5! $#!! ) <$ 19 I J( #$- @ !=B! ! %$> -#)! %! #$! )!7$ !1!%#O-()#$-(7%= C!E55$%!$ +-+-% *$ !I%-013J(!D+-!%)E#55$!!7%-6! %> !)! +)! %+7%-$-$#)+-!%*$+!7%!<6!))$B#%!0
0 .!#E%-0G I#B!!-!!%!B$6!%)!7$ !1!%<B$!%J(! )! )$B#%!( ! 7%! --$# )! #%-$! C$ ! )%- ! *%$6! #- 7%-6+! #5#%*+*!- D%-01(1(131!-13P! %-0@ G E77$C!- 7%#6$!*#--@-% 5+%!%I01J0 #%/C!#<#$-(7%! --$#)!
#%-$!@7%-6!%#%%! 7#)@)$55+%!!!-%!7%! --$#)! #%-$!(6*!-+! )! B#$% )! $>%! 7 6! !D$ -- +B!-!!*!- *#*!- ) )$B#%!( !- 7%! --$#)! #%-$!(6*!-+!)! B#$% )!$>%!7 6!!D$ --+B!-!!*!- *#*!-)!# $#)*%$6!I50%-03G J0 #%!(#<#-! @ 7%! --$# )! #%-$! !- @ EB#$% )! $>%! 7 6! !D$ -- *#*!- )! # $# ) *%$6! ! $-+%M- ) *#*!- ) )$B#%! IG 19 P G1333J0
N! 7=!( ! <6! )! 7%!*$=%! $ -! #%)#+ ! 7%-6! 7% *#$-$+ )! 7%! --$# )! #%-$!C$ ! )%-!*%$6!7%! )!*)!% ( #$-)<$ 1?9 13 !7-!*>%! ( )-! @ C!! ! <6!*!- )! )$B#%! ! - )!B! !D+-#$%!0
0 .!#! )#*!- 7%#)$- ()!*)!%! !E7 -%B$+)%-!*%$6!0 E! -! !!*!-CE!!#!+!-$B$-+%-$B!!-CE!!#-$ + @7%+B#A!7%#5! $#!!0.7%! --$#C$ !7!)-!*%$6! E+=B!@ 13E315%0()#-*#$-$+( #$-?E1?5%0%!B$!-@ #!D4+7#D0
! )!*)!% )$ 7# ! C- @ $ )E! 7%! --$# )! #%-$! )! 1??E2 5%0 *#*!-))$B#%!0B)! )-! )E55$$-$#!-)! $5#%*-$# )#+! 7% ! )$55+%!-! $ ! )!7! $#($A$!)E)*!--%!CE$!)$ 7# $-)E! 7%! --$# *#*!- ) *%$6!0 E!D4+7# ! )%#$- )= #% @ *#$-$+ ) *#--)!7%! --$#)!$>%!7 6!( #$-99E935%0
# +C!!( ! )!*)!% )#$- @ # !D4+7# ! #! )! 91E2?3 5%0 I99E934?E1?(J0
30 #5#%*+*!- @ <%$ 7%)!!( )!7$ ! <#% )+-!%*$- 7#% ! 7%-6! < CE*#*!-)-% 5!%-)!7%! --$#)! #%-$!#)!)!*!%!(!#<#$- )$B#%+>++5$$$%!)!!--!7%! --$#)%#$-@)! $-+%M- #*7! -#$%! %! *#--)!!!4$0! $-+%M- #-+ -D*$$**+6 !#E%-01 )!E#%)#! %7%+B#A!7%#5! $#!!B$!$! !( %B$B- !-$B$)$-+ ) 19 B%$ 193 I J # !# ! -D %+6!*!-$%!( $ !$4$ ! - 7+%$!% IG#7>$+ 2)19<$!-J
0 +*#*!- ! !% 7!%Q( 7%#+)%! +-- 6%-$-! I%-0 ? 0 !- 9&01)!#$ %7%#+)%!)*$$ -%-$B!)1 !7-!*>%!19J0
RRR
* 1 0 ) &
%%$%
23-$4-"$%5(!+6-+!%!-$%$+!%-!(7%8 '9
10 B$-! 4.! -$5-6 )!% .( 700 .K.. G( @ -% 5+%!%()#*7-!)!"# $!%&''''''''''(#-%-#09( #! )!91E2?35%0@.. . !5B!%)! ")*! &''''''''''( $ $ C! )! $-+%M- #*7! -#$%! ! )! # $)+%- ()= !13 !7-!*>%!< CE*#*!-)-% 5!%-0
0 NA#)*!!--C!)!>! #$0
0 $-C!7%#+)%!! -6%-$-!0
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
!#7$!#5#%*!)7%+ !-%%M-! -#-$5$+!D7%-$! $ $CN@N55$!5+)+% )! %! #$! 7%!6%!55!!