Contract Formation and Excuse for Non-Performance in Sale of Goods Dispute
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe court reviewed a dispute concerning an alleged breach of contract for the sale of goods, focusing on whether certain communications constituted a valid acceptance and whether performance was excused or properly tendered. The court reasoned that the crucial issue was the interpretation of the parties' exchanged writings to determine if a clear offer and acceptance existed, and if so, whether subsequent commercial impracticability or failure of a condition precedent justified non-performance by one party, ultimately holding that the writings demonstrated a contract and assessing liability based on the findings regarding performance and excuse.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contract Formation and Excuse for Non-Performance in Sale of Goods Dispute: The court reasoned that the crucial issue was the interpretation of the parties' exchanged writings to determine if a clear offer and acceptance existed, and if so, whether subsequent commercial impracticability or failure of a condition precedent justified non-performance by one party, ultimately holding that the writings demonstrated a contract and assessing liability based on the findings regarding performance and excuse.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertImposes the costs of the proceedings on the appellant who lost the appeal.
Orders the granting of legal aid to the appellant.
Volltext
%&'(%)+ %,((%)+
!!
- !.- -!
/ 0 1 # &( 2# )+
!"""# !$%&' % #&"!!""(#&)&%"!*
!"% !"""# +,
!&%
++ - + + . #8% / ++ / $!&0123 4144 44
++ + + %5!67 $!&417 4144 47
! "#$
190
3
4< % =>& 42 !'?% 1::0 1@ A?% %"? $%"@% "& $%!!# "'!% # 46;4&!"% #46;4 B(#&"&%"#& 4:"4630<
1< A"88%6=>&$%#"&# %"?$%"@%"&!#&C $%&" % !% $%&>% $% !"&"# '!"% $%#'!5 $%!8"!B"$%A#$!C%&%"><
7< =>& "'!% & ' #8""&"8 4: ='"% 1::; & #&# &%" (!88" %"?#46='"%1::;$!%C#&"!$%&><
D< %"?# &1D='"%1::; !""&#$%&"! % "&"&&"! $%#'!5 $" "&%$# "&"&&"! #8% $%"&"!"B%!&&'!"%$%&"B"%& %"> !"&&%4:"4630&4:='"%1::;<
0< +(>"&% "#&##&?"E
- B(&%'"# 4%!F&463D7:'%"4633$"4%"466: 74 #?% 4664 $!% + !"#&# 88""# G / . + !& "B"&% ( $ %&%!'# !$& !'%& ! %H
- B("&#&#$!5#$%%@A &% 74!F&4663 74 ="& 4666 B ! '!"% $%#'!5 #&# &%8#%# % !$& "?% $> !'%& $%@ / ++ I!$& J4:44226K&B("(#'"& 4:='"%1::; G/%<4(16:<60H
- B($!@!$&$%#'!5$%@ ++ - + + . / ++ B#&"& %#"&# 74='"%1::; /%<4D(003<30&74#?%1::0 /%<4D(406<-I!"&/%<4D(133<-4:='"%1::;KH
;< &% "(&'#%#E
- B("&88""#G ++ ( ++ + + + + + + I K
943091::; 790
- B ! !$& (#'"& G /%< 0(:33<6: !& %"> B" %$%#&"& "!5=!&"&#%L&$&$#%"!%"> /%<44(:13<6:74='"%1::;&/%<44(::0<3:74#?%1::0 I!"&/%<44(:47<104:='"%1::;K
- B!!$&#&"&%#"&# 74='"%1::; /%<424(D77<-& 74 #?% 1::0 /%< 4;:(6D; I!"& /%< 4;D(713<60 4: ='"% 1::;H
- B("$%"%%M 4%!'?%4662 !/%<;6(623<- $@ % !" 8##% % (!%>& G $%!$%"#&#!>&<
2< !&!&#&#&%"C$%&" #&&$%#"#B(G#8&(!?%'&"! %$%&#""$%&" %%L&%"&%%&&?<
3< (?(!?=&"!#"8"C# #&#>%#G=>%<
!
4< (%&<10!"8##%%"?%$>$%#'!5$%!8"! '"" %'"'&&"'""*#?%4667I/K &%#'">% 4%='"%1::: %@>$%!#%"'!%<!%B!=!"&!& $N!%%$%&&"!!%&"G$%&>%I%&<411&417 ! "'"- K =>""'!%!$#&&(%&<27<4!"8##%% $%#'!5 $%!8"! 10 =" 4631 IK !"& G @' %"? &!%!"$"4%!F&1::7 !"& $%@B(88"%" #&#&%"I%&<4D1 K C#&%(!88"$%&>%? # %#$%&"&"!#&%"#$%=>"'!%<
1< +!(%&<11/I!'&%'">%$"4%='"%1:::K "'!% $%&&"! !%&" B" %& %"> !& $%&># !8!%#& C%&<411 417 4D4&4D1 H%&<7G0 /($$"B& $%!>"!&&G&%8#%%I<4K<!%AB!=!"& $%&&"! !%&"G$%&>%!%%$!G"88#%&%$%&&"!!%&" >&# '!"% "?% $> C"&& #'&& !& "'!% & $%&&"!!%&" >&#'!"%"?%$>C"&&#'&& !&!"!%">I8<%&<1D/K<!% !=!& G $%&&"! !%&" & G ('!"% "?% $> C"&& !& !"! %"> "&#%L& !& "'!% I / 413 17:H /416DDDK<
943091::; D90
N$@ => $%"@% "& !%!# $%&> $% !"&"# $%&&"! !%&" B" %& %"> $% %< & $%&"& !& N $%& %"> 4: " 4630 N&% $%& 4: ='"%1::; &GB=>&"'!%&'C#&!"%<
7< +! !& $%!"& $%&&"! B" $& %"> $% %&/%<407(740<2:I4;D(713<60-44(:47<10K&"BB" $%%(#@'G/%<40(023<60I4D(133<-O4(16:<60K "&#%L&5& #=G #&# # $% "&"&&"! $%#'!5 #8%< (& ! 8"& % B" !"& G ! C-#$! !&& /%< ;3(3;3<D: I2;(;02<30-2(236<0:K<
D< !8!%#& G =%"$% $" =!% #&%"& $!% $%&> =B(!&&%8%&$%&&"!!%&"!% !=!"& "'!%#?##8"""%&&$%&&"!%!"&G"&#%L&!$&!"%% !&&-"< "&#%L&!&#&C""#>!(%&<41 (!%!%$%#'!5$%!8"!'"" %'"'&&"'""&# 43 '%" 463D I 1K ! ! &C %#>&"% " "-" & $#%"% I /!$?"#7;9:143="&1::7K
0< #!& % $%M $%!#% #&& >%&"& I%&< 27 < 1 & 36P<4!"%$%!#%""&%&"'41$&?%4630K<
QQQ
943091::; 090
! 3 !.- -!
#
456 7 8 9$ &+) ":
4< '"& ++ ( ++ + + + + + + G &%8#%% !$& !"% ! /%< ;3(3;3<D: G ++ - + + . / ++ / 8'%#<
1< '"& ++ ( ++ + ++ ++ + G'%% $ !&& "&#%L& !$&!"% !"#%& @ 4: ='"%1::;=B(!&&%8%&<
7< N5!&&B?!"<
D< "&B$%!#%&>%&"&<
0< 8!% $%&" B( $'& 8!%% %!% !&% $%#& %%L& #" 7: =!% @ !&"8"&"! $% $" %!# %# %"? 8##% % +AR"S%A!8B" ; ;::D &%!" C$"%< #" $& L&% $%!!>#< #!"% !"& E K ""B% C&& B #""! %!%& #"% !?&"% " & $ #""!&&B#H?KC$!%$!%B!&"8"&"$!'!"%%&& &%#""!HK$!%&%">&%!!%$%#&&<+"#!"% !&"& $ &%!" ##& ##%# ! &&% K ?K & K "- %"?8##%%$!%%$&%%&"@%%%!%B(" '%#%%"%%'?<#!"%%!%&"!%!%!5 $%' B" %!& =!"& "" B #""! &&B# & ('!$$ B#&#C$#"#%!%&I%&<471 4:;&4:3K< >%88"@% %#"&E "// T%"+ T !$"!8!%$%#&%%L&&!&"8"#C$%&"""BNGN88"8##% %!"$%>%88
943091::;