Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/393/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/393/2007 KI-generiert

Supersedeas Bond Interest Accrual Date Post-Appeal

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/393/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Teilweise gutgeheissen (Partially Allowed)
Kostenauflage zulasten Vorinstanz / Staat

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The case involves an appeal concerning the calculation of interest due on a judgment, specifically focusing on the date from which statutory interest should apply to portions of the award that were subject to an appeal bond. The court reasoned that while the general rule mandates interest from the date of the original judgment, when a supersedeas bond is posted, statutory interest accrues only from the date the judgment is affirmed or the appeal is otherwise resolved, because the bond ensures the judgment debtor is not unjustly enriched by withholding the funds during the appeal process, and therefore, interest on the amount covered by the bond should run from the date of affirmation, not the initial judgment date.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Supersedeas Bond Interest Accrual Date Post-Appeal: The court reasoned that while the general rule mandates interest from the date of the original judgment, when a supersedeas bond is posted, statutory interest accrues only from the date the judgment is affirmed or the appeal is otherwise resolved, because the bond ensures the judgment debtor is not unjustly enriched by withholding the funds during the appeal process, and therefore, interest on the amount covered by the bond should run from the date of affirmation, not the initial judgment date.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Zinsenlauf Obligation Abzug für Schuldzinsen Steuervorbescheid Feststellungsinteresse Auslegung von Urteilen

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs for the federal court proceedings.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs for the federal court proceedings.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

 

           "#$%&"$''(  ")%)"$''&



* +,*    * +

-.  )

! #$ /  $''& 

     !    "#$ % # !$   &!$'$##( )

$#

*   ) ++ % !1# # ,,  +  "#$ % !$       &!$'$#-. #!+ /  

$ 

 #     !  +  / + ""! "#$ % !$       &!$  '$#    0 

                ! ! 

   .4233.  

 0+

39  #!35,:$#% !(355;"#<+  =" ( > 3 "9 4 $ ?@9   !$! 11  ! A  *     )  # ++ (  3  B$ 355; = ."#( C  *$ D ## #   !1#431!%# #477;@9

49 # #-E$ !"!  ? %#  4774  !"F  $   $!  # G"# (# $$(%"#! %#=" ( >3"96@9

,9  3;   4774  *$   $$$! &F $ & "#$$   #$   ?6&67; 1#9 $  $$ #! &$$$   &#! #  " $!  $#%  F $$ "   34 %G# 4773  "#! $ -&  &!$ $ "  11  ! H$  " G  $!IG$ #"#$$  G#"J H$# $"$$ 9 F" -!- & " $!J % $"#J#&#!"## $ "E$#G!!1   #I"#$$  G#"J$-"#!-$ "## $"# $A$#1#$ %#=" ( 33"9,@9

?9 #     45 %#  $ 43   4774  !"F  $ %"#$J#"# $ !"#$$ #$ &#!=" (>3"96@9

89 #$$#3#$:B$4774!"F$1 #!#%$!  %##$##"#$ K$11$ # %#=" (> 3"9:@9

;9 # KJ$  ? "$G# 4774  -! F "#$  "# "   3: "$G#4774 # G"# (# $"#! %#!"F 9$ (#"#!%H"#1  $$!-&!" G!!1   $ & #$ "#$   &#. %  $!  #$ -I   "#!%H !$ $ !KA #%9   1 F! I  $! !- $G  A I!" A 4,&:8,1#9$$##"$A $ !"#$$ #$ &#!9 1  #!A*$ !G $#$$"$ G#"J  &#! $   % ##  #! $  "$   G# "J A %# # "# &F.

!"=" (>3@9

69 ""I!$! $#K$!$#KJ$#$-# #$% !1  $ 144$G#4774=" (>33"98@9

:9  *$   % #!    4,&:8, 1#9 %#  8%G# 4774 #  "$   G# "J %#$ "# &F.!" "#(   *      ++  L +++=" (>4@9



2345624778  .,233.  

59  45 %G# 4774  *$   1#!  # G  "# (# $ -I&# $"B$#1!## $(#-&#!"#!$ $  " $!  $#%  $ G!!1   $ &  $! "# "#$  J  1 $ G$%#$"#$$ #$ 9  -!-&% $  $! #!$# $$% #!"#(*    ++   L +++=" (6$33"98@9

379  3, !G# 4774  *       ++   L  +++  #$ $! A  *$   $$  4,&57: 1#9 ;8 %#  36 !G#4774=" (>,@9

339 &#!!$!  !%11$,7%G#4774=" (>33"98@9

349 47!G#4774*$ % ! # G"# (# $  $$  $ & 1#! -I  "% $ " "#!#  $#1#$ !$ 1  KJ$ %## $&#!#%# $$ (#" $!$#% $  !$ $ &11 G!!1 &#$#$# $$  "!(#-I !$ $MJ! " F$ $INH"$N( %# #$ $11  !"#( *$ $% $G!!1   #"$$ "#$$ I %  $!K-IAIMJ #$# $" ($"#$$ #$# $=" (8$ 33"98@9

3,9  : K% # 477,  # G  "# (# $  1 $ "#$   1 $ A &F.

!" $ & 1#! -& "% $ "#!$#    #!%     %$  %#=" (6@9

3?9 ,#477,&F.!"   # G"# (# $&  #!%    KJ$   %#9    A  #!%    KJ$   %#  ? "$G# 4774 $ A  $    F.#   %#$ &  $!!- $G4,&:8,1#9"HG " $1##$   677 1#9 "$  -  = $ ?4&777 1#9  $$@9  &""       !J! -& J# $  $  #  # A  %$ -I F $ $"EN$A G!#$ 1%#I"#$ 4("  #F.#  #$- % $%  !$$=" (> 33"9;$6@9

389 #"#$&F.!"F$-*$ % $"# !  ##!  #1$   1##  KJ$ ( # -IA  HF    "#!%HI!$ $#%9 &"" %#  F"!-I$#$ O " $!$#% % $!K-IAIMJ#$# $ I% $   $! "#!#$# $ "#$$ I %  $!$I% $"#P-  $! I#"#"#$J =" (>33"95@9

3;9 #KJ$3#!G#477, # G"# (# $ - #% $#""#$!"#%###- !$ $$  -



2345624778  .?233.   #-I $ $$ "#! $"$#1#$#! G#"J 1%#I!"FG!!1   ## #% $" G  $!&%# #$ $# I $ $$ "#!%H%$ # G"!$$9!-$$$ #  $   ! !  # # A $$# #  #!%   K-IA KJ$  # G $  #   #  $$$  ""$  #AI $ $$ "#!%H=" (>33@9

369 *$ !A&#!#$#$# $(3#K% #477?=" ( >8@9

3:9 # $  48 %#  4778 &F.!"      # G $  #  9  $   $  !" -&   $ & "#$ $$! - &#!&!$ $" % $KJ$ %#$-&# $A  $ !   "#$$   #$  ! "#  #!  # J &$# "#$ #! A  !1#  % ## "#  !G $  "$   G# "J  &#!    4,&:8, 1#9 " $!#E$ 8Q #! $   "$   G# "J9 &""  $ $-& ##$& $#$  "#!# "#  KJ   %# -& $   # # &#! &!$ $ " % $- " $!$#% &!$ $-$"# ##$-&  "#!%H "#1  &!$ $ #! ! #  "#!   %# $ - "#$$!!$1  $G$"#$J"#$$ #$ "# "# #KJ9K$!-&!$ $A$#$-!1#% $! #$ $$ 11%#"$&#!9

359  44 K  4778  !1#  ! - &#!  $ ""!  9  &"" F"!-& #% $#$%  "#$ #$- % $E$#$%###"$ G#"J # $ !"#$$  G#"J- #$# J "#&#! . %# $G #!-1  (##"#$$  %  1$#  -"!- %# $E$##! $#"$ %$-& "#$ %# $ E$##$ $!9

479 # !    6 "$G# 4778 &11  $  &#. %  $! = .

"#( C  @  ! A &""!    #$ $ (# & %  $!  3# K% #,7"$G#477,G!#$F& %  $!377Q$ .

#$& %  $!(3#$G#477,1$ &J#!& %  $!;8Q9

439 # #  : !G# 4778 $$$ "#!"#$ #$  # G  !""!&#!$  "#$ ! "#1 #% #" $ %9

449  3; K% # 477;  #  1#!  # G - &""!   % % $  +!!J   -  $ # #   "#!#   %#  " $%# GG$!!$"#$$$"#! #$A-



2345624778  .8233.    % $ !"!    #$ & %  $!9   #-   # G & $#"#$ #AK$9

4,9  3# 1!% # 477;  !1#  1#! &""!   -&A   $   !    &    $   %## #!$#$ %$  #$ & %  $!  377Q  3# K% #  ,7 "$G# 477, "   ;8Q  3# $G#  ,3 !G#477,9"#! !-  # G$#   $A%##A# $ !$$"#$$  "J  # $  &G J$   "#  $$  #! $  #$1$#9

4?9 ;1!%# #477;!1# -! # G!!   & 6"$G#4778$## #3#1!%# #477;#!A&""! 9$# !#!-!G$& " $!$#% &""! !$ $$!# #"#! %##$-&&% $"A%##  "#$$   #$  A  # " - &!%!$ #! !$ $ !KA #%$"#! %#9

489  37 1!%# # 477;  # G  ! A &  $ #  &""!       -# -  .  % $ !"!    "#$$  & %  $! $ &  N $ $  $# "#  #"#!$#   "#!$ "#!#9 4;9 # ## #  43 1!%# # 477;  !1#  1 #! A &""!   -& $ %###$& %  $!377Q3#K% #,7"$G# 477,A% ##$3&?8?1#9$#$%  ,:31#9 ( 1!%# #477;9

469 4? 477;$ #&""! 1#! # G! -& !$ $!J$N#J!!1 $!#E$"#!$"#!#9 "# $$$$$ J#"! $ $.H1 $!$$$$& " $!$#% A377Q36"$G#3?!G#4773A87Q6 3,K% #4774$A377Q(3?K% #4774-&"#$$  &#. %  $!!"!47K $477,9

4:9 5K 477; # G -!$$!# $#A#$A !1#9



 +

39 %,$G#477, 1 $=3(##!%  @$$#!% J# 3#K% #4778=#!#%#$  " $ $&$#!% J# !$! 1 F!  3# %#  477? $  3# K% # 477; R 477? 3677S@ $#'$   1 $ G# " $ !J "#!%H



2345624778  .;233.   "#1 =477?3;66@9+#"$!# " $% #-# $ &"" -  $ E$# $#N! A   (#  "#  "  -  #(J "" G $   % J#  $ O  1 $ K#  -$ !$# $$"# $= *34;3,; 9?G$#!1!#@9

I"("#!$ $ J#%#$"#!1# $ ! "#$$ #$ &""!#"$ G#"J #A $ %#"#!"$G#47749$$!-  1 $ !$# $  $ #! ! %$ I$#!  % J#   %  # $A#$ $E$#F !#J#& # $9#O $ !$!  1 ! "#  %   " $   ."#( $  $!  # %# $!# #3#K% #47789

49 I%#$#I$ "#!%AI#$96,93I$ $A IG#%$  I !  =+   $$ F  #   1!!#$"#!#$ K# "#NM$ 35:? "935D+ /T 0  /./ /   N$"1JN+0+ 35:,"93:4@9

,9  $ J"#$#&G J$ & $ $$ "#!%H%###"$  G#"J#$$"#$$ #$ % $#F.!"F$#$ 1 !"#KJ %#9

?9 @ F $#  &#$9 44 9 3 "# (# "N# *  "#$$   #$  - #$# J$"#$J! %#1#!$F#$9 34434,3?3$3?4  % 9+"# (# " $ !J #- &  !"F    $ 11  ! A  $ $$   "#!%H $ -&   "#!%H &$ #% N- !"F  # $ A   $ !   "#$$ #$ K $!"##!# J=#$934493 @9  #$   $   KJ "$ #1#  "#$J  &  !"F H ##$$$"#$ $=#$934, @9#%N#-& "#!%H $ #% "# &  !"F =MJ   #$# $  %  $!@  "#$J &$ $N -$ " " G ( # - $$  #$  "# 11$""# #$$"#!$$ A"#$$ #$ 9     & " G  $!  "#!#  "#$J   $! !- $G # =#$934? D *345??; 9893$#!1!#@9

G@ # 1  $#  " $  &  $! !- $G  A &  K $  %#$  &#$9 34?   KJ$   %# "$ "## # -& "#$    "#$$ #$ &!"F!G $## "$!# $  $!=#$944G 9 3      36 !G# 355, #   G# "J R*S@9  #   #-#  $$ 1  (###!&!"F!G $#&$$# G$  & #$  & " $ &$# "   !#$ 9 $$ " G  $! ""



2345624778  .6233.   $$1  -&   "#!%H &$ # #% "# &!"F !G $# = *345?:: 9,9893$,9894@9

@+&#$94493*#$9,A8 $"" G"#J  $#1#$"#$$ #$ - #$# J9 .  %$E$#  $ $#1!#! A & $ $$   "#!%H  &!"F G!!1   # =#$9 ,@  $  $"#!%H$#1#=#$9?@#O  $ " $"($"!=#$98@9

89 &"(K#&$#!1#"#! %#44$G#4774 "#!%H!$ $!KA#%"##" -&% $!$! # % $G!!1   $& .#$& %  $!9"## %$-  $ !   "#$$   #$   &F.!"F -  "$  # J % $ E$# $#1!#! #  "$   G# "J   #  KJ   %#     1 F!  N 11# :   " $ 1   KJ$   $! !- $G&#$934? 9

!1#F!$!KJ$ %#% #$4,&:8,1#9 %#  8%G# 4774 #  "$   G# "J %#$ "#  #9    #   & " $!  $#%  "#!$! "# &""!  !1##!!A*$  G#"J#  #$ $$   $$ -&   % $ "#!G$ %#!  F!$   KJ$ %#-&G$3,!G#47749

;9 H !$# # $&$#!1#"#! %# "#!%H!$ $!KA#%= *3,4?73 9494@9 $#$  $  1$ !$# # - &%#  # $ A  #$ & %  $!   "#!%H"#1 9&"#(&#$94; 9 3  " $    =#$9 45  @ &"" -$ "# J  A     # $ F "#$$  & %  $!9

+K# "#!J $#F"#$J% #"#!%H   #% &   "#!%H $ $ "#  $ 1 "#$ -9 #  #% &   "#!%H  1$ $#    & # $ #$ A  "#$$    "#!%H "#1  -  # " G  "#$J  % #  "#!%H A  G  "#$$  #% 9  #%&MJ#$# $# $A"#$$ & %  $! & K $ -  & K  $#% !  -  & K  !$! 11  ! A  "#!%H "#1 #O &$#'# $A"#$$ & $ $$   "#!%H "#$ #  "#$J  % #   "#!%H "#1   &$# K $   1%# = *   "G !  ,7 K% # 477?3527, 98#!! C+ +477?"9864@9

 #%N  #% 11$ % &   "#!%H #  "#$J  % #  "#!%H " G       $  "#$$  %#!  



2345624778  .:233.   % #A#G9$$ NH"$N( ""#$ $#KJ %#

1 F#  $$  &  $! !- $G  $$ "$  $ !!$ =+ 2*/ +U$#V+N J#N$3555 #$934?>,@9

$ (#"#!%H"#1 G J$ # F $#$ !$# $ %"#!J $#$## $A#$& %  $!%#$"# # "  #$ A#$EJ#F ("  #=J   1!!# A &""  & "#K$    #  "#!%H "#1  %   #% %$ $ %  $!  35 !G# 3568  356;  3?4 $ 477@9   $ #&#$94?93"#K$- ##"A&#$94;93   1!!#  -!-$$#!J$$ "#G$ ## !G$# $F"#$$ "#!%H"#1 $!G$# $ A  #$  &#. %  $!9  "   # G 1!!#  # H & $#"#!$#&#$94;93-#% FW  " $      1!!#  35 K  3585 # &#. %  $! =#$9 45  @ X "" G "# J  "# 1 F#     # $ A  #$   "#!%H"#1 %  -$&#$945 A&F &#$9?: 94 = * "G !41!%# #477;34?27? 9?9?94@9

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



2345624778  .5233.    &"( &   1 F! &%#$#  # $ A  #$  3# K% # 477, "# !    6 "$G# 4778  $ G  "#( &$#!  1#  "#!   %##$-&A$.A"#!%H&!$ $##%   -  # &""!  9  !- &$ A K$ $ $# -  !1#  % #!    4,&:8, 1#9 %#  8%G# 4774 #  "$ G#"J%#$"##9

69 %- "#!( % $$$#-&#%N&$A$#$- !1##!!#$ $$ "#$$ #$ %#!A& $ $$   G#"J#%#$&#$9,*"##% &#$944 93*#-$#1#$  $ #" $#KJ$F!$ #9

#$ "#!% $-#-I  $ $$ "#!%H$#1!#! "#$$ #$ A% $ $$ "#!%H$$# (#"#$$   $ E$##$ $!#O#$ $$ $! #"### " $  "#$$  I %  $!  "# #% %$ =#$9 , 9 4 *@9  &NH"$N( O  &H  "  #$ $$   "#$$  "# #% %$   "#$$  I %  $!  I  $ $$   "#!%H "%$ E$# #! $=#$9,9,*@9

"$  $#  "#!  -&!$$ ! -  $#1#$ & "#$    "#$$   #$  A  % $ $$   "#!%H . A % #   K $ %#!.#"#KJ$F!$ ##$ $$ "#$$   #$   $ E$# "#!!! &    1 $   KJ$ 1 F$  "#$J % # &   #!%     %$  #  11$ "$#  F %## % $$9""#$ $A&#! $  A & $ $$   "#!%H & $$#  "#!#   1 $    #!%    KJ$   %# =+ /  % # $   %# $ $ $$ "#!%H#!%H"#1  3555"95?3@9

&"($$!%$ $!&$"##! !" -&""!&!"!   1 $ KJ$ %# #!%   %$ #11$"$#  F %#9

L$$ ! -  !1# &!$ $ "  # $  #!# A & $ $$    G# "J   #  #$ $$    "#$$   #$    #! H #A%##A%A& $ $$  G#"J #$$4,&:8,1#9

:9 % $#$#N#-$  $!#E$#$ #9

$ (#"#!%H"#1  $ - $!#E$#$ # $  "#  !G $#  # A   11!#    $$  -  "#!% $ %$&$#!% J# &$# &#  =% # *3353,3@9# #A!1$ " $ #!J$ #$" -



2345624778  .37233.   $F& $!#E$#$ #$8Q=#$937?93 D3,7?3? *3353,8  9?338,6 9:@9#- $"#$$  G#"J & $!#E$ #$ # $ B A "#$ #  $ O  "#$$  % $ F J G $  -& $#"$   &#! #! #  $ ! # 1#!$ A &#$937494 D $"$! #-&%#$ $#!J #  $$ " $ =&## $ "#-& $ $$  "#!%H$% !$ "#N #""#$$#% @$    $  ! # -$  $ $ #  " $ = * 335  3,3  9?@9

 &"(  !1#  % #!    4,&:8, 1#9 %#  8%G# 4774 #  "$   G# "J %#$ "#  # "#(   *$    G# "J  #! $ + 9    3, !G# 4774 #    *$    G# "J   #    #$ $!  $$4,&57:1#9;8%#36!G#47749$$!-KJ$   %# $ $#!  1#  44 $G# 4774  F!$$  % #$  8 %G# 4774 #  "$   G# "J %#$ "#  #  !1#  " $ A $$ $  $$   $  ! # -$  $ $ #  " $  #$ - &F!$   $#1#$   "#$$    G# "J !$ $    F J G A $$ $9  !1  $ %  !1#  G$  #$ $$    "#$$    G# "J  3, !G# 4774 $  $#%"#!-$E $$ "$#  - &% $" F!$!  KJ$   %#9  !-  H      # A %## $!#E$#$ ##$#8Q(8%G#4774

59 %- "#!(G 1!# 9$#%!-% #$!1##!J $ !A"!###!$ # "#$$  -& %# A &""!  9  # G$$ J     $!3&7771#9 ##!A$ $#"#$  "$ A1#  $!"=#$9:5/9, @9



2345624778  .33233.  

  1 +0  +,*    * +

!

234 -- 5  6     7 8 #9$  :

  4 -

39 !##%G9

! 4

49 I$9

,9   *     )  ++ A %## A  *    ++  L +++#"$%#$ $$4,&:8,1#9" $!#E$A8Q& (8%G#47749

?9 !1#A%##A#  $!3I8771#9A $ $#!"9

89 1#  "#$    -I "%$ 1## ## $#  "#!$ ##E$   !   ,7 K# (  $ 1 $  "#(  # G 1!!# =+NZ V#N1- ;;77?  @"#% ##$ (## $ "G 1#!$F#$9:4 1!!## # G1!!#36 K  4778 = *@D  ! #  ##  $  -#    $ 1 $ H"#%$"#$# J$###$$ #D  $ E$# #!  # G 1!!# "# %  "$  "# %  !$# - F  $   &#$9 ?4  *9  "#!$ ##E$ $  " (  "   ##$ %-!H"#% %$E$#K $A&% 9 J#11 (#  "#! $         U# +  U   #!$ #.K# $C N  "" )  

" 1#"#!$##E$$$ 1 !F"#$   -IAI11 1!!# # "#J#11



2345624778