Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/347/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/347/2004 KI-generiert

Negligence and Liability in Traffic Collision

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/347/2004
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The litigant sought recovery for damages sustained in a collision involving a vehicle driven by the respondent, who contested liability by claiming the litigant's own negligence contributed to the accident. The court's reasoning, based on the evidence presented regarding the circumstances of the incident, concluded that the respondent was solely at fault for failing to maintain a proper lookout and adhere to traffic regulations, thereby rejecting the claim of comparative negligence and affirming the full liability of the respondent.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Negligence and Liability in Traffic Collision: The court's reasoning, based on the evidence presented regarding the circumstances of the incident, concluded that the respondent was solely at fault for failing to maintain a proper lookout and adhere to traffic regulations, thereby rejecting the claim of comparative negligence and affirming the full liability of the respondent.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Haftung bei Verkehrsunfällen Auffahrunfall Fahrerflucht Opfermitverantwortung Fahrradunfall Fahrlässig begangene Zuwiderhandlung

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

               &'()*&'+++ &,-*&(..-

##

 # "   "  #  "

% ',  (..- ,/  01  



2  34 5   2   * 3    !"#$%&'%()



+!

% 6666666666 ,-!-,.+ "/ -2 0 1 0"  



                 !"# $%

   "&3#"  

 2

%6 .+  7777777777  8,+ !-  +    +  )   !  9 !+%:+;!%#4$+< 9 =>?6 <!, -!- * @+ -!-> !&4A !%##4/<,, <! 2! , 2 +  ) 6

&6 <*,+B  -!- 22  - @     +*,! +     !,+2 + <")   ! ) )!   0--! + +*  B ! ,!+8 C!*!    !,+2 +    0--! + !, +* ",(0   .D%+;!%#4$ :%+!+E%##46

:6  ++", *!+! ! ++ 0   .;  !  ,+ !@<+!.+  7777777777-E !@<-9"

  /  +! E+!  @  - ) <!  -2!  E  ,(    ,+  +! ! + + ,B-  A  A ! +!+E +)*E ! -*E %##F    / ,+  *+   A)  @ +;! %##46  0   .  -9*! ;  -++9--,++!! ++! ! +!&A ! %##4!%$*%##56 !@<9*!, *!+)!-E !! - ,+-,-+!-!-,6+), !,- -!- -,+-  % )  %##$ !  +)    , *! +!+B-  ! @ <,!! +,0   .<,, *!,* !-F''26

G6 2  !,+.+  7777777777-!-,++-,A9*!  E,* ( !& 2-) %##$ ! / ! +,:% * %##$6  A9*!   E  ,* ( !  %# *  %##$  2  !-!-H!- !+!!! +-2!<! 26

F6  2  !  .+  7777777777  -!- ,++-  +) 2+   &# ,!*E%##$6  / ! ++ -!-++-%'+)*E%##$! - ,+,+! +2 8-%$-*E%##$6

46  % -*E %##$  0   .  ,+ !  -  FGIF#4 26 %' +,+!+;,++! ! + )-!A %##F !+;!%##46

56  !  &F A)  %###  - (  +! 2 -  -E !  -  +  -,! ++9@J!G&IGG:26F' ++", *! +! ! + , !  3 3 3   ,- +  A  A ! +!+E @ -*E%##FA) @+;!%##4+*,-*!A) @+!+E%##4!,,+! +!H-%##&@%##46

$6 + G2-) %###-E !<!+,,+-@!!-  +-9! ,+- 2+! )22 !,+ ,*!!,B*+!!

 3%&453%###   ":3#"   -*-!,)++ , ) -9 - -! *!!6,   -9- /  <-! !   !! +*!   , -9 9 9) /<  <) !,,B-+! ! +6

#6 + %52-) %###<22 ,+ !!2  ! )"+ ! ) -0   .-,H!<-!!++! +2  !< !-- 2 ! /  - -! ! *   :(*  ,+  +  FGIF#4 26 %' ! /< ) <-! !,-)  E,+- J +9,J 6

%'6 %%*%###0   ./  +  +!++ *! (<")  !) )!C ",( +  ++D * )-<+,,+ ! +2+*-,< !--@+G&IGG:26F'6

%%6 - !&4) %###-2  //2  !,++- ,A9*!&#,!*E%##$<!!+A+, / -6+!/ -  +   0   . ! ,-*!-   +) A9*! ) ! !) !+)8!-2!E ) !K!- )-6

 +!!, *+!!!, - ( + (/ *+!! -*- @ ! !  -,! +  +9  + ! , 9+E !+  2 ! !-K!/ -+!+ !<,(%'I%G426F'6

 -2 () + /  *    %# A  %##$  -  + <+!+        !    ! / !+! ,+- @ + +!-! !,!!/< J++ !,, *!6! */< *!  -,! +  +9  0   . ! )  !-*!   -  + + *K* /<  ,B ! -9 (*!  *+!! +)6  A %##$@) %###< !--) !-A@,B-FIF''26

2   ,+ !  +  !-  &5 A ! %##$  - !   E  ,* ( ! , /   *- /  2  ! ,+ + ! ,++-6  ,-  !   /K! /<  ) ! 8,+ !-  > ,! ,  ) 9!/,!@J ! (-22 <-! !-!- +- +! /<  ) ! ; ,,+!  2+ ,+, ,+ +!  + 8,+ !! + +!! ,+ ,B    ! /<@ 2  %##5  ) ! A!-  + ++E--2 )!* +F'I'''26/< ) !-!- +! !) < ) !,@2 28J9JB,+!J- 6

+!)!/<,B!,!,-<*+!!%&I'''26FF  -*+!-/< ) !2 !+,+ E,+,B,! !!6

%&6+ &&A) &''& +  +++-- %# 2-) &''&@0   .,+ 2 ,!+E)! +A! -,+-26

 3%&453%###   "G3#"   %:6 - !%%-*E&''&*+! !/+! + -,! ++9<-! !,,-*!-, /-!-A+ *K*   2  !  < !-- /< -! !  ,+ + <!  -2!  E - )- !8,+(")E8+!!!+")*!9   ! /,+ !<) !,-!-, ,++)  9 2 ! /-E !) !-!---2  !6 ,- /2  !-!-H!- !/<!-2!E  -!-- )- ) <B!-!-)- 8- ++/-:(*6

 +2 */-E !) !+  !-,, *! !@,+- ,-  ! - ++", *!+! ! + 3 3 !8  -  +! ! +   -9 *  +! + 2*      /  +! ! + ! 8  - ,+  ,-)+B +  +  +)! + +! )  !)   < + 9)+   + 6  +!  -2 ) ! </ !! J/ *+  ,(  <22   ,+ !  *+!! 2 8- ,  ,+(")E     + ! %I''' 26 +   <-! ! , 8-!-  ,+(")E +!!!  +")*!  9     ) ! -!- - )- @  * +!      @  8 (* ,+- ,-6  -E ! <!+/ !!--9*!,+*,!,!,-6

 *,- /<9*!) !-!-+))!-  + -,! ++9!/<+-/+*,!)-,-E ! )! !-  +) !-!-, +*,!6 )J B -  +*,!)-,< !--,(<)+ -  +&FA) %### + !  !+!  +  %'I:'' 26 FF +! %I#F' 26 %' +! -!- !! E- 8 +! ! +-9 *+! +2*  !8+! ! +,-)+B +  ! 8  - +  +)! + +! )  !)   < + 9)+   +  *+!! /  <-! ! ,    -,! +  +96

 *+!!  +9  ,-! +   * (  )!L %FIG$F 26 F' ,+  +! ! + " " M $I:4G 26 F' ,+  +! ! + JH*9M 5':26 &'  2  *  !! 2M 4I$&: 26 $F < !-K! *+!+ M %I&#4 26  2 ,+ !!G&'26!8+! +6

2 0   .()/< !--<!22! )*!/ !!-// *+!! +)!  ,! ,-  ,- +  A  @ -*E %##F   +!  %##5 *  /  +! ! +  !!  %##F ! %##4 + ! E  )!/-2- )! E--2 )!* +6

 3%&453%###   "F3#"  

 #

%6 + 9)+ <+9 ! +A   CD-!-*+ 2 -! ! !-(  % +;! &'':   E !+   + 6 +2+*-*! @ <! : -: ,+ ! +! !+  !+ !)!<!- ) 9+ !,!)! +  +!+++!-!- !*  <+22    E !+   +  !!!  ! /C26! F4D6+*,-!  E-!   -!E ,+A9<,(6

&6 + 2--,! 9--+ !+ 4+!+E &'''C D!!-) 9%A) &'':!N!*+ 2 ! + +*E ,+ ! +-9+* I +!!/  +I!6F& 6-+* ,+E  !-I*,+B!-9- * (,-! -/I,)!@I!6F& !!6$%!$& +! -!- E+9-6   I,( ! !+!2+  -9  ,   ,+ ! +  ) 9 A/I:%-*E&''&-9,  ,+/(9,, E +!   ) 9  *+*! +O  2 ! A  /*! -!* !  +! ,+ !C 0%&5G45+ 6%D6

:6 <!6 $%   C ) 9 A/< :% -*E &''&D -+  (9 ,!  ( 8/ ! +*   ,+-  -,! +  +96 I,(!! ,+ ! +  +*,! +- -,! +I +9 - , I*,+B  + ! +! 2  @  "   -  + +! /  ,! 2+* +,,+ ! +   !! A+ ,(     C6 % !&D6  +*,! +* ! !-  ++ !!! A+ -9*! ! + ,   -J-   + ! ,+!   )! I!+ !-  +  !+  / I*,+B  + +*   C6 :D C 0%&&45+ 6GD6

G6  /! + @ -+  ,-E  <,( !   )+     -E ! ) !   +   2  !  ) / !- ,+ )+   -  +  -,! +  +9 ! ,!! ,+ 2+* +,,+ ! + ,  -2   ,-!,+-6

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

46 K!,%##5,655+ 6:  E2--  + -- /  2  !  +! /  +  2  !  -2  <,(-! !))!!@/< ! *-) !-  + -,! +  +9 !  --*! /  + ! - *! K! ,   + -! + ,+ -  @ ! ! ,-E <  ) ! + / !- ,+ 2+* +,,+ ! + @  -  +  -,! +  +9 )+  ,+ -2 @  *  -,! +  +96 +  A , +/< -  !+)  2  ! <*  !! +   2  ! ! JE  !- @  ,-!  ,+-*! (< C 0 %#F%,6%#'+ 6%!-2-X   %#F% ,6 :GFD6     <JB,+!J( +O  -  + ,+!!   , *!  +! ! +  --  -!-  ,( <+)!   2  !  -E !" -E !<!,JE  !-@+!!!!-  +C %##:,6%$&+ 6%ED2 + !)! +*-   / ! +2  !6

56 +A ,! ! < ++  ) ,!2  <+EA!<! +-,! ++9<!6F& E  /<  B  ! ! !-  -E !  +! ! + !  ,+E  +9  2+*!   - ! !+! @ 2 !  22-! , /  - + +)!   2  !  <*,+B +  +! ! + -J !  /  ,-!! + -,! ++92+,+E  !-! /<!-2  @<!6F& C26 0%&:%4$+ 6:D

$6  --,! ++90   .8 ! !-A@*+*! <+)!8 (*2  !-E !&#,!*E%##$2  ! ,! *2  !6!!JB,+!J(-  +0   . -,! +  +9  ! ; K! +! 2 - @ <*  !! +   2  ! ! ,+ !   2  !   -E ! -! !     E  ,,!! @  *!<) !,/ !-,+)+  !-  +6

#6 +) !+-!* @/*+*!!---,! + +96 + I!6 F&   I*,+B /  !! +*! + , -9 9 9) I+E) ,  , ,! + !      +9 @     +*,! + ! ! @ -,! +6  *! (  +! ! + /  ,-!J*,I,, ! +,  ,!! ,+ ! +-9+9  ,+ ! +/ I*,+B  - , @ I  !+! + ,!     /I  ) @  *,+B- ! /  +! ! + +,+!  !+)! !- *! 2,,-  ,-*,! + + I!6 %4 6 %  M + +/ 

 3%&453%###   "53#"   +! ! + *! *,B-   +  I +)E  !-  I*,+B C 0%&%:$G+ 6:EE:$$+ 6:%%:&F5)6%%&%F5+ 6&D6   ,* ( -)! !-  +9 ! -,!- )  *+*!  I)(*!,-*,! +C 0%&:%&+ 6FE%%&%F5+ 6&%'$ %#G+ 6&!K! !-DM+*+*!+O+! ! + ,)!,K!,Y+,+-+  -9@I +)E  !-  -E ! C 0 %&:  %& + 6 FE %&%  :$G + 6 :EE %%:  &F4 %%&%F5+ 6&D6

%'6 +9) !(/I++ !*!!/+! ! +,)! ,K!+)-,+*+! 2A  /+*+! 22 !C 0%&4 GGG+ 6:%&%:$G+ 6:EE:$$+ 6:D6  2  !  +I *,+ E  !-,+ -,-+! ! +,+- +  +)*!+9E , !-,!-K!) A+   2  !M  A+   )  +9 */      --,! +C 0%&#%#:+ 6&6&M 0%&:%4 + 6FD!!@,! /+!- FI!6$&6% 

2    C2 ! +9ED6   +!  22! *!  !8!  <!6 F&     8   ,+ ! + -9*!  <,, ! + C!6 $% $& ! %:$  D / <8 ! < -  -,! +  +9 -, < -  +      +*,! + + < * 2!! +  )++!- /+/-*!<*  !! +< 6 !!+! 9 /  ,  22-*+*! -A/<@/  +! + !,2)+E!/!+@* 2+! ,+/<!JJC 0%&:%&+ 6FD6

%%6 <,(2  !-2-!-,++-&2-) %##$6 <!+ A+"@/+2+*-*!@A ,!--0   . -,! ++96

%&6  2 ! /  2  !  ! -!- ,   +  -2! <! 2 < , <     !       - *  *!   -!* ! +*+*!+ +9*+*!@,! /  -   ,-*,! + < - + @ +  ! /  !) !  (9 9--*+*!, +2  !C 0%&#%#:+ 6&6: 

2 D6

%:6  -!  , (  +  /  0   .  ,+ !   2  !  -2 ,++- , A9*!   E  ,* ( !  &#,!*E %##$   --  +! ! +    )-  , <*,+B* +,--,! ++9/) !,   *+*!A9*!2  !&2-) %##$6

%G6  *  ! + ; ,+   -  -,! +  +9 2  !-E !+)!&#,!*E%##$!+! 2 -  +

 3%&453%###   "$3#"   -,! +  +9  &F A)  %### @ <*  !! +   2  !  +*,-!! ,+  )+  ! +  -E ! /  ) ! ,  *+*!  <+)!2  !+ ! ,+E ,,!!@*6

%F6  +-/   E  - +!!   !-   -  +  &FA) %###+! 2 -@,+/ <) !,/ !-,+)+ ! A!!** )-<+,,+ ! +0   .6

 3%&453%###   "#3#"  

#  2 " # "   "  #  "

%

04   7  3   89 ')( "$

%6 +!! !--  +0   .&FA) %###6

&6 A!!** )-<+,,+ ! +%%*%###6

:6 2+*  ,!    /< ,)! 2+* + +!  ,-! K!   -   :' A+ (  +! 2 ! + , ,  +- -   E 2--   JV WJ+2/  4 4''G     !+  8*, 6  -   ,! K! ,++9-6  *-*+  + !L D  / 8!*!/-  ++!- +E!  !,-  + !!/-M ED 8,+ ,+ / *+! 2  ! * ,+)+  * !! ! -  +M D ,+!   9! +   + ,-!!6    *-*+   +! ! ,  !+  --*! -*-- + !! D ED ! D  "   E2--,+,!*! (+/<  )- )E6*-*+ +*! ++*+B  ,) /  +! A+ !    /  -  + !!/- ! <)+,,  /-!-8,- -+!C!6%:&%'4!%'$D6  922 (L  - !L    00 T  T             922 ("A !L !J         

+, +2+*,-!K!!+! 2 -8,!   /<@<22 2-- + ,922



 3%&453%###