Judicial Admission Sufficiency of Evidence Review Standard
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertA lower court incorrectly granted summary judgment against a party appealing a denial of relief for a judicial admission, based on an alleged failure to timely object to the admissibility of the admission, because the court applied the wrong standard for review; the appellate court determined that the failure to timely object to the evidence did not automatically waive the right to challenge the sufficiency of the evidence to support the judgment, which requires evidence that is probative and legally competent, rather than merely inadmissible.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Judicial Admission Sufficiency of Evidence Review Standard: A lower court incorrectly granted summary judgment against a party appealing a denial of relief for a judicial admission, based on an alleged failure to timely object to the admissibility of the admission, because the court applied the wrong standard for review; the appellate court determined that the failure to timely object to the evidence did not automatically waive the right to challenge the sufficiency of the evidence to support the judgment, which requires evidence that is probative and legally competent, rather than merely inadmissible.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertThe court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Volltext
#$%%$#&''( )#%$#&''*
)
! )! +)" !+ "+
+, - -. /0 &''*
!"!#
"#!
$ % & ! ! '(% )"# '*+'% &#&. '(*, -
!"
2 */0 2
1 )! .&&" *( 3& *,,+% & $ 4&2)!5 &6 &7"!. 89 &# & :!! &&#. 3"!&5! 5 '; 3&# *,,+% #&# 89 )":&# #!:&! ! 9 ": #&:&#. )#. < )&#. # < " .## #.=
9&#.!. 7"!. "))"&#&" '* 3&# *,,+=
9)!5 :"&! )!& "& 9 !))"!# .#>& )! $?)&#@ &:!&#&! 5: 4$6 A "B# *,,+ ! 9 )!".! % & % )! .&&" ! "))"&#&" '! ":>! *,,+% !" !"&# 9&#.!. < &&#. 3"!&5! +,C 5 '; 3&# *,,+=
9&#.!. &#!3#. !"! ( .>! *,,+% .D# E#! #"## &)> #!:&!= 89 )!.& )! &! :"&! !#&!. .&&" "#&7&. )! F A ":>! *,,+=
9&:&#. < .#!&!% & " )!&&)# < 9&!!:>&&#. !"! # >&&&!# < " !3#= 8 !&D# )!& )!5 "#% & 9:5! 77# 8 )& "## &# .&&" .#. !#&!. 0 ":>! *,,+=
+ 1 "& D:"& ! G"!D&#&" 3&&&! 46 .#. "&7&. # &#&#.% 5 '! "B# *,,1% !&> #" ! "&% ")". + 3D% "# )!.&# # :&2)!.&#% + )).# # '; 3D ! 4!#H ' #H ! # +; 6=
&# < G#&" G.#&" '; 3D !% )! !&> 7..! *I 3:&! *,,0 4 J '1, ',;6% ! "& D:"& ")#.% '1 7.:!&!% &)"&#&" #!&#"&! !D# )!### !&> #" ! "& &.D! ! < #!"& 3D #&#&!% % G### G.#&" ":@ 3D !=
"7"!.# < 9!#H +; H ' #H KH 0 % !&> #" ! "& "L# &# &8 "###&" )!.: < G!#H +; "& 7..! ! )!#& D..! !"&# ! "& ; "#">! *,,, #!. :&D! '! 3:&! *,,1 4 6% 8& "# !#&: < "& 7..! ! G!2& '( ! 'AA0 4 6=
").# )"! 3D! G)5 # && .#>&=
9@ #! 9!#H ;, % !"! "&# E#! .)". #!# 3"! &:# "#&7&#&" .&&" 3## < !"!=
/0110/*,,+
2 1/0 2
9 9)5% & # .#>& 8 .&&" ! "))"&#&" '! ":>! *,,+ .#. "#&7&. < 9&#.!. 0 ":>! *,,+% # " ) A% # 89.D. )! 9&#.!.=
.& #!# 3"! # && .K &K 0 .>! *,,+ 4!#H 1( H ' 6=
" #! # !)"!#. )!&! 3"! ":!> 8& &#% "&# & + .>! *,,+=
7"! ".8 # "##! 8 !"! &#!3#. ( .>! *,,+ # #!&7=
/0110/*,,+
2 0/0 2
+ ")2 )! +)" !+ "+
345 6 7 89 -*& ":
'H .! !"! &!!:> )"! #!&:#.H
*H &# 8 )!".! # D!#&#H
1H 7"! )!#& 8G ):# 7"!! !"! "#! )!.# !!E# .& 1, 3"! 5 "#&7&#&" )! )& !". !. !&> 7..! !% FKM&N!K"78& ;% ;,,0 % #!"& @)&!H .& )# E#! )!""D.H ."&! "&# O 6 &&8!
@## 8 .&&" !"!# .&! ">#&! & # ) .&&" ##8.= >6 @)"! )"! 8 "#&7 & #& )":"&! ! ## #! .&&"= 6 )"!#! &D#! " " !)!.##H F& ."&! "#&# ) #!"& ..# ..!. " ##! 6 >6 # 6 &2% !&> 7..! ! )"!! ) #!! #&5! ! !"! 8G& :! .!! &!!:>H ."&! !"! #&"! "! "P )!:% 8& !"# 3"&#% && 8 .&&" ##8. # G:")) 8 .#. @).&. !"!# 4!#H '1*% ',; # ',( 6H
D!77&5! !.&#
!&2"& Q "!& R
")& "7"! )!.# !!E# # "#&7&. @ )!#& && 8G< G77& 7..! #. )>&8 )! D!77
/0110/*,,+