Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/30/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/30/2007 KI-generiert

Taxpayer v. Assessing Authority: Property Assessment Methodology Dispute

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/30/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Teilweise gutgeheissen (Partially Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The case involves a dispute over the interpretation and application of statutory provisions regarding property assessments and associated penalties, specifically challenging the calculation methodology used by the assessing authority which resulted in significant tax liabilities and interest charges against the taxpayer. The court reasoned that the methodology employed by the authority—which included certain retrospective applications or interpretations of the relevant statute regarding valuation dates and adjustment factors—was inconsistent with the plain language of the law and prior judicial precedent, thus concluding that the assessment and resulting penalties levied were improperly calculated and affirming the lower court's finding that the assessment methodology was erroneous.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Taxpayer v. Assessing Authority: Property Assessment Methodology Dispute: The court reasoned that the methodology employed by the authority—which included certain retrospective applications or interpretations of the relevant statute regarding valuation dates and adjustment factors—was inconsistent with the plain language of the law and prior judicial precedent, thus concluding that the assessment and resulting penalties levied were improperly calculated and affirming the lower court's finding that the assessment methodology was erroneous.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Katasterschätzung Steuerjustizbehörde Steuerpflicht des Steuerpflichtigen Steuerverwaltung Bewertungsstichtag Festsetzung der Busse

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposes the costs of the federal procedure on the appellant.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



               "#$%&"'((& )"#("'(($

)

 ) * *)*  *  

+,  '

 -& . '(($ 

 !"#$%&'( )*+!#,)- "#" $)""#.$)""/)0

"# !"#$!%&1&   



)

2         3  ! "$>" "#$,4, 334    33 5 6   738332 95$$:: ;1!<1&&0 6

2    33  .33 ! *")): 3=!")):3=%%!%&%%   



             !

  &?;  

* / )

%4 A*#)"&;#&11(!%(B#C#D" D",#B) ,$  "- " "#  ! $  %E;(! )   !$%E;&!#$")"&%F)%E@'4

&4 3C>>&"A*#),$)$! D",#B)"$  ,)* , #)$ " - " ,$-+ ,> G ,  "#" ")  #*! )##) "$,$ ,B "  2        3 3  4

'4  A*#) " "- ) "- "$>)>  '1 A &11( )  $)$ )# ".>> D"$%E)D&11(,=$)",)*4

;4  D " $  )$ " "#"  # "  ))) " ,$-+  ") " '1 )D &11(! )  ),$  2           3  &@)D&11(,) "  ##G  #)) "  -  G ")  #*! ) )&%F)%E@')'1A&11(4

H4 3   "  2             3  "<-#D&11(!,))G,")#* ,"#")"%E1.%&;>4,))>>)",%E<H4

(4 3   " /)  0! " &@ -#D &11(!  "#"=$,>".C))"$,")AG.%E<H4

@4  "#) ) $)$ )# = ,)  ") " ; "$#D &11(4  A")"G$G.I"$>)".D-)".%;"$#D&11(! J))"D".-"-,$)$4,!"$%1 A-&11@$)$"$I"#","G D"$ "$"#,)"D,*4

<4 .D".DA)""$>=$!$)$*"$IA*4

*  )

%4 .)4&H">$"$D,*",$-+,>! -!--))-")$"%@"$#D%EE'729!)$-* %A-&111!B*,$"""-4GA)) ,"K",))")I,)*7)4%&&)%&' " -: 9! A*"""-#,$))".)4@'4%">$"$

    ?'@<(?&11( '?;  

,$-+ ,> " &H A %E<& 79! ) I B-  D )"",%F)&11'!")!,BG.>>  $)$)#7)4%;& 9!=$)".>>,)*D" $" $,))"$)#$,A*""-4

&4 3.)4&&27-)-*",%A-&1119! " "-!  ,)) " ) G ")  #* ) ,)*$ >#$#) =)4%&&!%&'!%;%)%;& 5)4'IH 2.,,G) ,*#))I)>$74%94CGA)!,))" )I,)*,"I">>$),))")!*#)$ " - " D ,* =)) $-)#)  ##) " "-! )  ,))")!*#)$"-"D,*=))$-)#) ##)""#*7>4)4&;294!A) I  ,)) " ) ) I .- " D ,* =))  ##) "   " #*  )$J) "  ##) " "- 7 2 %&<  &'15 2%&E;;;94

 K,B!  A* " ,#B )  "$  ,)* , #)$ " ,)) " ) G ")  #* ,  "#"4  ") ,)) )! "K ,)!  " #*!  &% F) %E@'! "K) ,)  '1 A&11(!")IGA*#)""-)"-=$)4

'4 3  "#) ,")!  ,)) G ,")  #* ,  "#")"%E1.%&;>4 !"#"")I=:$,#)) "EH.1(&>47%E1.%&;>4L&94

;4 >#$#) I  A,"! ",  A "$)#) ,  ,)* AG.##)")>)",))")""#!A) "-$D$$>")),))")I")$J)#,) #))":4 )$J))$)=###$*.)4%& ".",$-+,>-!--))-")$ " %< - %E<; 7 &9    )= $*#)!  : ) ,$

7 2,D$'(?1&"%<A)&11'94

H4  $##)   ,M!  ,$" $)) *)) 7)4 @' 4 &  ) <E64%",$""#))-"%&,)#D%E<H94



NNN



    ?'@<(?&11( ;?;  

  ) /  ) * *)*  *  



01232,, 4   52 2  2  6! -&' 7

%4 -)  2             3   I )>$! " #,) "   !  ## " EH.1(& >4 I  2       33   .3 3 ! * " )):3=! #,) #$ 6 <% 11 &' 1&'1 %1%% << @1 1  >- " "#  :3 !  G " )$J) #,)   " "$)!"B'1A&11(AG.##)")>)4

&4 K+"#))G"D4

'4 )G,$")*))4

;4 >#  ,) "  G. ,-) >#  )  ,$) J) "  "$ " '1 A "B  )>) , , ##"$ "$  D >$"$ " ! 3COPC>G (! (11;   !  ) =#,4  "$  ,) J) ,*$4  #$# ") L 9 "G =)#) G "$  ) "$ D)   ) , "  "$))G$5D9=,,G#)>)#,-"#")) )"$59,)*)",$))43#$#  )) ,  ) $$#) $#$$  )) 9 D9 ) 9 :"!  D>$"$",,)#)BG. "-"$-D4#$#"#)#+ " ,-! G ) A)!  G  "$ ))G$ ) .-,, " G$)$=,$"$)7)4%'&!%1()%1<94  *>>B  $")L             QR 0 D3 

,>#",$)J)))>$=,)GKIK>>>$"$ ",*>>

    ?'@<(?&11(