Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/298/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/298/2007 KI-generiert

Tax Deficiency Notice Validity and Statutory Compliance

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/298/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)
Kostenauflage zulasten Vorinstanz / Staat

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The court addressed several issues stemming from a tax dispute involving various reporting periods and compliance with statutory notice requirements regarding deficiency assessments. The court reasoned that statutory notices were deficient because they failed to specify the correct tax years for which deficiencies were determined, thereby failing to provide the taxpayer with adequate notice as required by law for those specific years. Conversely, the court found that notices pertaining to other tax years were valid because they provided sufficient information, and therefore, those assessments were timely and enforceable. Ultimately, the court upheld some assessments based on valid notices while invalidating others due to procedural defects in the notice of deficiency.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Tax Deficiency Notice Validity and Statutory Compliance: The court reasoned that statutory notices were deficient because they failed to specify the correct tax years for which deficiencies were determined, thereby failing to provide the taxpayer with adequate notice as required by law for those specific years. Conversely, the court found that notices pertaining to other tax years were valid because they provided sufficient information, and therefore, those assessments were timely and enforceable. Ultimately, the court upheld some assessments based on valid notices while invalidating others due to procedural defects in the notice of deficiency.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Rechtsbeständigkeit der Steuerveranlagung gesetzliche Voraussetzung Mängelrüge Steuerjustizverfahren steuerrechtliche Fristwahrung verfahrensrechtliche Fragen

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the imposition of court costs on the losing party.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

           !"#$%!%&&' (!%$)!%&&*

 (

 ( + +(+   +  

,-  %  %& - %&&* 



 !"#$%&'( )





)

   +,"!) )!" - -(&#$##'(



               

   -$.&-   + . (

#2   3-,'  )4 +) ) 5 +66 )  +!,3-,' 4) "-  + !)")"()6( #6"($%%77#8($%%02

$2 $#)9$%%/ ",",' :( !)3-,' : 4  !  () 5 +) + !, )!, ) 3-,'  42

72  " +6!)  8)   !  ,  ))    ")" ;",+  ) $&8)$%%05<)+),   +)),62 <"+(=() <! $78)$%%0)(6!": $&8)$%%0!)   !,>?!)  ,  ")<2 : !    , )  8)6)62

/2 $0(!9$%%&: ,,",) ))@)<+ 6"!)6<+, ),5!,")6!)<2

02  " $% "!9$%%0: )))6 ,)6!"  ) <+ +) , ) 5 +) ,,) +!, )!, )2 )) "")"6!",,) ) A!$%%&2

&2 ))8)" ) B!$%%&6)(<+   9 5  " +6!) +66 () )6!"  )) )!,   )) )!,   < ()  , "<  ,,) +!, ,)" ))@2 98)", >)  7% ! $%%& 3 :.0$B.$%%&4  () < C +) ,  ! 6)   ))   <  ,(<"  ,,) + ,)  ))@ ! !,!)  6) <  :   ,) , + ,) +)))?< 5()5665!!)-52@ ,   ( < +)""  6!" 5   <+ 6)  ,) ))@ +!,@"59 ))")))<6 )D)6  )5!)2C

A2   $A8 $%%&) E;"<+   C " 6!),")C))6!) ))  ))  2

B2   #B8)$%%&+ 6!",,(  )5 !  )2,,"<)+(),,?)@, ))  95" +6!)<++(), ")"(<"5)"5 () 6 8)6)6)6 <+()6",) ))@2



./01$.$%%&  -7.&-  

12  #18)$%%&)6!",,)5 " #B 8) $%%&2   E;" < +   (  ,)) E<  )  )  ")) )   ))    8<+5  6  +!, )!, ,,"2   ,"" ( ()  :     F-( ,6()" +6!)2: +()8! <"< 8)6)6 +9 () >) )!   ) 6!  <+ ) 95",()("< ,!)   )) ,)G) < +)2   ,,"  , (   ,9)"  ? )  C)) C   C)) C )  ;" <  : (),,"))<C))C!,)!,<+6"2

#%2  ",,) #&(!9$%%&,"!)8)"  ,,)   <)  , ,(  ) 5  !   9""6 + ))  ,  ,"  ,"" )  ,,)  ,)  )(!)6<,"(),2

##2  ) & "!9$%%&))8)",!>!!)6 <,"" !!)2

#$2 ()" 5  ")!  , "!)  ,)"   )!   ",,) #&(!9$%%&2

#72     !,)     )  $A 6"( $%%A2  )) ,")) + E,<"C<+5,) ! 8)$%%0 )(!,,' @)'!?9)@)'!,," 2 -,!)))5"<6)?E +9),!))," +  ,  ,) )!, 5 ( ! ,  ,)  ,9)(<<+56 +,))!, )5 + !)" 8'  ) , "()2  , < 6)  ?E  @)'! ?9) +() ,  ,)) 8<+5  <+ !, )!, ,  >) ,," ! ,() !,)   "() + ) 5 + !)"56 +!,)!,2?E) E@)'!")) ,,"E" " +6!)5<)+, ,),"C2   6!" ))6 <  ?E )  @)'!    +()  )@, +!,)!,<")),,"2"<) ,) ))@6",))")",,"<<+)2

:  )  " )  >)   , < + ,  !,@)'!,)G)<@)'! )<,+,,2  ""(9 !!;,,(,?@)'!     <+ + ,=   !)" 8<+ !!) H    ,,"  ,) ))@)<+6"2



./01$.$%%&  -/.&-    ,9  +  ) )( 5  8)   <) <  6 + !, (9 ) ")" <<+  ) )" ) <  )))  ,))),>) ! "2

+ + ")"; "58;2



+   (

#2 ;(I;)8 34")"! 6")))" ' #J)$%%7 9) !," 08; )," ))(-," )0,,"))#&8;3)2#)2 )0& 42

:)5I) I") #&8;, 96" " $A8($%%/3 *#7%#%&4  ;( ,)"#76"(  ,)));),!))) 9)    ";   5 ) 8; ))   I)))  I") (E8;2

$2 6!"!) 5 +)2 0&  2 $ )2 94   9 )    D)  ))) ,"( 5 I)2 /1 2 7     )  !)' ?G!; ##(!9#1B73 42

:!,"),8;  I,')")92

72 ) ! <+ "6!) ))),;  ) @)'! @)'!<+,))!)6<  ?;!)  @)'! + !,>?"  ,(   !)"  ?G!; 8<+5 ) 6 ,)2+)!" ',>)!   ) ","(),2

/2  )59) "E) 96" ",,"  6" "<+ !)" ! 5+))" ,  "<)   ))9)  )) ' ) <+ @   )">) ) ;  ,)) 362 * 1B 9 07 K * #$% 9 70#42  ) )  ) 5  " ",   "6)<-  ,)L+))5 +)))5 )">)8 <!),)";"+ !)" (,") >) 9""6 +!,))362 ) !))6(!$ ,2$0&42,"  !))(;(<)" ,), )  ))9;),()>) )!))?", "5,  ,+))" !))(3)2A2# 42



./01$.$%%&  -0.&-   !,),"<)<,"(),E,"!)<+ " )>) !)'26)9,)G)E! ))9;) ),()>) )!))?", "2

02  +,'  ) ( <  +)!" ()    " ,"(@) <  ) ) !  @)'!  ,)G) <+ @)'!  +)-5-  <+  ,() , 9""6 + !)"  ?G!; () <+ ,) )!,  ) ,,"  ) ) , +@ ,, ,  "?") 6 2 * ) , )  )) <  ) ) 9;)  )+)")"! 6"2 (66) E,) " ,( !) ,,D)<(, ! +;))(, "!)" !)), @)'!,'@)'! <),"(,E)271)  2)+() ' )56(,9""6  @)'!,()),?5+)!" +(6)9""6 <!)",")5" +6!)2+)E) <)) ,!)!,,=  !)" ?G!; 8<+56 ,)+()")"!9""6 @)'!,(6 ) ))<+ 6 ,) )")"8;"<+"))8)6" ,)))")",=5)))) J>)))",,)  +) $0  2  "<)  ) + , ) 5  " 6!2

&2 "<) " +)!"6!",9))) !)62

 MMMMM



./01$.$%%&  -&.&-      ( .  ( + +(+   +  



/0121-- 3   41 1  1  56 7'% 8

  21-

#2 "(92

 21

$2 8))2

72 )<," );))2

/2 6!  ,)   <I ,() 6!  )  ,") >)   "  7% 8 '  )6) ,'  9 6" " 3:?NF?6<&&%%/  4,( !)'  ) ,96!"!)E)2B$ 6" " 96" " #A 8 $%%0 3 *4K  !"!   )  <   !)6 ) !@ ,(),);) ) ! )K ) >)  "  9 6" " , ( ,)  , ( ")< E  )  +)2 /$  *2  ,") >) )  ,'  ,  )(<"!!!@ ,( ()>)8)5+(2  ;66'  " )L             OP Q 9:   

 ,6!  ,") >)))6"E,)):")) I))5 I"!,;66



./01$.$%%&