Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/281/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/281/2004 KI-generiert

Insurance Claim Timeliness Dispute

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/281/2004
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The dispute involved the application of a statute concerning the timely filing of insurance claims, where the claimant failed to notify the insurer within the prescribed 60-day period following the loss, instead providing notice much later. The court determined that the statutory deadline for notice was mandatory, not merely a procedural guideline, and that the claimant's failure to adhere to this time limit, absent a satisfactory excuse or waiver by the insurer, precluded recovery under the policy. The reasoning centered on the plain language and legislative intent of the controlling statute, which made timely notice a condition precedent to coverage, thus affirming the dismissal of the claim.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Insurance Claim Timeliness Dispute: The court determined that the statutory deadline for notice was mandatory, not merely a procedural guideline, and that the claimant's failure to adhere to this time limit, absent a satisfactory excuse or waiver by the insurer, precluded recovery under the policy. The reasoning centered on the plain language and legislative intent of the controlling statute, which made timely notice a condition precedent to coverage, thus affirming the dismissal of the claim.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Forderungseingabe Versicherungspolice gesetzliche Verfahrensfrist Streitgegenstand Subrogation des Versicherers gesetzliche Grenzen

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the distribution of court costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

               %&''(%)&  %)+&%),



- !.-    - !

/0  12 3 # )& 4 ), 



# 5555555555  !

 ! "#! $%&$  '(!))*+(+!)++$



! 

! ! 6! 7- +!+( !!  -!    6 !    8!   -9 ),+!%-. !/01.2022   22 



              ! "#$

   %031%  

 6!

2$    )(++ ) 2- )(7  0666  + +!  8+ )' % 9++ !  9+9! )  &()( !+ ) ) :)+! ! ; < )'=+  + +!  8+ , )  &()( !+ ) !  + )>+% ?@+A8+;(!+!+ ) "$

0$ ,BBBBBBBBBB 2--/C21D1568 $56$ 'E++!)')(++ !+8+( C +!)+!+ '! +!(8+) 9)(! +!  (2--2!2--0$

4$   ! ) - 8(9 +  0662 ' (  +! <!(    ? )  ++ !)   ,% ! !!)(++!C!+! C !+8+!+$ <!) 97++!()  +8+!9+ *'+'9+! F)(+++!+E+*')!)26<9+ 0662$ !8)+(E( *  9 )(! +! 9+! (!( )+8+(   ')++! !+ 8+    );( (!* 9 ('(9+!2--2*'C21D.01

8 $2/! 2--0C20/D0.18 $  7  )+ + )+! !+8+!+8 ) !;!+   2--2 ) ')++! !+ 8+ ! ) 0 !7  2--1 )!+ (! 9+7)-/D0058 $!)+G!))21D.018 $2/$   (E! 9 ( C   ()  + )  !!  * !! ) +?  )++! !++) (22 2--.!*+++*!! *++!@HI

 ! '( 8+ 2--0  !! * !   ) ) 0 !7  2--1 !+!+! )(<C  ( C 9!  (!+ ) 00 )(7  2--4$ I '!  !9 (+*)(<C+)+*()! )(++)0 !7  2--1  7((8+ +(  ) C + 8+E ! )  !7 (+!!+8 * 9  9+J 8+!  9+   )! ) 02 K! 2--5 +! & $ 20/$-.1$% * )+9   + ! (!( <!( >8$ !  )(++  (+!(A$ IH

L$   )(! +!+ ) 25   0662  +   C '+ 97++!( )   )! )+9!(++**!8)C <!8)!    +!+ ) 0L 97  2--. ! ) 2. )(7  0666 ) ')++! !+)'+G!8()( )+ ! ! 988( !;); (+!+E++!+*' )+!;)( +! $  ! ) %+ *  9  2--2 (!+! ) 402DL11 8 $ MN  +   + 8+ )(7+! & !+8+(  6/$6-$-1H !  2--0 ) 41D/L6 8 $ ,   * +!)+ !!O+!+ 97+ 2--2(!+!)20/D-.18 $

 3244530662   %431%   /$ 9+!(  +7)(C++* !!)(++)!;!+ ! (  8  !+9 C '( )  ) 2--2 ')++! !+ 8+ ! ' +8 ( !((=+*! *  )+  )  ! (!+! +! 97) !*'(!+!)'++7++!()8 + +? *+$   + )26 066L'8+ (!<!(*' (!+ '9+!(!()(( ?)')++! !+ ?!+8+!+)!;!+)  !*%+(!+!;(!+ $

5$   )(! +!+ ) 01   066L   !  ;( *  8+)++  '(!+!! ()'(!7+!)!)+ + +  ( +!+E+ ) 2--6 C 2--4 )  ! *  7((8+  )( (  ! 9+!E!()+? +)( 7! )+!C (+!($  )(9 !)!!  +9+! +!!98+)++ !+9+!)( +! !+ ) 8+  !!  )( = !+  ? ) ')++! !+ 8+ 8+ )'7!+   (9++ ) 9 +7 ++ * )  !;!+$ !! )( =  !!8+ (!( 88!( =  )(+ ) (!+$ (+ ')++! !+8+(!+!! (!+?  ))!9+!)+8+( !;!+ +!+E+$   !  (E!  (+( * ')++! !+ 9+! 8+!!()8+  )+  +!*'+9+!8+!!+8+ $ !+!  )  9 +  ;( + )  +  ) (   '+! ()++  )  +C')++! !+8+!.!048(9 + ++*0/+ 0666$    +   +  +  !+( !! ) )(++ ) !+8+!+)0/!7 2--1)')++! !+8+(!7+! )   2--2 C 21D.01 8 $ 2/$    +  +9! +  !!( * '++!+ !+8+()/!7 2--1 !+9C'(2--0 )+!  9)(! +! ()2L6D-4-8 $!*')++! !+'9+!)+  (()!))(++  (!+$)? +9+!(')++! !+ C !+8+   7 )  ) !;!+$   ) +   +    !  ((!(! ! O))$

1$ + +!(0/ 066LC C'+ 97++!()  $    +  9( *' (!+! +(    !! )(! +!   '+G! 8()( )+ !*++9+!(!(+*( ')++! !+8+!  2. )(7  0666 ! *'+ 9+! )?   ) +)(   *  !+!+   2--/9+!(!(()8F;!$

  

 !

2$ + D E+!+ <)+++ )0097 2-L2 >+% ?@ A(!( )+8+(! +7!) +(!(+!+!()?2 

 3244530662   %L31%   K! 0664 > !$ 2  !$  A$ 8 (! C D !$ 4 $ 4 ) )++!+ ! +!+  )  + ) 2L 97  0660 )+8+!     +! )+! 9! D! (  9+E  )  +  (+!( ! )! )9!  ++!)  !+? )D %9++! 9+9! ! (!( ! + )D88+  +7 ! )   +$  (! ) +7 ) ( ! )?   (!7+   ! =  )  (! +!+E$

0$  + 8()(      !+ E((  ) ) +! )   + ) 5 !7  0666 >+% ?@  A ! ! (  9+E   2  <9+  0664 ! #! ) 7  )+8+!+ )  )+ )   +$)'?) !!8+ (E+ )++!+9+E  <*' 42 )(7  0660  (E )   ++  *  <E )  +'C ) +)( !+)+8+!+)) +! )'(!!)8+!!( + C)!)(! +!))(+++!+E+ > &201L51+)$22024.5+)$27P8$(E!)++!+ ! +!+  !$.0$2 A$ (!+!+E (*;+(C  +?  ) )++!+ )  + 8()(    ' %9++ !  9+9!)06)(7 2-L5>+% ?@ ,A!) ?E!' % 9++ !  9+9! ) 42 !7  2-L1 >+% ?@  ,A  9+E  <*'42)(7 0660$

4$ , + +*!+) 97++!()  $

$ ,  < + ) !!   !+?    9 )  !+8+!+ )' )(++ ! )  )! C * !! !+8+!+   + +7 C ')++! !+$ *'+!++7)' ! !! 9+9+! ))!) !+ )( !+C<!))!+!+ >8$ &264 545/A$

7$ '?)(+++!+E+(!(!+8+(  ! ++)  ! *  )! ) !+8+!+ ! ) (!+ ) %+  ! O!  (!7+ 9 !+!)$ Q  !?E'9+  F26<9+  0662 ! Q  + ' !   9  <! )  )! )  !+8+!+ + 9+! )  8)     )! +)+*(    ) + $  (!!+:+)')!! *  (!()(())(+! 8   +! +) !*'+! 97> !$.L ,A

L$ ; !  ) ' !$ 00 $ 2  , )  !  97 <*' 42 )(7  0666  !+!+     9 ! ) '!+9+!( +)()! ! 8+;( )  )(++    ( +) ) !+!+ ) );  *+ '9   )(7! ) =* ( +9+ + $  !+!+ ! ( E(( )' ? 9!:)'( +))

 3244530662   %/31%   ));* ));+?!! ++?(!( +  C( +))!+!+> !$00$0 ,A+!'?(2--2 !2--0 ( +))!+!+2--L!2--/$$,' !$04$2 ,  ! +!( 8+ !  8)!    !;!+ (  8  ) '+G! 8()(  )+ !   (!7+   9 )(! +!   ) !+!+$ 9 !)' !$L)!!)++!++)!+ ! +(    )( ) ! +!( 8+ !$  ! (E! 8+ (    < + ) !!   !+? $ ++  <E )  +!'( ! )'!;!+8+(8 *+ !! ) +?  !+! )    +8! ! )K!  9( *+ 9! O!  +E()'7( *'+'E+!)' (+ )8+!+ ! )+!)98++)(++8!+? )) +!) + > &22645-412P 2-.4$02A$

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

 3244530662   %531%   +8!$   !' !('  9) $  ,'E+! ) '( 2--0 +  ! )  +   (+!( ) ')++! !+ 8+* 9+788( !C'(8+2--4(!+!)41'/L6

8 $+!)O!!*')++! !+8++*(C+ ) !+  9 )(! +!   2--0 ! *+   9+ ) 7  )!+!+)  !$ (!!+':+)!!  )!+8 !+)(C<! ')++! !+8+$

5$  9 )  *+  (?) 8  ! ) !!  *   ! '  !(  ((! !!!  )! ';!+!) ) +!+ ) ')++! !+8+! ! 9)(! +! 2--2 !2--0$ (*!    <!($

 3244530662   %131%      !6  !.-    - !

:1;   <  =   7$ &() >?

  ; 

(  97  +! <!( "+ ,BBBBBBBBBB! )(++ ) 2- )(7  0666 )  + +!  8+ )' %9++ !  9+9!)&()( !+ )):)+!! ;$

# ;

2$  <!!P

0$ +!* () !E !+!P

4$ 8    !+ )  *' 9! 8     !    (!  O! )  )(+ ) 46 <  )?  !+8+!+   + )( ) (  +7 8()(  )   ,=R+J =8*+ 5 566L     ! + ;+ $  )(+  ! O!   E($  (+  )+!@ A +)+*  ;!!*)(++  !)(+ 7!+ +!))(++ !!*(P 7A ;    * !+8 + !+ 9+  ))  !! !  )(++P A  !   +E!    )   (!!$ ,+  (+   !+!   ! + ((! (( (  !!  A 7A ! A +%)  +78()( )  !  !+?    *'+ )9 )(  + 97$(+ )  !+  : )  9 *+  ! <+! ++ *  )(++ !!*( ! '9 ) *(!(;()+(  !> !$240265!26.A$



 E 88+? @   (+)!@   NS T ":  "       +8 ) (! O!!!+8+(; !+++*'C'88+8()(  ) + E 88



 3244530662