Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/276/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/276/2004 KI-generiert

Challenge to Monetary Obligations Based on Alleged Procedural Defects in Legislative Act

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/276/2004
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Teilweise gutgeheissen (Partially Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The petitioner challenged the imposition of certain monetary obligations, arguing that the underlying legislative acts were unconstitutional due to procedural deficiencies in their enactment, specifically citing failures in proper publishing and notification requirements, and asserting that the statutory time limits for appeal had not yet begun to run. The court reasoned that the requirements for the official publication and certification of the acts were satisfied, and thus the legislative acts were properly promulgated and in effect, meaning the appeal period commenced upon that official promulgation, leading to the dismissal of the petition as untimely.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Challenge to Monetary Obligations Based on Alleged Procedural Defects in Legislative Act: The court reasoned that the requirements for the official publication and certification of the acts were satisfied, and thus the legislative acts were properly promulgated and in effect, meaning the appeal period commenced upon that official promulgation, leading to the dismissal of the petition as untimely.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Verfahrenshandlungen Verfahrensmangel gesetzliche Voraussetzung Einrede der Verfassungswidrigkeit Pflichten des Beamten Anfechtbare Handlungen

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Art. 64 LTF

The court ruled on the request for legal aid.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

               $%&'($)((*  $)+,$)((-



. !.    . !

-/  01 2  )% 3 )((- 



4 5666666666  ! "# "$   %& ''("&" '""



 

77!     8$ ' )* " "& +,$  -./+$010023-



            ! "#

   #1407#  

 7!

08 !"9:::::::::$&;"06+7$"& 2' "< ;'%)" ;$ '%"=" &'"$    >&&<" '% '"#  '%"3"'" & '" " &8 %&  '&&  '' '   " 2 ' %<<"  '?=&@"#2%  A' '153> 066+@<8"20  A8

18 6<&3"1770$%   "<"&0.'&""B%&$  >&&<" '   " & "     <&'& B   ' 0 ;3" 066/8%  "<&%&(%"3"  ="  "$3' C'%"3"'" &$'+7D ('20 >1770" '' "'& "  =" "" (  & "  &" "   "  B <" " &'="8 $  "'""" 'E86.58# "@<8"2F,  A8

.8  '&"" ' +  > 1770$ %    "   '    '   " & " '2  "  $      '% =" '% "3" &   " ' %& ' %&$ !' 9:::::::::$ B )  ' E8..G/-78#8   '3$%&3" >&&<"" '   " & " <&'&    3H"   '   " & " B'E810-8#"$>"'' %'"  'E8/G,558#@<8"2F+  A8

,8 "'.0 >1770$%&<&" "  '&""$    ="  " %  8&(<" 8<<"  '% =3 )'"   "" ( ' " '%&""   (%" 3"  >" '%3"1,)1,8& " 2  '&'   '  3" ( "'"$ "' (%" I"  ""  '  28   '"    "<"  &'" & >"   '  :::::::::$     ' > H)" "( & &  8 '"   "  <8   $ ' >"<" " ?)'%"  & &'&8

+8 %    (" ' "=  ' % $     ( "" '% "  "   ' % $ '  " & "  ( 8 3"   '"  B   ""  ''=&H8""(" B'' ' &3""$ %    B %&  '=& '%"3"'" & ' 077D '2  03>17708

-8 '&""" "'1+177.$%  " '&""'+  > 1770$   "< ( %"' '  3"  >"  <" ' %" &&   " '""'3"$""(3"'3"   *  & C"3    ='  "   &J   "' '3"  *   & &=   %& "#*$  '%    (%"  & &

  405674177.  #.407#    "3"' B 077D 3 <<  &  "<  0 3> 1770   (%3  " % C&   "3" &  "3  (  '=& '%"3"'" && " '+7D8%  "'&& (C"   KL#'$   " ' %"'   '  3"  '  8 3"  >"3" * &M$?=&'10$("3"3" B'""8

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

58   &3" ' 0/ ;" 177.$ %      ;  ' $  "= ("= "$<"'  %  ' >2       " '  &   '  &8  & "  '%    '%   '%  " &&)"( ' 0/ ;"  066-    > "'%  &'" "  $( 8" *   "  2  3"    "$ (%  '  B  & ' "   ( %&>3"("%"'&'(%" "  "" "  8 %   23 ( %& %"'"(   " (" %*)" $ "3"' B 077D$ '   & ' %"'    3"&" &&'<"B'""8%  " B "'& ( %& ' %& '3"  *    '%C   "3" &  "3$H 3=" "<""8

68 "'05;" 177.$%&  %&" "'%   ("<' '%  " &&)"('  '' <"'  ' &" &'%"' '%"  &&B

  405674177.  #,407#    <"8  "'2 (%"  & & & >" B  "< " ' '"  ( 8   >" "& "<'3"   ( 3"<"2''        " "  "8 %   $ "#* &   "3"' B 077D$" &"& C "3" & 3"B "  '" '"B&"'%'<"8

078 %  " &'"8

008 ''%"  "'$ ">'&$( & & " '%<<" '2  0 P  177.$  "" & %  ' '"  ' %& 3(& "'"' "8%&  C& (  &   "3&  N"  0660$ 3  (  <   "$ (% & "   < "    "   "(    <I"8<" 8$&06//$  >&=3 '(%"3" 1    '"   '"  "   8   C"(& ( & "   &('=3'"'   " <" '&"  "" =3"'%&""& & 88C& '&"   %=""   3" <"" 3  <" "3"'$ ?=& ' 1- $    '&' 8

018 %  %  &B; "8$<"  " ""( '"3 &=& '  "   "$    ( ' >"$ '   "  '" "#28







 !

08 "<&'& "=&&''" '"'- > 1777 @ A    &  3"=  0 ;3" 177.8  '"" " %"(  C   " 3&      3  ' )"  0$ B " (  " <&'&     " & " B % 3""$ 3"3    "3"'" & ' 06  06-+ %H '&= C&  @<8  8 0 80   # N 5.08.7A8   '%2   &" &="   '"" "  3"= ;(% .0 '&> 1771$  &='  ""  (  2= ">     3"=    O  <"  ;"'"(  '& "     '"  @<8 E 01/  ,-/ "'8 0A$  &3 ' 2= ' &' ("   "&'"   ">8  '"" " &=  "    '2  " & '    3"= ;(%.0'&>17718

  405674177.  #+407#  

18 "=3"%=" ";'"""'113>06,0& &'"<"&  "'0,3>1771  "> '" & & " " &$ '2  0 P  177.8 <&  B % " . "& . ' '"" " " "$   " '"  3  % &  3"= '  & " ' '3  "" ' "2'   "& "<&'&    & & "'%<<"  "> '"$   " "($        "   "2 '   " & " B % N4  @<8  8+- A8& ' ">'& ""& >" ;=''%28

.8 %" && (" % " &&   '&""  & " ' %     <  $  &"    '  .7 ; (" "3    "<" " '  '&""  & "$ 2 ' % " & &   @ 8 6 '  "     " <&'& & " B % 3""   3"3    B %"3"'" &$'0, >06-+Q E/07R 8,.'"   "   & " B % 3""   3"3    B %"3"'" &'1+ >06-5Q /0+R 8/'"<&'&   "& "B%3""$3"3  "3"'" & ' 06  06-+ #  A8  ; & '  '&"   < "    "$   3>8

,8 %>; '" "=" B'& "%"3" '' =" )H )& "(%&'  $&)& $B'(   8

+8 N % " 1 "& 1  8   $  & = ("    '""    &"')>" N"'"3 >&&<""'  "& " * " ( " "%" )>" &N"' '"C &&' "&'"  ' B "'("''   " & " %" '" B $B ""  B  "'" & ;"2 ' % "3"'" &8  >&&<""  '   " & " "  '&  @ 8 .>  A   &" C 3 '& "  @ 8 .  A8     '    " & "  ' B    ' '&  (" C2'   3 '& " @ 8.80 A8

-8 <&  B % " . "& 0  8 =  $  3 '& "          ' <  '   H  '"  %  '""8   '"" "      "> (%  &   >"= " ;"'"( B ' &&  ' < $    & ' B  " && '3 '< <"3"'" ' $3" B 3" &'="(%" C"='%

  405674177.  #-407#   (%C "3" & "3@ E01017+"'8,$00/156"'8 1A8

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

58 " &= $'<"C "'3)H )& "($' " ' <"  (  " '%  "3" &  "3 C"=  &"' '%'  "$   (%2=>'3"<"$"" &= " )& ' %" S   "> B  " '%  " ?=8  "" &3 "2'%  "2'"3 " " RB &='$ ;"''%"'%"'" ''"3 " '"" (%#'B '  ( #"("2 &$  <  3"   2= =&&3"%C"=">"" &'%" "'% &" " "2 '>'3"<"@ E00+00"'8+$ 00,  00 "'8 />A8   ;"'    "" '% " &   3 '"  ' '"3  &  3"=  0 ;3" 1777$ "  %  (%

  405674177.  #/407#   3 '""' ='&3H'&"&3% "011 $  &&3 " '  ""  '%?= #"'"(&   '&"  "= '   @N 4E">=)$9 TN)"'=) $UV")0666$15 '  8 01+ RN)KT$ 9  '  8 01+ $ " =>' N)KT$ N)"'=) $?1777$-.A8% "0,  '%)H )2 (% B3"<"'<< " '&<'>  * (%    ' "(  $ "      "" Q &'" &(Q''C "'  C"' "&B3  '>"3" C 8 '""Q("23    ''" ' (''" "3"Q "'"(%"%=" '%C"$B "2'% $" '( '" Q< "'  ?= Q '%C"= ' %& '% (&  '   " & " (%%C"'% "3" & "38

68 N $% "+ &3" &= (3'& "  '       2     3  ' %C"'% "3" & "3 ' H '" % '"" @ 8+80 8 ; A8" '%=")H )& "(" 3"  <& C'"" "<&'&3"=8

078 %2$%   =")H )& "('%&'E8..G/-78#'2  0  > 1770 @<8 "2 F +   A8  %&( '  '&"" '$ %&' & " ?=&',58   &(%"  "3)H )& "(&$'2(<" 8$&1+ P 06//$<<'%=3)'" ""('"'%&"" (  &   '  & &"   3"   8   $  <"  >" '%"'  '3"( "'" " &"& &   &8      "  ' 3 ' %  $  (  & "   3"  "    KL#'   (%    "  %' 8'  #B82=('O& 3"   <" ' "2    '     "$ " " "  ""> '% 3" '  '%)H )& "( "   ' &"  B  '"" "8(<" >&&<"'% ""   '%#"3"'" & ("#* "3"'B077D8

008 %" "&<' '%  " &&)"('0/;" 066-  > "'%<<"   &'" "  $' "& ( 8 " *  "23"  " (%"> 3" (" %"'&' (% " "  " "   "  8 %    ""( $"3"'B077D$" &' %"'    3" &" &   & '  <" B '""R ""$ %& '   '3"  *    '%C   "3" &  "3$ H 3=" "<""8

  405674177.  #5407#  

018  '  '" '  " $     C& (  & "3&N"0660$3< "8   < "  "( <I"8N<" 8  >&=3  ' (%" 3"  'C    '"R '" $ "       ' "( "=8''&'"  ;  " ' =3 " '%&""$ B  "  '( "     H& ';>' 'C ";  (('"C;B% 8 N&%'<"$'"(%" >&>&8'" *    3"$; " $"< %"'B3* "$<" " $ "  '  "" " "3  "    '"" '  3"8    * =" &$ ""2 " O"&3"  " ( <"8<   ''""    3"8C("#* 3" B%'<"<" &$"''$  <<&= '%&  '&"<8  $&  ' &% ==3& (%" 3  "  <"  '% ) 8 %   $ 8 %    '%* "'&'% (2$" "3(%"" ="<8

0.8  & '"2''"(<"'   " '%&"" H =' $ (%" << '%  '   ; B <' '"   "  <8>"'%"'&="2 "  '% " "(    '""'3"$""('%3"  @<8''  ( "" '% "  "   ' % $ ' 01 ;" 066-$ "2 C F07  A8 :::::::::&"&1- >1770( 8& ' > H)" "( &32 '"   "  <$ ' B  &) )"8   "    2   '&'       " '"  *  3"& 1,)41,$ 3" ("   &   2 @<8 C "2 .  A8 <"$ %&   '  & '   %  ==3&R " %  >& B %&" B<C3  &" $"3 "<" )'"&("<"" )  "<<&= '%&  '&"<$" ("& &"3"'B077D@<8 '::::::::::' 1,;"1771 ' ::::::::::'11 >1771$<.$'"  A8

0,8 %$ ">'&  (%&' $?=&'  ' ,5  B %&( '  '&"" " "="$ % ;" C& '% "3" &  "3$(" 'H!&'"'""3&N"  06608  %   "2  & B %&' " ' <      ""2  B  ' 8$ &32  )'"& '" %?= ' 'C    '"8  &=' B  =3" & ' )'" ( &  8$ ;'%)" ;$ B %" '" '")=('" %&8#C& ' <I'& "&'%'"' "#$<" (   "#*"3"'B077D$ ">'&"'2('  '%2$   "  C"= ' %& '   (%    "3" &  "38   '" "$ %  B  ( %       ="

  405674177.  #6407#   )H )& "( ' ..G/-7 <8     &( '"     3H&B%  <"(%"''3'&""$ " '% 3)H )& "('%&8

0+8  3)H )& "(  $" 00G1+.<8("<"="  '  '&"" " "="$  "> ' & 23 ( %" "& $  '&"" >&( $ &    "  "   ' %"3"'" & ' '077D8

  405674177.  #07407#  

   !7  !.    . !

 0494   :  ;44 4  <# %,) 

  94 

08 &3>R

 94

18 %'  '&""'+ >1770R

.8 3"B%  3'&""''"'& R

,8       ' 1G777 <8 B "  '  "" " B  <"   '&R

+8 "  (   ("  "  C   " & " <&'&$   " 3  <     &  *  '  '&" ' .7 ; '2   "<" "  " '& '&  "> <&'& ' $ N)K"T)<("-$-77,   $  "C"8 &"'" JA "'"(C  ('&"" '&"> "" ' '&""  (&R >A C  (  "<     " 3" ''     '&""R A    "=  '    '  &  8N"&" "  "&& &&&  A >A   A "#'$  "> <&'& '         "2    (%" '3 '& "3>8  &" '   "H'3$(" ;" &"%"%="  ' "2  " '  8 N  &=  ;"   &"  '&""  (&   %3 ' (   & & C&'"&    @ 80.107- 075A8

 =<<"J  &"' J     W"'  !  "   

"<'& *   "<"&C """(%B%<<"<&'& '"=<<

  405674177.