Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/268/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/268/2006 KI-generiert

Property Owner Development Permit Street Widening Exaction

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/268/2006
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The dispute involved whether a property owner, seeking to develop land, was required to dedicate a portion of it for public street widening as a condition for receiving a development permit under existing municipal regulations. The court reasoned that the dedication requirement, imposed without a specific determination of the public need directly attributable to the proposed development's impact, constituted an unconstitutional exaction lacking the requisite nexus and proportionality to the development, effectively amounting to a taking of property without just compensation.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Owner Development Permit Street Widening Exaction: The court reasoned that the dedication requirement, imposed without a specific determination of the public need directly attributable to the proposed development's impact, constituted an unconstitutional exaction lacking the requisite nexus and proportionality to the development, effectively amounting to a taking of property without just compensation.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Bauträger Gemeindeland Veränderung der Belastung Liegenschaftsgrenze Verhältnismässigkeitserfordernisse Enteignungsberechtigung

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision regulates the decision on court costs, as cited in the final dispositive order.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

                !"!# !$$%  !&' !$$%



( )(* *+*  (* +)

,- .

 #%  !$$& 



 !"#$%&'%(""(( $"$% ) %*%$ ($$+$$



"%$



,,       ,   -  !($ (%(' "%.$(%/0!#"%1123!4144   1



           

   +157+  

* /)

48 ,"9"$($:)#"(+"9($%("$'($(#%(";<( 100/: '%.( #$ )99( $'=("  #% >(+#$? @!   )%($(%4$<(100/A)99(%")#"(>(+#$?  @8

18 ,$   )((%'! (='  ; <( 100/! )(%'$'  ((B' &"($ %$&('4$<(100134'.$1003CDE , B(%' &A#(%#!((BCDF >,CG(D@ 8 ' A.''9(($)((%'CH=?34'.$10038

38 E , %("'!$)%%%%(")#"I$'%.(11$100/ B )(%'$' &(%%$&('4$<(1001129'&$($100/!#'$("$% B&(%#$J"($!(B)&(%'%'(.'$')".(=%(" %$&($A"#%$34'.$10038

/8  12 $ 100/  34 <&($ 1006! )(%'$'  %$&(' #"$ F  >,CG(D@ B(%'"."$%$(:%$:$##8

68 $'(("19'&$($1006! (%"=&"(CH=>(+#$?  (@  (9"$' )$' B   )((%'  4$ <( 100/ '%(% $#"$%'4$9'&$($1006!"%(9B)%$4$<(100/%34<&($1006! $&#$"&%"%(&(%'#$?F >,CG(D@ '%(% "( '= A )((%'  CH= A B  $(% # #$'%$!  "$% B)((%(")$(%#&"($(8

K8 #$'%'#$"'#"L! !)$'9"$'"##"(%("%  149'&$($100/!'=%B)#$? &"($'%' (('#"$129'&$($100/!  )'%(% #$'%'  (! "(%  4$ $ 100/! A )  (& "M  9"$($&(%'%'$#(8 )&(%#$J"#(!("(%$"%$( &(%((B'B)&(%%%$)N%$"%%'#$"($#$"8   9( $ 100/!  &(% %$"&'  "& #"( $ ## % $%(%  )%%% )N%$ "%%' #$  "($ % (#%(%  $%$ A  %$ ((%$%(&8 "A)"%$"()((%'CH=#"$"( $100/%(100/8

;8 $ '(("  42 <(% 1006!  (  $<%' )"##"(%("  )$'! "%(9 #$(B)$#(;<(100/9"$($(%(%':)#"(+ "9($%("   $'($(#%("  ; <( 100/: "%$(=' #$ )(%'$'8  $$"*%!N()&(%"(9($%)($(#%("CH=A% %'$($A4$<(100/!9%)&"($9"$(9"$($:((%(" #$"$':> @'(%$"("(#$'&#$"(!"$"(%A )((%'$(%'%(%8



5121451006  +357+  

78 $%47"O%1006!)$'!$#$'%'#$""(!(%$<%'$"$! '=%B))'%(%.(#$'%'A(CH=(&%4$ $100/%B)9"$($!"%"#((#'%''(&$'!&(%'%'$#(8  9"%("($ ( &(% ((B' B) &(% %%$ )N%$ "%%' #$  #$844$100/! 'A) $"&% )%"$(%("'<"$"'#"%($%"$'9"$($$#(#$ "&#"I$46&$(100/8 &(%9"$(A(CH=%" "%B(('%(%'%"'#"L&(%'$(%A#($$#$(A (  $'%  #(%  ((%'  CH= 8 )$' 9(% =$(9A()&"($99%'BN%(%$#"$&'$(9($% "($(#%("8 "%#(%)((%'CH=#"$#'$(" $100/!"(#%%("K009$840"$$#"%($.$% $'('CDF !%#"$(100/!"(#%%(")($4)/00 9$8

28   $'#"  ; "%".$ 1006!  ( $?& B (% L '$C  "($"$%!$&(='""(B>, @$"#$ "$$($  13 "O% 1006! B) &  ''%   #"("!  $"$% )'%(%#$'%'44$100/%$)()(++(&%  % )($(#%("  '%' "(9('  "'B8  (  '$ #$N% A #%$&$$((%'CH=A)$'?44$100/!" (#%%("=((%$'(($8,)=(%(%(=B(.(%B%A% 99%(&)($(#%("!()$%A<%(8

408 &(%'A'%$($!$"$%#$(%A"%($B))%($(%4$ $ 100/! $&% B) ) <( $J  "$$($  46 $ 100/  "&"B%#"$34$100/8

448  $(.  %  #$%(  (  "#$%(" #$"  44 <&($ 100K8  $"$%  '$' B) )'%(% #$'%'  CH= %$? $#(%#$?9(""%$%%$&(129'&$($100/!"(%4$" 1$100/8 %&"($(='9"$($#$'+($(#%("!(% B(I9(=$)#'%'($(%(P$##B)(9B)(%%  %("  <%( #"$ B ) %% B) )'%(% .( ($(%  $ 100/%"<(8($?&B%#$'+($(#%(")%# "#'%!()!B()%'%$('8

418 ,$B"(!'%'=$'A<=$8









5121451006  +/57+   

* +)

48 "(=&"($Q"$=(%("<((($>@'%'"(9('%(%(%'!? 4$"O%1003! $(.%"$"(!"#"'6<=! "%  #$'(% %  &(+#$'(%! 6 ##'% % 4K <= $ >$%8 4 %8$%6K @8

,(%AQ%("Q'%("4K<=$!#$ $(.9''$ 1;<&($100/> R43040K@!$ "(=&"("#%'!439'&$($!  (#"(%("%$(%"($$=%#$%%% $(.%"$ "(  ('=$  $ A %$"( <= %(%($! !  Q%%%  Q'%(""&L<=$8

18 "9"$'% A )$%8 6K 8 4 %8  C8 7 !  $(. %"  $"("*%(%(B"%%%("#$'&AQ$%86K "(9''$$#$%(=''$$"(%$"(7"%".$ 1000 > @ B( "% $%(& A  "( 9''$ $ Q$+CH= ".(=%"($%Q((%'Q("&.((%'16<(4271> @8

,"#'%#"$<=$Q#?%(('%.(8

38 %$<%'   9"$ % '( #$$(% #$  "(!  $"$ % A % '=$ $&.>$%86K%K0 @8

/8  $(.'$?&#$'.%B)(%('$"*%B$"$% )% .( ($(%  CH=  $ 100/! '%% #$'(' B   )((%'  #"$%% B $  "(  $ % ( 100/8 , $ "$(%(=(%99%(&AB)%($(%!A&"($4$!&"($ 1$100/!"44$100/""%(%)(%('8

68 ,")$%84;81 !&"#%!)$'%%#$'%$ A""(("A)%"$(%'"#'%%(%H%B#"(.!( # %$  #$($ <"$ #"$ B ( #$'% A )((%'  CH=P ( "(% (%"9"$$L#$$(#%(""%$H'(%'#$ "(9''$8

"9"$'% A )$%8 42 8 3  !  " " )"99( "#'%% " "9($%("A)$'%AB()%#$'%' %(B)( C"((8%"%$#".(("'"%$HB("(&% N%$ ((   #% <"$ A "#%$   % A B ( )% #$'%' A )"99("#'%%8)%"$(%'%"#%#$""=$'(<B)AB(D<"$  L(! "%%    ((% "%(98 "$  " ($(#%("!)$'"(%#$'%$(&$"%%)"99("#'%%(%$"(% "')($(#%("I%?(9"$%(B%(?$#%%



5121451006  +657+   $C'%$&(> , @%$%A)$'"#(%('A(>98 $%81084A3 @8

K8  )#?! ( I  (  $&$  #$($ ( B  "' $%(& A  $"$% )"% # '%' ((   I%? (9"$%(B  ,  (( B )L#(B  ($%$(  )    "$$($ $'  / "%".$ 1006 A )'#"L$"$%!?"$B))'%(%##$'%'A"&"%(" 34$100/>98#(?"8/K$"$%@8#%"'B%($$ (9"$%("  9(C($ (9"$%(B  ,  B% A  % )($(#%("  CH=$"$%8

 $"$% "%% &"($ $J  "&"%("  46 $ 100/ #"$  34  N"(!$?&B)($(%'%'"(%'$N%)I"$(%!%%(=%( 9J""%""($'%'%$(%'#$)((%$%("8

$"M +()%#AN 9"$($#$&)&"( "&"%("!  $(.  ' "(?$ B)( "&(%   9"$ $  '$%("%(%($ %)%%$B))#$J "&"%(" 46$100/8

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

 $(."%%A%'=$B9"$($#$'($(#%("A) (=' #$$"$%"#"$%%B(#%($L9J"TC(99$ <"$"(#%N%$"(%C(99$:44:!(&("(C(99$$"(!"(%  C(99$   C(99$ $"( >98 #(? "8 K (@8  "&(%  $&$ #%B%(.$##"'$(%9"$($%("($%% 44 $ 100/ % B  "&"%("  46 $ 100/ 9(% '=% $'9'$ A )($(#%("44$100/>98#(?"8/;$"$%@8



5121451006  +K57+   &B(#$'?! $(."(?$B)()%#'%.(A%(9%(" $"(%B$"$%'#"')((%'4$"1$100/P $&C!%44$100/%((%.!"$%B)$"(%A ((%'  CH= ? %% %! " '%("  =( (%$'(($ $'('$%(100/8



;8 $"$%!B(".%(%#$%(%=($"(%A((%'A%(%$ '#8









































5121451006  +;57+   



  +)/  )(* *+*  (* +)

 

01232 4  522 2  67 #&! + 8

  32

48 '$$"$$&.8

 32

18 )%#$%(%8

38 ")(%('A&$$((%'CH=A$"$%?44 $100/!"('$%8

/8 ")(%('A#I$A$"$%"R$87008+A%(%$'#8

68 9"$  #$%(   BQ #&% 9"$$ $"$ "%$  #$'% $$N%   '(  30 <"$ ?  "%(9(%(" #$ #( $"' $'  $(. 9''$  $! ,CG(D$C"9B( K! K00/   !  %$"( L#($8  '(  #% N%$ #$""='8  '"($ "(%T @ ((B$ L%%B'(("$"$%'($".%($(%#'((" %%B'P .@ L#"$ #"$ B "%(9 ( %( #"&"($ $ %% %$ '(("P @ #"$%$  (=%$ "   " $#$'%%8 ,(  '"($  "%(% #  %$"( ''% ''$' " %%$ @ .@ % @ (+!  $(.9''$$#"$$#%$$%(?$$$"$BQ( &$'$$($$&.8'"($$"$%("$"$"I  #$&! B( $"% <"(%! (( B  '((" %%B' % Q&"##  B'%'L#'('$"$%>$%8431!40K%407@8  =$99($T  $'(%T      (   U(      



5121451006  +757+    "#("9"$ #$'% $$N%%"%(9('L#$%(%,$'%$(%Q %%A Q'""(#$=$99



5121451006