Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/257/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/257/2007 KI-generiert

Apportionment of Damages in Motor Vehicle Accident Litigation

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/257/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The plaintiff sued for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident, alleging the defendant ran a red light and caused the collision; the defendant counterclaimed, asserting the plaintiff was negligent. The court reviewed evidence including damage estimates, medical bills, and accident reports for multiple accidents involving the plaintiff and determined that the evidence, when viewed most favorably to the plaintiff, established that a substantial portion of the plaintiff's injuries and damages were attributable to prior, unrelated accidents and pre-existing conditions, and that the defendant's negligence was not the sole proximate cause of all the claimed damages, thus affirming the judgment that limited the defendant's liability to damages uniquely caused by the subject accident.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 106 al. 1 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Apportionment of Damages in Motor Vehicle Accident Litigation: The court reviewed evidence including damage estimates, medical bills, and accident reports for multiple accidents involving the plaintiff and determined that the evidence, when viewed most favorably to the plaintiff, established that a substantial portion of the plaintiff's injuries and damages were attributable to prior, unrelated accidents and pre-existing conditions, and that the defendant's negligence was not the sole proximate cause of all the claimed damages, thus affirming the judgment that limited the defendant's liability to damages uniquely caused by the subject accident.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Verkehrsunfallschadensersatz Widerklage Opfermitverantwortung beschränkte Haftung Abtretung zivilrechtlicher Ansprüche medizinische Beweismittel

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 106 al. 1 LTF

Used to declare the appeal inadmissible based on procedural grounds.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed costs for the unsuccessful appeal.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



            !" "##$ "$%"##%



& '&( ()(  &(  ) '

*+, $  % + "##% 



  !"#$"%%% !!" &"'"! ( )%*!"

"!

++   & (( ,   ! %"%$ -./ 

            

   ,3016,  

( -'

17  $#!%1.82"%99:;)< %"=> % "*!1.217

37  !"%!  % &#!% 3441   %%$  "   "!#% : /4? % : 54?@31 "*!3441 !!%"$7

67  18 #*! 3441   $ $    !""% ;!, %#%%"$#;"!%;!"7

87 (  ! !" $%  5 $*! 3441  "!  !%A;!$"""%"; ! %"!  %""%";* *!BAB7

57 ! !"$%38C#%!3443"! $%%"  $% %"! " $% "!%""  ;!$  %A"%D$  !  %"! # "!*  !-"B !%D !" "  !%"$ *%"$!  !%$ E$!  "F7 ( % %"$  "!#% $"%"  54?  32  "*!344461!344164?1!#!%1. "*!3441" 54?  %  31  "*! 3441   $%7   !!D$ D %  "%" "!#%%" #"A  !"%"  "!*  "-   %""% " %7$"%"$A"AG$ !!%"$*%"$!7

H7 "! $%%""""$319$#!%!3443D "%" 99!%" ; B- % *%"$! AG" !9%" " %"!""*%*!-"%99!7  !"%"%#$"%"62H?:!%""862?:AB7

/7 6%3443"!+ $%%""B%!!A%!#%, 9%%%D$D;%#%"# "%":! !%"32C%1... !*%%A%D:"!7C%" :  %"%  %  !!%! D;% #%" !$  3. C% 1... : "" !%@!7 (  %  "%" !$"%"  !%"$ *%"$! "   B@ 9!;;D%$"%"9""7

27 12 "*!3443"! %D$:;99%"  ;!,%#%%"$E%, !@I FD ! %"!%*%" C"%9%!% %"$"!#%:54?A!$7""9%%%D$ D;%;#%"  !#;!$ %35C%3443"D$""#%"  $"$!%!!"B$!%D" %!7

.7 (! !"12"1.$*!3443"! D%#%" !$>%$ ;!$  11 #*! 3443  $"" $"%" ""%%! !   "!%""!%D";99"%!%D #%"""G"!D%9%$



0123103445  ,6016,   %!7      C"%9%%"   !!G"  "!#%  "7  "%"%" "9"!AA!#"!;$""A$$!%"%# "! !*@ " 99!%"  "%" ""  99" A$$!> %$ : ;B- %7  "!%"" *$",*D" D%  !"$A%" "!  !-"B% ; A%" $A" ;99" %! "!%*" : A"!  9"%A "  #!"%A7  !!G"  "!#% """$  54?  32  "*! 3444  61 ! 3441  64?  1! #!% 3441  1.  "*! 3441 "  54? @  31  "*! 3441 $"%" C"%9%*   !%A%D   ! J  99"   "BA% !%D *% D %! ;C"%" > - "< A$$!> "%#" ;!!G"  "!#%7 $%*"  "%" 99!%" ;"! 9"! #" > %D!  % %"$  "!#%7  !"% !%A%D $"%" !%% *%AA!#"% #%"G"!>7

147 ! !"12K"3446"!) $%%""A% ""!A%%%D$D "%"$"%" !%$ %;$3444" D; !%A$"%""":9%"$D"7#!"%#$"%"9%"   B@ $"%" *% "$!$7 %%  $9%%" %"%9 "   B@  *%"  C"%9%!  %%"%    %"$  "!#%7 &!$  %A%" $A"  "!*  ;$D%%*! "   ;$"%"  "  %!7

117  3H C#%! 3448  "!   """$ D  %""% !%D " #%" G"! %$!$  *$%A " D; $"%"  "%* # #%!""%#%"$ !9%!"!%"% "!%"" !%D7 "9%  !%   " : ;B- !- "%"% "  - "<   %""% !9% $A!$* D% #%"  $! % #%!%""!#!:;!$"%#%"$ !9% "!"J !!%"$"!%!! %*,G!-"B;"%#%"$7 ;-#%" !%! !"%:99""!;99"%!%A%D "  !*@ 7  - "< $A@!" #!"%A%> "  ,$*!%$"$ A$$!$ ! ;B- % #%" G"! >!*$  !$   %""% $A!$*7  !%%" "%99%%;""!;#%$% D;"- ""A% %"!'!%#%%"$:54?7

137 (!  *   ! !"  (!#% $% !$A% $  ;!, %#%%"$ E%, !@I (F  %$!$   ! !"  38 9$#!%! 3448 D ;!$ !$"%"""%":"$;!,%#%%"$" D;%;-#%"!"%%"$"!%%"%" "!#% "  DD !% $%7  >%"%" !"%"  9"! , $%> !> %D!%%"%" "!#%""!$7

167 !$%%5!3448; !9$:;!$""!%":!" "%9D;""%"!%D$"%" "%*##%!""%#%"$ !9%  !"!%"% ;""%" %"%#  C"%9%%"    



0123103445  ,8016,   %%"% %"$"!#%@!D;$"%" !%$"!$"" 9"%>"7

187 !;%"!$%%!%;!$9!$ %"%:""$%% ! !!%!38!3448764C%3448%D$:;  % !!%!3HC%3448"!:%D 99!   %""% %"!%""" ; !%  "%  % %%"9"%#"$""9"%A ""!7( %"$ "!#%"54?$%7

157 3.C%"3448"!!A%D$"!  D;% #%" !#  "%" %" :  "%" % $#D" $#""  $% "$!A! "!%"%! *!@# %#%  DD !$%%#  #!"%A7  %A%" $A"  !   *! !%" !D;"%""G" "%" !B %A7%$#% D "B$!"  %#   ,#%@! !%" "!'"  $$!"%"D%!%"$#"" C!!<$#$"D% " !$$$%"! B$-%D#-! #!"$*! ! %!,*%D: !"%! D"B$!"7$"%" %* D!"%A"""%# !9%%9%"% B$-%D"- #!"$*! "> %D!- "< !$"$7

1H7  3 $*! 3448  "!   %D$ : ;  D  "%" 99!%"  -!$A"% #!"$*!,*%%!7 ( "!#% "  99!" "*!"DE B %AF$B%"- "< !!*!!"- !#%,*!B%9%*"#!"%A7 %"%"%#%"$*%" !%:A"!7

1/7   #% $%  6 C#%! 3445  (  %%D$ D  "! ) ;#%" !"  !A" ! ""!%*!  -!$A"% #!"*!,*%%! :  ""%" #"%*%! " D ,% ;#%" ! $D"%9! %"$"!#%>%A%*;!$7 "%"! >B"%9%#%"""9%!"! ;%!"%" "-!$A"%"%,%#%"%9! %"$"!#% ;%"$!$7

127  3/ C#%! 3445  "!   %D$ : ;  D  "!* 9"% !%D " 99!%" ;!$ $"%" "" *% "!<$ !  "!%"" *$",*D"7 "  %A"%  -!$A"% #!"$*!,*%%! %,% ;$"%"    !!"  !" D;%  #%"  !! D" : ;$#" !$ !%  "" ""%" !   %"$  "!#%7 !%!9%!$D !*@!%D"%"%"  ;!!G""!#%A!$7



0123103445  ,5016,  

1.7  18 9$#!%! 3445  "!   $%%"  $% %"! " B$"A%  !$  ! !"  "! 7  "%"  %A%" !%% ";"B$%":;!%"";AG % !"" %$ :  %%"%  ;L7  !$"%"  $%  A!#%"$  !" #!%* B-  !%9$!"%# !-"%!7  >%"%"  $9%%"    "%  ;$!-"B! L$"% A!$ ;* ;%99% !$7 ;@  % !!%" 9%! $#D!  -"% D% ; A%"#";*%;$!-"B! L$"%7

347 ( ;#% $%  15 9$#!%! 3445  (  "!  9%!%" D ;!%A%  -!$A"% !#$A$""%# ;$"%"  !%D "D"!);$"%"$C: !$:C"! !" 12K"34467 %%!A" !"$ !"! !   !$! ; %"% ;$"%"   "%*  %9%!  %! !"(389$#!%!34487

317   ! !"  8 ! 3445  (  9%" $"" ; $% $A@! D%  #%"C"%9%!%%"% %"$"!#%>%A%*7

337 ! $%% !  %"%  3H #!% 3445 ;   !C"$ ,%7   "" "%#$  $%% !  9%" D  "!*  ;$D%%*! $A$ ;#%"  G"!*C"%#$% !"!)% !"! "D>,%;$"%" ;!%A%!%D7 ##% ( % ;- #%" ! %!  %  !"%!  -!$A"% #!"$*!, *%%!7

367 !"3/%3445;!$! !$"$ !%%"!C"$!! "! "" $%%  " !$ !"%!" :  D; > !"% $% !%%% %%! %" !$ " !%% " : ;"%   $%% ""D$ " ;"!% ; !" ;%#%%"$  %"  $ 7   "" 9%" #%! D  9%" D  "!*  ;$D%%*! $A$  #%"G"!*C"%#$";$"%" ;!%A%!%DBA%"!% 9%" D >,% >%"%" * " *%7    "! !%"%D$  9%" D ;%"%$ *%" #%! %%"$ ;-    > %  % !%A%D " %"%9 " $!"$  #%  !A "  ;B$"A7  $"%" $%!  !$!:%#"%A"% @"9!;> !"%9%; !"! $%!%" ! ""  ""%" %  $#% !  "! 7   ! %! %%D$ D; !"%" 9!$D"  $"!%"  "% ;$"99! D;% % !!%#%" ;G"! !@  ;$#%" #  $ "  "%  !" ;$D%%*!  "" ;*%A"M9!$D":!!G"!"!#% !!!:;%9%!!%9% ;-!#%!%7 ; %$A$$ $"" % ""!33#!%3445"!:%7



0123103445  ,H016,  

387 !!%!$%9%"$"";$#"%!D$ !"B$% 9"" $C: !$" % D% #%" " : A"!   ">" ; $% D% %" !**" !!!  !"@!  A!#%"$   #%" %  -  !!"% ! ;%""7   9%!$  "! ;>%"!#%*!B%A%!%"D%;AA!#%"9"%B!A B-%D"!#%7!*%%"$ !%%$""%"%" "!  A! B%    !"%% % ! %"% "!#%" ; "%"  "!#% "%"7

357 !$ !!3.C%3445;%"%$!C"!! !$9$!">!A"%#D$ !$$"7

3H7 !;% !"% ! !"%18 "*!3445 !!"  $!$ D; %%" *   "!#% D ;$"%"   % "!" % %" *   "% @ ! D; #%" "!#%! # !NA$"7 % %!$#%" : D7!;AA!#%"  "% !#D%"> "G" !" "  #!"%A7  #%" %  "%  9!%" #%A%A"C*" %7 "<"$!%"! % 9%%" !9%7 ;C"%" !""%"% ;!%A$ !  #%A7   B@ $"%" !9% "!@ $%* "  !%""!@%**!%"7 "9%#%!" !9%;$"%" "!@*!-"799!%"$A"* ;*%";%D%$"%" $!$"7  $"$ 3448  #%" "$  "!  :  %" ;%7 !D;$"%""$!"*!" !""-!B"; *;$"%"""; "!#$ !"!!D;K"" ;$"%" !%"7 ! B   ;$"%"  *$7  #%" ! %!  #!"%A"B%"7

3/7 1. "*!3445 !%*$%D$> !"%D;%#%" ;%""%  ""!  O#!  > !"% "%%% %%! "   9%!  "!;> !"%$%:@#7!$A"$ %*%%"$ $"!%!!D"%%!:""!:;> !"7 !"%;" 9!$ *!#"%:"$A!7

327 ! !  6 #*! 3445  !%*  $  %  O#!  > !"%"%%% %%!"%:""9% "!&> !"%$%: @#7

3.7 32 "*!344H"!!! !"&> !"%%"!%% %%!7 P"%" %$ : "" > !"%  !B"A "  $%%"  $% B-%D "  !$ ""%  !A  -B%"! "  A%A7  @A  > !"  $  %A"% # !$ !% !   %"$  "!#%  !#%A% B!%D ! "!* $A$$!"%9 $!$ 6, 8 " 



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

647 1/#*!344H&%"%$&"$"!%$!! !"&> !"%C%%%!  !#" D  !!" $%"   %"$  "!#%  /5?   !9%%99:&)< %"=>" %"$"!#% @"  "%#%"$  %99 "!%"%7  $"" &%"%$  !%"$   %7

617  2 $*! 344H  !!"  !% %"% !  ! !" &> !"% "  %"  % !$$"7   !%"  !!%! D  !  #%" !$ :  "%!7   !!%!  $%  > %D$D%A"% $%*%">"7""$""9%!   !B"A%D D&% &A%%" & -! "9!  & !**9%*!-A%7(!$"%" !$! ! ""!#%&!%A%$%D9"% %"%%$! <"$!%""AA!#$ !99!"7%D %$*"&$ 344H &$""  "$   !!"  &$"%"  $C!$7 " :   %"$ 



0123103445  ,2016,   "!#%%"%$D "%"$"%" *"!#%!>% " D"!B!7

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

637  !%*$)&"%9!$1.C#%!344/D  -$ !$"%"% %"$"!#%:54?"!@A""D  !%" > %%"$ C!%@! $"%" $ %$7 (  *!#"%  & -!  !!" $"%"      !$ !  !*@  "$ 99%*% 99"$   #%#%"$ "  -%  $ %"   * #"$"% !9%%""7(%$""#%"&$%!!"D ""$%!"%$"%""""$ !!"%9%"$% !!%"! !! "%#%"$"> !$%$ !$%"!%""$%H%"  $%!:%9%"%&!A%"%%"!7 D"% !%* $  #%! % & -! !%"  "$  3441 D  !!" %%N"  ">  "!#%  144 ? : /5 ?  ) " !$  D&% & C% $"$ D"%3441D&%%N" %A!$">&% %"$144:/5 ?7

667 !!!%!35C#%!344/& -! !%! !$%$D%%"I





0123103445  ,.016,                                                   !"           #  #                      $  %   ! &           '   %         (  !

)          *               #             $          +,$  !-    $       '  #        '            ./  $    0   !

687 !$!%"!.9$#!%!344/!!" !%"$%7 !#$ D  !$   )  9%" D 9%!!  *%,9$   > %"%7!%!!D&AA!#%"  " !#D%"  >  "G" "  #!"%A &""  D& #%" 9!$D" & !  ! % "" " B% $7 (  %"$  "!#% "!@ !"!%" $"%" $A" 9%!$ !  #% ""  $% "!%""7

657 &%"%$$A"%"% !!!%!61C#%!344/7

6H7 (!$"$A!$:CA!7



( )'

17    " "!$  #%A!  1! C#%! 3446 "!'"  %9%"%  *!% %"%$A%&!,%#%%"$7!D ""9% & >%  !%" $#" :  !" &%#%%"$ !  $!% !$$"&"!$#%A! %-%& %D! !%% A$$! !%""!%"%!D,GBA"*$A, !@A  %* "   #%A!  " J  9%" C!%%D" $"!%"  " !%"7 %  !%" :  !" %",% G"! >%$  !A!&%!%" ! $!%CD&61$*!3443"9"% #!$A""%$A !@"""E +164866%71" !$9$!F7

  D% !  !#B  !$! " : $9"  !@A "!%"%! "!%!  # !%" & %D  !$!# @  C!   "!$  #%A!E +11/.6%7H*F7 &" !D% !$! "1!



0123103445  ,14016,   C#%!3446%"!%" !@"""#" !%*" $""  "%@! &! % " !$A% !  # !@A  !$! " :    " !  % %"%  !$! "   %99$!"% $%%9%$ ! 7

37 "!C"$$%"9! !!%" !%!!"!#*E!"75H  F7

67 (;!"78 ;%#%%"$"%%"% %"$A% !$$ !"   A !$ D% !$" ; ""%" :  "$ B-%D  " !#" ; %9%!%"$ A$%" ; %  ; %"7 ;""%" :  "$ ;"   :   $"!%" "  ! !%  %$!"% D   ! J  "!'  % %"$  "!#% -"  99" !   %"$  A%  ;!$ EQ, ( A"M R*!%#%#!%B!AS!%B1../ 72F7

#!"C!% !"%;%#%%"$!%"! % "  "% $%D "  $%T  "  $D $%D*C"%#;% %"$9"%D;%% !";$#!E + 114  3/5 %7 8 145  34/ %7 3F7 !D; !%  ;%"%#%"$  ;!$  $ $%D 9" $9" % -  %   9! !  $;!!$%!J !""";$#! %"$  "!#%  ;%"$!$   "%#%"$ !%*" >%A%* E + 115  166%73145152%71F7

"%&%#%%"$"&% %"$A%"D$9%%   % "! " ! !% C!&B% !  !"7 / " 2    %9%"%"%7

87 >"!;!"73271 #%A!CD&61C#%!3446;!$ !%":!""%@!;%"%#%:HH306?%:%,!";% " %#% : 54 ?  %  :  D!"  !" ;% " %#% : 84 ?  %T $%*;!$ "; !@;!"73271*%  !$"! %,!";%"%#%:84?%7

&"!$#%A!8@!$#%% %9%$"!&!"7327 1   !"%9 : &$B"  !"   "> &%#%%"$7 ! D& !" "%@! $"%" !$  !#" :  !$ @ D  A!$ &%#%%"$ ""%A%"HH306?""% %"% !$#%"$!%&"!-!"!%,D!" !" :  !$ !$""  A!$ &%#%%"$ & % H4 ? "  !" "%@!:%"">" $!%!:/4?%"%!"%#:&"!% & D!"  & %,!" !" %BA$7  !#B  !%%  $# $ CD&! !  C!% !  "%@! &$#"%  &%#%%"$ !#" ! #%%"$ D  %"  & %!        8@



0123103445  ,11016,   !$#%% E +164682%7678T +  *%$1/%3445 /045%73H "*!344838.048%78F7

57   !"$#"%"$!$E !> %&%"&% %"$  "!#% &%#%%"$ &""%" : &%"$A!%"$ B-%D  "F  " &%"!"%  9%" &!! $%7  "NB  $% %" : !"!  CA" ! &$""  "$ " : %%D!  D ! " ! D "%#%"$ &!$ " :  "%9 % *  "!#%!7  "!  $ $% "%""  $$" "% ! $"!%! D "!#>  " !!%*">%A!&!$E +1353H1%78115168 %7 3 118  618 %7 6 145  152 %7 1F7  $ $% !"""A$$!" !$%"%*C"%#7& !""! """% D% #" G"! 9%" : &% & "A &*!#"% !9% D "  "%* &G"! %9$ !  $$" *C"%9%$ !""&!$ ""AE +  *%$H %3446/H3043F7

 CA  ;$!"  !%%    "%9 % $!"%9  % ; > !"% C%%%! $%  "NB  ;> !" $"" !$%$"  ""!  % $%:% %"% !!%9%! "$%>;$"" 9%"$7""%"!!%;$!"!;> !"%C%%%!9%" D ,% "%"  "!%"%  D; !,> !"% !$ !  "!%*  %9%!  %  %@! #%"7  "! !D ;"! $%%"$""" %%"!%! ":""!$!%" " !"%$"%;> !" ">! %"! !$""% %#!A"  %   !%! !  CA   *%  %"!"%  $"%!   9! ; # > !"% $% E +135653%76*FF7

D%!#! !*";! !"$%D%"$"!%" ;" D  %" %"%A%> %" 9%" ;*C" ; $" %!"%$ D  ! !"  9 !  >  " D;% ! $A"  %$!"% %"> !%$ ! !>%$D;%%"$"$$"*% % %  ;@ D  !% "%  ">" $% " ; !$%"%%""%$%%"%!"9%D% ;> !" %" K" "%#$7  !" ;$$" $"!%" !  #! !*" ;" % ;!%A%  -  !# %  $%A"%  ! !"> !"%%*"*%"E +135653%7 61331H4%71"!$9$!F7

(&A%" ! !" $"*% !$%"!%""CA "" %""%!  "9%"D&> $!%$%"!%"""A$$!"%    " : !! !"% !  "%"  !%   !"%  9%D%&%":!%!E +135651%76*0"F7



0123103445  ,13016,   H7  &!! % #%" &!! : &> !"% "%%% %%!  "! &> !"% $%  % #! !*"7  ! %"  99" "  !%"@!$$!$ !C!% ! !$%"$7

(  > !"  !!" !$"   %"$  "!#%  /5?   "%#%"$""G144?""D%99"!%"%  ""  "  ""  99"% B-%D " -B%D "  " ""%"7

!" &$#"%    %"$  "!#% !  > !" C%%%! "  "!%"% #   ! 7  "  !$ & > !"%"%%% %%!D% !%%$!"%&*99"%  !!" "  $"$ $"*%  % %   %! $% %" $A"  &#%  $% "!%"" % #%"  !  !$9$! > % & " > !"% &""  D&% 9" $A" "%!  "  !#$ %,   D & !$%"%  $% "!%"" " G"!  !%" & !"% *C"%#%"$   ! J %  "   "  !! !"% !  "%"  !%  !"%  9% !"%%@!7

"#!%D& -!""$A"D!!" %"!#%!:  ">  $!%! : 54?7 (  C!% ! !$%"$ & !$%"% $% & !" ""9%  !%%  !  """% !@"    %"$  "!#% !> !&"A&*!#"% !9%7*!#"% & -!#"G"!%%$:99"$!&""A " "!:""!"%&> !"%C%%%!7

 !!" & ! %!  %  $#%   $"!%"%  2$*! 344H  "!%"% !!""  &> !"% " &    9%"$""&#%&"! $%%""""$!%"" !"%  % %$ "  & %% %#!A"  $% "!%""7  !%*  $  #%" @ !  "%9 ! &$!"!  &> !"% "%%% %%!C%%%!7

/7  !"  A%   !!" &" @ !   $!%! : 35?   "%#%"$"">D%"%99%" !#!%!!%":!"7  !" ! %! D  !!" !!%" : "! A"!  ">  "!#%  !@ ):/5?7 &" %% $%!&$"*%!%! &%#% B- "B$"%D BM  "!  -! "  $"!%!  !"  A% !  !%"!%!"%D&!%"!$%$>):144?7

27 #D% !$@!!!!C"$7



0123103445  ,16016,  

  )'-  '&( ()(  &(  ) '



./010++ 2  300 0  45 6" )7

  10+

17 $!!!!#*7

 10

37 !C""7

67 %"D !$!"A!"%"7

87 9!  !"%   D; #" 9!! !! "!  !$" !!G"   $%  64 C! @  "%9%"%  !@  !%* 9$$! E(BU%M!B9D%HH448  F !#%!!"%@!!%" *%9!$">!"723%9$$!! !%*9$$!1/ C% 3445 E +FT  $%!  !! %" %%D!  % "%9 " - !#" !"!%A"!!!""%!T%%" G"! !$  !%* 9$$! ! #% "  ! #% $"!%D > %"%  &!"7 83  +7  !$" !!G" "  %@  %  !!"%#D$- !#%#"G"!C%":&#%7  A!99%@!   !$%"         %! )  ( -  

 %9! !$"!!G"""%9%$> !"%%%D;:;99%9$$! !% !A!99





0123103445