Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/252/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/252/2004 KI-generiert

Lien Validity Following Dismissed Foreclosure and Settlement

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/252/2004
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The case involves a challenge to the validity of a lien placed on property where the creditor had previously initiated foreclosure proceedings that were subsequently dismissed without prejudice after a settlement agreement. The court held that the dismissal of the foreclosure action, even without prejudice, revived the lien, as the underlying debt remained enforceable, and the settlement agreement did not explicitly require the lien's release; thus, the lien was valid because the lien itself was not extinguished, only the immediate right to enforce it through that specific foreclosure action was suspended until the dismissal.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Lien Validity Following Dismissed Foreclosure and Settlement: The court held that the dismissal of the foreclosure action, even without prejudice, revived the lien, as the underlying debt remained enforceable, and the settlement agreement did not explicitly require the lien's release; thus, the lien was valid because the lien itself was not extinguished, only the immediate right to enforce it through that specific foreclosure action was suspended until the dismissal.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Grundpfand Aberkennungsklage Grundpfandverwertungsverfahren Gültigkeit der Kündigung Gültigkeit der Schuldanerkennung Gültigkeit der Schiedsvereinbarung

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

     

     !"#"$$" "%""$$!

&

' (') )*)  ') *(

 % + "$$!

%,  - .

  

  //////////  !  " ##$    !

! 

*00( )*)  1')2()3(( %&  ' (  ! )*+ ,*-. /0 1!12

               $ *3%$

) 0(

,5 "' 67777777777  !1! ' 1 ! 8 92:01 2  ,%). !

 102  #1  !;  ,%%* 2 '  '1 1!1 '  2<  15 *5 /  1 ' 0;  ,%%* =1!2 2  2 > !1 > = $ 011 !  010!  !! ?    !101!2  !105 .5  '211 ' ,,   ,%%. =@@1 @2'2  ' 2@:12 1   '2 =1  #15 )5  ,) 0;  ,%%& = 2  '22  '' '  !!1 'A $ 101'1!2  / ' =@@1 ! ' = $101'1!2 B1$ / C  D 01! > =;!!1 '= ! '=101'1!2  1 '  2!! (E!1? 0 ! ; '(!E(1?5 +5    ! 2'1 > =!!!1 ' =  ' ,+ '2;  ,%%&    7777777777 2'1 ! 1!! ' = 2  1'1?2 ?  !1!  2!1!

' !22'! ' (E '1 ' ;  2 '2F> ! ?= '2!1 (E!1?  20/  01! !102  ;1  (E1! 1 < !1!!1 10 1!1  ' (E1! 1 ' /0 B1$ / C D5 =11!2 ' ! 01 2!1! !! '1 ?= 11!  !1! > 01  *, !;  ,%%.5   ! 2!1! F1!   ! ' !!1 (E1! 1? ' ,G @20 1 ,%%. 2! '  7777777777 '  ? '1:!1?1!

 11! E9  !1!   ;/ ' 1!!1 B( '= 1:1  :   1 '1  @1 '1212 ; '=!101!2D 11 ? '  ;; ! ; '(!E(1?5   '  ! '!2 ' ,- 0;  !

2!;1   H 2'1  '1:!1 2 2!1!  E '  1  > 01 ! ; '21 !  21@12  ;; !  20/  '2 1! : 5  1!2 ' ! 01 '  !1! =  @1! =;F! '=  21!1 '   !

'  2'15 G5    ! 2'1 2!1  ' *. 0 1 *--,    7777777777  1'1?2 ? =2!! ' !2 '  !1! 2!1! '2F> 101'!

0!   102  #1 ! 2!1! !!11 5  '1:!1 !1! 1E:2 !

=!!1! (E1?  1  !!1!  '=01:  ! 01 '1 1  2 '2F>5   ?!11  2!1    ! ; (E1?    7777777777   212 ?  ! ; <1!1! '2F> '1  '191 '=2 ! ? =11!2 ' ! 01 > ,-- I 2!1! ' 1?! > =@@!1 !5

3,)*43*--* $ .3%$

&5  '211 ' .- 0 1 *--* =   F!2  '' '  !!1 0!

? =!!1! >  !2 2!1! '2F> 101'! 0! = 102 ' = 2  #15

45 = 2  1! F!2   !  !! '211  / '  11 ! '    !1/  '= $101'1!2 B1$ / C  11D   1 ' ., 1 *--* 10?!  0!1 ' 2 1!2 1 !   #1 ! =<$J:015 %5   201 ' .- F1! *--* =     F! '   0! ?=1 ( 01! 1 '=1? = H!2 @2'2   !  !!! ' 2@:12 ! ' ! 1' ' = $011 !  010! ! ' = $101'1!2 !

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

) *(

,5  1 :01  A :1!1 F'111  ' 0;  ,%), B1$ / C D  2!2 '1@12 !  1; ! '   1  2!2 1!1!2 '/  , K! *--. B@5  !5 , !5 D5 @ 2! > A !5 . 5 . ' '11!1 ! 1!1  '  1 ' ,) 0;  *--* '1@1!     1! '1! 0! A! 2  01: '  1  21!2 ! '! '0!

 11 ! '    !1/  'A $101'1!2 ! 2!2

3,)*43*--* $ )3%$

! 1 'A@@1  1; ! '   15  2! ' 1; ' 2 ! '/   2!;1  M!  '  2! 1!1:5 *5  1 @2'2     !1 :22  ' ' 1! '   1 ' G !;  *--- B1$ / C  D ! ! 2  01:  , F01 *--. ! M! ' ;  '1@1!1 '  '1 ' = $101'1!25   '=/ '  !!@1 2:1   '11!1  01: F?= ., '2;  *--*  2: '   11  ?  F: '   1 =  >  '   1'2 !1  '1@1!1 ' ' 1!  ' =2!! ' @1!

!2 1  >  '! '2! 1! '  '211 1!1:1 B N ,*&  )G& 1'5 , O ,*,  .4G 1'5 ,; O @5 2:! '11!1 ! 1!1   !5 4* 5 ,  D5   2! 1!1:    2? <12 >  1/  ' '11!1 '  1 @2'2   = $101'1!2 ' ,% F1 ,%+% B1$ / C  D ! ' /:!  = $101'1!2 ' ,& F01 ,%G, B1$ / C  D  01: F?= ., '2;  *--*5 .5 22 '  @  ! '21 12   1   2!   ! 0;  0 ! '  !5 G%   ! 4) '  1 @2'2   = $011 !

 010! ' *- '2;  ,%)G B1$ / C  #D5 )5   ! '!!! $H   01 ' 1! >  !  '11  '=101'1!2   ?!1 ?1   '  '  '   2!  2'  ! ' 01 1   ' 1! >  ! <!  '11  '=101'1!2 11 ?=  !1! '  2 1!  ' ,. K! *--*5 +5   2;  1; 1@    ! ?=1 1  !1! 1?!

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

3,)*43*--* $ +3%$

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

1? 2 B !5 , 5 * @D5 ! !!@1 ?   '1 !10  !  ! B1$ / C  O P )*-&D  ?=   (! ' 1! >   !!1  2 '  ?1!2 ' 2@:12 1 1 1; '=  !   0   '1! =!!!!1 21 2!;1  =@@1 @2'2  ' 2@:125    =!!!!1  '1!

 ! >  ' '< 1 0!  '! ' '2Q! '  ''5  =/  '! 1    ! =! ?  '211 ' ,,   ,%%. '! ?1  1! 1@@1!  : ' ' '11!1 !125  = !!@1  2?   ! 0!   201 '  0!1 1:2   #1 0 = <$J:01 ?1  ! > ' '1!1 1'!1? ? = @5  @@!  0!1 =1?  #1 !  <$J:01 >  2:1!1 @2'2   = $101'1!2 R5 , !5  1! B11D ! !5 ; 1!

B11DS5 #=:1! ' ! <!  '11   0!1  201! ?   !1! (:0 =( ! ' 1! ?=1 :! ?=1  0!  '11  #1 ! 1 12'1!! 0!  '! >  !1 ' ? 1 ''!  ! 1 ! 21'2  #1 ' 1/  11!  '! + 2 !1/   1 B !5 & !5 ; ! 4 !5 'D5 &5 #=:1! ' '1!1 ' @'  ' 1! '  !1! 1 < ! <!  '11  ' = $101'1!2 ! '2! 12   '11!1 '   # B !5 .%  ,  D5 # = !5 )* 5 ,  #   !1! 1 ?1 !  '11 !  21' E;1!  #1 ! ' 1! >  ! <!  '11  =1 !  H ;  '=2 '=  ?    '   '=L: 1

3,)*43*--* $ G3%$

 0!   2!'  >  !  '11    ?=1 =!  2!2 1 > =;1:!1 ' 0  ' !1!1 '!  2 !1/   15  ' 1!

01! 2:! >    010!5  1!!1 ! 1 ! <11!2  =@@1 @2'2  '   1 '  '1 !10 O  ! <!  '11  ! ! (2  ?  '1!1 ' ' 2 11 ' !1!1 <1:1;  =! 1 '= !  '11  =!

 1 ! ?  ;22@111  '   !!1     '22'2  21 2!2  2 '!  H ;  ' 1 ?   '=L: BP &--, D5  '1!1 '  ' 2 ' !1!1 /! ! 212  ?=    2!2  2 ;1:!1 !  @!!10!  1! !1 '1  , F01 ?1 1! =1! '  *- 2 F?=>   0 ' =202!  25  =!  !   21  ?    1! 2F 2  #1 '1  1 BP &--. D5 #! 1  ;22@1 '  ! <!  '11  '=101'1!2    101' ' 1  '/  @ ?1 ! '1112  #1 B !5 .% 5 ,  D5  =:1! '   101' '1  1  ?1 !

'0 101'   !< F!1@1! =! 1 '= ! 0!

=1! '  *,/ 2 1 ?1 =!  ?1  ' 1! >  !  '11  BP &--G D5   2!'  >  ! <!  '11  '=101'1!2   !1! 2! : 101' ' 1  '/  @  '1!  01 @ 2! 2F 2  #1 '1  15  '1!1 '=! 1 ! 212  ?     2 ! ! 2  #1 0!

'=01 !!1! =L: ' *-  205 !@1  ! <!  '11  '=101'1!2  ! H!  0 2 ?= @1 2E  '21 '   ?1 BP &--& D5

45  =/ ? =  ;  = @    0!1 ' 2 1!2 1 1:2 0  J:01   !  ' 1! < ! <!  '11  ' = $101'1!2 < H '1!1 ?   !1! 1  !! ?= 1! 2!2 '1112  #1 '= 1/  11!  '!

1? 2 12'1!! 0!  '! >  !1 ' ?   ''2  !5  ' 1! '  !1! 1 < ! <!  '11  ! '2! 12    #5   0 ' H    !1! ;1? 1 :! ?A1  0!  '11  #1 ! 1 12'1!! 0!  '! >  !1 ' ? 1 ''!  ! 1 ! 21'2  #1 ' 1/  11!  '! 1? 2  1 B !5 & 0!1D5   !1! 1 ?1 !  '11 !  21' E;1!  #1 ! ' 1! >  ! <!  '11  A1 !  H ;  'A2 'A  ?    '   'AL: 1  0!   2!' 

3,)*43*--* $ &3%$

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

3,)*43*--* $ 43%$

! ' 1! < ! <!  '11  ' = $011 !  010! 11 ? ' = $101'1!2 < H '1!1 ?   !1! 15   @' 1!$1 ' ? = 2 1  '1!1 ' @'

!10! >  ! !  ?1 =!      = 0 1$'5 %5  0 '  ?1  2/'    ! F!25

3,)*43*--* $ %3%$

  *(0  (') )*)  ') *(

4 5676   8  966 6  1: ;" *<

  76 

2  0;    1! F!2  "' 67777777777 !   '211 ' =@@1 ! ' = $101'1!2 ' .- 0 1 *--*5

 76

,5  F!!5 *5 1! ?=1 =!   V '=2! 1 2 '=1'1!25 .5 @    !1 '  ?A 0! @    !    2!  H!

'  '21 ' .- F  '/  !1@1!1  1 '2 ' 2  1; @2'2  '   #EW19 E@?1 G G--)     ! 1 <1 5  '21  ! H!   :25  21  '1! C D 1'1? <!! ? '211   ! '21  ;!1  1 !  '  '211 !!?2O ;D <  ? !1@ 1 !1 01 '' !! !  '211O D  !  1:!    '   2!!5 #1  21   !1!   ! 1 22! 22 2  !!  D ;D ! D 1$'  1; @2'2  '       !   !1/      ?A1 '0  '2  1 0;5  21  '   !1     ( '  0 ?1  ! F1! 11 ?  '211 !!?2 ! A0 ' ?   2!2 <2'12   ! B !5 ,.* ,-G ! ,-4 D5

 : @@1/  C   21'! C JX  Y "(  " 

  2!1 $F 1! C " 1 8 ""

 1 @  '  2!  H! ! !1@12 <  !1 11 ?=> =@@1 @2'2  '   1   : @@

3,)*43*--*