Earth Movement Exclusion in Insurance Coverage Dispute
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe decision addresses the proper interpretation of certain insurance policy provisions regarding coverage for losses arising from earth movement. The court reasoned that since the policy expressly excluded coverage for damage caused by earth movement, and the specific loss suffered was found to be a direct result of such movement, the insurer was not obligated to indemnify the policyholder, regardless of any concurrent causation or policy language suggesting broader coverage elsewhere.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Earth Movement Exclusion in Insurance Coverage Dispute: The court reasoned that since the policy expressly excluded coverage for damage caused by earth movement, and the specific loss suffered was found to be a direct result of such movement, the insurer was not obligated to indemnify the policyholder, regardless of any concurrent causation or policy language suggesting broader coverage elsewhere.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertProvision cited for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Volltext
"#$%&"'((% "'#)"'((*
+ ,+ - + -,
./0 # * / '((*
1 2222222222 !"#$
$ 1/ 2222222222 !$%#
&$
, ,3, 4-5 -6,-$' &%()*+ !0$ 6-,- , 7+ 8 ,&-../
!
/13
6,
45 $67&44 /..(8*9:$ $ :,$ *$ & ,$! & $ 7 &$&! 4; <& /... ,$ "
/5 ' 9 00$ 8 , & 0 67& ,$! &! $ : ,$ *$ &$!,$&7,$ & !+ $,$!+#,$0
25 :&&,,? $& ,$ , +$@,!&!&&! $& > 67& +$ & + !0 & 0 /. 6 /..( & !&! &$ @00 $ : ! /2 +:$ /..( ,$ A!& ,$&75
-5 $ : ! &! $ & && ,$!+# , &$,! +$ & && ,$ & >$ && + $ > ,$ $ $& $ 7 &&$4;<&/...&/.6 /..(5
35 @ &$& !,$ $ :!,$ @!&: $0 & +&B
• $ $$ $ /8 6+ $ /..) C D " E >!>$+ &!&!00 !4$6+ $/...24$ /../$&$&41;4)/)1 5 $F@ & && ,$!+# ,$&& :$ ,7 4.@;-; 0$5 33 +$ 4$ 6+ $/...$$,$ &$&5,$&& :$,7$ $ 7 @!+ & ? 4.@8;) 0$5 8.5 24 $ /../ ,$&& :$ ,7 $! & 4;@;-) 0$5 43 !&! &$0!$! ? + & && ,$!+# '' G E '' @' " 5
• 30!+$ $/..)'C''E >!>$!& &$!4$ +$ /../ 6>@ 2. +$ /..- $ &$& 5 E2(8) % '& 0&7 $ &&& & ' ' 5 ,$&& :$ ,7&$ 7!& & &&4/+:$/..- &$0!$!,$&& :$,7/8@22-0$5)3? '' G E '' @' " 5
• $ $$ $ ) 0!+$ $ /..) '' % ' ' G E '' H I >! > $ ,! &,$&& $& & +$2(@/4;0$58.&> ,$&& $& & $ 7 7&! &!$J& 6>@ & +$ @!+ & ? 43@/)3 0$5 835 0 $! + $
1-2(31/..( 213
$F && 4;@-;) 0$5 43 42 6 /../ C D & /8@28-0$5)34(+:$/..-'C''E 5
(5 $ >! $ :!$!,& :$,7>@+$&,$*E '' @'' 5
)5 & & !&! &$ A ,$& & 43 0!+$ $ /..)5 6$ & $ >!>$ 7&:&@&&& 8@833 0$5 .3 > $ &$0!$! ,& $ $ ,& :$ ,7A%!,&>@?!0&@:$+& @ /;0!+$ $/..) $$J&$ &$$&&:5
;5 @:@:6& ! 0 A!!&!7$!?67$5
-,
45 @$&5/3 0!!$$ :$,7,$!+#,$0 + $+ +&& + &!4)!:$4882HEI&$!+ 7$ 4$6+ $/...$*7,$!$ +$5$>6 && ,K$$,$&& $& ?,$&7$H$&54//&4/2 + % I 67 +$,!&&@$&5)254 0!!$$ ,$!+# ,$0 /3 6 48;/ HI & ? *+ $ : &$ , 4$<&/..2 &,$*>@00 $ !&!&$ H$&54-/ IA!&$@00 ,$&7$: ! $!,$& & !&$ !,$67 +$5
/5 '@$&5//EH+&$+ 7$, 4$6+ $/...I +$ ,$&& $& > $& $ 7 & ,$&7! 0$!& A$&54//4/24-4&4-/ B$&52?3 E@,, >& ,$7 &&?&$0!$$H54I5$9>6 &,$&& $& ?,$&7$$$,? 00!$&$,$&& $& 7&! + $ :$ ,7 A && !+&& & +$ & ,$&& $& 7&!+ $ :$,7A &&!+&& & $ 7H05$&5/-EI5$6& ? ,$&& $& & ? @+ $ :$ ,7 A && & $ 7 &!$J& & +$ H E 4/; /2.B E4/8---I5
K,* 67 ,$ *$ & $! ,$&7 ,$ & ! ,$&& $& > $& $ 7 ,$ $5 &
1-2(31/..( -13
,$& & & K ,$& $ 7 4; <& /... K&$ ,$& /. 6 /..(&?>67& +$&+A!& $5
25 ' & ,$ & $ ,! & ,$&& > & $ 7 4.@8;) 0$5 8. ,$* C D " E& ? > + & @6&$ &!$J& 6>@ +$ H/@/.20$5(3I &42@4840$5335 &$ + &$,$&& > & $ 7 ,$* '' % ' ' G E '' ,$&&43@/)30$583H &!$J& & +$,$ I &,$&& &&&$ 7 /;@-()0$53.5
,$&& $& & +$@!*+>&??2(@/4;0$58.5 ,$* !& @+ $ > & $ 7 & /;@-() 0$5 3. ? ,$&7$ & * $ ? )@)34 0$5 -. H& 8@833 0$5 .3 >!,$$$$,$ $ :! &&$4- 0!+$ $/..)I5 !>$ & & !?A%!, &2@;)30$5).5
-5 0$!& ? 6$ ,$ , 6$ !&$ & ,$ ,$&7 6>@&&$0$&,$&& $& $6 & +$!:!!0 $&&,$&& $ &? &!$J&,& $$ &&% 5 &!$J&&!&A !7@$&54/ @$$,$!+#,$0 + $+ +&& + &! 4; +$ 48;- H /I &A $!7& $ % & ,!$ $ H E,: !2(1./4;6 &/..2I
35 !& $ ,$F ,$!$ !&& 7$& & H$&5 )2 5 / & ;8D54 $,$!$ &$& +4/,&:$48;3I5
LLL
1-2(31/..( 313
1-,6 ,+ - + -,
9:;// < = >! ?%' - @
45 + & '' % ' ' G E ''%
). ? E '' @' ' 0+$ "
!$&*/.6 /..(6>@&&$0$&5
/5 K#&&>: 5
25 &>,$!$&7$& &5
-5 0$ ,$& >K ,+& 0$$ $$ &$ ,$!& $$J& ! 2. 6$ * & 0 & ,$* $ : 0!!$ H'9M N$90> ((..- I,$+ $$& *$$ & ,: 0$!&A$&5;/ 0!!$$ $ :0!!$4) 6 /..3 H EIB ! $ $$ & >$ & 0 & #,$+&,$&$ 7&$$$&& $B & J&$ $! $ : 0!!$ ,$ + ,& ,$ + !&$ > A & @$&5 -/ E5 ,$!& $$J& & , * , $$& +>!#,$+ +&J&$6 &?@+ 5 7$00 *$ $! &P '#+ D "O
, 0$,$!&$$J&&& 0 !A,$& >K?K00 0!!$ $ ,$7$00
1-2(31/..(