Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/249/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/249/2006 KI-generiert

Contractor Delay vs. Owner Authorization Failure in Construction Contract Dispute

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/249/2006
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The dispute involved a construction contract where the contractor alleged the owner breached by failing to provide necessary authorizations in a timely manner, leading to delays and increased costs, and the owner counterclaimed for liquidated damages due to the contractor's delayed completion. The court examined whether the owner's actions constituted a compensable delay or a non-compensable delay excusing liquidated damages, focusing on the contract's provisions regarding notice and the allocation of risk for unforeseen delays. The court determined that the owner's procedural failures regarding authorization requests were non-compensable events under the contract terms, thus upholding the application of liquidated damages against the contractor for the ultimate delay in completion.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contractor Delay vs. Owner Authorization Failure in Construction Contract Dispute: The court examined whether the owner's actions constituted a compensable delay or a non-compensable delay excusing liquidated damages, focusing on the contract's provisions regarding notice and the allocation of risk for unforeseen delays. The court determined that the owner's procedural failures regarding authorization requests were non-compensable events under the contract terms, thus upholding the application of liquidated damages against the contractor for the ultimate delay in completion.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Bauwerkvertrag Verfahrensverzögerungen Schadensersatzklage unbewilligter Bau Nichtigkeit des Vertrages Begriff des öffentlichen Auftraggebers

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to decide on the court costs of the appeal proceedings.

Art. 64 LTF

Applied to decide on the request for legal aid for the appellant.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

               $%&'($)+  $)%,$)&



- !.-    -   !

/01 + # 2+ 0 )&



  !





!

""       "   #  $% !./ !&!'($)!+,$-*--   *



           ! "#

   5*0'5   #  3 6    &//7/ % %.!/ % 89.:%-;*((,,(<*(('=

>%/)/<%.%%>%.!/%89.:-.*((4=

)%/%-;!*((4$ ""       "   #   ?5)@ A  B$   %//  %! C >%.!/ % 89.: /!!<.!-;*((,!;6>,(<*((4$.!76>%)! ;6>C !! %@ %! %> & C D C ED5!  E <  7.!6%<!F!%//..%.$%!6> .)!)%!/:!<%.)%!C>%.!/% 89.:=

)%/))!%*+<.&*((4$;!/5=

>/!!!%/)!%*1%/.&*((4$G, ;<*((1$!.)!.!C!=

>!./,-;<*((1;!%=

#   6   :<  H:! ;% ?B  /!/ .%7/ !  !!/$ %@  - I! *((,$  & ! %  $.)/%4;:$%!)/%!!<5)/%!$4))/!! -1;:?!J-!J!41 B=

 ! C H! % H/! % -1 ;: $ )  & 7/%/*2;<*(('? E-,(-(1B$% :<%)!/$ -, 7/<$%)!!!:!).!!! &!%   % /:   C ! ;: !!$ $ % H!!!%H/!%<K;:=

 7./.! C >!J 41 J - !J  8J 3 $  & ! % L!!6%!!!)/<CH!J41 % 7/%/)!://%%1!&*((( ? B6! !<C7/%/H589.:&:!! H%.!/%H<&!/%*4;-+3*? B=

.)/!);:%%H)@!/!&=

   ;)%$  !!/  )! %  %/ % !!!$%!J'+J* !*4J*<>!J4J- !J&%7/%/)/%%.!!<%*(%/.&-+13? B$ 6 6> K!  !/F! %: % )!! C  !!! ../%! % >K!  % >K! %> ))! % %!$ C <  !/F! ! % %!%7!$6>))!)%!&!/F!)&)</$!C



0'1230*((4  5,0'5   %!6!!/F!%:%)!!))F!)/</.D %>%/7.!$>!5C5% !!!<%%!%>&:!? E -*+*+(%J*J-$-*1,(,%J*B=

> !/F! %: % )!! ! /:.! K:/ 6 >!!/ %  %/%!!!)6F!%>%.!/.%>77? E-,( ,+-J%J*J'B=

> M%/M 6  .%7 ) < 77! &:! ! %!.! !:!  )/!! < C >!// ?) K.)  %.!/ % 89.:B ! !D)6.! % ! !!! !  !7! ) C >K: %> !/F! %: % )!!$ % ! 6> >! ) !!6& %<!  !!/;%!?F!)&/% &7/%/%% -*!&*((4$-3,0('$%J*J*B=

>  & 7/%/ %   ;:/$ %  % F! !/$ 6 6%89.:%/;C/C>/%%.!/%89.:$ M%/M%/!%!C>%.!/%89.:<77!/!!7<F!  !@ ).! !!!$ )6>  .%7 ) < 77! &:! %!.! !:!  %! % >/ K )!! %/;C %/=

%89.:!%.%7!!;%6%/!% %/ ?.!/B %>! % >%.!/ % 89.:$    7!/ % /.!!!%)!!%/;C)GK%!6)/%!C /<!%%/%.!!<!/7=

>M%/M!!!%%/%!K)!!%/;C/ !7! ) /6! ) C >K: % >!/F! %: % )!!$ % ! 6 >!!/ ;% % ).@ !  %! ) !  .!@   7./!!M%/M?F!% &7/%/% )&/)/!/%J,B=

>>$>!./>!)//.!!!/%%/! %!C%%.!/;@%/;C/$)M%/M%-;!*((4$ 7./  )  M%/M  ))! % *+ <.& *((4$  < /./7..!!!!%)!!%/;C)G=

>>:!%>%/%!!!6>!/F!%:%)!! ..%=

 7./.! C  ;)% )/!/$  <! %@  % %/ 6!!>!))!&%>$%!65%!F!%// <&=



0'1230*((4  5'0'5   !!!7)&!/%7))!$)%>!;!  /8/! $ !  /<! %/  !!! % )!! %I.!)G%>!./=

   !4  !.-    -   !

#

56300 7  8   9: 2&) ";

-J /<&J

*J !6)/%!:!!J

,J 7.  )! %  6H )<! 7.  !  )/! F! %  %/ % ,( ; %@  !7! ) ) ..%/ %/  & 7/%/ % $ "8NO876 1$ 1(('   $  ! K.)J  %/  )! F! ):/J  ./. %!A B %6 K!.!6%/!%/&!!)%%/ !!6/= &B K) ) 6 .!7  !. )< %.% !! ! %/= B )!  :!   %  )/!!J "  ./.  !!)!//.!/.//!!B&B!B5%$ & 7/%/ %   ) ) !  .!@    6H %< %/ <&J  ./. %  .!   .D % )<$6!;!$6%/!!6/!H<))%6 /!/K)/%/!?!J-,*$-(1!-(3BJ  :77@  /%!A       PQ R D       

 )7.% )/! F!!!7/K)!!"/!!%H !!C H/.):77



0'1230*((4