Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/211/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/211/2004 KI-generiert

Appeals Concerning Validity and Interpretation of Prior Judgments

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/211/2004
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Teilweise gutgeheissen (Partially Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The case concerns multiple appeals stemming from various legal instruments concerning the validity and interpretation of several prior judgments. The court system addressed numerous distinct claims presented across the appeals, which involved issues such as contractual obligations, property rights, and procedural challenges under various statutory frameworks, with the appellate court ultimately affirming, reversing, or modifying the lower court decisions based on its interpretation of the relevant statutes, precedents, and the evidence presented in each separate matter.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appeals Concerning Validity and Interpretation of Prior Judgments: The court system addressed numerous distinct claims presented across the appeals, which involved issues such as contractual obligations, property rights, and procedural challenges under various statutory frameworks, with the appellate court ultimately affirming, reversing, or modifying the lower court decisions based on its interpretation of the relevant statutes, precedents, and the evidence presented in each separate matter.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Auslegung von Urteilen Rechtssysteme gesetzlicher Anspruch verfahrensrechtliche Fragen Wirkungen der Urteile zur Prüfung der Gültigkeit Vorabentscheidungsverfahren

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of costs in the final disposition.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

     

    !"#$%!$%%$ !$""!$%%#

&

' ()' *  ' *(

 +"  $%%#

,-  . /

  

  )0000000000 



*11( *  2'3(4((     !"#  $ %&'# (&((    () **+,

               

- &.(/-

 1(

(0 1* 2222222222# , 3 (!%4#  5*,  * *   6 788-*50

&0 $*  5 9 * :7   8 ;7 $  *5*  *  <*=    (4 + (!!)# *   *$*,  5*  *  +<;* 7*6  < ,;,,*8 5 <; *,*80

)0  *5  + ++ 788  >* $ 9-*5**,  ,, *+$ $ 9,#  *  <;   0

%0  ,**  &/ 5+< (!!'# 988*   9-*5**, :*- $? @  =   , A 9,  +*- ?  ( 8,5* (!!'# ,** 6*  ,, 8*+,   $  B;+   ++**    C-  :*-$? @ ++**  =  (4 $+< (!!40

'0  ,<  9, (!!"# 9   ***,  $,  ,5**  * A  0     -*# 9, *  ++*6,  (& 8,5* (!!" 6  ,  9,* $ +,*,0 C  * <6, $ ++  * * 8,6++    ,  <  *0    8+# * 8** ,;*?+  >* A  +*# ** 6  5, 9$$+0  ,* A  77 9 +$* A '/D 5 9*  9-7E+;# +*  ,+7 ,* +, 5*0 C F;   ,  , ,* *,  $ 5 ++ +*8  80

40   $$  (" + (!!"#   2222222222# 7*$**#  , 6 9,  ,    $* ,* **  69* $,*  *$*,  5*  '/ A (//D   * $56, $  880   $,  *;* 9 * %-' 5 $* $* * '- C(0  $  +<;*# 9, 88* 9 *+**  8  < *0  +,*  ,;+ >$*6, 6  $* 5* ,,  *+ 7G *  && + (!!)  (! 5* (!!%  69* 5* *+$  *+ $  * 8**?#   + H * 95* $ ,;,  $*+  9-+*0  *+ 5* ,, $* 7G  7*$** A $*  % + (!!"0   ;;,,  $, A  >+ +,* $ ,,5  $*,  5*#   + H  *5*, *+$*6  88 5*

.(%&/.&//&

- ).(/-

  $  7; *6*  $56  7 6  $* *0

"0  ) 5* (!!"# 9   ++*6, A 9, 6  $,  ,5** ,* +*,  69* 5* , 6  ;, 9*5**, 95* $ 7;,#   69* $5* * A <,,8**   +I+ 0

J0  (( +*  4 $+< (!!J# 9,  <,,8**, 9 $* +$*  988*   9+$* ++     <*<*7?60  *5*,  3 I *+$ ?  " $+< (!!J#  *  <;   0

!0    (" $+< (!!J# 9,  8+,  +  ,5**# 8*  $5* <,,8** 9  9*5**, A (//D0  9 +*5, $  ,,**   ,  , 6* ,**  5  *+ +,*0

(/0   $$  (& < (!!J#   2222222222  *;*6,  +<;* < 5  + > 7*60 9*$*,  5* ,*  (//D ?  " $+< (!!J  $  , *,+*,0   $ * <5, 6  $* 5* 8*  7 7 $;*6  ,<  +*  $+< (!!J 6  *+ 5* +,*,0 C  +# * * 8* $5* 8* +*> 69 *+$ +,**0

((0   $$  )/ 5+< &///#   12222222222    2222222222   $***6  ?5  KE$*> *5**  ?5 :*-$? @ K=  , 6 9,  ,  9, *  9;;5  6  $*,  $5* I +,*, $  + +,*0 C  5* A +$ $* A +** 6* $5* I *+$ $  7;+  $**   $*<**,  9; *  *;  +$0 C  *;*# * 88*  +<;* 7*6  < ,;,,*8 5 <; *,*8  9  $-* +*  95-< ;7 5 $  8  )JD0 9, *   # +,,# 5  ;;5*  8+  <;# 5  8L *,;*?# $* 8* $ +*# $8* $* 8* $ B# ,*  $** ;,0  +,*  ,  *+$  A  $$*   7*? +<-, *    +* +<* ;70  *#  +<**, +<* ,* 8+ *+*,0  M 8* $ ,  ,8** ;*6# 7+*  *+**   +**,  < ;70

.(%&/.&//&

- %.(/-

(&0 C +  9 #   2222222222  88,  >$*  9,  ,  9,0   $$  (4 < &//(# *  *;*6,  +<;* 7*6 $, $*  +< ,  ><, $  * 5  (!!)0 C  $* <B*5# 9>$*, 5*   $+  <   <   ,;* +<*0  $5 ;  +I+ $** $  (/ A (' +*# * 5* ++   $**0  5* $ * , A    $  8># ?  6 76 * $56*  <;0 >-* 5*  * $* 8* $ +*  9<*;* A  70 C   2222222222# 9*$*,  5* ,*  &/D  +* $* (!!)0  9,* ;;5, $*    5* *+ *  +>*++ *  66 ,0  +  ,$* $8* 9,* $ 5*;<  * 9,* $  $ $*< 9+,*  $*,  5* * $  + +,* * $  +  >***0  $*,  5*  9, 9,* $ $,* A > 7 $ B0

()0  (% B5* &//&#  C5* +,* ,;*  + :*-$? @  C1=  9-*5**, 9 $,   *  9,0   $$, 9>$* 88, $   2222222222  (!!'# 6  8* +*  +<;* ,**5 ? (!"/ ,*  *$*  5* 76 ,# ** 6  $<?+ 8** N  ,;+  9,# A +I+ 9>$*6  $*  $* 0 C  C1#  ,  >+ 88, $  $***6  +,* :*;$7*# ,7;$7*# - +<*= ,* $$< A >  (!!'0   +* 6  * < ,;,,*8  *6#  *+;  *$7*0  95*   5*#  * <B*5 ,* *?0  5*#  $*,  5*   *5*, $, ,* *+ >*;*< A '/D#   +$  *$* ,*, $  5  +<;* *;O0  *#  >+ +,*> ,  8** $ , 9 ;;5*# +* 9 ,**+ $7 *6 6*  $5* I  ++  9 *5**, $+0

(%0  *   ++** 9 $B  8   +  ,5**# 9,  ++*6,  " 8,5* &//& A 9  69* ,*  9*+$*<**,  5*  *     <; 6* $5*  $* A 9*+$ 6 ++0 C  ,* , <6,  ,++    5* ,, + * 69* 5* 9*+$*  5* ++  ,7; ,*6  <  *0

.(%&/.&//&

- '.(/-

('0   ,**  && + &//&# 9   B,  +  ,5**  9,0

(40     (J 5* &//&# 9,     ,**   *+$**+ A  *  A 9* 9  9*5**, *?0 * $,<# *  +,  ->$*0   ,;+ **,  * 5 9  $<   ++**  0

("0   ,+**  &% B* &//&# 9     B  0   8* 5* 69* 9 5* $ 9,,+ 5>  85 9 ;;5* *;*8**5  <   69* 9 5* $ *  8*  $$,** *88,   $*,  5*  0

(J0  ! B* &//&# 9   +* A  ++**    *8* +,* 6 * 5* ,# $  #   2222222222# $ 6  $**  , 69* *  9+?  9>+ **6   <* *;*6 6  $* 88*  <; *,*8 +<* 5 +<*;* ,5?  8,6# A +   +$  *$7* +<* ,;,0  95*   +,*# * 5* 9  +*?  9* 9  A (//D#   + H 9  $5* $ *+;* 7G  $*  $* 9 *5*, $8*#  *  97** **60

(!0   +$* $    (% B5* &//%#    ,, 69* ,* *+$*<  7*88  +<  <; 69* 5*   (!!'  69* 5* B97*0   9,* ;;5, ;+   69* 5* +* +  $+0   ,;+ **6, 69* 95* $ 8* 9<B 9 >+ +,* $  C1 ,+0 8*# *  8* ,  *88*, 8**?  69* ,*  *+ *,$ $* 6 ,0

 *(

(0  * ;5*  M;** B***  && 5+< (!%(  ,, +*8*,   *<    *  ,, **, ?  ( 3 &//) :80 0 ( 0  =0 8+,+ A M0 ) 0 ) 

.(%&/.&//&

- 4.(/-

*$** **   *  (% 5+< &//& +*8*  #   ** 5 M,  5*;   * $,*,  $ 5  ++**     +*? M-*5**,  ,, +* M88*  *<    *0  +$,  *<  ,  ?  ,<* $ 7  $, **;0

&0  * 8,,   $* ;,,  *   *  4 < &/// :*-$?  =  ,  5*;  ( B5* &//)# N  +< +*8**   +*  9- *5**,0   9$? + 8* ,;* $  *$**  5*; B69 )( ,+< &//&#  ,;  $**$  6  B;   * 9 $ A $  *,*  +*8**  *   9,  8* $,* A   ,+*   ,** **;* : P (&"  %4"# *0 (# (&(  )J4# *0 (< Q 80 ,;+ *$** **# 0 J& 0 (  =0  $, **;   ,6 >+*, A  +*?  *$**   * 8,,  9-*5**,  (! B* (!'! :*-$?  =    ?;+  5*; B69 )( ,+< &//&0

)0 ,$,   8+  ,* *+$, $  *#  $,   5< A  8+#  5  * 4!    J% *   * 8,,  9-5**  5*5  &/ ,+< (!%4 :*-$?  C=0

%0 > +  90 %(  #     *5 I ;+,# ,*  $$*+,# $ 95*# *  ;, 9*5**,  +*8*  +*? A *8  * A  $*0   ,5**    * 988*   + :0 J" 0(  =0   +  ,5**# 9, *  $*< 6 9*5**, 9 +*8*,  +*? A *8  *#  90 J" 0 )  0

6 9+***   +*?   5 +#  * ,*  8*  9 6  +*8**  ;, 9*5**,  $*< $ 9, 9 88*5+ $*0 C*   6  ;, 9*5**,  9 $ +*8*, $*  *? ,** ,  8#  +  A B0    *#  * >+* *  +*8** , $+  8  * A    A  ;+*  -*0    #  B;   +I+ 5* 9>+ : P (("  (!J# (/!  (('=0

.(%&/.&//&

- ".(/-

'0  9$?# 9   ,  +*?   +  ,5**  0  $$* ?   *<  , 9>+* *  ,  , 9 +*8*,  $*  * 5*  * A   9*5**, *?0

40 C  B*$   *< 8,,  # 6  >$* ,     $, +***5  ,<* $  $,** #   < 9<5* $$8*  9*5*;* +$?# ** 69 $* *  *#  6  >$ <* A  , 5*#  B;  *  , * ;+$ 69 **   $+     <*-8, : P (&'  )')=0

  6*   5 $< 9 $$ +,*#  6*  ,+* 9 6  $* **;*> *+$ * 8* 9<B 9 , 8*,# 6  $$  8   >+ +$# 69* $ ,;+  *,*  $* >$*+,# 69* * ,, ,<*  $* *  * :+?=# 6  *$*  > +,* * *  6  *  +,* * <* +*5, : P (&'  )'& *0 )# P (&&  (4/ *0 (   ,8,=0

 # 6M* $$,*  $$ ,<* $  +,* *#  B; $  * * +$  8* 6#  M>$,*#  +,* *  ;,,+ *#    # A $ $* $  $*  *   *  8* 6* M* A  *0 **#  B*$  $  $* > * 8* $  $,** 6MA M$$,**  M*$*,  5* $  +,*  8+* : P (&'  )') *0 )<.   ,8,#  (!!'# $0 %%Q  (!JJ $0 '/% *0 &=0

"0  9$?#  7*$** *  #   2222222222# 8* *+ , 9 ;;5*   ,  0   2222222222    2222222222   $***6  +,**  K  ,;+ >+*,    $,, A  >+ +,*> $$,+*0  5*  5 6 9  $+*? 8* 6  +,*  ,, ,  69*  9;*  $  +,* *  9,0   $$  )/ 5+< &///# * **6 6 9,  9, 5  9;;5  69* $,  *$*,  5* A (//D   6 788-*50 C  *5*, A +$ $* A +**# $5 I *+$ $  7;+  $**  $ 

.(%&/.&//&

- J.(/-

$*<**,  9;# $*   *;  +$0   >$*  (4 < &//(# 9>$ +, $ 9 #   2222222222 *5 A  +I+ *0  *+ 6 9,  $ I $,   +7,  5*#   + H  *5*, **+$  + > 7 $ B $* I >*;*<0  + 8* 6  <;  *88** A >$*60  ,$ A  6* $ I 77,   ,*,  9,# +I+ 9* 8*  $  5,#  $*  $* *+$    *? ,#  ,**+ $7 *6   7 $0 8*#   2222222222  8*  +I+ * 6  +,* $,,   * *  * 6 9*$*,  5*  0

 ,$*   5* +,*>#  C1  *,, 6 9,  ,    9,* $ ;;5,     *#   +   >+ 9*+;* +,*  +* $  +*8**  H  ,**+ $7 *6  $5* I  ++  9 *5**, $+0   $ A 5 6  +,*  C1 9 $ 56, 9, $  5 >+0  $$  (% B5* &//&  * ?  I *,,  $**$ ++  >$*# 8+,+ A  B*$   +*?0

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

.(%&/.&//&

- !.(/-

  6*  9<,*, 6*  ,, 5,#  9# 9 $# $ 9 ;5*, >I+0 9 $#     ;* $* 9>+ +,* 88, $   2222222222  $+< (!!'# +*  $*  $* 9 *+*, A % R* :((/ R* $ (J&+  < &//(#   $$   2222222222=0 8*#   *  $< 9, 9 ,**+ $7 *6 6*  ;;5,  * A  ,  * 8 $  +*8   $ 9*$*,  5* ,<*0

J0   2222222222   *,, 6   $5* 5* > 7 $ B# * 5* 9+  *$*,  5*  "'D0  $; 5  * A   *?0

!0 C 90 JJ <* 0 ( 0   # 9;+*    $ 88  $ E ?  +* H  +  ,5**  $,,# *  9 $+< (!!J0

(/0  5   6* $,?# * 5* 9  ,** 6,  9      *? 9*5**, ?  ( $+< (!!J0

.(%&/.&//&

- (/.(/-

  *(1  ()' *  ' *(

 

 5 6 

, 5<   *B, $ 1* 2222222222   ,**  && + &//&  988*   9-*5**,0

 6

(0 9+0

&0   ,** 6,0

)0 *     9*5**, *? ?  ( $+< (!!J0

%0 * 69* 9 $ $L 9,++ * , 9*+*,0

'0 8+  $*   6M $5 8+    $, I   ,*  )/ B ?  *8** $ $* ++, ,  *< 8,,  # C7S*G786* 4# 4//%   #  * >+$*0  ,*  $ I $;,0  +,+* * @ = **6 >+ 6M ,**   ,* <*  *  $   ,** 6,Q <= >$ $ 6 +*8 * *+ $5* +   ,**Q = $  *;     $,0 C*  +,+*  * $  * ,,+ ,+,,   = <=  = *-#  *< 8,,    $ $   +*?    6M* 5 , *5<0  +,+*   +*   +   $5# 6*  B*# ** 6  ,** 6,  M5$$  6   ,, >$,*,   :0 ()&# (/4  (/J =0

 ;88*? @  ,* @

TO  U 1   1 

 $* 8+  $, I  *8*, > $* ** 6MA M88* 8,,   * $  ;88

.(%&/.&//&