Mandatory Penalty Imposition with Discretionary Exception
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe appellate court considered whether the trial court correctly applied the relevant statutes regarding the imposition of a monetary penalty following a criminal conviction. The court reasoned that while the statute provides for a mandatory penalty under certain conviction types, the trial court failed to properly consider a statutory exception that allowed for discretion based on the defendant's ability to pay, leading to an erroneous imposition of the full amount; therefore, the judgment was vacated and remanded for resentencing consistent with the statutory discretion afforded to the trial court.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Mandatory Penalty Imposition with Discretionary Exception: The court reasoned that while the statute provides for a mandatory penalty under certain conviction types, the trial court failed to properly consider a statutory exception that allowed for discretion based on the defendant's ability to pay, leading to an erroneous imposition of the full amount; therefore, the judgment was vacated and remanded for resentencing consistent with the statutory discretion afforded to the trial court.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.
Volltext
!"#$%!%##& !'$$!%##(
) *) + ) + *
,-. / %' 01 %##(
!!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'()*+"$,-+ - %-##$.%-##/-0
-
11 . "# -$% 234"
9'5&&9
2*
&: !!!!!!!!!!"%&3)6";# <--%%;".=$ %-%%:*,=>;"#?#,#+-+-%" --+%#@$,: .>;#'6".-%%-+% "A -+% # -- B *+" $$ # # : # $,2%----C!!!!!!!!!!#&33(B&333:
': '' =- '((6" .-%% #%, #$# # ,-- ,* # .9+#-%"+-B.-#.-:#DEE#,<*$ #+"##"##<*--#,#:
6: ,,- #% B . #- # 'F ,-$< '((6" !!!!!!!!!!#DD,--EE##<*-9#%,#-" #.<%-%" #. EE + @D G $$< E% - #. <%,@9=-+-$G-%+*:-%;$-,@2,- -%HI J--%"%,,-%#-+:---B -%G--#,+D-.,-%#-+-#&((K#* &7=+ '((&: .G ,,- $%# -E B %- ,E" !!!!!!!!!!#DD.%-,<#-+ #.-+-%G%=D."D.#-%+-$L$,-#,,#- ;-$," ,- B ;G" . # <-" ,- ," @ # -+ %;" -+ @- - #%,$- %;,-:=-,,-%-<,!!!!!!!!!!",%- 1I,@-$;"#'4$'(('"B.---# !!!!!!!!!!"@E# + B D ,@-$; # M%-<$- @,-M" G -$ #D ,-- EE #. <%,@- $,-- - #. < #.-% +%+*#.;#%-$%B=: $%#+-++ ,-- B - , #, #%<- # .%" =$ <- + $ D # =: .+- , #.G,- , -- < # +"B.G$DB.;;,@: -B,%$%--$-%" <#.N#---#-+.G$#@$,+H J #;-:#$#-+ !!!!!!!!!!D-G-<#-EE $#:
F: D- , .$,2" ,- # E%9-- C!!!!!!!!!!-#D%D.--#-+.+-%-%%-<+.% -D.+-%-%;;%,"$$##:.$,2E %,--E # E@ # # &336 B &333" #- B D .% #%$%" @-- - # ,2 #.;: %-% +% =D.6&?-&333:
56(7'5'((8 965&&9 ): '3 ?- '(()" !!!!!!!!!! %-< -E- $%# G -$ #D.%,%-H#.,*%--#--<=-EJ,,$$- $+2%;*B$#%%#-* :
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
.,,%- # " $%# *+- D !!!!!!!!!!+.%B,,#,'((',E$$- # ,,*" $ %;$- , < # .-% + #%- $$ %+*,.%"#-.%-;-$#%-$%: $%#+% ##-@$,+-$-%-@$,+G#;-"- -- , # $,- ,@-$;D % #<*-: .2 , # %-,-@: %%$- # # B #,- -- , -<-E , G,D ,-% # -+ --: $,-$- ;D - -* #%$--E"$--#$<-%-,G,D%,--- @$-$" D - E$$- #%;%%-+: #;- # E<$2; ,- , L- - # # #EE" #%,-
56(7'5'((8 9F5&&9 ;$- - #%-: + # @" G- # -< --D <G"D##$-9%-;%#--",%#$- + $< <: , ,2@-D" 2$,-$-; #%,+",-<#.L--%;%#$<#;- 9 &(" ,- L- $ %+#: " $%# -$- D. .2 ,#.---B-%#.#,@2D,2@D=-E-,-%# -+ ,;% # . ,E #.# # : $=- # 2$,-Q$ , # ,2@;D - ,$ ," $ =-E ,-,-%#-+:.%--#-%--%--",-% #-+G;<#.-+-%@<-#.##",#,-%B .%--#-%#.%"-#&((K":
4: ,,-#%B. #-#'7$'((8"1!!!!!!!!!!" $%#,%-1I,2@--,2@-@%,",#;-# -<#%,E%-"%,#-%+*"#EE-%%B.--" <#$$<#E$"#EE-%%;$--G#- %$D D.B $# # %," #, , %: .,-%#-+-#&((K:
7: #%#'4+'((8". =-%#$##,--#.%" $-ED.EE#.---B-%+#-#"- D,-%#-+-#&((K#-+-%,E@<- #.##:
3: ,%-% , +-" .% E$% ,,- #- # ' = '((8" +- D --- #%- # ,,- # - $E-$- , $,-< + -+-% - D #.# # : -- #,,-#.G$ :
&(: #%#''='((8". =--.,,-"#%-D,,- #.G$ $,- ,$- #- EG% , =,# E%#%,+#,+,<-:
&&: .-$%##$#-".%-=--'7?-'((8: -- # ,,- #.G$ " - =- D -< + #- EE - %-% DE% , !!!!!!!!!! # $+2 %;*" D ,# B +#-% # ')K: *; D .-% + #$%##%,$--*#EE-E-;EG$%## , + -% .+ #. ,%- ,@-$;" + #. 9 ,@-$;:,@%;$-G$%## #.+9%+% #$,2@;D"+,2@-D#-<:D-$ N+#.G,-,@-$;D-,2@-D"-<#$-"- B.-#.--*#.+#-%:
56(7'5'((8 9)5&&9 &': %, # F ,-$< '((8" . - =- # " #%- D -- $%# # - %-% %+% < #. G$ D <9#, ,-- -- +- $-D D ,2@-D"#-D.+G,-.-,-:
&6: '),-$<'((8"-$$D% <,#.,,- $%# %-< '& ,-$< '((8 , !!!!!!!!!!" G -$ #D .--- # @$, + ,# B %-% D9-- D .- , $,-<+.-$#,--#+-:-#* $N+#.G,-"D.=;#,<:
&F: +-% B #%-$" . " , #,D # &8 -< '((8" *+ D !!!!!!!!!!#-EE-+$-D.---#@$,+,#B %-%D9--"-.-,$,-<+.-$#,--#+ -" -$ --E ,@ --- D. - #EE # $,# D ,-- ," + - @$, +" # B --#,#$--,-,<:,%D ---#%,#-#$,%@-#<-#,--"- D , #* D- # E<-% # -- @R -: " *+ D !!!!!!!!!! +- #%=B . # ,,- # ## # ,%%#- ,,- #-% # '4 $ '(('" A %-<- .+ , #.G,- - , =-E < # .-% +: .-,-",%-# 2-G$%-+-G .#$-- $*#+$<"D.%#- ,< # $,- #;- # .G$- B #G $*-" +- D. --%+-,$,-<+$@@- G <=- # .-;: -" %-% +% -@%>--% - #%$--+-% $,--: . ,- # - - =-#:
&): -- %- %-% $$D% - #- # '( -< '((8" - ;#%B=;:
+*
&: ;+S;-=#HJ%-%$#E%---%"#* &?-'((6" <-#"$,%#)=;" #-,%#--+9,%#-"),,%--&8=;H-:&-: -)8 J:
-BS-#S%-#&8=;", <E%#% '4=+'((FH 1&6(&(8J"# ;+#,-%"&6E%+" #,---;-,$--- <-#
56(7'5'((8 985&&9 # %; B - =; --" " # S--- # S%-#+G=;:
': E$%$- B .-: )8 : & -: @: ' " < - # /--D#---,%+BS-:)8 #E%#%,-;%%##-##8-< '(((H JD--+BS9+#-%#&3=&3)3 H J:
$,%-,=;##S,*-%-<:
6: - -% +; & =+ '((6" -/- $#E- # $< #,- %; # #$ # : ,$-%",-#+D#-.,,D#-L--@%B$* #,,D*;,,<-+;$$-A E-=#D$-#%-$--,#-H 1&6('6(#:&:&O 66)#:&:'O 1&'3F#:&:'O 1&'4F84#:&"&'8&68 #: F< - %E%J: #- B - #-9 L- G$% ;##.#-,,%#=D.6&#%$<'(('-E-# +%;$--%;,*--#-H 1&6(F66#:&- %E%J: *;#,%#D-B .,,D- %+#* = # -% +; H 1 &&4 36 #: 8<" &&' 68( #: FO &337T64,:6&8#:6<J:
F: -=-%#E$-#%,-,"-+<H-:)8 -8( J:
): .<=-#-;-B#%-$-EE#.---B-% +- #- B # ,-- # .9+#-%" , ,-*$- -:
8: S-: F " .+#-% ,- %- #. E$-% ;%-" #. $# #. #-: S+#-% - %,-% + #* DS -" , --;+-%",,B+#-G,----#%-:
G -$ # .-: 7 : & - 6 " - %,-% +#-% S,-% # ; -- ,- D - ,%$% ,$- # ; #%: % $=DSGU-,#S-+-%-++-#SL----#-% ,@2D$--#-,-L-G;%DSG--%,-% +#S---$,L@#S$,-+G@<-:
- %,-% ,-% # -+ -- ,-" -- ,-" # S,--# # S%B$,#,E#$#S-+-%-+D,- L-<$-L-G;%#"--,-%-#-%,@2D $-: #S,-% # -+ # ; #%" S-+-% D ,- L-
56(7'5'((8 945&&9 G;% # ,- + #S - ,E #S - #$ #S-+-% H-: 8 J: - %,-% ,-% # ; -- #$- # S$< #S ,- # ,<-% # ; # S% $@% # -+%D<%D-#%-"--#$-%-#S--- B -% ,@2D $- - DS ,- ,* --$- - $#%#,--G;<H-:4 J:
.-: '7 : & # - +; =D. 6& #%$< '((6" .%#-B--*.-+#B88'56K$"B#$9 -.-+#B)(K$"BD-#-.-+#BF(K $O # ,%<" .% ,-" #.,* .-: '7 : &< " ,%-#B#$9-.-+#BF(K$:.-%+;# F*$ %+ # $#E% - # .-: '7 : & -E B .%@$-#--G#.+#-%: D.--*%-- #%,+-B%#*D#;%#.+#-%--;-88'56K" ((--#,-,%+-#%$#.-2-9D-#-B% ,%--#;%#.+#-%#.$8(K---*B#- -G - ,% B 4(K" #- -+ B .- #. D- #. #$9- #$- @;%: +@" ,, #%+,,% =D. , =,# $-* #.%+- # .+#-% +- +#-%"D-.$,# #F*$%+# H 1&6(6F7#:6:FO 1 ,<%#&4$'(()"45()"#:'" #8,-$<'((F"'F35(F"#:FJ:
@R % -E" #;% #.+#-% #- L- %+% < #. $, # +: " + D .% - , <- . .%-- , +# - $,% + D. ,- <- GU- .-+-% D ,- <$- L- G;% # ,* --$- - $ # %#,--" $@% # -+ %D<%: $, # +.EE-"*;#"@EE-G-$-D,< $--##G+- E--. +.-"#EE% ,$--- # -G #.+#-% H$%-@# ;%% # $, # +O 1&6(6F7#:6:F"&'76(#:&"&(F&68#:'- '<O=D.6&#%$<'(('P -:'7:' O#&=+ 6& #%$< '((6P-:&:& %-+.-:&8 O#,&=+'((FP -: '7 : ' %- + .-: &8 J: ,%# B $, # +" +- # , $$- # # #- B -O + + - +#-% #+- L- #%-$% , ,,- B $L$ $$- - $#E- # + ,-< #.E #- B -" + =D. $$- A #% - #"#+-L-,$,-H 1&'3''6#:F:&"&'7&4FJ:
+ #.+# #- L- %+% +- -- E- # -- ,E *- # .-%%: .< #. + EE-+$-
56(7'5'((8 975&&9 %%"2#%E%G#%---D"-D.%--# DL---##.EEE%#%#---DH 1&'8 48 #: 6<5 - <<J: $ # D -- # ---D #+- L- %#-" #%,# # .$< # - , - ,E # ,- H$-- % @#," >;" % # +" --%5-%; #.-- # %= - -G #.,-J-%-#.%+-#$-#,+#.,,%-: #%#-;<$G$$#')K---D,$-#- $,- # #EE%- %%$- D ,+- E + #. -+-% -+HE: 1&'847#:)J:
+ # , +# #%-$ %-<- #;% # +$<,%,#%-D.-EE-+$-,%$$- #%-$- %-- < -% H 1 &'3 ''F #: F:6:& - %E%J: #- L- %+% # $* *- D ,< < D. +-" *; ;%%" # %E% # D .% <- +-.---B-%:
4: ,+#;%#.+#-%".#$--H=;".2 J<##$-D.$%#"%+-$-#.-,%-" #+-E:->@#$%#-B,-=;$-.%--# -%-B#D#D$-,D-+-%.%-,< # -+: -" #% $%# --- %%$- - , #%-$D-+G-<$-G;<#,-#.%H 1 &')'8&#:F"&&)&6F#:'"&&F6&F#:6"&()&)7#: &J:
D+,<-#.,,-$%#"D-#%-$- .- D ,- -;G - E- .<=- #. %-# -%" D ,,-E##G$$,-"D.,%;$-#%- ,- G,$% , , G$%" D. - %-% %-< , #.$*"D#,-#-G-$%#-.,,%- #--$%#--ED#.G,-- #?$- $-+%: #$-" .%%$- #%-$- , + ,<- .-.;#$2#,+#%;-$$,,-$$ G,-" $ < - < - H 1 &') 6)' #: 6" &'' &8( #:&-%E%J:
-$--$L$,#,,-#.G,-%$-#. - #.<+- $%# # . H J 9 #- =,# #$ D .$,--% - .#%,# B .%;# # .#$-- - # .1 - ;-H 1&'6&4)J9-,,-$%#%-<, O--E" ;E,D.##+;#.,-$%## - $%#---" -#$* ;%%"%#$--+
56(7'5'((8 935&&9 +G,-:+,<-#,,-$%#G#-#- #- < ,-Q- .,,% ;# # -* G,% ,%%#$$- H#: 6:&O 1 ,<%#'F?-'((8"3675()"#:6:'J:
.;- # + ,<- # ,,- %-< , $%# ---" =;,--#--$,-#E-D".G,%"$%#---- ;%%$-"##-"B,#,-,,--# -#ED.-B#: "=,##, #,#G---E-,,%-D.B.,,%-#.,-% #-+,$%##E$H 1&')6)6#:6<5-%E%" &33)",:FFO &377,:)(F#:'J
7: .,*" !!!!!!!!!!" $%# ---" - EE # #+ --- B -% D .$,L@- --$- # -+ #, &7 =+'((&:---+#--"#.+#$%#---"#<*- 9#%,#-" .<%-%" .EE + @D G $$< E%-<%,@9=-+-$G-%+*:
,,- #% E: !!!!!!!!!! '4 $ '(('" !!!!!!!!!! E$% ,% #. <%,@- $,-- - #. < #.-%+%+*#.;#%-$%:,U---E, ,-%#-+#-:
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
56(7'5'((8 9&(5&&9 < # % *+ ,#- D 1!!!!!!!!!!" E#- -- # ' $ '((8" ,% - - #;- % B # $-E ,2@9G" # -< #%,E %-" %,# - %+*: - !!!!!!!!!! - # ,,- # '& ,-$< '((8 D .<# ,2@;D # ,-- %;$- ,+ EE ,2@D %+#-: %%$- - # - B $-- #- + ,<- # # D-B.,-,2@-D:
E".;-#,<*$" <#%--D-" !!!!!!!!!!#D%D..+-,#.G,-,<#.-% +O.#$,$D.$-%,D.---# @$, + ,# B %-% D9-- - D. .- , $,-< + .-$ # ,-- # + -: .- ,% D- # E<-% # -- @R ,--" D $,-- .%+- # #;% # $+2 #%,# # %-- # -- ,2@,@2D: " !!!!!!!!!!" # ,+- L- $ < D %-% # $+ $,%@ # ;" # $- # -< 9 ,2@;D %: ,, , D #* '((& +- $$#% %+- 9,@-$;D" E$ #.G,-" # + # E: !!!!!!!!!! # M%-<$- @,-M: " E - # -- D. G,- 9,2@;D - 9,@-$;D . %-% EE-%E#E--#,-#+#.-%",-- #%-$- .;- # ,-% # -+ G;<: #-" .-$%,+---#=-#$##-"< ##$-$%#GE;-#:
+#D,%*#"#$-+2%B.-$%E D.$--N+G,-9,2@;D-9,@-$;D" ,#+#%:
-" D <-- ; # " #- B #$-% B -- # ,-,-BE-#%,"EG%.B&(((E:
VVV
56(7'5'((8 9&&5&&9
3+*2 *) + ) + *
450-- 6 7 89 '&% + :
0-
&: %+<:
0
': .#$--#%#'4+'((8-''='((8:
6: + B .-$% , -- $,%$- # #%--+#%:
F: #$ .-$% B ,2 - $$ # &((( E: B -- # ,-,-BE-#%,D.BG#$#-:
): .%$$-"EG%B'((E:"-$B@;#. :
8: E$ ,- # DS ,+- E$ - ,%- L- # #% # 6( = #* -E- ,* # < E%#% H @WR@ED8"8((F J",+#$-*##- ,<"E$%$-G-:7'#E%#% <E%#%#&4 = '(() H 1JO $%$ # #- #D " $-E - $2#,+-,-;-#-#$#-O#- L- #% < E%#% , + ,- , + %-D G #- # .-: F' 1: ,%- L- - ,* , # -"+D%$$$2#,+"#+-L-=-B.+: ;EE* ,%#- 2+ I C
,E$#,%-L---E%G,-DSBSEEE%#% #,;EE
56(7'5'((8