Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/185/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/185/2006 KI-generiert

Appellant's Disclosures on Trust Assets: Admission vs. Waiver of Privilege

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/185/2006
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)
Kostenauflage zulasten Vorinstanz / Staat

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The appellate court considered whether certain disclosures made by the appellant, who was a party to an ongoing financial dispute involving trust assets, were sufficiently specific to constitute an admission of liability or a waiver of privilege regarding those assets. The court reasoned that the vague statements and general references to financial arrangements, while potentially relevant to the underlying matter, did not meet the requisite standard of clarity or specificity to be interpreted as an unequivocal admission or a knowing abandonment of legal protections concerning the specific trusts at issue, thereby affirming the lower court's finding that no such admission or waiver had occurred.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Appellant's Disclosures on Trust Assets: Admission vs. Waiver of Privilege: The court reasoned that the vague statements and general references to financial arrangements, while potentially relevant to the underlying matter, did not meet the requisite standard of clarity or specificity to be interpreted as an unequivocal admission or a knowing abandonment of legal protections concerning the specific trusts at issue, thereby affirming the lower court's finding that no such admission or waiver had occurred.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Haftungsprivileg Verzicht auf Entscheidbegründung Trust Streitgegenstand Vermögen gesetzliche Auskunftspflicht

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to rule on the procedural costs of the appeal.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the assignment of costs for legal aid.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

     

   

#$%&'#())* +#',*#())-

+

! +! .+"  !. ".

./  '

 (' 01 ())-

  

 !!!!!!!!!! "

"

##      #    $   "./ % "&" '($  )" +,$ -*--    *

            !" 

3 *01 3

 2+

-4  !!!!!!!!!! 5" /"  *+ 6 *((' 7 588 " % 5.) 93):  ; "  "/ 5" %5%."/ % 53<=.> %:  - ?" *(('4   %@/ 6 "6/  %   6 %  /"/ A!!!!!!!!!! # 93):  /"/; % - ?6 *((,  ,( ? *(('4  6" /"/ / )  .)B  *C 6 *((' 6 88"  ,( ? *(('

) %  /.@4   )// @5 /"" "  >" % .. 9 ;  "" @5%."" %  /"/$ "" %  >" %6% %)  * ?" *((-4  6" 8./  .)B$ )  % *D 6 *(('$ @5 %/." %  )" %5%.""4

5)"   5 )%" /"/ %/ @5 6 *((24

#  8. .) )  . % ?" 7 6.& *((' "  """" % > "./% B "6$  " )) @ 5"// 6"

"6/ ): %  /"/ %"  )/% % "=4

*4  %/ % -1 %/.& *(('$ 5  ?"/  %.% %5%."/$ %/" @ %"  %E  )//%"  )"$ 5"// 6"

"6/ )  /"/ %"  /"" 7  8 5.)B/ " 5%.""$ " ) @  6"  " "/ 7 "6$ ):  ."$  > "./%4

,4 5"//  8./ ))" 7 %" %/  -1 ?6 *((24   E)@/ @

3 F?   ) %."" % "" /"/ 9<> @ ?56 )"/  % 5>>." ) &" . .);$

3  8" %   %" 5>> @  /"/ @  %  )" % "" 5 ) 8"  /$

3 .. 7  ?  5  /"/ 8"$ ?5/ %"."   ) %.% . %"$

3 ?  )6 ) 8 %588" % > "./%F4

'4 # %.% % 5 $ 5"//  )%"  E"" % .)" %6% % "" ): %   % .)" G 3  $  @   /"/ / %  /"/ % 8/6 7 %/.& *((* " % ?6 7 %/.& *((,$  %  /)$ B" "6/  @"/ % .)"& 7  % *(H )  /"/ % ?" 7 "& *(('$  @  ):36& % 5.&/ >// % " %  /"/ %"/ % -2 . *(('$  >/$   % @  6" 8./  %/. % )" %5%.""$  !!!!!!!!!!  /%"4

0,1+-0*((2

3 ,01 3

  )  )// @5 6" )/"/ 7 "" 8% +DH % " " @5 6" /%/  "  %  %/. %  8" %5%.""4

5 5" >/ ): %  /"/ I!!!!!!!!!! #7$ 8% %  /"/$ "  &"  8." @  5"//   /)  )/%"

) %5" %  /"/ @ 5"// 6" %/" 7 "" 8% ?@5 -D . *(('4

24  %/ % *1 )".& *((2$   " >6 % <=.>  )"." %. 5))" % 5"//$ %/" @ 3 )6"  6 6  %" E %."/ 7 .)" % *- 6 *((2$ B" /"/ /"& @5  %/"" ) 7 "" %" % )")" 8: %  /"/4 """

 6< @5):  ." )  /.@ 6 88"  ,( ? *(('$  6" "/ 7 )6  "6"/   % %" /"/  > "./% 7 ""  . ?@5 6.& *(('$   8./ @5  )6" ) )/"% 7 5%."/ % <=.>  %  )"  - ?"

*(('4

C4 5"//  "?"/   *C "& *((2 " %" %/4  :6 @ 5"6"/ "./% @5  E/ ): %  /"/  /"/ 88"/ 6  "." % 5 4  ""  %& @"/ %5.)B " %5.)B/$ >" @  /"/   6" ?. ))" )@  " %/" 5/"" 7 "" 8%4

14 6"/ 7  %/".$ 5  "/>." )"/ %  %/  ))" % *1 )".& *((24

D4  )" " /"/ "% )  & % /  ,- ?6 *((C4  "  )// @ J

F /"/  /"/ //  ?" *((- ) % . ."%" " .3.K.4 5 )/)/  )?" " E 5" 8/4 5 %L )"  .%" %5%."" ) @5 6" @ ? ) >> . )&"/4  "" % "6 5 /"/  @  - ? *((* ) @ ?5/"   &//8 %5 %/3% % 53<=.> 9> "./%;4  /"/ ?5  "6/  6 %  /"/ %) 8/6 *((*4

  "< %3)"</"4  /" %E 7 "6  @"/ % "<$ 5" ) /""  &//8 %5 %)=.$ ) .4

 !!!!!!!!!! /""  )/"" % "$  /"" />."

5 %  /"/4 5"  @ 5)" %  >" %  /"/4  . "" % >  %." .)""4 5"  @ " %/%/ ) E.) % 5>>." % ) ))/."4 5  . ." 7 % "."   <E %  )$  @"/ )84

0,1+-0*((2

3 '01 3

 ?" *((-$ %" %  /" %  /"/ 7 8/6 *((*$ ? 5 E/  "6"/   %  /"/4  8"  5E"" )  /."

9) % E$ "4;4

): . ." ?5 "/ 7 "6 )  /"/ .. "<$ .  > "./%4 56 & % " .) ) @ ? <" &"  %)=.4 5  "6/  ) . %5 .3".)4 5" ) 5 ) /"/ /$ ) @  /"/ 6" & %5 "< %)=./4

 6   %  %/.& *((2$  !!!!!!!!!!$ !!!!!!!!!! " .3.K.4 5 <"/  &" %  /"/ " ? .  .

7 . .)" %) ?6 *((C4 5 7 )/" %5" " @   /"/ A!!!!!!!!!!4

"  .." M ?5 %/ . %/. .. %."" 96 *(('; "

 %"  >" % .. 96 *((2;$   .5 ) /"/ %.%/ % > % %." )  /"/$ "" .)." ) @5 5B  6" ) &4    )  @  " )/   %/ /"" . "6" 6" %L K" ) %" "" )/%4

 E)" .5" %.%/ "  "//) @ ?5 %/ 7    *' . *((2 %)  /"/4  5/.> 7  .."37 ) % <=.> " ?56 ../ 7 "6 )  /"/ 7 ) ".)$  ?@57 %/.& *((2F4

+4 # @    /"/ >%/ 7 ?>4

 "+

-4   >6  N>" ?% 9;  /"/ .%8/ "  ""/$ %:  - L" *((,$  & " %  $ .)/ % 2 ?>$ %"  )/%" "  63)/%"$ 2 ))/" " -C ?>  9"4 - "4  " 2C ;4

#" 7 N" % N/" % -C ?> $ )  & 8/%/  *1 ?6 *((' 9 G -,(  -(C;$  %  >6  %)"/$  -, 8/6$  %)" "" >" )."""  & " %   % />   7 " ?> ""$ $ % N""" % N/" % 6E ?> 4

*4 8./." 7 5"4 2C  4 - "4  <4 D $  & " %   O"  " @ % """ )/6 7 N"4 2C

0,1+-0*((2

3 201 3

%   8/%/   )" >// % %" %   % C "& *((( 9 ; @ " "6 7   8/%/  N3<=.> &>" " N%."/   %N6&"/ % *2 ? -+D* 9 ;4

# .)/" ) ?> %  %N): "  /"&4

"?"/ %  %/ " 8. />E$   " 6& 9"4 2C " C( 9 P # D,(4-; " '+ 4 * %   >6  .": % <=.> 9#  * *(;4

,4 5/  %" 7 5%."/ % <=.> 5 "  .)  )"."  .) 9"4 D 4 - "4   ;4

E ". % N"4 ,- 4 , "4   $ N" ) %" 7 N%."/   % /%" % N< % "6$  ) @ 8E"  %/ @ )% N.)B P  )6"  8 %/&." P  @"/ %N/$ % ..& %N> %>" % N")   % %/"" %N )")" 8: 7 N")4

#  ?)%$  "6 @ ?" %N "" )8 .)& 7  %N .)B N ) %" 7 N%."/ @$ & @ / 8.." )  ")$  " 7 )%  %/ % N.)B  8 3 % .: %/"."4    "$  88"$  %/"" )  & %N %)"  N%."/ % <=.>  />.""  .": %N%."/   % /%" % N< % "6 9 G -*,  *,';4 " />%$  E"  /"" )/. "  %" 7 N%."/   % /%" % N< % "6 "  %" 7 N%."/ % <=.>4  " %.  :> >// @  ) @ "  %" % >" %6%  %"  )")" % N") N/:6 7 *(H  )$ " /)"/ ) EQ"  8   %/ % N.)B 9  #   (-0+*$ )4 ' R -C;4

 .)"." % N/ @ / 3.K.  ))" % "6  "" @ / P ""  6"  )" %N.)B P " @ )/"% " 7 % %."/ % <=.> 8 % ." % )/% % %88"/ % N") " % )6 )% "/."  "6"/ / %  ") @ " %NE"$ .."  & % %"    @N "  />.""  N%."/   % /%" % N< % "6$ @ E" " "/> % ) %  % B" %" 9 -++D$ R ,$ )4 D;4

"  )" 6/   %N/ %)" %N )6 / %  /"/ @$ ) % ." ./$ <<" 7 &" % %."/ 8 % ."  6  /"/ )%"  )/% /.@." %884

0,1+-0*((2

3 C01 3

 "" "  6< %88/" @  /  "6" %  )" .& 7  %N .)B @"" %/8"6." N")   %  8." % 3 S  )    " ) %N .)"." 6" 7 /%  & 84   6 % .K. @% N") " %NE"$ . @N " /$ ) " % /" %  ""$ .)" %/8"6." ""  6  /"/ 9 G -*,  *,';4

'4  5):$ 5"//  /"/ %."" %  /"/ %)  * ?" *((-4   %@/$  % 5% % .)" )$ @5 6" /"/ 7 5> %  /" % 3$ 6 % . ."%"4 % & .K.   5)" ) %"." %  >" %  /"/$ 8 " % "" @ 5"

 @$   @"/ %5%."" @$ "" %  >" %6%$ >"  %." .)""4  " 6 @  "" 58." %  ."$ %"/ % *C 6 *(('$  /"/ >/ )  !!!!!!!!!!$ )/"" % "4  5 " ) . 6 @5 6"   )&"/$ ""  .$ %58 % .: %/"."  %/ %  /"/4 5"// "  %  "/> % ) @ "  %& @"/ %5.)B " %5.)B/4

#  ?)% ."/$  )" %."" @  "" "

%88/"   / .)" %/8"6." ""  6  /"/ @ " %5E" ):  /" % ""4 $ 5"//  "6/ ?@5 6.& *((' )  /"/$  > "./%$ ) 7 ) ".) ?@57 %/.& *((24  O" 7 " />% @   %/ 6" %L K" ) )  /"/ ):  ."$ F  " )  @  " )/F4  " % %/" % 5"//$ "% )  & % /$ @5  @ @N  " >%/ 6  /"/ %  ": /""4 # )"   .. > %  /"/ " %/6 ) %/". 5 )  )" .& 7  %5 .)B/ 9K" % G --(0(,;S   %" % 5)" )." %5%.""  /@6@ @ 5/  @""/  /"/4   %" 5" "6  5): @5 6 *((24

 /@$ 5" 7 .)" % "" %" " %  . M   %/""

)  )")" 8: %  /"/$ @  %" 7 % %."/ % <=.> )" K" 6"4

  %/  ))" %"3 K" 8./ "   ?"/4

0,1+-0*((2

3 101 3

 . "+2  +! .+"  !. ".



340   5  6   78 '-( "9

  0 

-4 /   6&4

 0

*4  ?""4

,4 " @  )/% " >""4

'4 8.  )" %  @N )6" 8.  "  )/" K"

%  %/ % ,( ? %:  "8" ) ) ..%/ %/  & 8/%/ % $ #<TU<8@ C$ C(('   $  " E.)4  %/  )" K" )>/4  ./. %" J ; %@ E"." @ %/  " %/ &"   " ) %  %/ ""@/S &; E) ) @ ."8  ". )6 %.% "" " %/S ; )"  >"   %  )/""4 #  ./.  "" )  " //." /.//  "" ; &; " ; 3%$  & 8/%/ %   ) ) "  .":    @N %6 %/ 6&4  ./. %  ."   .B % )6$ @ " ?"$  @  %/ ""@/ " N6)) % @   /"/ E)/%/  " 9"4 -,*$ -(C " -(D ;4

 >88:  /%" J

3  V  W   

 ) 8. % )/" K" " "8/ E )" "  #/"" %N "" 7 N/. )  >88 

0,1+-0*((2