Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/176/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/176/2004 KI-generiert

Property Costs Obligation Superseded by Separate Agreement Dispute

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/176/2004
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The case involves a dispute over an obligation for costs arising from a property transaction where an initial obligation was superseded by a subsequent, separate agreement concerning a different matter, but the original obligation was not explicitly waived. The court reasoned that absent a clear and unequivocal release or novation of the original obligation, the subsequent agreement dealing with a distinct subject matter did not extinguish the prior, unambiguous contractual duty regarding the transaction costs, thus affirming the enforceability of the initial cost obligation.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Costs Obligation Superseded by Separate Agreement Dispute: The court reasoned that absent a clear and unequivocal release or novation of the original obligation, the subsequent agreement dealing with a distinct subject matter did not extinguish the prior, unambiguous contractual duty regarding the transaction costs, thus affirming the enforceability of the initial cost obligation.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
vertragliche Pflichten Sondergut Streitgegenstand Lastenbereinigung Abzug für Liegenschaftsaufwand Erwerb von Grundstücken

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposes costs on the appellant for the federal court proceedings.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

         

    !"##$!$%%$ !"#&!$%%'

(

) *+) ,  ) ,*

 "-  $%%'

./  0 1





23333333333 )+       

 



* , 4,*  , *,  !"#$%$$   %& ''()  

                  

   *%+,* 

 5*

 $-  .)'' . $  (/ %""%#  '  01' . (' 2'*3  '4  '5')  67777777777  .)(  8) %""$ )/'  ( .9 : ' . '' ;+ + + # 5' .8.('''# (('# (.# 5' . <'# '  ')= (' : >?, " 5-  (  .9 3 30( 8)1'@:':%? ,,5>"- .)('(A'' '5')%$9%""%-

%-  ' . $ / %""%#  /  B'') 8'.0   ()C'D. ((''.('3.8* 1'' @  ( )() : ' . 5' . (('# : 1'&""5#)0@)')''.C0 '''1:/'5/1')'.31 0))./))1-<'@)@.)'.95'@8'1'.9 C0.5'.'' 800): .)('.)'. .)''('-

- 1') :  #  '# .  )1' . %  / %""%#  5' (@@8%""$#''1')))0'3(E)1.  @ '  '' 8)' 55'1( (')  %""%# ' '1'  @  1( ' .'5-  ' <'@ @8  /'0) . 8)0').'(155'')@8.@ 5  51 @' '  .(.)# /' @8 ' '/ < /3( )/-

>-    )'@) @  )')  5' . (('# . &"" 5# )'<'5.:E#.%?,&F5-

G-  '  5' (@ @8  1'   '( . (('1'.':@855'')@'5''E 

+$,,%+%""% * +,* 

'''.5'.(('- .(.. '/# '  .'  ' . $& 5)1' %"">  H'5''5 . ((' .)- 1)@8')0').(()()  ) %""$  %""% 1' )) E)# E ('  .'1 (('  (.-

!-  '/ . )   .(.)  / 8' ('' (0)   - )'1-

 ,*



$-  ' . $> 1(/ %""% (.'5'  ' 01'  80'' H.'''2I %"G4#)1'0$9%"" #'') '/  .  '   ' '@# ((   ''1:'5).)8*1''2'*3 ;I 5--$#-G!-$#-C-$4- 5()(:8- - . .''' '' .  ' . $>1(/ %""% (.'5'  #  '.'18)1'0.')')..1  ((''  .   ('3 .8*1''  )) ('.855' '/.'-() . '/.).)/'-

%-  ' 5).)   ' 0)) . .' .  ' . !/%""" 2 4  )  1'0  $ H1' %"" # J . (/ (.'5'' .  .(' . 8*1''-   .83 .( 5' )0'   .'''  1'0 H@8 $.)(/ %""%#  )0.  ''  @  H0 .  '8:.'.)'(.'5''..'.8) . 5' )' :  . .)(' .  .)'' ''0' 2 K $%,  >!,# '.-$# $%$  F!# '.- $/I 5- )0( .''' ''# 

+$,,%+%""% *>+,* 

-F%-$  4-  )''0 )@<('): ('3 ..'''.'8*1''.30(1'0 H@8 $ .)(/ %""%-  .''' )0  .3  ') . '-

-  '/@#'H)('#2-F> ;4 1/5(-

>-  ( . '' . 8  )- ; .( ''0'  @'.5'.<''():8)-

 -  ''  E) :  ' . ('   (E# C@ (' * 1' C@ '( '  (E 8 @  . ') 2- > - $ -  . 30(  8*1''  1'1 L ;M4-  '' .   )'. . '(  <'0'/ : 8<'' .  )'.  .'1 = E) .  .'< H '1 2- >-> ;4-

 /- 8' , ') $  ; )1'  '/'')   ' . ('.8.<.E''@' 1(.)('5<''''.  .)' '#  ((' )'  '('  .)' )('.$":%"H- 1.8')%.(=(.'''# (('J<.$":%""5:C0.8'))-

G-  83#'5'<):&""5<.)'. .''%""$-;((')).)#%"( %""$ 25)1' %""$4# %  1' %""$ 2( %""$4# %$ 9 %""$ 2H' %""$4# $&/ %""$ 2(/ %""$4# %" 1(/ %""$ 2/ %""$4# $>.)(/ %""$ 21(/ %""$4   %% H1' %""% 2.)(/ %""$4# 'C.8 )((.$""5-;8E H'(('



+$,,%+%""% *G+,* 

 (. .8. . $"" 5 C# '  * . '.'.8)%""$-

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

 -   )')(    83- O0) . ((' '1 '@(C@('#'):8@'.(. 1 .-   ( . <#  '/ . )  .81' @8' 

+$,,%+%""% *!+,* 

''.''))0.:H'.. K   ('3  @8'   H'5' ( .  ).'-  1 . '.)'  .  H'. @' )3.#  0'5 '1@)   813'5.)-

6 6 6



+$,,%+%""% *,+,* 

  ,*5  *+) ,  ) ,*

 78   9 : ;   :<= "&$ ,>

 : 8  $- @1/I

 8 %- HI 

- 5(  ' .  @? 1 5(    ) H0( .  .)' . " H .3  '5''  ' ((.) .)  '/ 5).) . # ;CP'QC5@' !# !"">   #  ' <('-  ()(' .' R 4 '.'@ <( @.)''.)'/''..)''@)I /4 <  @ ('5   '( 1' .(.   .)''I 4   '0 .   .  )- ;'  ()('  '   ' ))( )())   4 /4  4 '* .# '/5).).('3  @?' .1 .) '1/-  ()(' .  (' (E.1#@'H'()('?'?0'.'3 ' . - ; )0( H'  ()('  .)'' @)  ?1 . @   )) <).')   2- $ %# $"!$"F4-   055'3R  )'.R

'KK S'; S

 



 ' 5( . ) =  '5') < '  : 855' 5).) . '055



+$,,%+%""%