Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/1367/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1367/2007 KI-generiert

Service vs. Sales Tax Classification of Custom Installations

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/1367/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The case concerns the proper classification of specific service transactions for tax purposes, specifically whether they constituted services provided to the client or sales of tangible property. The court reasoned that the transactions, which involved the creation and installation of custom components where the ultimate value rested in the intellectual design and specialized knowledge rather than the mere physical materials, were predominantly service contracts, not sales of goods, thereby falling under the service tax provisions rather than the sales tax provisions applicable to tangible personal property.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Service vs. Sales Tax Classification of Custom Installations: The court reasoned that the transactions, which involved the creation and installation of custom components where the ultimate value rested in the intellectual design and specialized knowledge rather than the mere physical materials, were predominantly service contracts, not sales of goods, thereby falling under the service tax provisions rather than the sales tax provisions applicable to tangible personal property.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Dienstleistung Steuerliche Vorschriften / Steuerrecht Wert der Umsätze Liegenschaftssteuer Mobiliarvermögen Speziessache

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the ordering of court costs, which is explicitly mentioned in the dispositive section (Order 2).

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



           !"#$$!%&&' !(#)'*%&&'

++

,- +./-      , -+  . 

01  #  %2 1  %&&' 



 !"#$%#&  && " "# '%#(#") "& 

 #"

* +  ,&"&" -- .  &#&%

                 

   63/26  

,-  3 .

%#%$&#&7&##--"#-8 !#9"3440:

 !" %&&   3 ;$&" 3442 *  +   ""6&#  & <& = !"##& $<<#1-%9"3440 #&<>#" 97&## 6=###'%#&#!"#& &#%$&#:

" !! &#& ?;&3442'""!"#&# %"& ='"% ### >  ##&# =  #%  ## "&@" %#&#  "#&   &#% ! ""%7&&7 &!"@,>&# &#;>'-8"3442 A&#!1-%9"3440B:

&&'" "'"% "&9# " & ""C#-4 # 9"344? <&"%%&& '"":

  "&9 <%%"  " && =   # "    ""C# #%  33 <%$"&"3445&" "'"%%;D# .#%&&  " !! &#& ?;&3442#"$ E%='""6&#=,"D! "  "&"  !" %" =  &#"#&   !%#&" #  ""   $ %&& :

!" ""&"3-;&3445'""6&#!" ! %='"%  #" &7!"#"  D&#&!"&" &! "!!" 9#& >#& &" >&"&#"%=&">'"%! "#"&# , &7:

!" ""&"8;&#3445'"%!" ! %#" &#"7!"#='""6 &#:

 &6& &  "%!  !" ##"  -- !#9" 3445 >' '7  &  $&##&!" ! %#" &#" :

!" ""&"32!#9"3445'"%&&>%='"">'!"&#&#     $ &"  % '  7!"# #& %     ""&"  8 ;&#3445:

 !"  ""&"  8 # 9" 3445 '""6&#  "!!% = '"% >'& &#"$&#   "D &&#"#&< ,"D% '7%#"   & '#6=6&" # "&#% #" &"&D#  !" %": >'&   ##% > '"% '$&# <&# $ &"   #&<"%#&  &&&!#&<#%%<&$" 7!"# !" ! %: >'&   &%"% >   " F  7!"# !" ! % "!&&# = #&<#&  # #  7&D !"###    &%""   7!"#&!"#&7&'$&#!= &<&" , &7:>'%<&&#&$&$&#%&%  <&"'7!"#&" :



/0122/3445  61/26   !" ""&"-5 # 9"3445'"%; &#'""&G<&"!"$&"  &#!##& '7!"#" ,&""D&D"%%!" . &#=&  #&<&"%&& < "$&&#& $ &#%&" "G:

 !"  ""&"  8  $9" 3445 '"%  &&  "&9  % ' G" "G #='#& G%&& 8 # 9"3445G#= &#&  '!%&&#, &7! "!" %"=7!"#&" ,&""D&:

 !"  ""&"  8  $9" 3445 '""  &&>% $ &" #%  ":

 !"  ""&"  -2  $9" 3445 '"" '#  #" %# % !"@  '"%  " "  #  $&# &&  "&9  %  &D# >    ""&"8 # 9"3445 #&#&##%&& #>'%& &$&#%#%&!"#&:

 !"  ""&"  -?  $9" 3445 '"%  &< "%  "&9  % > '""$&#G%%&& 8 # 9"3445G#" $%&&  #8 $9"3445:>'7! %> ""&">&"%'""  #  8 # 9" 3445  #&#&#    #  %&&  >'  ! $&#  &"'% "%&14; "&#"$&"#>%!=,#" -'244<"H$&# &C#" %:

.,+   ,+.

  < "%#='"#H2?H-#H,H2 &D$ &"' "D&#&  ;&&&"AB "&9# " & (#&#&>  ###& !"%$=I"#&2? &<%%""!"#&D%%"" &#  "  &  ? # 9" 3444 A B "#&$ =   & <%%" " I"6&#34"-8J-A B:

 !%# "&9%#@ "%#9&:

 < "%#='"#H08H- '"" &#""!"%"&#%&&  >& ! "## "  !"##&  "%  &; #&  &! "## $ > '&#%"%'#!' ":

 #& %&& '## #< &!%<&& :

'  ""! !#= #& %&& '"#H2 >& ! "#% D%%"  #&@" '"  & A$ &" !" 7! ) -34  108  &H39B:

   '"#H 2 H -    #  &%"%    %&&   "  '# "&#%'!@< %"" &#!9&<%%"E#! " 9;#KB  "%"   &<&"  '"  " &#   9&D#& : 9B   ##"



/0122/3445  60/26   '7&# '&7&#  '%#  " &#  ' 9&D#& : B  ";#"   %""&""$9##="%" &<&""  ##" " &## 9&D#& :

%&& &&#"#%"&>#=!"<&#>'#!"& " !" %"#>' #&#>'%#!$"%&& <&:

' D%%"  ! "# "  >#&   !" %" A " &# &&#"#&< $ H  3@ %&#&  & = ; " # D#% " 3443 !H 33?:  (#  L " %" &&#"#&$ " 3444 !H 3?3 H: "% . "&#%  " &# &&#"#&<$ H!HJ?JB:

  %&&  ' " #   !" %"    '"#H 23 H - & <&    #  %&&  &&#  #&@"  !" %" 7&$#    " "# &"#  #7# <"M& #   ## &! &#&  A$ &" & ))-88803?-B:>'=#&#"'7!%&& ' " #!" %"  #"&#& !"#&&"%&& "#&$= ##&  &"= !& !" %"="%#& ='&#;&&&"D"#&#  " %&& "#& $'%#9&#<&#:>'#%D##& % %&&  "   !%#    '"#H 12   A""   !"#& D%%"" &#" &N! &#< "# $ O 9& -/3441!!H35#0- #08B:

'& " "#   >& !"%@ >   ""&" "% = '"%  #  8 # 9"3445 & &&>#     '7!"# "# ! " !" %" =   7 "&# "# !  #&#"  %&&  I " #   !" %" & ## # >'""$&#< "#&&>%$ &" &#>&'#!:

'"%%#&# &#!&>'%='""!" ""&"-5 # 9"3445& #&<&"%&& < "$&&#& $ &#%& " ":

  G" "G &#";#%  8  $9" 3445 $# C > '""    &# =    ""&"  -5 # 9" 3445  &# !"  %># C#" %"% &""$9 <#%&& &&#< "!#&9" "H





/0122/3445  62/26  

 +  4 .3  +./-      , -+  . 



 5 1

-H %"" "&""$9H

3H &#>!" %"#D"#&#H

1H < "  !"#&   >I !$# < "" " "  #"  !"%# ""C#   %&  14 ; " @   #&<&#&  !"@  "&9 <%%" A.,P&Q", <>&??440  B!"$ &" "#&@"" &# !9& < "%#7"#HJ3 &<%%"" "&9<%%"-5 ;& 3442 A )B:  % &"  " "  &# &&>"   &   #&< #  E!"$#! "#"&D#"" "#  #&":& &# C#" "%  "&9 <%%" !" $ & ! #  !" $ & %#" &> 7  &#&   '"#H 03  )H  !"%# ""C# #  !&@  ! &   " "#&$ >%  E!"$ &$#C#"; &#='$ &H   D"<<&@"  !"%&#         &)) R"&.  R



 !& < "!"%#""C## #&<&%7!"#&&&>I=I<<&<%%" #%!9&>!"D"<<



/0122/3445