Late Witness Disclosure and Abuse of Discretion
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe lower court erred in allowing testimony from a witness whose identity was disclosed shortly before trial, as this prejudiced the opposing party who was denied adequate time for preparation and investigation; while the rules allow for some flexibility in discovery deadlines, the substantial surprise caused by the late disclosure of a key witness, coupled with the trial court's failure to impose remedial measures like granting a continuance, constituted an abuse of discretion that likely affected the outcome of the trial.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Late Witness Disclosure and Abuse of Discretion: The lower court erred in allowing testimony from a witness whose identity was disclosed shortly before trial, as this prejudiced the opposing party who was denied adequate time for preparation and investigation; while the rules allow for some flexibility in discovery deadlines, the substantial surprise caused by the late disclosure of a key witness, coupled with the trial court's failure to impose remedial measures like granting a continuance, constituted an abuse of discretion that likely affected the outcome of the trial.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertApplied for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Volltext
$%&'($'))* $%++$')),
!!
- !.- / -! /.
+0 12 3 %4 56 ')),
77777777777
. / 8/. 9/ ##-. !"#$%&''()*'+,'
! "#
1'/21
:.
*3 !#444444444445 .&-"*(((6 8 " .,&& --## 9## 6# 5##+ # #,#-3 6:# 9# -- ; < =6# .. -##1&.# ..9. , #9 #,> : *%&-"*((()%?#'%%% -## ..9. , #9 #, > : )% ?# '%%% '% ?# '%%) -## ,#1&.# ..9. , #9 #, > : '% ?# '%%) )*-'%%$&# -##,#1&.# ,#9#,> : + )* - '%%$3 6 > ?3 .9- -## , #9 #, > : !##,# 44444444444 ; &# '%?#'%%*<3!#44444444444##-- -##&.# #,#9#,> : &#'%?#'%%)3
'3 ##. , 55 )* .-" '%%) !# 44444444444 6 ## &+ 655# 6-&# ;#1&+ < ##. ,- 6# -#. @A-9>-& *?,#'%%$3
)3 .## *(5.,#'%%$6 ?. - -#5=6#.## & " =#. 6-&B 6-&B. =6# .# & .= #-&#" #5# =6# ,# .- & -&# = # .5###, #,#. 6&#& # 6#.. , #+ &# # &- "..5## 6 # -#.3
$3 6. 5-. .-# .## *( - '%%$3 :&#=. ,# & A #.. - '%%' &+ 9-#  .# .-#='%C # -##D5# &., #.E ##F3 .9. ,# .. ##. & # 6&# ##+- -## !# 44444444444 = A -?#. &# #.. ,# -"@6 -#!#844444444444#& 6.3 #.,#-# &,# .## #...9. & #= 6-&B. .9- ##,# ..##. ,#"..5##. 6# -#. @A-93
G3 6 #,#. 6. > 5# #, - -- 9# ## #..&# &+1," 6-".9.. ## 5# . ##- 699- !#8444444444443
03 6. .& & -9 .#= G ?# '%%$ =6 =6 -## ..9.#&,#& .## -
/*('0/'%%$ 1)/21 9# ##3 .-# 5#-. D @ =6# A# # #- # # #- & '%C &# #.. =6# 6,# &,# .## ,. 6## -?##F3 869# ##- # &.#. = # ,# .. .# . & & 6-". ## -# -#+ #. & !#444444444443
23 -9 *' ?# '%%$ 6. &.#. = 6 -## ?#5## & 5# =6# .# > 6#9# #.. =6# @## &., 6#-9 #+ -&# &+ &.# #55##3# #=.=#=6# .#&.#6-" &#-# =6 -## # # D> ,# -##-- 9#- 6## -?##F "# = # 5+ &,# .##3
H3 .##&&## *0?#'%%$&.-#5#-. .## *(5.,#'%%$3,.=6..#?,#1&.# -## #..,#9#,> :=6# .#'%C &# #..=#55##?#& > -=6#: #5 .##3 .. ,. = 6. ,# 6# -# =6# # -## 5# &., #.E ##3 #-=6#6,# &-&#,#.. # > # -#.#..#.35#..#9.=6-.# &#" , 6 -&B. ## #.. @= # > 6# -#..:-#.# #,# -5# @3
(3 # *G&-"'%%$6.#?. .##3 #-& = "#&E--# ##-"" > # -# # = 6 & 3 && 5# ==-&B. #..&&,=##-. .=#,=3 & # ,# &#"##. 6#5 ,. 6&# -#+ .-#3 & # # I44444444444 #= #-. #.-& & #.. # (J)0(53)%)% .-"'%%'38##,@& .. ,. '%%)3 .9- ?# &# 6:# -& # #,# ;.*'?#'%%$<3= ##,... *$'J$GH53&6.'%%'3
*%3 ,#. > & 6#. ##-. .& " '%%$ ? 3 && = 69# --" # 6 -### # 6 & .# .-# +- &"##. =6# : # #.. &#=6# #& : 9 6 &,# .-#3 -## ## -" .9#3 & 6#. ##-. 5# -= =
/*('0/'%%$ 1$/21 -&# & & ## #, > &.# ## -K#6&.-&L #K-#-&- .. -&"##. -- .3 = .#1 ## *?,#'%%')* .-"'%%)6.6@.#=?=6 -# ,-"'%%'# M-#3
!/.
*3 #9,# '',-"*($*69##? ###;N 'G< .. - #5#. ##. + * O '%%) #" #3-&. #=?9 &.# ,#1&.# #=&&.#M?9;3*3G0 <3
8#>6# 6.# ?9& #"5. .; 7< '2?,#'%%$; 7*)%*%0< #9,# &.*)5.,# #&## ## 9 ;3 *0' < &- 8 #.9 > # ?9 ## 6 6.# ,: ?93
'3 5-.- > J3 G0 3 * 3 @3 H 8 P # #= # &., > 6# G0 #, > # 5. . 'G?# *(H' 61@A-9 "#9# 6# -#. 6#,"##.; <38-&.&?9 6&+ ."#3
)3 ##9&&# ,##-&# ## #>J# -#. @A-9;3H3 <3
$3 8J3)*3)3 J& #>J# -#. . # J@# ,#&=#5#: .##=& J-&B1 &, #5 # ."- 1 =#. J#. --" J 9 ##9 J&# . J&####+ > J&#N # , -E- ?# & =# &. J
G3 E !3 $ &-" *((2 &"#. : 7 *') ')$ #"
5. . :&##. -#5 5 J&&## 9#= +9>J# J# -#. @A-93
J&+ ?#& ,#=#?# J##&5# -&"> J-&BJ& #>J# -#. @A-9= "#=##.5--&&### 5#: .## J-&B > #5 1# -#+ .-#3 #55 .#&"## J #&##J# -#.
/*('0/'%%$ 1G/21 @A-9.9-#-#+ J# -#. . # J@# ,#&##J3)*3)3 3
## ,@ #55. = #. , &## #-#" > J -&B =# .5###,- J&# # 5- 1#N &# # & J -&-,#>. #3, -E-= J&## J:# -# = #. & # .### -& .5###,-#,#..3-- JJ#.. & &##& &. # -#. @A-9 ; 7 *') ')H # 32"/""N8'%%* Q*$&&3$*1$'# 3'N '%%)Q''&3'$* # 3'<3
5# " &,#?# J&##9> J-&B,- # -#. @A-9>& # ,#..=#J-&B#&&P#9:# J&+35.-#&& ,-#5=#&.# .> :#93J9#, &-A & ,# - J-&#=#6 ##-# #>J# -#. @A-9 ;53 3 H 3 * 3 " <3 # A 5#- :." J9# J -&B. =# & ,# #1 = &#- # J , & -E- & & 5# ##9 =# "# = 5-- ##. &#, #,#. & -& #.. = ,##3 & &## &##+ & &, 55 : #5 & ,# =J "# =# ?- @A-9 #55##- A"; 7*')')(# 32"/""N '%%)Q''&3'$'# 3$<3
6 # -.# 69 ##9 =# .-# 6 5L 9#=63)*3)3 =#,#>-"" -&# "?#53 &## =6# 69# .-# = &#"##. 55#, 6 ##9 6#5 & .## 6 &##,# & -&&&#:#  ."# 6. &,# .## 5# #+; *((2/*((0&3''2<3
:&# > &##& & 7 --" # 6 -### # #& : 9 ;3 2*0 2*0 " < 6 &,# .-# 63 )* 3 ) 3 3 --" # 6 -### # : &# & E : =6# # .# .-# & +- &"##. =6# : # #..; 7*'''2)N 7 )/%) '$-'%%$<3 7 #-.=& ,#6.#&A"#.. ,# &,# . #.. &,# @@ > "#
/*('0/'%%$ 10/21 # -#. 5# -## ,# #.. & &.# .-#=- #55##& ##- #-.=6#6,#& #>6# -#. . # 6@# ,#3
7 .--6# &.#=6&6",..-- = # ?#& & " # -# "# #= 6" = &. .?> ,- 6# -#. > ,# ?# 6##-&"> 6-&B; '%%)&3'$%<3
88.# 6 >6.-#;8 <+99..#,# # . & =# # #9 # #,# &##&# 6.+,>'%C&--&:L #5 .## 6-&B;##R %*/('&3$Q*0<3
03 6&+5 =-,.'%C #-#=6#& -.9S -##,#1 &.# 1 #.. =# 6-&B# , -E- & D&., #.E ##F3 # 6,# &.#,6&#N-E-6# .5 &,#B:A &.& . # P # #- , ## # #53 6B 6&55#-- 6..-&- 6. &.-&#=6#&#B,#" -K:9 #& -B 6#55-# ,. #..=# 6##.3
23 .9 :# .#=#&.+ ?.3
/*('0/'%%$ 12/21
! /.: !.- / -! /.
;15 < = ># %(' /?
5
*3 .,"N
5
'3 ?N
)3 #=&. 9#N
$3 5- &# =6 &, 5- &. E .# )% ? + #5## & &# -- . . #" 5. . 8@T#M@5=# 0 0%%$ # :- .# & E &9.3 -.-# #U < # #= :-= .## .#"##& .## =.N "< :& & = -#5 # #- &,# - .##N < & #9 &.3 8# -.-# # & # ..- .-.. < "< < #1 #"5. . &&-#+=6# , .#,"3-.-# -#-B &, =# ?# ## = .## =. 6,&& =..:&. #.;3*)'*%0*%H<3 955#+U .# U #77 V#8 V
- &. E#5#.:.# 6 > 6.-#&955
/*('0/'%%$