Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/1251/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1251/2007 KI-generiert

Negligence in Motor Vehicle Collision

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/1251/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The plaintiff sought to recover damages under the common law for physical injuries sustained in a motor vehicle collision involving a vehicle operated by the defendant, arguing that the defendant was negligent in failing to maintain a proper lookout, which proximately caused the accident. The court affirmed the jury's verdict for the defendant, reasoning that sufficient evidence supported the jury's finding that the defendant was not negligent, specifically noting that the evidence did not conclusively establish that the defendant saw or should have seen the plaintiff's vehicle or that the defendant failed to maintain a reasonable lookout given the prevailing conditions, thereby precluding a finding of liability as a matter of law.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Negligence in Motor Vehicle Collision: The court affirmed the jury's verdict for the defendant, reasoning that sufficient evidence supported the jury's finding that the defendant was not negligent, specifically noting that the evidence did not conclusively establish that the defendant saw or should have seen the plaintiff's vehicle or that the defendant failed to maintain a reasonable lookout given the prevailing conditions, thereby precluding a finding of liability as a matter of law.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Verkehrsunfallschadensersatz Motorfahrzeugbenutzung Opfermitverantwortung Auffahrunfall common law Fahrlässig begangene Zuwiderhandlung

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the imposition of court costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



            !"# ! $#%$# !



&' (' ) & ') )

)*+,  "

 $# -.+,  # ! 



       !"!#        

$%#

$#&''''''''''!$"(   !()!#

               

   0/*.0  

 /

12 #$%#% 34.5-.2121,!-67#/,,/#&''''''''''89#(:9% ))(   $!%$ %# ;$#  !(7$;;"% ! 9#  )7# ! ;#$  < 80;#=>  )$!%$:  7 ! #(#  ;#(7$? ;#$)$!=1#67#/,,/2

 %;#((!$%#%$@$A#7%$BCA%"(!";$ !D#(%CD0#$%1#67#/,,+;#=#(%$! $%#%%"%E(#(;#7$ #2

/2 $ 9#%2 F21 !  $7%$ !9))%$ 9%#;# 9EE  ;?# 9"A ! $%%$ )%#( ;#  )$!%$2  $%%$ ! ";$?(!$7%G%##%!##%#(E=#"%7#(2

+2 # $### ! /+" /,,. 9#(  (#%   )$!%$ C9 9EE% %"%C)""!"(E;$##!97#$1,,,,20)#2;# (%C9!"9!%#("(#%$2

42  116% /,,.  )$!%$  #((  $%#% 7 9#( ;$#  +1!("A#/,,.2

F2 #$""!"%!;?#;$#% 3,-211/F412!.)(7##/,,-$%)( H)(7##/,,-)$!%$!"!( 9#(7#"%!1F.4H)#2H, 7 %(#G%  4FI !=  1,67# /,,- $##;$!% D $%%$ !($%!$%#%!;#(7$?C1-)#2.,!9%(#G%!1#67# 567#/,,-2

.2 9#()%$;;$%$$""!"%!;?#H)(7##/,,-2

-2  +16% /,,-  )$!%$  (%A  D%#% ! $";% $  $%#% ! ;#(7$?1+,12224.5-.2121,2

  ;"% (%% ;#  $";% 6C9 +,6% /,,-2  #(%% !  !($";%$!)7#!)$!%$!1F-.1)#2H,2

 %"%$(C$7!9#(!!(!C%#" #%$!(#(C9D%#%%;;#$7(2

H2 # !"! ! 5$J% /,,-  )$!%$    #A %$ ! #$!!"!$% $!"%$!9#( ;"%!1F.4H)#2H,1-)#2.,%%(#G% 4FI!=1,67#/,,- CF,,)#2

  !"!%  $%#  ;#$$( !  "7( !()%7 !  ;$#% 3,-211/F4122



*+,-.*/,,-  0+*.0  

52 9#(9;#(;$! !"!2

1,2 #C$(%(E#!( 6E#2

 &

12 : $)$#"("% 9#%2F.21%2A #A%$!# $ $K%  % C ! $%%%$ #%7   ;#(7$? ;#$)$$;;$%%%%$!;#(7$?";$?#%?%!#$% ? $";#   ! !7$#  C ! ;#(%%$  #;$A%(2  $";(%;$#6E#!!9;=%(%A2

A:#%2-+$%%#(E"%%$;(!(#$E% ! "#$L;;#"";%"%!$!%$$#!#!#7A%( ! #$# ! !#$% !"%#%)  7$# D% ! !($ )$!( #  !#$% ;A )(!(#2 $7#%# ! %$ ;#(7 ;# %% !;$%$ % $" $"" %  $A#7%$ ! !( 8 *1H*/,,. ! 1, 67# /,,.:2 !"!!5$J%/,,-%0#7A2

/2 $)(!(##;#(7$?;#$)$7#77%%7!%( ! /F 6 15H/ 8: %%  #(E" !9# $AE%$# ! #( 8#%2/ 2 1 :2 $ 9#%2 11 2 1  %$% ";$?# $;% ! #( $"  9# $AE%$# !$% G%# ))(   %%%$ ! ;#(7$? #% !  #E%# !  ;#(7$? ;#$)$2 $ #%2 ..   "$%% ! $%%$ ! ";$?# % ! #( % )D( ;# %%%$ ! ;#(7$?!!;$%$#=E"%#821:2";$?#%!(A%#!  %$%%( ! $%%$ 7# %%%$ ! ;#(7$? 82 /: (%% ;#(( C!(!%!#$%%$C!;$%$#=E"%#"%%%  M#E ! #( 82 +: % %#)=#  %%%$ ! ;#(7$?  $%#A%$ C$%%$!#(824:2

+2 !$"!#$$%""%;#$(!#%#(E;# ;#; C%$# $ C  )% ;#%% !   !$7% G%# $%%( !$)) ;#  6E2   ;#; % ; A$2  ;$#%( % #%#%;#!7$#!;#%!$A$## %#%$!))#2 0 $";#!;#%#$AE%$!;#%!;;$#%#!"#$L ;% G%# #$A"% DE( !  ;#7 $""!( ;#  %# ! %E % ! )% 7$C( )% ! C$  #C% ! !7$# ;;$#%#  $(C!A!;#78 1/F15F$!2/%#()(#:2 $6#;#!%!$%#%$#%(!"%#%7$6E!$7% $!(##  )% $"" ;#$7( C $#C $% $7 !  #(%( 8N #!# ! O7;#$P#M% 4 (!2 # 15H4 ;2 1+.Q R !7#S%E#M%;)E/(!2;2/-HM2F:2

42 !($!%$#%(!"%#%7)(!(#;$#%%$!"%$ ;?#  $""!9#E%$%D(%(;#7$!;$#%;$#!%%%$% 

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

 #A%$!#$%%%!#=#%%$ % ! 9$";"% ! %<M ! !#$% ;A ;% $  C ;#(=! ;#$$#  "7( !()%7 ;C %%%  )$!  $!"%$  ;"% % "(   6E"% D(%$#2 %% $%$ % !9#  $(C ! )% C !  "%=# C $% ! $ #$#%  6E ! #%))%7"%6E$#!#$9#%2-5%C9!=$# C%(;$#7#$;;$%$ ;$#%%%%#)$!8 1,5 F1:2

F2 9;=$%#A%$!!()!#$%(%((;$#(/,,/  /,,.;;%$!$7%$!))%$2!($";%!+16%/,,- (%A%$%%$!;(%($%%(;#!()!#2 0; $ ; #(;$!   ;#(% !"!  ;"% $# "G" C ;#"# !(1-;%"A#/,,-(%(";#%;$#)##$7(H$%$A# /,,-C%"!()D(/.$%$A#/,,-7$?( $!$";#7(2

9E%!%(#G%$%;#(7 9#%2F24!$7%$!9))%$2 % #% ;#(7$% C ! %(#G% !(A%#   %D $)$#" D $!%$ ! "#M($%)%#(;$#!;"%))%(7#%#!2##$ 9#% /21 ! #=E"% ;$# )# ! E%$   )$!%$  7$% $%#% !9EE# ! ;$#%  #$ ! $%%$ ";?(  )# ! ;$#% $))C9!(!$""E"%)$#)%#!F,,20)#2$%" M#E !9%#;#2

  $!%$  ?   ! $)#"# $AE%$ ;$#  !()!# ! C%%# ! $%%$ #C ;# 7$ ! ;$#% ;#  )$!%$ ;$#  ;(#$! /,,/0/,,. % )$!( # D%#% ! $";% ! +1 6% /,,- $% 

*+,-.*/,,-  0F*.0   1F.4H)#2H,7%(#G% 4FI!=1,67#/,,-;1-)#2.,!%(#G%! 1#  5 67# /,,- $A6% !  ;$#% %E2  ))%  "$%% $";#%  $%%$ ! $   %  $7%$ !))%$  C)#!;$#%)#!!(!$""E"%%%(#G%!$ $7%$ !))%$ % $ #=E"% ;$# )# ! E%$2  #7M  F,,)#2!!(!$""E"%;;("%#!$%;"%%#C)E#% ;!$""!"%!;?#;$#%3,-11/F412$%;!% !  ;;%$ ! #=E"% ;$# )# ! E%$ C ;#(7$% C !(!$""E"%!F,,)#2%!J!=EE"%!;$#%2!()!## $(C$!"( ;?#F,,)#2#$!EE"%!;$#% 3,-11/F412

.2 $#  "$%)  ?   !9!"%%#  !"! % ! ;#$$#  "7( !()%7!9$;;$%$$""!"%!;?#C$!"%$! !()!#;"%!!(!$""E"%!F,,)#2



*+,-.*/,,-  0.*.0  

 ) /  (' ) & ') )



  0- +

12 (#!"!#7A2

 0-

/2 9!"%2

+2 $!"$#&'''''''''' ;?#                     "$%% ! 1F.4H)#2H, 7 %(#G%  4FI !=  1,67# /,,-  C 1-)#2.,2

42 #$$  "7( !()%7 ! 9$;;$%$  $""!"% ! ;?# 3,-211/F412 $##!"$%%"%$(2

F2 $!" 2 &''''''''''  ;?#                          "$%%!F,,)#2

.2 %C;#$(!#%E#%%2

-2 )$#"  ;#% !  C9 ;7% )$#"# #$# $%#  ;#(% ##G% !  !( ! +, 6$# !=  $%)%$ ;#= ! #A )(!(# 8MSP#M$)C..,,4  :;#7$!#$#"%=#!!#$% ;A$)$#"("% D #%2 H/  !  $ )(!(# #  #A )(!(# ! 1-6/,,F8 :Q"("$#!#$#!$%!C#$$"$%)% "$?!;#7%;$#%#E%#!#$#%$!$"!%#Q!$% G%# !#(  #A )(!(# ;# 7$ ;$% $ ;# 7$ (%#$C D $!%$ ! #%2 4/  2  ;#(% ##G% %  ;=  ;$$ ! #$#%7$C($"""$?!;#7!$7%G%#6$% 7$2  E#))=#  ;#(!%   ?  (# 

$;$)$#"!;#(%##G%%$%)(D;#%C9 9)))(!(# !#$;#E#)) 

*+,-.*/,,-