Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/1104/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1104/2007 KI-generiert

Constitutional Supremacy Over Conflicting Revenue Distribution Statutes

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/1104/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)
Kostenauflage zulasten Vorinstanz / Staat

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

A litigant challenged the validity of several statutory provisions enacted by a legislative body following a referendum that approved an amendment to the state constitution concerning the distribution of certain revenues. The court reasoned that the constitutional amendment, which specified the allocation method for revenue derived from a particular source, was self-executing, meaning it immediately established the rule for distribution without requiring further legislative action. Consequently, the court found that the subsequent statutory provisions attempting to mandate a different distribution scheme were unconstitutional because they conflicted directly with the clear and mandatory language of the newly adopted constitutional provision, rendering the statutes invalid.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Constitutional Supremacy Over Conflicting Revenue Distribution Statutes: The court reasoned that the constitutional amendment, which specified the allocation method for revenue derived from a particular source, was self-executing, meaning it immediately established the rule for distribution without requiring further legislative action. Consequently, the court found that the subsequent statutory provisions attempting to mandate a different distribution scheme were unconstitutional because they conflicted directly with the clear and mandatory language of the newly adopted constitutional provision, rendering the statutes invalid.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Gesetzesänderung Verfassung Kollisionsregel Gesetzesreferendum Statut im internationalen Privatrecht Steuerrecht

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court explicitly orders the appellant to pay the judicial costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



           '()*('+,,- "'((,)'+,,-

"

 " "#    # 

./ 0 ! (, 1/ +,,- 



 !" #$# $ %

%

$$ & $   ' () %!"  

           ! "# $%  &! !

   #-*0#  

 $"

(1 "%"!2""3 4%% 4!5%!55 $6 !%7#589$ : 433% 4!5 7#589 : - "!2-..0+ "!2-..)1

-1 -(;-..)6%<%% 4!5%!55""=4" "2%%-/;-..)!!  258 4&5>""% ;=4+ "!2-..)1

?1  % %%  "  %% 4!5 %!5 4"  @   !2% +4.)+31).1

+1  ) "!2 -..) 4"  =   !%" ;8 58    'A!> $ 7#589:1

01  " ,;6-../#3"!%3=4"% 5 (- !  %6 ! < %%   ! B  46% 33%6!%%6"= -/;+ "!2-..)1

)1  " (-!-../;%"455%3!"54"< "5"%"1

/1 % ((6-../4"%%%% "%< %%<4%  !%" 'A!><!5% 0 "!2-..)1 3%64C% 4%% %6 8- "!2-..0%42>%  "% 4D%%8!% 52  " -+'%5"  %%1

,1 "5 -.6-../4%!"%;% 1

E1 D% % E!-../ 2 "5 4%%;=4< % 5"  *+.00*-..)5 % 6% 23" "% %52"!%=!1

(.1 D% (/F%-../7, (),*-../: 23" " !% "5"5$"%% 4%%<4"!7$ :<4% ;>!%  2  "  -/ 3"6 -../ 7 *+.00*-..) $*-.,*-../: % #1

((1    -E F% -../  2  " !!= 4D% 5"%"  % % 46% <  3 6   !%%     " "'"%(/5%!2-../1 %%""51





*(+,(*-../  #?*0#    #"

(1 3!"!% < 4%1 0) 1 ( %1  '1 ,    >6  4>% ;  7:  2 %    G%  % =  %%% 5"6 < H% 0)    3" "   5% >""  %     ) %2 -... 7 : = % %6<3" "H#'A!>2>%%H !%" H62%" -0;(E,-7 :1

$!5"%5;>  H58%"%21

-1 "5"   3! % " ">C   % 62 7%1 0) % ).  :1

?1  23" "I%%%"  *+.00*-..)I %% =5 4%% 5"%5" 53% 5  #1

+1  %>5% % %<4 !%" 'A!><!5% 0 "!2-..)1

01 H"  % < H !%"  'A!> %!!% H %  !5  5%!%  !5 7%1 , 1 ( %1     3" "  4 'A!>2>%%4 !%" 462%" -0;(E,-# :1 % "5%"  !5  = H% 5 5% <  55%  %6 % = ''<C%6%"<5%!57%1(.1( :1

 %<H !%" 'A!>55= %%6<5"  %%%""=H"%2""7%1,1(%1 :1

C%! 4%1(?1( %6> 8(;%-..? = !%  "# 5"6<%33%7%1E1?:C" % J !  !  %6%" ! < %% !5%   % %6<5"  %%1

01 $ 4%1 (+ 1 (   % 2""   % %6 <  5"   %%  5 =   !%  "#  % 5 % 5  J!%%H"%%55%<55% %6%H%5 5!5 %%6<5"  %%%!!% ! 7%12:1$4"%!5D'" %5 % "3"< J!%33!!% %!55 % "# 5=" 5"  %%33%7 $"%% H%%<H"!# $  # %6 < 4 !%"  'A!>   ;6 -..? *(-,:1  % C% % %"%42 5"  %%%4!5D'!% 4C%6%"!<%%7$ ;6-..?*(-E:1



*(+,(*-../  #+*0#   )1 458%"%"!2""3 4%% 4!5%!5 - "!2 -..0  + "!2 -..) ! 4  "%" %6"  6  4&5>""= -/;+ "!2-..)1

   5% D% !  2""3 4  !%3  2"%   % %6<5"  %%%5"%  %51

 4>% 8  "%!4C" % J!!%6%" !<%%1

/1  % ">    D%  (/ F% -../ 7,  (),*./:  2 3" "   "" =  %% 4!5 %!5 >" % 4" % 4%%  865"%"5$ 4% %C% !% 36 'A!=4%5 %C5%%  %=6%<  5!%%  %%  % C 5%% 5  2 4 %6%" ! < %% 4 " 33%  >   4%1 (? 1 (  1 %3 8  = 4" 46% 33%6!% %6" = 5 %  "3"<(-!!5%5 %5"6<4%1(?1(  1  %%    5"%% 5  %"%= 4 %%  %66% "2%33%3 4!5%"!"%6"54%% C>  3% 4 %6 455%% 2 5 <  5%%  4  =4<6"%5% 45%% %615"  4%%%  56%  D% 5   "%  %% 4%6%" ! < %%1

,1  458"%% %=;5 %5"%"I %% =5"  - "!2-..0-);-..) %=%4 33%6!%5%6"%D%5!5%!!%6%"!< %%15"  %%% 8 4 "3"<(-!  %=%45 %<4 !%" 'A!>1

"=5%=4D%;%"1



*(+,(*-../  #0*0#  

  #"$  " "#    # 

!

2/2.

(1 5 4%%  *(+,(*-../1

 2 3.

-1 "621

! 3

?1 ;%%1

+1 %=5" %>%%1

01 3!  5%   =H 56% 3!  %  5"% D%   "  ?. ; 8  %3% 58  2 3" " 7$'KJ'3=))..+  :56 !%8  % 523!"!%C%1,- 3" " 23" " (/ ; -..0 7 L:M  !"!   %  =   !%3 % !I 56%5%>% % ! %M % D%  "  2 3" " 5 6 5%  5 6 "%= C  %  4%1 +-  L1  5"% D% %  58  5  %6="!!!I 56 6%D%;%<461  >338  5" %          &  $ I       

 5 3!  5"% D% % %3" C 5%  =H $"%% 4%%<4"!5>33



*(+,(*-../