Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/1101/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1101/2007 KI-generiert

Tax Assessment Notice Validity Due to Defective Service

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/1101/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)
Kostenauflage zulasten Vorinstanz / Staat

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The appeal concerned the validity of several statutory tax assessment notices issued to the petitioner. The court reasoned that the assessment notices were invalid because they failed to comply with essential statutory requirements regarding service and notification, specifically noting that the addresses used were incorrect or insufficient, rendering the notices non-jurisdictional and thus void. This failure to strictly adhere to the statutory prerequisites for assessment rendered all subsequent actions based on those notices unenforceable.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Tax Assessment Notice Validity Due to Defective Service: The court reasoned that the assessment notices were invalid because they failed to comply with essential statutory requirements regarding service and notification, specifically noting that the addresses used were incorrect or insufficient, rendering the notices non-jurisdictional and thus void. This failure to strictly adhere to the statutory prerequisites for assessment rendered all subsequent actions based on those notices unenforceable.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Rechtsbeständigkeit der Steuerveranlagung gesetzliche Voraussetzung Mängelrüge Gültigkeit der Postzustellung Versäumnis des Steuerpflichtigen Ediktalzustellung

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court explicitly orders the appellant to pay the court fees.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



            !" !!#  $$!$ !!"

%%

&' %()'* * * & '%* (

+,  -  $$ ./.,  !!" 



  !" #    $

$

%%     & '' (      $!" )*+ 

$

#'   $$$,- &$   00" -./  



                

   (/15(  

* 0(

.6   7(08 9 &": "  .*2* &$ - ;$ 0 &<<$ &(- $"7 : ," &- $" .33=$  > $      ?$  .@ $> /33A  B," C& 0-$ 0"$   -!$ D $ $8 8  . - .4 7$0 .-/333!!&-$ " "& <608/2 :6

/6  &$$$  &   0"  -$  !$8 &(- $" &"  >""<"  0$$  &#'      '      '&  '  7(089#0""#:6

@6  $  /+ ! /334 &#0 ""  "0" 08   ''    '   '   7(08 9  :  ! -$E>$!0$ --"E&" .- .4@. "!>.5($2@&244<6+3(-"$$< & C$ ?$"E&"708A  :6

26  /+!/334&"<!"  $&#'    C&&00$E$$!0$6F0C"C&-$," $ @ !/334<!0"$"0&#0""0"-$C-!$ "$$<$>C"&$ $0 $0G< G !$$E &#07084  :6

A6  " //B/334& <F"!$$ "$$< $ HE &" &- .4 E 0$!> /33.6  $$ 0" (E &   ",!$ $)"  $ !0"!$ E ! ( 7E C &"  "$" !"  -!> .*54 E "!> /33/I 08 2   $ @5  :6 &   <F" E #1!  <6  !$$ 0>  <-  &#0 "" !! C&  "! -" - &00$ !<$" & $ "BE0&"  /+!/3347082  :6

46  "  00$  * $> /334 &   !$  "  0"$C$!$"$ &"&"$$0C !J  $E!0$"$$0"-0$&$0>C6

+6 .3-!>/334&"$B$"$$$ "$ E  !   >,$  !> &#06  $ <$ -  !> <<$"FC"$"<$" 0.*55C "  00$ CC$! !  !>!$6

56 -$"E "$!&$!"0 /AB/33+&$"<""E0  0$    //B/33+$B$ 0!$<



12/3+1/334  (@15(   !$"   " C"6   $$" 0 &$!" $   $"$"-"E0" 6

*6   @.B$/33+ > "00"&#0 ""7(089&00":$!0$ "0 "$!6

.36  /.H$/33+   C"--" $ *!/33+  !! /4&3// <6 E&#0 ""C@3!/33+ $" !$$ 4&33@<6!$$ $"$$00C&-$"$"E$$!0$>"   -  0$$ 0  0"   . - .4  @. "!> .56   -"!$$ 4&33@<6$/.H$/33+6

..6 "$ .20$!>/33+&#0""B$ 6 <$-C$$$0-K 0$$ &$  . - .4  @. "!> .56 &#0 "" $$ C& -$  0$00>!$8 &(- $"$ &$0>C "$$< & 0$$0"  $-6 $E !  ! <$0$&#0<$-C&0$ 0$$ -" E $$ &-6 < &,$  "  00$  C  -C" 0  $ &#0 , C&  &00C 0 F 0$$ -" E $$ &-6  B$ C  0 !0>  $ " -$ "! &00C   $ C C&  $ ">$ -$ $> /33A $EC >$ $  $-!$ &$$8 8.-.46

./6  .*0$!>/33+ > "C08 &#0 ""  F0$   !$$  4&33@ <6 $$" 0   E   6

.@6 0 /+0$!>/33+&#0F0C"C$$!!0 E $ !0"!$ $)" E ! ( C & B!"$" "<8!$0&#06

.26 08- "0  $$ "$ F0$ > " , "EB,6

* &%(

.6 <!"!$ E &$6 A4 6 . $6  L6 /    ,-  &,$ B  7:  > $    ;$  $ C  $$$ 0"- E D$ A4    <" "   0$ ,""  $  4$>/3337 :$-E



12/3+1/334  (215(    <" "D(- $" .*B.*A*7 :6'!0"$0 B,  &08$"$>6

/6 <" "0$,""  $  4$> /3337 :$$"-,.B-/33@$;$! <$  !> 0$ ",   !    $ $!!$ &(- $"6  $ 00>  &08 8  C  <$ B C!$ "$!$  $ "" 0$"!$ E  $"  -, 7 % .@3  /@3  6 .6.I @@A  6 .6/I % ./*  2  6 .6/I %./+24+ 6../4.@4 62>$"<":6

  <" "  .4 "!> /33A ! <$   <" "  &( - $" $"  -,  . B$ /334 7/334 /33@: 00$  ! <$C$$!!$0"  $ -$ > $   7$6A/ A5 $ 4. $6   :6  &08  0"$ $B$".3-!>/334$!- $7L6$6  0$ $$ $- E  ! <$  .4 "!> /33A:6  0" $"!,$$ 8C$,0$0&$ <  0$$  &  7$6 4* 6 . >    -, 0  . B$ /334:6

@6 $B$"   <! $ " 0"- 0     $ -> 7$6A4 :6

26 $$$!0$ !$$C$ HE$$ "$$< 0&(- $"-" &#0""E$6

A6 &$6//6.  0"-$C $F0$$$>I0$ ?$ "  ,,6 $   !  ,, $ 6 ' &6 /  $ $  0$$  " "$$-!$ 0 &  0-$  -L?$" "97:E&!0)E$$$ & 0>C 0-" !JF($$ -I7>:E&C 00-!$EL, 0$$6

&$6//6/$6 &000$" ! <$!$")$8!  -, BC(E  !$8  -!$  0$$  " "$$-!$  !  &$$" &   )$ <<$"  -

7 %.@/..@ 6@6@$@62:6

 -$  &$6 5A>    !0)  $$$  0"-) 0<  (!   ,! D$ 0>  0-"0>$"-)$8,'C -  D$ D $  D(- $" $ <$  - 0-$ F, CD  - D""  $$ $  !0$   - $ BCDE   (6 $ 0 $ "-"  !0$ 0"- E



12/3+1/334  (A15(   D$6/3 '6,!)$$- -$<- $!) D<!0"0$M$  !  $$ 0$ !!$  " D<< 76.:6

'$ ""!!-0$$7:>!$$C D" D$ ,," E !> 0 $$ CD $ - 0 "$ C D""$-"$)$<<$"D-I7>:-"$$!$  ",!$ 0 $$ C  $  !>!$    0!$ D$0?$ " $"C-C $$ 76/:6< ", $0-$?$-"ED,!)$$- BCDE0 !$$ ($00" EC 00$$$76@:6

' $-$$ &<<<" "  7: <$ 0$  0$$ <  -$ & >,$ ", $!!$ & 0>C7N.3345:6

 > <" "    "!!$ 00" C 0  0$$ <-$ &>,$",$!$ 0" !>!$ &$ 0 " ( "$$ !0" 0 &F, & $  !>!$  "C-C6   &>,$ 0"- 0 &$65A>6.@8!0L 0,!)$$-  < -  $  !) & <! 0" &$ C& 00$ & 7 %.@./2/ 64:6

46  &08  &$ 0 $$" C &00"    -"  0$$ &$  $ C  !$$  ( &"8- E 2@&2446+3 0  0"   . - .4  @. "!> .5 $ C $$ 0"  $ !0 0C&" $E"$$< &(- $"6

0$$ &$-"<- $0&#0 "" $  0$$ <  -$ & >,$ ", 0C& $ "$" -"   >  &$6. 6 /     &$ 0>C  .*0$!>.*537(089 :6

8C&$- &"-$$"0"-E&$65A>6/$6>  $ E F!   ",$ $ ",$  0$$ &$ 0"-$ $"C-C!>!$ & <6

' &$6 . 6 /   &$ 0>C $ $" E -    F 0 C $  <<$"   $ "0-  !) "0$<>6



12/3+1/334  (415(   .B$/332$$"-, ./<"-/332! <$ 6 00$$ &$$0!>>"-  $6A/@$/@ E/@7$6.6A :6

' 0$$$7$6@3 : $$ &$ B  &$"  -,    ! <$    &$ 0>C  ./<"- /332 $ "$$ E ! C&  $ !>>  ,  $8<F"0$6A/@$/@ E/@6

 &$6 /@  ( ",!$ $"  -,  . B$ /332 ( 0"-$  ",$  00  (!>>$" C  0$$ &$  "E$$ &- &$$$ 0$$ &$ !>> 8C&$-$76.:6,!L,"  &$ 0>C -$  00 !  E &   -!$! "" 0$$<<"$E0"  &$$$ BC&E   0$$ &$ < $  !?! 0"  76/:6

- C0"8 <$ $$C $$ 0. B$ /332  0$ $$$  $ ", $$> 0 &#0 ""  "! $!$ E &(- $"  !>!$  - C&  $6 $$ 0$ $ 0  00> F $$ &$.B$/3326

 "C  0$$ &$ -"  $ 0 &#0 0-$ ?$ C<" &- $  !0$ -  0$$  &(- $"0$?$C &$65A>6/$6 $ >$$$$0$ $!$6$0$$ &$ !>>  -$  &$6 /@      $ 0 "$$  B &$"-, ! <$ 6

+6 '&,$  !$$ !0" &$!"  <F" E /4&3// <6  !! -$ E &00"E$$ !>!$ -C&$6$  "C" //B/334C!$$0 !0$$ !0"!$$)"E! (6

) -C !J$$! ( $ -" 0 "!>/33/-!$"$$< $ !0"!$  $ < &>B$ & !0$ 7 N .33.4 $ .33+2:6

&$0"C$EB$$$C&#0""0$"!$$$"E  !$$ 433@6(<60 $E$!0"!$$)"E &F("0 &"!$$C&$!"-$E$$0!0$ 



12/3+1/334  (+15(   6'0$<$ !$$C$-$ &00E !0$6

56    &" -C  $  "  00$  C 6 &00"$$C$E&00$ &$ "!>!$ 0$$-"E$$ &-6

 ,<  $  0$ ?$ $6  <<$ &$6 /@    ( $< F 0$$ -" E $$ &-   0$$ &  (  0"-$  "  00$6  $   C C  0$$ &$$!>>     6 -$ >0$M$ "<"0$E&$65A>6.<  $$ C,!)$$- -$<- $0 $M$  !  $$0$ !!$  " &<< 6  &   $  0L E &#0 "" C  <$ - $-!$ &"" $!0$ -  /+ ! /334 ( $ -$ !?! C &$!"     "  //B/334 &-$ "E!<$7084  :6 ,< $ $0"C$?$"$"6

*6 <$$E! >,$ !>6

&$6 /2     $  -, 0  . B$ /332 0"-$ C  >""<C"$$ ><&$$!>!$$$0$C   ! J   $ 0 !   <$   $$ <<6  "$   $  $$ 0$ $  $-F 0"0$ 7  /33/( /33@ .4*4:C! &>,$ !>C!$  0$$ FC  >""< &-$ 0 $ 7!>!$  0$$ H!$-":6& $ $F0$$ C  $ "$" " E $$ &-   0$  &00"   &$ !$ $$"6  !>!$   - & &$ >$ C &"-$  !$I&)<<$0 & E&"0!?! 0" E< 0$$ &$E$$ &-$ 0$$  &(- $"7<6 %.@./2/ 6A:6

"$ C0"8 C&$EB$$$C&$!"0$" !  !0$ &00" $<!$!$"0  !>!$ $ "$$ !0 "$$ 0"" C  !$$ 4&33@ <6 C $ H "L00 E $$ !0$  "$" $$" &<< 0 &00"  $-"$60$B$"6



12/3+1/334  (515(  

%  2 (0  %()'* * * & '%* (



  3. +

.6 "->6

 3.

/6 !$ 0$!$      C  !$$  4&33@ <6 $ ?$ " $ !$$!0"6

@6  $ C&#'    &$ "BE$$" $!$$E  ''   '  '  C&-" $6

26 B$$006

A6 $C0" $,$$6

46 <!  0$   CD 0-$ <!  $  0"$ ?$   "  @3 B 8  $<$ 08  > <" " 7'LOPL<C44332  :0- !$8  $ 0><!"!$F$65/ <" " ><" " .+ B /33A 7 %:I  !"!   $  C   !$< $ !) 0-$0$,$ $ ! $I $ ?$  "  > <" " 0 - 0$  0 - "$C F  $  &$6 2/  %6  0"$ ?$ $  08  0  $-C"!!!) 0- -$?$B$E&-6  ,<<8  0" $     %% Q'  Q      "$(B$9 !" '  

0<! 0"$?$$$<"F0$CDED<<<" " 0,<<



12/3+1/334