Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/110/2008 • CJ GE ATAS/110/2008 KI-generiert

Prior Assessment Preclusion on Tax Deficiency Determination

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/110/2008
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

A party challenged the assessment of a deficiency by claiming that certain transactions were not taxable transfers under the relevant statute, arguing that an earlier transactional assessment involving the same subject matter precluded the current deficiency determination. The court ruled that the earlier assessment, which only dealt with whether the transactions were subject to a specific transfer tax, did not have preclusive effect on the current deficiency assessment, which involved a different tax based on the characterization of the transactions as sales or leases; therefore, the court affirmed the deficiency assessment as the prior finding did not resolve the specific issue of whether the property transfers were taxable sales under the applicable tax law.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Prior Assessment Preclusion on Tax Deficiency Determination: The court ruled that the earlier assessment, which only dealt with whether the transactions were subject to a specific transfer tax, did not have preclusive effect on the current deficiency assessment, which involved a different tax based on the characterization of the transactions as sales or leases; therefore, the court affirmed the deficiency assessment as the prior finding did not resolve the specific issue of whether the property transfers were taxable sales under the applicable tax law.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Steuerveranlagungen Steuerbare Umsätze Handänderungssteuer Mietsache Steuervorbescheid Beweislast der steuerpflichtigen Person

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section concerning the order for costs.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section concerning the order for legal aid.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



           &''('&)+ ,&--*&)(

,

 ,. ,     .

/0"  - % )1 2 )(         !"#$  %    %    &&   ' ()*!+  %"# !,!,)- .%/0/1 2322 / 

       !   "  ! # $% % 

   ,34-,  

 3.,

28 %9##:!'!#,!!'!"%%! ;.%"9300-5.%"930068

38 %%%  ; <% 3007 +' ')% .  "  == !'". %)  " ! *% 3007  '&&        >, .? @   !#  .  ! 7 <% 3007   !#  25 <% 3007 .'+%%!9A%8'%##'%.B#%#8

/8  !# ! 27 <% 3007  ' ' :"# +  !% $ '!"%# #%% .!.!#!20*8

58 /.%"93007 '%##:"#..% B.+%+')%)  !'A *+' 2/ *% 3007  +' )% %)# $ ;0C  %% D%+'#%%.%).!%!B"*%3007  +' )% !?   +' #%% !.# !'::% ! == !% %% .#!8

;8 !#!7)"93007 ()*!+!'&&     ' > @  *%#  ..%   ..% +  ?  . ')% !<"% :"#  ) 3007 !  #%# ! .)  ==!'". +!9"E"%)%$",%".%+!9"E" )%8#A"%#%#)#+'%##)%!#*$#%#%# .==!'".$%.8

-8 '%##%*%#30)"93007%!%!#8#.?%  "E" A"%  *%% +' )% #A"% %# ! .9?" ! =A"%!'!8

78 #.!-!#"93007 ()*!+!' %*% !8

68  9!#!#".%.!.%2;*) 30068%..+'%##)%%.!'A%""# %)$D!?)3007 !'.% %+')%!<"%::%# ==!'".."!*3007 !'%.%8 , +%%#%%"E".%!B?".#!!*%% ."?"!*% "?A').". )+'.%% ) +'#%%#A"%%!'::%!!#"=.?!'".F .%%*%8

18 (#%#A!#$*A8



4556543007  ,/4-,    .,

28 :"#"% $ '%8 ;- 8 2 %8  =8 6 !   A)  'A% *! >@   9 % !   G%  % + ! %%% .#) $ H% ;- !   :#!#   .% A## ! !% !   ! - %9 3000 > @ + % %)$:#!#H,=I"A9A%%H!"%# !H)9%#!3;*21638

(".#%.*A!!H.?%#%98

38 %*%# !  !# % :" .#) .      !% E% !## )9 >%8 -0 % -2 !   :#!#   .% A## !   ! - %9 3000    . ) ! H%8 2 8 2 !  :#!#  H,=I"A 9A% % H!"%#   !H)9%# ! 3; * 2163   %%861!A).#!!"%%)!23 .%"9216;  @8

/8  %A .%   !% ! ' ! . $ '% ! '%##  .!'!#!!B*!'B!!%$'!"%#. ').!%==!'".."!*%30078

58 B %" ! H%8 27 8 3    H# + :% ) ! .%% !H !%  ) H% ! H:: ! %) ".#%%  %.! %%  + H .% 9"% BA !  . #)%  =I"A  H9#A8"9.%!==!%) 9!= !.:+HBJ%.##!""%8!%..%.)!::% +H:8

'%83-!'!H,=I"A> @.#+K

L2 H# !% 9  == !H".   ?A A##   "#%=!!.%%!8   H)% . %= ! !"%#  H# !% : $ H:: ".#%%.)!::%+H%.!.%)!%)8 39  !%..%%%.).=+.#!!%I"%%% *%:%:.%!+!")%."*)9+ % %% !%8 (H    . " !  !#  H:: ".#%%  ".%%!#9.:8("%#"% H:".#% +H$HB.%!!# %H9!HB)9 == !H"..%.E%.!#%8 /  H::".#%%%I=+"==!H".!H#

..%!H%8/082%8  H#.!!HB !  !% $ H!"%#  H  :% .  .9 . %)  %)



4556543007  ,54-,   )98 H%8 5; 8 2 %8  ! H!  H =I"A 9A%%H!"%#!H)9%#!/2<%216/> @.%$ % #A! +  . ! HB ! !% $ H!"%# .! ::% $ .%!."*+%%!..%!%)+H#% !)=I"...:%+HH%.::""%::# !%)%))9)%!%"9=I"A8H#!%! H%! !#*$ !%  !# ! A# $ ! == !H". >  2167 "#3 .852! 2@8

;8 !#!.%..%$A)%#!:%!'#% .%B#! ."%:!. -0*>%8/08/ @8('%8 5;83  !#!.%!2$2;*!:%#A?  !2-$/0*!:%!A)%#"F%!/2$-0*! :% A)8 '%8 5; 8 /   !. +' F  :% A) + '# 9!".#.%#)9E%#!'9%)". +':".#.%#)9"%:)98

 ! H..#% !  A)%# !  :%   F   ! .!  ".% +H#%%)#!==!H". +H.%) %".$.%".>E%.9#M8!23!#"9211;  3/141; % M8!25"216-  2-/46;@8

 & .*A#..%.!+*!!%$ H!"%#.#$H%!H=I"+H)%:%.!%!# !A#!B"+!==.!%+%"%.!% !B ! "  .!% +  )% )   > E% ! &   .9#8!2-.%"93003 252403@8#A"%:"#. ! + * ! !% $ H!"%# %%  =I" + )% %)# !".%"..!%%"%H)%::%#== !H". !% H)% ! " )%  : ! %%8  HA% !H # + #%% +:# !   %? !"# !  :%# ! A#  9A%  . % % %#   .  % >E% ! &   .9# 8!2-"3000  3;6411M%@8

-8 +.) *A!:!!# : !.% % !      :% +  :% !'E% #%9 ! "? #:%9 ..%"".)"99 '%,$,!+.#%% !A#!)"9.#.!#%8::%!.+':%.E% !##"%""=F.%=?.98"%##"%!:% #A#  )A9   *A !%    #=#%  % B +  .%..99> &23-/-0!8;9 23;21;!83% #:#N:8 &2/0/35!8/83%/8/@8 'B%,%,. !% ! ..+'!"%%*A!)% %% !!% :)!'#> &23-/33!8;@8



4556543007  ,;4-,  

78 '.? ..%!.%:%+.#?!+'%##'.%" :"!==!'".!"!*%3007 .+ '   :A#  . ! !B * !  !% $ '!"%# ! =I"A8 '%##  B.+# +'#%% .# $ ) !  !'A $ !+%=.**+'2/*%3007 %%)%.?"% $;0C%%D )%!:%+'.%%)!3; *%  6 <% 3007  E% !.# ! '9A% !'::% ! == !'".8

&%%%:!%%+%%%)%#%#%%#.? ."% )3007 :%+'#%%%!%$%.! !==!'"."E"'#%%.#%%*#%% %)%%8F#A"%!)+'%##!#*$#%# %#$%..==!'". *) :#)% )30078()!#9%%+3;*%3007 '%##% .#%! )  ! 9 : +' #%% !.# !  :% ! ==  ".8!!% ..%% #=#% !A.? !?."%8.%++'%)+A !   .  % ! )%A > & 235  32;  E% ! 9 :#!# 47742112@8

F!?!"%..!.!!%!'%## B!"%#!',=I"A8

68 ( '#= ! . #9# .  (#%% !'#%% $ '#" >( @   . .#) . == !'".  ) ' 'A% !  ."?!;$1*%''A%!!:!20$21*>   *)3007473@8

 '.?  '   :B#  % $ !B *8 & % ! %% + %% % % *%:# % .%  !"%  .. !  ..%%#  #%%..#+'%##'#%%!#*$):A!.!!%. "E""%:8

 ":!# !%,E%*%#8









4556543007  ,-4-,  

  4,.3  ,. ,     .

%

  5 0

28 #)98

% 5 

38 *%%8

/8 %+.#!%A%%8

58 :"  .% !  +H .)% :"  %  .#% E% !  !# ! /0 * !?  %:% .? ! 9 :#!# >(=OP=:+- -005  @ .)!"%?!!% .9 :"#"%B%863!:#!# 9:#!#!27 * 300; > &@N  "#" !  !% !+    "%: % "F!.)%.%A%!%!"!%N!% E% !#  9 :#!# . ) .%  . ) #%+ B !% ! '%8 53  &8  .#% E% %  .?  . ! % )+#"""F!.) !)%E%*%$')8  A::?  #!%     ,  Q 

 . :" ! .#% E% % %:# B .%  +H (#%% !'%%$'#".A::



4556543007