Property Owner Challenge to Waterway Regulation Statute
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertA party challenged the constitutionality of a statute that imposes certain duties and liabilities on owners of property adjacent to a public waterway, arguing that the statute was an unconstitutional taking and an undue burden on commerce. The court reasoned that the statute served a legitimate public purpose of protecting water quality and navigation, and since the regulation did not deprive the property owners of all economically viable use of their land or impose a burden on commerce that was clearly excessive in relation to the purported public benefit, the statute was a valid exercise of the police power, not an unconstitutional taking or an impermissible burden on interstate commerce.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Owner Challenge to Waterway Regulation Statute: The court reasoned that the statute served a legitimate public purpose of protecting water quality and navigation, and since the regulation did not deprive the property owners of all economically viable use of their land or impose a burden on commerce that was clearly excessive in relation to the purported public benefit, the statute was a valid exercise of the police power, not an unconstitutional taking or an impermissible burden on interstate commerce.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited in the dispositive for ordering the respondent to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Volltext
#$%&'#())$ #$)'#())%
*
+ ,!+ - + -,
). ())%
$/ 0 1
, ,-2,- 34 2 ,- 5 , -+6 7, 8 !"#$ %&%% %% '! 9999999999 () *(!(*+" ,"' (-(! '! .''&%/ ' (!(011111111112 %&&& 3 4) 5
! "
"&6%/"
2,
%; ' (!( 01111111111 2 (!( (( 2 <= ! ! - ! ' 4 5 % )(= %##8; !! ' (!( = ! *' >! ?' ' ! '!!. @*'! 'A !( != !'*' !*> ! B;C' 1111111111(! ! ! @ !( D' ("-(!E >(() D -! = 4); * < /& ' C5;
&; ' (!( (!( )) ( 2 !*') 'D )((! ' ' F ! *!', 4 C5 < % )(= %##8; 011111111112'(*'!(( <!' )) ! '2 C!G@D' D'H!%###;
/; I! @ ' (!( ' ( )) !( ) < * D(!(%##$E* @<*( '! ! G !2*!>%##$E '! ! 'D'!*(!(*F(( (-,!E*'! ' E'!H ) D'>G!*' !;
7; CD!='! !(*'* !*(2D'! ' (!(EDF!*'>! * !'! ! ' 6 6 !, ( @ '! ! ' (- '! ' ) A (' ! ' *( ( 2 ' (!( (! ! !( = 4); * <%92%$' C5;
8; %:&:::EC' 1111111111D!@ !!(D*! '! ! ' ((!) !)' D!!!! ' *F(! D(%###ED'J! !* !*(!%9&:::4);* < %#2&&E/%' C5;
6%7896&::% "/6%/"
9; G-!%/(>%###E*> (+ KG= &:::E > * < ! (*> @ ! !' <= *''( ) ! 01111111111 2 4); * < # ' C5; # )(= &:::E* ' @ ! '(!(*> (+ 4);* <%:' C5; ) E!/% &:::ED)) ) ! )'( C@ ) ! = ! (!( L!( * ()! D! ) ' G-! 7 = &::: 4); * <%%' C5;
K; C *' ! ( ) ! 01111111111 2 *' '!! KM87KE9: ); 4); * < 8 2 K ' C5; '!! '*' , '! ! ' * ! ! '! >! ' ! < D'! ' ) !( *F( *( ' )(= E = 2 'H! %### ! '*(! G= 2 (> %##$E F ) !! ) ! *' !E!,'! '! !(N!'!' '! ! '! N!(G'G-!) !;
$; ( ' %& G= &::%E C '! ) ( 2 C' 1111111111(*! ''-*''!!KM87KE9: );4);* <%' C5;
#; K )(= &::%E C' 1111111111 )'( '' ! ' 2 ( ' * D !( +" 4); * < / ' C5E '! ) @ ' (!( D= ! = '( * *! '' ! <!!! < !! ''* (- --=;
%:; ! & &::%E C @ =( D'' ! ' )'( * C' 1111111111E ' (! @D @ !( -(! >(() D -! = E *'> !( (! ! --( D! 8& ;' CEC' 1111111111= !DN! = - !'!* !'! ! '' E.!*! !@ ' (!(= ! )) !() <;
6%7896&::% "76%/"
%%; %$ = &::%E C' 1111111111 '!!( =' ' = '! ' !! ''(- --=D! 8& ! '2D => !(D! ' C;
%&; !) !'!* E!!@>' E*! ? ' !B*(!N!;
-,
: 1
'= ! *( @ ' )(( *! -(( ' ! ' 9 '!'> &::: 4 A $/:;%5 ! !( = - % G= &::/E !I! ' ) ! ' '> *' ! ' (-' D"= != =!;*(!! (' (- * *' ! ' = - G@D /% (> &::&E(-* *'@<- >'!= - '!'J) !G @!(! !'!*' !4 +%&879K ' ; %5; '!E G- ( (- !( ( ' !!@(E <- -((E D*< D(!! ) ! , !! '! 'J ( ' ! - (!( 4); +%&%/99' ;%>5;
6%7896&::% "86%/"
;
, ! D! $& ( % <-! D = != =!/%'!'>%#7KE!/%(>&::&4 5E ' ! (*! ' * ! '@ '*! ' ) !*=' *( '(*! '( D(2'*! '! 'J ' '- !E !'! E 2 D,* ! ' D ( @2'*!) !'->;
'! !2!!! *' ! 'E D- !D' D( *(*! '2' (D')) 4); +%%&$E' ;7A %#$9E*;7#/5;'@' !( =D!* >' *'*( 2 ( * *! ' * '- (E ( ! > 4! $& (& 5;
> )(( 4 + 5 *'( * * @D '*! ' ?' '-B *' ! ' *( !(E 2*! '!'J' !'I!E F*N!!D!!! '@D' !' !D!!D!!!'*!*! @E@ '! *!!! * '= '! ! 'E *' ! G! ) '> -! '(*'-4); +%%9K8E' ;/>A%%/%$%E' ; &A%%&$E' ;7A %#$/E*;%:$5;) !(! !!''!! @D DF ? '! ' * ! *') !E 2 ! >B 4); + O P ?.>! >- Q'R E , < ( ! ' *- %%&5E D'J (! *!( ;
) ! ' ''! * >' D! )E D * ( ! ' '- '! ! 'J *! '! !> ! >! ' ! ('*! ) (!> * D)) ) !' @ !E'2!2@S' !!()!> ; ))!E @ > ! *! ) ! ' *'(
6%7896&::% "96%/"
''! !=! !!! ''-! !(N!E-((E' *! @! >,E(G2)) !' '-E'! 'J ''! '( !'! ) (E'2 'JD(!! ''! '! D =! '!(!((*'(!*=!N!'!(; '!"2E( !E'= !N!-((E'I!D(!!! )E''! ' (! = *'>>4); +%%9%9%E' ;7A %##: *-7%8A %#$KE*;9:K5;
' G *E '- ! (*!( = '@ '! ! '*=!*N!*SE*''! )G @ ') ! 4); %#$/E *; 7KKA %#$$E *; %/K5; '@ '! ! ' ! *F( 'D '=> !(D*'F4*''5E'- ! (*!( = '! 'J ( '! ! ' '! ('=>E D!"2" '!'JE(-2D '=> !(D*'FE'! ! ' *=! * N! *S ' *'( ' ; 4); C .T U .'U = .-. !E='*;9#5;
D'=! ) ! *! *! *E 2 E =' (! ('=>; E'@ @ ! ') !(!( *)!D! )E'-!(*!(=2'!"24 +%:/ %&&E' ;7A %#K$E*;&9:5;D- !'!'JE <')) E ) !(!((( )!4); %#K/E*;K$E' ;&5; !(-E* *'!@D!)'@ '! !D''* ' @ ! ' ) !!!) 2 !!*'(; !( )) !@E*''S! !!EG-(!> !D>> 2 @ ! 2 ! >, ( !@D D !*!('! ! ' 4); + %:$8&E' ;8A %#$/E*;%:#5;
D*<E* ') !' (!((!(*> ( !#)(= &:::+ ; D!'2'!"2@ ' ) !@D @ !> '-;<'E*'! ' '! ) (2C' 1111111111%&G= &::%E*!(( D ')'(!2D! $&;% ;
6%7896&::% "K6%/"
() )'( '' ! ' /: G' 2 '*! '! ) ! '( '4! $%;& 5;
(*'!!!@N! =(&&::%E C- !*! E'!@D!=>2)'4! $% (/ 5;
E ' -=' D'- ! ' G && '=>%#7%4A &;:85(!(' ) (! >!' (!( ! !( < % 'H! &::/E !!! ! @E '!! '!!! ' ! = 2 ' )(( D"= ! = =! 4); ! %E!;!89=E;%E!;E. ))%5;
(!(' D')) *(! >E')'(!2 D! /E ; /E ' %7 '=> &::& ' ) ! ' D'- ! ' G 45E@ !<''*(!!*'G-D*<;
;
,!D! 8& 4!= -/%(> &::&5ED*'F' !'= '-@D (= '!* *! ' !! '!'*(- --=; @!! ! *' ! '*( 4 %#$#E*;%%K5;
D*<E '- ' ! *! ( '! ! '> * C) !' (!(011111111112*' '!! KM87KE9: );E *(!! '! ! ' * ! @ '! >! ' ! < D'! ' ) !( *F( *( ' )(= E= 2'H!%###!'*(! G= 2(>%##$EF'*
6%7896&::% "$6%/"
) !! )!*' !E!,'! ' @ !(N! '!' '! ! 'N!(G'G-!) !;
D! %7 ; % E '(! ' = ! /7 ! =! E * ! D'> -! ' *' D*'F ( .@ '! ! ' (!=" 2 '*! '=*'* '! ! '; *'F' =!='F , E*( ' @!E* < '*!> '! =( 2 (E < 2 @ '! ! '* ! * !N!(!) D'>G!( ';
> )(( )) ( ,*(! @ D'> -! '(-(*'-' !N!'@'J '- ! H 2 = '! ' !! ' ' * (- - -=E * D*'FE * *! ' (- ! D 4 %#K$E *; &8#A %#K&E *;9$K5; '*! '@ '!!@D> '-* ! ''>=! '* *! '*!!!@D*'F= '("
!! '!'' *(- --=E'J D, ! *D ) !' 2(- ! !(''*'!!'2D>D )!4 %#$/E*;%:%5;
'@D*'F!*''E'-(*'! ' !E2! !> E'-(* " E'!!@ *' ' D, ! * '! 'J *'> !( ! --( 4); . ))9::/ ! =D+ **! ''! ! '"A + %%7K#' ;/A %#$$E*;%/9' ;/ A %#$8E*;97#' ;&5;
?'-BE )!!!'!*'*.F @@ *(! *' ' 2 D,!( ' @ *! , ) ( = '*'!! " 4); . )) 9::7 5; '@D ! D ' (!( 'FE + D! !'G' ()(( 2 D! K87E * (E '(! ' = D! K8#E * ( ; ')'(! 2 ! E !'! *' .-( D !! 'E -! ' '!LE (*'!2D(-' (!(EN@D=.@! ' '(
6%7896&::% "#6%/"
' E '- @D @! !! '! ' * (- -2=' !*'@ (*'!DN'-'! !' !;'!(*!(.-(D !! '-! ' D! K89 ?'!'-( '( -(,*(! '!E (-!*'@ *!))! =!( ' =!'-E'@ !-! '*'*! !F! *! *(*'(! 2 )'! ' =''!( ' (!(B 4); + %:K /8/E' ;8A +%%&%#$85;
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
D'E ' D,! ! - ! 'E () (! ! ! @ !( D' ( -(!E >(() D -! = E* %)(= %##8!!!'!*( ''J'! ! ' D'! * (!( *F(; = ! =' * (! @ , D *
6%7896&::% "%:6%/"
' ( ! *'> !( *! ' N! --(; ! 2 , D, ! D(- --=*!* *! '(- !D E(!! E =' E@()D*- !! '!;
G *'!!E + '@D F= !(- - -= '@ D*'F ')' ! * 2 @ *'= ! N! '>!, -(!'!*'*> ! !! ' ! @!N '!4); %#K&E*;9#:5; @D'!' !D, -2!(-E' !'N!(=(D*<@D' *! ' ! !!E ! < '*!> !( ! -! 'E D *'FN!(-' @D !((;
*! =@D!!*F!'! ! 'ED*'F *= 2 ! ' !* = E * ,* ' D * ( ! !(' ' !! -! = )' ; '= ! *!E*'@D!'*'!!!'>*!( !''* D!; 8& E @ D' * !! @ D*'F = ! ' ( !'>G! =*@D *'= !2'!!='!* ! D@ !! !! ( '>E (= !! !! < @D '-' !(2 '*! 'E @D,!( ; ! '!E(- --= (END(. D !4); %#$8E*;9:&5;
D! !'!)' * D'E @D = DN! ('!( "';
() ) ! =' @D ' @! < ! ! %##$E ' (!(> E'*'*E> *'!!!!E! ! *'!!F!( (.-*!! = !.' '= -*> !(;<-=' ( !!(- !*' ! F!*!!*!>!! !<E!= * @! '! 'E*(!' E*(**'G!*'!! ' ! '; *( @))'! !!= '!* (((
6%7896&::% "%%6%/"
)!!! E=' ' E=!@' (!('!!(*! ( ';E'!= D*>'! E'!@D D*>; () =' ('))(2 C*') !' ! *(! =' !'G' )=' ( * ! .- ' ; ! (-E ) !=' D=' G ! (D-!'! ! '' *'*F D!)' ;
'!* <) -!' @E!(%##9! %##KE()*'F(E@G= 2= %##$E !!( (' (!(;'=*'(!(--(% %##$E (!( ( /% '!'> %##$; ! ' '!!> @D F > (! ' *'E @ D *(=! ()E ! )) ' (@D D- !2DD !!<)) D*<;
> <= @D ! %& (> %##KE () '( K:M9&9);*'D(%##$E@ '*' !2 ' E!@!'.(*=!; D!@D' %###E '@D*'F' @(2 CD!!!! ' *F(! D(%##$E@D !@D*!E = !-!('*'* 2 K$M8%#E9: ); ! @ D! *!E = ! =( /:M::: ); '= *'F(E ' ! =! ) ! ! %:$M8%#E9: );; !! ( ! ' '( *' D( %##$ ! D> ! ) ! )*!D*'F!*! '!!I('*(! '! ! '2.!8M8$/E/:);*) !!,!F! )47%%);5; F '!!@! (('! !D! ( C;
E'D)) () "NE )!E!* ' E =' ' *'('= !<;+'! (!,*( E' !*!' ! *'!!2'E () H! H N! * = - !E .! D,!N )) !( @D ! 2 '! ! '= !<; () *'= ! * @ 2 (! ! ' *! > DN! ( '>; ! !
6%7896&::% "%&6%/"
H!H*!L! *I!'!(!' ='(2D(.E'!@ <-! '! ! ' (( D ! * H N! ))((; ' ' -@D!) %###!@(*L!> (!((*'(E'@D '! !(G2 > @2(! !!!(;
'I!E >'!!@E!( !2D(%##$E C(- <!H(* <'*!>) D(!> '!! '! ! ' ; '! (-! ' C @E < D( %##9 (G2E '! ! ' D(!! * =( ( (-,E * ! D !(N!'!' !D(!(((!*'(*' !'! (!( !(; < *( ' ! ! G ! 2 *!> %##$E ! '! ! ' *F( '! H ) ' ! D'>G! *' !E (' ! ' *( !E ) !E D * ! *(; > <= * @ D! ! 2 ! (*L! !! * ! *' '!! ' '! ! 'E @ () D! ) ! @ !!( D *! '! ! ' ((E' !'!!8D%:/EK8);E'*'!*( (! 2*!*(;*I!<' )) D!!@()?!'G' )=' (* !.-' B;
E ' -@()E@ ' ! *) !! !! ') < )) @' (!(D!!'=(< D(!( %##$E D ! ) ! =' !! -! 2 (- * ' !( D! '!*( @ !* *;
' 'E=@ *(<E >(' < @()D*E@ !(-(!E* '> -! '(-@ '> !=!'! -@D'*'= !!! ; ) !E ) ! *= (- - -= D! 8& ! ' ! (*' '-> * C) !' (!(;
6%7896&::% "%/6%/"
-,2 ,!+ - + -,
<; = : 3< $'( -
;
%; S' !A
;
&; <=D'' ! ')'(*C' 1111111111A
/; )'*! @M*=!)'''!*(!N! ( /: G' < '! ) ! ' * * '( ( >)((E.T U.')@ 9E9::7 E!' ,* ; ( *! N! *''-(; (' ' ! P 5 @ ,!! @ ( ' '! ( '>! ! * ( '!!@(A>5,*'*'@'! ) ! *'=' !! !( 'A5*'! -!''*(!!; (' '! !*!' ((!((('!!5>5!5 "E > )(( *' * ! ! < ' @M =( =>;(' '! '' 'F*=E@ '!G' !E @( '!!@(!M=' @(!(,*( (()4!;%/&E%:9!%:$5;
-)) <P *( !P C "' 3 ' W
(! "G !P ,
'* ')'*(!N!!'! ) (,*! @M2M')) )(( ' *-))
6%7896&::%