Liquidated Damages Enforceability: Summary Judgment Reversal and Remand
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe lower court erred in granting summary judgment for the defendant in this dispute over the enforceability of contractual liquidated damages clauses, as the plaintiff presented sufficient evidence to suggest that the stipulated amount was an unenforceable penalty rather than a reasonable pre-estimate of damages. The appellate court reasoned that when a liquidated damages clause is challenged, the party seeking to enforce it bears the burden of demonstrating that the amount was a reasonable forecast of just compensation for the breach at the time the contract was made, and since the trial court failed to properly consider the evidence concerning the reasonableness of the stipulated amount, the case must be remanded for a proper factual determination on that issue.
Legislator-Regeste
Amtlich; AI(ASSURANCE) ; NOUVELLE DEMANDE ; AGGRAVATION DE L'ATTEINTE À LA SANTÉ ; ÉTAT DE SANTÉ; MODIFICATION(EN GÉNÉRAL) ; PREUVE ; DÉCISION D'IRRECEVABILITÉ | RAI.87.4;
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited in the dispositive to regulate the costs of the proceedings.
Volltext
"#$%%"#%%& "'%()"#%%&
*+ + * +
, # ! #$ -. #%%&
-! /00000000000 ! "#! $" % ! &'!(()$'$!($$
!
// + +1*2+$ $!$' (*+,-./
!
410+4
/
56 "$ 788888888888 !$! !9$ ' :! 5+3; <''=$ (> = !$ ( ! 4'! $$ ! $/' ?$ ='/ $ 5++2 ! * ! /$')$!'(>'! $$6
16 (! ( @ A$ 1221 > ' ('' (( ( !!$ ( > 4$/$($!'/$!- ( ''(!$(B =$ - >! $ (> ! $ ( ! < !!$) ( /$4 ( !(>(' $6
C6 ( ( &$! !$ ( (( >77 > ?? 4 D$4 . > E <' ($/ (! '($F !& '6
88888888888 9 ( ! ( ;!< 1225 - 88888888888 '($ ! $!! =$! '!! (> F 9$) 6 ? $ > ' '!$! ( 'G' (> $9$ !$ >$!'9 ! ( ( (> '!! F$4(' $=6 >$! !$ (> / ! $!! !$(' /$! '!' $/$ (> !! '$ !$ ( >'!! ! !$! $9$! ( < A ' ( ! $ H $ ($$! I J6
(!(5 !< 1225 88888888888$! $!( ' ! 88888888888 '($4$ ( > $/' K ??? 6 !$! '!$!$$!'!!(! /$($;!< 1225 $ (> '!! F$4(' $= / !$!$6 '!$! <<! /$!$ (>*( (I< !J!<$!'$'! 6
;6 ( ( !! B > ' '!' $ - F !$ *G$! $) ($! 88888888888 $ *G$! ! $!!6 ? ! ( 5+ ='/ $ 1221 >F !$' '!$! !G9$ (' $/ (>$!$!' * ! '!$! ! . ==!' ( ! ( '$ 6 '!$!$/$<$!(>F !($5;/< 1225!'!$!!! ! $!! !$(' !!6 '!$! $$!' !! ( ! /$ ( '$('! $'$'-! (! /$!-!F$$ (>(=$6
36 ? (( ( > K ??? > ' '!' $ - (F$. F !$ *G$! $) ($! 7888888888886 !(11A$!1221>F !($9!$)'(! <F$F!(' $= $F! $$ )> F9' !$ ( *!L0$!$6 = ' $ $/!M I < ) > ' >F ! /! <$ =$ I $J $4$ == $! ==!$/! (> (' $ ( (9 '
01+2201223 4C0+4 '9 6/ 'A!!(! $!!'($!F(/ $! !! '(!$ $9$=$!$/ ( *!L !!! $ ( ! /$-522N()! $$!,:!1221J6
@6 !(55:!1221->!!!$(> 88888888888 ($9!$)'( $/4( 9$G $) ! <!!$)( /$4( ! < (' $= A ' ! '/. !' $!$) *G!$) '!! ( ! $9 ! < F$F '$=$' G* !$ !' $('G'G $)$$)($(> $9$ $('! $' ($ 55 A$ 12256 $ !$! '!$! $$!' !! ( ! /$6 ! < >'!$! $' - <. ( $9 !$ $ - ( 9 $ >'!$! '!$ - ( '/'! ( /$ (/ 6
,6 ! ( 52 !< 1221 /$ ( ?" ' ('(! ( > 4$/$($!'!!'F$$))> ' '!$!( ! < F$F ! (' $= $F!6 $!' ( ! /$ '!$! !! ($ ,:!1221! ((>!$/$!'G<$!6
O6 ! ( 3 A/$ 122C 88888888888 ($9!$)' ( /$4< G$9$ 9G ! <!!$)!('9'' !$=$/( ( !$($ ;4 3! G $4($ 34 @$$) ( $ << $==$ / !'< 4<$$ 6 >'!! ( !' >'!$! 99 /'($53!< 12216><(($9!$/$!$= $!' ( ! /$6 ?>9$! ( $!' ( ! /$ /' ) !$! '!$! (>$ !! ! < $/ ( G$ /$4( ! #!(/ !$9!($6>$$!''!$!!A !!6
+6 ! ( C 122C *G$! 88888888888 $($)' ) > '/$! '!'$$!'!!(! /$(5+!< 122553 :!1221$!' !!(! /$(5@:!5;!< 1221$ $$!'!!(! /$($53!< 12216$>'!'1221$*/$! (!'$ !$(!G*$6
526 ! ( 5 A$! 122C ?" ' /' ) &99 /!$ ( >'!!(!'- !$ (53!< 1221 !' 88888888888 >/$! '!' '!*' ( /F (! '($F6 ==! ! (> ' '< (5CA$!1225'!$! ($9 G$ /$ ( 51 ('< 1225 ! ( G$ /$ ( 1@ /< 1221 =$$! #! )) ! < ('9'' !$= < ! $$ ( 9$ ( 53 !< 1221 '!$! !$. ! 6 88888888888 /$! )! - $ /' ) >'!! $! >'$ ! ($ >'!' 12216 /$! ')! ( '=' - >F !$ ( 788888888888 )$ $!->F$9$<$$!'(>!$/$!'F ' ''(!($:!12216
01+2201223 4;0+4
556 ('$$ ( 55 ('< 122C > ! *' - > ' ! !$. (>$/$($!'(5 A$C2/< 12216
516 $ (5CA/$ 122;> '= '$!$-!!('$$=$! /$ )'!!(!'>'!$!99 /'($53!< 1221)>$>'!$! '$ '/ $122C$)>$>'!$!-/'A '- !$ (A$122C6? *G$! $/$! $!$$!'(! /$-32N($A$122C! '($! $!!>/$!$ B!(! /$!- !$ (!< 122C6
5C6 (!(5@A/$ 122;> '(''/((( !!$ (> 4$/$($!'/$!->! $(> !6
5;6 $ ( 5C ='/ $ 122; $ ! $ ($==' ! (! '($F - > 6 !$=$! ( 88888888888 ( + ='/ $ 122; !!!$! (> $$!' ( ! /$ ( !$= *G$! $) ( 32N $ (> '!! (' $= (! >$!$!' $$! ( '9. - *6 ! ( PL$!F $/ $!$ ( ./ ( ; :! 122C !!$! '/$( *( =$< *9$) ( !! >G'$ 9G / $ ( !$ ( ( $/!<$'6$9 $'($( 88888888888(1, /< 1221=$$!'!!(&/!!$!$!(&($ .! /$ !G 34 @/ !$($ '*! !$!' $ 9G (= ( 6
536 ! ( 1 $ 122; 88888888888 ($9!$)' ( $ $==$/ !'< 4<$$ (! <!!$)!('9'' !$=( <$ $$)>=$< *9$6>'!!(!'>'!$!99 /' ($'/$ 6>$$!'(! /$'!$!!!6
5@6 ! ( C $ 122; 88888888888 ($9!$)' '$( (' $= '9 $$ )> G* !$ !' $6 !! $$) '!$! $G9' !>$$!' ( $*G$! $)>'/$!-32N ($ 1CA$122C6
5,6 ('$$ ( 5O A$ 122; > A!' >$!$ = ' ! ('$$ ( 5C A/$ 122;6 ! ==$ $(' ' ) > ' >'!$! ' $$ ( $ ( ! $)>$ (!!$! '$ !$( '!!(!' / $($!'(! /$ $)&$ /$!!!'( !)$'!$!( ! !6
5O6 ('$$(C 1223> A!'(F$.(((> '( 1 122; =$! /$ ) ( $ >/$! '!<$ ( $. $< ) (9 ' (>$/$($!' >'!$! ($=$' ( $. - $= ( $! - !6 ==!(!'($F('! $!)>$ '!$!!A B!!$!)>!( $( !! *'(5 A$ C2/< 12216
01+2201223 430+4 5+6 $ ( O / $ 1223 > ' = ' $!$ - !! ('$$ =$! /$ 99 /!$('!!(!'6
126 $ ( 53 A$ 1223 $ '!' $!$6 F$)' ) '(!G' $/*G$! >'!$!$!$=$'($=$122C6 88888888888 $(' $! ) ($ $ ( A$ 122C '!! ( !' >'!$!= !!99 /'$)<!!$/$'($ '9$ $!' '$((! /$'!$!(32N6 !- 88888888888 !$$! )&$ '!$!$$!'!!(! /$ $!!( <. (> ( *G$) ! <$ (>$/$(! 'G' !$ ( / !$9 / !(>')$$< !($6. $A!$=$$!($! * $($4 !(>$/$($!'!(> ( ( =$6
156 ('$$(5;A$!1223> A!'>$!$6>==$/$! ( ('$$( !$$!'(!(A$-/< 1221(!(55 ('< 122C)> '>/$!!!' =(65@A/$ 122; $ /$! ('' / (( ( !!$ '9! ) $!' ( ! /$ '!$! '($! ( 32N ($ 1C A$ 122C ! ( 522N ($ 13 !< 122C6 (! (! ($! !!$! '/$( (>99 /!$ <A!$/ ! $9$=$!$/ ( >'!! ( !'6 ==! *G$! $)''! !' 88888888888($==' $!( F '/)' 788888888888 ( ! (>F !$ ( 11A$!1221 ! !$) ?" ' >/$! /' 99 /!$ ( >'!! ( !' !$=$! '($F '!<$ '($ ! $!!=$!'!!)($!<A!$/$==$! =( ( $! F !!$(> 4$/$($!'6
116 $ ( 5, :! 1223 > ' ! !! ('$$ . ( $< ( ' ! $! ( (' - >! $ (> ($4 ! (>$/$($!' $$ )>- >! $ ( =$6 =$! /$ ) > >/$!!!( !'($F( 88888888888)$ =$ $! ( !!!$ <A!$/ !$ ( ! $! (> $9$ /$4( 4<$ )$ >$ $/$! ( !F! ( =$< *9$6 ! ==$ >/$! $ $(' !$ /$ '($F '!( 88888888888)$('$!(!(+='/ $ 122; 99 /!$ ( >'!! ( !'6 /$! $$ (!$ ( (! ($<>99 /!$<A!$/!$9$=$!$/('!!!>'!$!) >$!$'>$!A9'!$(=$ '( -F !$<$4($$$$ 6
1C6 '(53!< 1223> >! '=' '-('$$$$ )>F$.(($ ! A!( 6
01+2201223 4@0+4 *
56 $ 9/$ > 9$!$ A($$$ ( 11 /< 5+;5 DE '!' ($=$' ! $!$!' (. 5 :! 122C $< ! ( $'(3A9(! '$(!!/$4 '$(!3'!! 5@A9 D !65!6 !3@ E6
?$!->!$(>'!$(5@A9 $<='(' 1,A/$ 122;D 75C252@E ( $9/$(!'5C='/ $ ($$!$! $!$ 9! !!! $<!( $($'9 -CA9!$!$ (>!!!(>'!$ (/FA9 6
16 = '! - & !6 3@ 6 5 !6 G6 1 $< ! ( $#!$!$)(!!!$ '/-> !63@ ($='(' !$9'' (( $!( $(@!< 1222 D E )$ ! !$/ - $ ='(' > 4$/$($!' ( 5+A$5+3+D E6?'!!('!<$6
C6 ! ! ' /$9 5 A/$ 122C ! #! ( ($=$!$ '9$!$/ !! ( ( $! ( & 4$/$($!'6 $! ( / ! ! $$$< .9(( $!/$9 !H =$! A $($)! ('! $! ! ($! ! A9 ( $=( $$ '$ &'!!(=$! '$'- (! ('! $! ( ('$$ $!$ $!$9$ D 7 51+ ; $(6561Q 5@+ $(6 5Q C3@ $(6 5 ! B! $!'E6 . &99 /!$ $/)' $! ($! 122C ($$!$ ( &$)!( $!(=(6 )$ '( !-('=!( .9 ! $!$ ! $ / ( $! &$) ' / (. A ( ! ' /$9 D 7 55, +C $(6 @<Q 551 C@2 $(6 ;Q " 5++ORC,6C5@$(6C<E6
;6 $< ( ' !! ) $! A!' ( = ! ('$ $! $! /<-= D=6 !6@2 E6
36 ) ! &!$ $!! '!' =' ) (9 ' (&$/$($!' '!$! $==$! )&$ &* /$! (&$! / ((!B! F$')$& ' ($<)$/$($!' $!&!($=$'($. -$= ( $!D !6O,6C!;( .9! & 4$/$($!'(5,A/$ 5+@54 E6 !!F$9($! !! - &($$! !$ )$ ''(! ( ('$$ ( = ( !!$ ! ' = (&' ! F ( / (( ( ) & ' < - ''! B 9! '9 ($=$!$(=$!('! $!D 7513;51$(61<Q55, 122 $(6 ;< ! '=' E6 )& ! $$ (& / ((
01+2201223 4,0+4 &($$! !$ ($! F$ $ '9!$ ( & ' ! (& $. 9'' $<6 ?$ ! &! &==$ ! $)$(' (&! '(!! $/!$9!$ =(&! '!$. 6 ! '9 ( &($$! !$ ! (&!! F$9! '$ !. $<('9!$(& ')(!)$&!'' ($ ('$$ !' $ ! < =6 A$! $! (& !$ /$ (& '$!$)A9($! $$ ! 6 $$A9($!F$ !&($$! !$! G')!$(&! '!$. ) ) $!!$!$9$F&!4-4($ )(&($$! !$ ='(&! !$. =(! & !6O,6; !)& '$! A!' !$=6 ! L &! $!' A($$$ &! /G '$ ) &($$! !$ ! ! ' !$. / (( D 7 52+ 55; $(6 1<E6 $$ ('/' A $ ( !$ / / (( ( !!$ D !6 O, 6 C ! ; E ! $< 9$-((( '/$$D 75C2,C$(6CE6
B! ( 5@ !< 122C D 7 5C2 @;E $< ='(' ( D$4 . 7 E($=$'A $ ( !$/-& !6O,6C D( ! /$9 A)& C5 ('< 1221E ! A9' ) $$ $)$$!$ ) =$! !$! ( ($/! B! !!' (&==$ &! $!' D=6 7 513 5+3 $(6 1Q 511 53O $(6 5 ! '=' E&$)-!! '( 6 '9 ( !. !*$)( 4$ ( ( $! ( $ ! P! '$' ) &($$! !$/$!$) 9$& !6,C D/$9 A)&C5 ('< 1221Q!!/$ & !6;C6C E4)$ !F 9 (& 4$/$($!'(!! &'!!(($ ( =(& '( ' 4- '( '9$ & !6O,6C -($!$(&!$ F $$('!( !!$(<=$D=6 !636C!+ !6Q 7 6 <$' ( 5C A$! 1222 P 1+20+OE6 $$ )& ' $! ($! / (( ( !!$ '( ( '/$$ ( $<)$/$($!'$!!($=$'!! < ! - /* - ( $. '($ )&$ ( ($ !' $ ! - ( /$ '($F )$ (/ $! $ B! $$ (&==$ &($$! !$ ($! $ $ !$ ('$ $< (' *( /&/ !$!)&&! !$. (( H$$ $!-$A!$6 =$ ') * ' $! !$! (&! ! )&$ $! ( ! - ( $< =$! '9'6 ?$ !! '( ! !' A9 ($! F$ $!!$ (& . &'!! ( =$! ! )&$ '!$! ! H &($$! !$!!'6 !!/A $ (/! =! $$ ) ==$ (!(/!! $<!(G9! D=6 75115O;$(6C<Q " 1222SC,2652@$(61/ '=' $!'E6
01+2201223 4O0+4 @6 &$!$' &! <' & !6 O, 6 ; A! (F$. (( ( !! !$. =($/)!=$!)&$&/$! ( $< 99 /!$ ( '!! ( !'6 ? & (! '($F ($!-&$(/(( !!!(!! (&99 /!$$9$=$!$/!<A!$/(&'!!(!'Q *G$! $) ''! !' 88888888888 ($==' $! ( F '/)' &F !788888888888! !$) !$=$!'!<$ 88888888888= $!'!!)($!(& ' )$!$==$! =( ( $!F !!$(& 4$/$($!'6
& $ /$! ( ('! $ $ &==$ $!$' /$! ! F A! (( ( ! $! ! !$. ($! ((6 $< ( ' ($! ( ! &'!! ( =$! A)&-(!(('$$ $!$(&$!$'D5;A$!1223E6 ! &F(A9( !(&<'$$!'($4$ $! ( /$ $ $. ('' '( ($$! !$/ A!$=$$! $(&$! !$(($ 6
$<('!!) ! ($! !('($ ! $!!(1$122;=$!'!!(&=$< *9$)$!$!/ ($9!$6 !!==!$!! ('A-'/)' PL$!F$/ $!$ ( ./ ( ! (&:! 122C )$ ! '/$( *( =$< *9$) ( !! >G'$ 9G / $ ( !$ ( ( $/! <$' D51 $! 5O ! ( FE6 !! =$< *9$ ($9!$)' 88888888888 122; ($! B! $/!$9'$)!!==!$&'!$! '! ( $. (( ( !6 $ $9 $ '($ ( 88888888888 ( 1, /< 1221 =$! '!! (& / !!$! D($ .! /$ !G 34 @ / !$ ($ ' *! !$ !' $ 9G ( = ( E )&$ /$! '9! (&F$ 6 =$ &'!! *G$) ( !(/ B! $/!$9'-//&!!!!$( 88888888888! <'!$)$'! <!= ( F6
& (/$!(. (&! !$. /((( ! !( '( -&$! !$(($ 6
<$ =(' ')! ($ ! /*' - & $! !$ ( (( !! ! / ($9!$ ( =$< *9$!/('$$6
,6 ! )$ <!$! 9$ ( ( $! - ( (' )$ ! =$F' - 5&322= 6
01+2201223 4+0+4 * / + *+ + * +
!
34-5- 6 7-- - 89 ':# +;<
5-
56 ' /<6
! 5-
16 &(!6
C6 /$($ -&$!$' $! !$(((!/('$$6
;6 (&$!$'-* !5&322= 6-!$! (('6
36 = !$ ( )> /! = ! '! B! ( ('$ ( C2 A (. !$=$!$ $ (' ( ' $< ='(' ( ?GT$U G=)$ @ @22; ! $ F$ 6 ('$ ! B! 9'6 '$ ($!M E $($) F!!)('$$ !('$ <!$ $!(('$$ !!)'Q <E F ) !$= $ !$ /$ (( !! ! ('$$Q E ! $9! ( '!!6 ?$ '$ !$! ! $ ''! '' ' !! E <E ! E $4( $<='(' ( ! !$. )>$ (/ (' $ /<6'$ ( !$ * ( / )$ ! A$! $$ ) ('$$ !!)' ! >/ ( )'!'F'($' !D !65C152@!52OE6 9 ==$ '$(! $ ? <? '!$ 4A $!M
7 '(' $) ?
$= ( '! B!!!$=$'F !$$$)>->==$='(' ( $ 9 ==
01+2201223