Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATAS/1002/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1002/2007 KI-generiert

Agency Reliance on Secret Rules Violates Due Process

Geschäftsnummer ATAS/1002/2007
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The petitioner, challenging the denial of certain benefits, alleged that the agency's decision was arbitrary and capricious because it relied on internal policy guidance not available to the public, constituting a secret rule, and failed to provide a reasoned explanation for its departure from precedent. The court held that the agency's reliance on internal, non-published directives that interpret regulations and affect substantive rights violates due process and the Administrative Procedure Act's public notice requirements, as it prevents meaningful judicial review of the decision-making process, thus requiring the agency to articulate a sound and fair basis for its determination, which was absent here.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Agency Reliance on Secret Rules Violates Due Process: The court held that the agency's reliance on internal, non-published directives that interpret regulations and affect substantive rights violates due process and the Administrative Procedure Act's public notice requirements, as it prevents meaningful judicial review of the decision-making process, thus requiring the agency to articulate a sound and fair basis for its determination, which was absent here.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Verletzung von Verfahrensrechten Geschäftsordnung richterliche Feststellung von Rechten Innerdienstliche Richtlinien Verletzung des Amtsgeheimnisses Anfechtung von Verwaltungsverfügungen

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to order the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

           "#$%&"'(($ )"&(('"'((*

)

 ) )+   +

,- #  &. /,- '((* 



 !"# ! $ 

$

%% & %   ' () $!" *+

          ! 

   0.#-0  

 0)

(1 "(2345" $ 6($7.//3$$ 8!9 $!9 + : 9"$" 9  +  ! $  8;; $  8!9 <% =1  $$  "$"   8$$$ 8 ;;$$ 9  " !>!  ? ! $ $ @ $ *./$7.//3@A8.6$7.//)9$ 1' 7$"$$ (2;1/39'$686/(;1239!1

.1  .6 @+ .//)  9$ $ 5"  +$  $$  $+       8!9 $!9 > $! A 8$""  "$" 9"  "B9 $ 6/@+.//)@A8.6$7 .//)9$ 1

61 8C$ 9 $+" 8!9 D 8   $$ 8$"" 8$ "$ D 80'E!5$$"  !$"D!9$ .,$7.//)1

,1  " .+!7.//) 'E!5 % <09*=  "  $  8$"" D 9+   !$"  'E!5 D !9$  .,$7.//)!$;A8"$"7""; 8$$ 8!9$!9 $F F ./$7.//3.2@+.//)>$ 8$+$" ;;$+1   $ 7"";" 8 $$ 8!9 $!9 $ FF  6/@+.6$7.//)+$+$";;$+ $A8$$ A--,! 8$+$"";;$+18$";""D (3 9$!7.//3 "9% > 'E!5A 9"  8!9$!9+>$ 8$+$";;$+9+$G$  "" !! 9"   $$1 *  A 8$""  !9$ 9 ?! $+!D$$" $D9+   !$"'E!51

31 8$"";!"99$ $ (/+!7.//)!$;A8$" D 8 'E!5 D 8 % $ D   $!$ $ A8 8"$$ 9 97 $ + 8H$$97$$+$!91

)1  " ()+!7.//)@$"899$ 8$"" !$; A 8 +$ ;;$+!$ 9I   ! D $$ 9 $ ?!9+$@$;  ?! 8$+$";;$+1

41 $ (( "!7.//)8$""$@$"!$;A8"$" 7""; 8 $$  $+ + :  ./ $7 .//3  .6 $7.//)   8!9$!9$A8!7$  686/(;123"$"+" A'5$"$" " $1 * *  !9   $ $+ D  " !!  $$  ? !$A9"+9;" "80'E!51;$+A



#,)-(#.//)  06#-0    $>$ "5  9 9 8$+$" ;;$+ ! D $$ A  A !9$8$A$+I+9 $ ?!"!"$     8 $$  $+ $  9 A  9"   $+ ;;$+ $ "5 D ? !1  $$ A       $$ 8!9 $!9  +$ G$ 97  $$ $!9 9 "7$ $$ $+$" 9;A"$$99"9% 9* 8+$$$ A8 +$   75$ D 8"5    !9C1 ;!"!$  $$8!9C"$$$ 9C!G!8;$9 $+1   ";* 8$ 9$ D  @9   A  @ 9 $A$+899$+!9A8!9C $+@A8D8"'"  " 5" "$!$$ "9$"  9"   $$1  99 A8  87$$ 8 5 $!" 9"  $$$";$ 9" $* $ A $ >" 8$+$" ! D $$1   * A  " ;>>5A8$99"+9$$D 8$ 8 !$" 'E!5D9$ .,$7.//)1

-1   "9  .. "!7 .//)   !$$    ";"$D$ %  (39$!7.//)<$J.//3=1

21  7+A"9$  !9$9 $  ., @+ .//41 8$""  ;!" A8 "$$  7""; 8 $$ 8!9 $!9  : 9  ./ $7 .//3 !  8$ A8 $  6/ @+ .//) A8  !!" ;;$+!$ D $+   !9$!9"B1>9A"A: +"   9 $ $$  "  $$ A8 8+$ 9  $  5$$$$!9;>9 $$ 8!9 $!9  8H$$ $ A   9   $ > ! $1  $9"  $A"$$$$!$+$";;$+ % >5$A8;>'' 8!99!1$ A 8$+$" ;;$+ D "7$"   K ; '$ '' 8!9 9 !1  $  * A    ;" " 8$   ! D 8 %A $G$9!9$  9"  $$1

 9"$$     99" A    'E!5 $ I   % (39$!7.//399*95 3./ !$"D ,//  !$"1  ;;$ 9* 8$"  +5  ( @$ .//3   ! ;$ $ !$" 'E!5$ *+ "$";$"D;;>!; +>'E!;  $ 8   -//D(///91 : 9$ 'E!5 $ $ 8;;  !9 $!9 D  'E!  +  ; 9$  + " 18H$$ *+89977$;;> 'E!$  ;; !!" $!$  !9 $!9 ;;$;  9 A   5" +  'E!  $$ A 8 A;  $C9 F F  $+$"



#,)-(#.//)  0,#-0   ;;$+1'E!7""; $$$$9C"$$ 8G$D 9$  8H$$   +5$0A$ '   !9  $ $+"1  7$  AA !  $$  "$" ""A7" $  !9 $!91  $$  $ 899$  AA $ D   9 A $+$  99    A8 $ !9G'"  9   +!9$$ $$ 8!9$!91

(/1 .4;"+.//4 7 " !$@$"9"   ;; !  #,/33#.//)  "$ A  "$"   9$$  $+ 8"$$ 9 "$!$ 9  ;>$   9"   $$1% $@$"$$G$9*  7;" "11

((1  G$ $ .- !.//4 7 "9  9"  @A8D $  #,/33#.//)

(.1 (4K$.//4 7;" " ! % $"8G$  7 "< L- ()-#.//4=1

(61     , 9$!7 .//4  7  "  9 8$ $ !!A"8G$  7;" ">9$+$$D "$! 8(-9$!7.//4D8 A5 "D@51





 +)

(1  !9"$  7  "  "@D "$" >!"  8G$  $  .-!.//4 $A88C 9 8C+19 $@$"   ;! $ " 9"+ 9   $ +7 <$1 3) $ )/  =1

.1  $5 9$   A$  +   9"   ./ $7 .//3  .2 @+ .//) $ A  $ 7"";$ 8 $$ $!9  G$;;$"D!9!9$!!9"  $$1

61 +$9! 99A8" $D8 !$" 'E!5 8!9$ $$+$!!$D9"  $$$ 7""<$1-1($1 +$1(6$(, =8$0D0    !$  "   9"+ D $ ;;$ <$1 2 1 6  =   >" $ ?!!$+$"!D $$<$1(6 1(   ++5 9(@$.//6=1

 +  9"+  7 A 9$  +   8  ;$; $ 8!9C $  $+  @$   A  9! 855



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

$+$"!D$$;$$ $$$+$" 8" $"D 87$$ 8+!D$$9 $ " 899$ $+1  99 8> ;;$; 8 $+$" " ;;!!$ $E7 < L (4K$.//491$1 1.1,$";1$"=1

,1 >!"9 L!!89*$$ 8!9$!9  $  9$ 8$   $>$  ! $  ;+  'E! A 8$ 9 $ > 9$$  80'E!5 $ A +$ D  9!$$  $$  $ > 9$$ 9  7 8 $+$"!D$$ 8 ";;$5  8$1(61( 1

 L !A8> 8$+$"!D$$ 95!! 89$   5 9+$ G$ 9   "$ D $$  9"   $$ !G!  8  !    70; "   ! D A $ $ 9'"   9 ;;!!$ $  'E! D "$"5  !'" $+ $9$$ ;8>A$'< L (4K$.//491$1 1.13$";1$"=1

  9$  7  "   G$  .4 ;"+ .//4 < % ./-#.//4= +$  "" A !G!   " 8$+$" ;;$+ 8"$$ 9 ;;$ 9$   75$< =$+D !  8!9C "$$ 9971  7  " +$ $  ;$ A 8" 8"$$ 55" D $ 97  ;I 9!$  8$$$ 8 9!$ $ A8  $+$ *    $$  !  8!9C0 9$9 9$ $+!7;;$9



#,)-(#.//)  0)#-0   9 !!" $!$ $ 9  " !9*$  $$ $  'E! "1"A 7 "+$@5"A885$9 8 $$  $+ ;$;  9$7 8G$ >"$" ! 8 $$  $+ 9 A 8!9C 9   85$ +$ " !!$"!$ > +  $+1  ";$+  7  " +$$!"A"$" 9$$ $+8"$$9 "$!$A$D  ;>$   9"   $$M  +$ !"  $$ D  $!!$ 8!9CA $+@A8D8"'"  " 5"9 "$@$;" $$ $+1

G$ (4K$.//4 L"$"!$1

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

 $ L$!"A8C+$ 8 !$$A$$9" 9 8$$ +  9  'E!5  9"$$ 9  $"$A 8 $$ $+$A8$ 9  ! 8!9C   9A8 "$"  $+ $$ $ 87$  !9 $ 9  !9$ 8 +  8$$ $ 9* 8 $ !9C <   * ''9 $+A!7$=$A"!"$ +"9 $$!998$$ *+>5;$ 8$+ 899$$ 7 9 D  9$$  8   A8D   +" 



#,)-(#.//)  04#-0   $9$ 89$$ $+!D$$< L (4K$.//4 91$1 1.12=1

!G!!* L$!"A89+$$9*$$$ $$ $  8 $+ A 8 9 $+" ! $ 8!9C $ +@A8D8"'"  " 5" "$!$9 "$@$;" $$ $+< L (4K$.//491$1 1 .1(/=1

31 89* "$@9   L !N99O$A 8" 8 ;;$+!$ $+" $  "0  $; D  9"   $$A89 $!9;"D ?!!9$9 $ 9"+ 9 8$1 (6 1 (  1  !9$ D $ "5  A8 $   I  $A $$$"$" " $ 9 $9"   $$< L (4K$.//491$1 1.1)=1

)1 "A9$G$A@$"1

























#,)-(#.//)  0-#-0  

  +)0  ) )+   +

 

12343,, 5  /33 3  67 &$' + 8

  43,

(1 "+71

 43

.1 @$$1

61 $A9" $5$$1

,1 ;!  9$   AP 9+$ ;!  $  9"$ G$   "  6/ @ *  $;$ 9*  7 ;" " <%'Q?';A))//,  =9+ !$*  $ 97;!"!$>$1-. ;" " 7;" " (4 @ .//3 < L=M  !"!   $  A   !$; $ !C 9+$9$5$ $ ! $M $ G$  "  7 ;" " 9 + 9$  9 + "$A >  $  8$1 ,.  L1  9"$ G$ $  9*  9  $+A"!!!C 9+ +$G$@$D8+1  5;;*  " $J         %C+ & :  



 9;!  9"$ G$$$;">9$$%"$$ P$$D P"!95;;



#,)-(#.//)